Homework in the Comment Box
Of the roughly 21,000 reader comments on our archive, about 800 mention a teacher, a class, homework, an essay or an exam. Many of them are about poems on school reading lists, such as The Road Not Taken. The counts show a clear rise and decline.
| Year | Comments mentioning school |
|---|---|
| 2005 | 321 |
| 2006 | 154 |
| 2007 | 89 |
| 2008 | 50 |
| After 2012 | Under 10 per year |
The comments follow a few familiar patterns. Some students argued that Pound's two-line "In a Station of the Metro" could not count as a poem. Some of them returned later, read it again, and found more in it. Others asked for help with symbolism the night before an exam, or said they were irritated at being made to read Pound's Cantos.
After 2008, comments from teenagers became rare. Students looking for homework help went to other sites and to social media, and the requests in our comment boxes declined from year to year.
The Assigned Canon: Frost First
When we sort the roughly 800 school-related comments by the poem they discuss, one name leads. Robert Frost holds the top three places. The Road Not Taken comes first, followed by Nothing Gold Can Stay and Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening.
A fourth Frost poem, Fire and Ice, appears further down the list. No other poet has as many titles among the poems students mention most.
| Poet | Poems among the most mentioned |
|---|---|
| Robert Frost | 4 |
| E. E. Cummings | 3 |
| Langston Hughes | 2 |
| Poe, Whitman, Riley, Silverstein, Longfellow, Angelou | 1 each |
The four Frost poems share some features. They are short, they rhyme, and they can be read in a few minutes. Nothing Gold Can Stay and Fire and Ice each run under ten lines.
That brevity suits a class period or a homework assignment. It also leaves room for the questions students brought to our pages, such as what a fork in a road stands for, or why a traveler stops in the snow.
cummings in the Classroom
Among the roughly 800 comments on our site that mention a teacher, a class, homework, an essay or an exam, three poems by E. E. Cummings appear on the list of those most often discussed. Only Robert Frost has more poems on that list. Langston Hughes has two.
The three are anyone lived in a pretty how town, maggie and milly and molly and may, and in Just-. Each one asks a reader to slow down. The lowercase titles, the broken lines and the odd word order are the first things a student meets.
anyone lived in a pretty how town opens with its own title and then a second line: "(with up so floating many bells down)." That line alone gives a class something to work on. You can read it several ways, and the comments that mention school often come from readers trying to settle which way is right.
The questions students left on these pages follow the same pattern we see elsewhere on the site. Some asked for help with meaning or symbolism before a test. Others were still working out whether the unusual form was a rule being broken on purpose, and what that purpose might be.
The Raven, O Captain and the Nineteenth Century
Two of the poems most often named in our classroom comments are older than the rest. The Raven and O Captain! My Captain! sit on that list beside Frost and cummings. They came to our readers through the same channel: a teacher, a class or an assignment.
Of roughly 21,000 reader comments on our archive, about 800 mention school in some form. That means a teacher, homework, an essay or an exam. Poe and Whitman appear in that group often enough to rank among the most frequently cited poems.
The comments on these pages follow the patterns we see elsewhere. Some students ask for help with symbolism before a test. Others write as if a poem has been placed in front of them and they are still deciding what to make of it.
| Year | School-related comments |
|---|---|
| 2005 | 321 |
| 2006 | 154 |
| 2007 | 89 |
| 2008 | 50 |
The timing matters. Most of these comments arrived in the mid-2000s, when The Raven and O Captain! My Captain! drew students looking for help. After 2008, that kind of help moved to other sites and to social media. By the years after 2012, fewer than ten school-related comments reached us each year.
Silverstein, Hughes and Angelou
The list of poems students mention most is not only Frost, Cummings and Poe. Four of the titles come from three other poets: Shel Silverstein, Langston Hughes and Maya Angelou. They sit beside the older standards in the same comment threads.
Silverstein appears through Messy Room. It is the only one of his poems on the list. Its place there shows that school reading in our comments reached past the nineteenth-century canon.
Hughes is the one poet of the three with two titles. Students left comments on Mother to Son and on Theme for English B. The second poem is itself set in a classroom, which gives it a particular fit with readers who arrived with an assignment in hand.
Angelou's Phenomenal Woman completes the group. Like the others, it drew the kinds of comments we saw across the archive: requests for help with meaning and symbolism, often written close to an exam or an essay deadline.
What the Students Said About the Poems
The student comments in our archive fall into a few familiar patterns. Some are complaints. Some ask for help. A smaller number show a reader changing their mind.
A common one concerns Ezra Pound's In a Station of the Metro. Students objected that a poem of two lines could not count as a poem at all. Then a second reading would turn up more than they expected, and the tone of the comment would shift.
Others arrived the night before an exam, asking what a symbol meant or what a poem was "really about." These requests gathered around the poems teachers assigned most, such as Nothing Gold Can Stay, where so much is compressed into a few lines. The questions were direct and practical. They wanted an answer they could write down.
Pound appears again at the other end of the scale. Where his short poem drew doubt, his Cantos drew irritation from students who had been made to read them. Taken together, these comments show what a classroom assignment feels like from the desk: sometimes frustrating and often rushed, though now and then it led to a closer reading.
What the Record Says About Teaching Poetry
Of the roughly 21,000 reader comments in our archive, about 800 mention a teacher, a class, homework, an essay or an exam. That is a small share. It is also a clear record of how students met poetry online in the 2000s.
| Year | School-related comments |
|---|---|
| 2005 | 321 |
| 2006 | 154 |
| 2007 | 89 |
| 2008 | 50 |
| After 2012 | Under 10 a year |
The numbers peak in 2005 and fall every year after. Teenagers did not stop reading poems. Homework help moved to other sites and to social media after 2008, and their comments here faded with it.
The poems named most often in these comments lean toward Robert Frost. The Road Not Taken leads the list, followed by other short, frequently assigned works by Frost, E. E. Cummings, Langston Hughes and Walt Whitman. These are the poems that appeared on syllabi, so they are the poems students came looking for.
The comments themselves follow a few patterns. Some students argued that Pound's In a Station of the Metro, at two lines, could not count as a poem. Some of them came back after a second reading and found more in it. Others asked for help with symbolism the night before an exam, or complained about being assigned Pound's Cantos.