maggie and milly and molly and may
went down to the beach(to play one day)
and maggie discovered a shell that sang
so sweetly she couldn't remember her troubles,and
milly befriended a stranded star
whose rays five languid fingers were;
and molly was chased by a horrible thing
which raced sideways while blowing bubbles:and
may came home with a smooth round stone
as small as a world and as large as alone.
For whatever we lose(like a you or a me)
it's always ourselves we find in the sea
✦
Analysis
maggie and milly and molly and may: analysis
Introduction
"maggie and milly and molly and may" is a short poem about four girls who spend a day at the beach. Each girl finds something there. One finds a singing shell, one a starfish, one a frightening crab and one a stone.
The poem calls the starfish a "stranded star" and never names the crab at all. It describes both as a child might see them. The closing couplet steps back from the girls and speaks for everyone. Whatever we lose, it says, what we find in the sea is ourselves.
The poem sounds like a nursery rhyme, with its chiming names and couplets. Under the play it touches on trouble, fear and loneliness. The line "as small as a world and as large as alone" carries much of its weight.
Summary
Lines 1–2 name four girls: maggie, milly, molly and may. They go down to the beach one day to play. The phrase "(to play one day)" sits in brackets, closed up against the word "beach".
In lines 3–4, maggie discovers a shell that sings. Its song is so sweet that she cannot remember her troubles. The stanza ends on the word "and", which runs on into the next girl's story.
In lines 5–6, milly befriends a "stranded star". Its rays are "five languid fingers". The word order of line 6 is inverted, with the verb "were" placed last.
In lines 7–8, molly is chased by "a horrible thing". The thing races sideways and blows bubbles. It is never named. Like line 4, line 8 ends on "and".
In lines 9–10, may comes home with "a smooth round stone". The stone is "as small as a world and as large as alone". She is the only girl said to bring something home.
Lines 11–12 turn from the girls to "we". The bracket gives examples of what might be lost: "a you or a me". Whatever we lose, the speaker says, "it's always ourselves we find in the sea". The poem ends there, with no final punctuation.
Themes and meaning
The closing couplet states the central idea: what we find in the sea is "ourselves". Each girl's find can then be read as a picture of the girl. maggie finds a song and forgets her troubles. milly finds a creature that is stranded and needs a friend. molly meets fear, and may finds something small, smooth and solitary.
The last couplet also pairs losing with finding. The bracket "(like a you or a me)" makes the lost thing a person, or a self. That gives the ending a darker edge than the rest of the poem. It can be read as comfort: loss sends us back to ourselves. It can also be read more bleakly, as saying the self is all we are sure to find.
Childhood and play frame everything. The girls go down "to play one day", and the poem keeps a child's view of the shore. The crab is only "a horrible thing", and the starfish is a "star" with fingers. Yet in play the girls meet troubles, strandedness, fear and solitude. The poem lets these arrive in the middle of a game.
Line 10 turns on scale and solitude. The stone is "as small as a world", which reverses the usual sense of a world as vast. It is "as large as alone", which turns a state of being into a size. The line suggests that a whole world can fit in one hand. It also suggests that being alone can feel immense, and may carries that feeling home.
Tone
The tone begins light and sing-song. The chiming names and the easy rhyme of "may" with "one day" set up a nursery-rhyme mood. The comic crab, which "raced sideways while blowing bubbles", keeps it playful.
Yet the tone darkens by degrees. maggie has "troubles" to forget. milly's star is "stranded", and molly's pursuer is "horrible", even if it is funny to an adult. The stone couplet slows the pace with long vowels and ends on the word "alone".
The final couplet shifts from story to statement. Its voice is calm and general, and it uses "we" for the first time. But it speaks of loss. The poem ends balanced between comfort and sadness.
Form and structure
The poem has 12 lines in 6 stanzas, each a couplet of 2 lines.
Three couplets rhyme within themselves: "may" with "day", "stone" with "alone", and "me" with "sea". Lines 3–4 and 8–9 do not. Instead both end on "and", so they rhyme with each other across the gap. "troubles" and "bubbles" chime just before those endings. Lines 5–6 pair "star" with "were" as a near rhyme.
The spoken lines run from eight to thirteen syllables. The metre is loose and accentual, with about four stresses a line. Line 1 sets a dactylic lilt, and later lines vary it freely. Brackets close up against the words beside them. The only capital letter is in "For", which opens line 11.
Poetic devices
alliteration line 1
maggie and milly and molly and may The repeated m sound binds the four names together. The girls sound alike before the poem shows how they differ.
repetition line 1
and milly and molly and may The chain of 'and' strings the girls together like a child's list. The same word later ends lines 5 and 9.
sibilance line 4
so sweetly she The soft s sounds imitate the hush of the shell's song. The sound itself seems to lull maggie out of her troubles.
enjambment line 8
blowing bubbles:and The line and stanza end on 'and', pushing straight on to may. The stories spill into each other rather than closing off.
metaphor line 5
a stranded star A starfish becomes a 'star' fallen to the shore. The alliteration of st makes the image memorable, and 'stranded' makes it lonely.
personification line 6
five languid fingers The starfish's rays become slack fingers, like a tired hand. It explains why milly treats the creature as a friend.
anastrophe line 6
whose rays five languid fingers were The verb is moved to the end of the line. The inversion sounds old-fashioned and storybook-like, and it sets up the near rhyme with 'star'.
periphrasis line 8
which raced sideways while blowing bubbles The crab is described rather than named, as if by a frightened child. The comic detail undercuts the 'horrible thing' of line 8.
simile line 10
as small as a world The comparison runs backwards, since a world is usually a measure of vastness. The stone holds a whole world in miniature.
paradox line 10
as large as alone A feeling is used as a unit of size. The stone is tiny and immense at once, as solitude can be.
parenthesis line 11
(like a you or a me) The pronouns become nouns with 'a', so a person becomes a thing that can be lost. The bracket slips the heaviest idea in quietly.
rhyme line 12
find in the sea The final rhyme of 'sea' with 'me' ties the self to the sea. It closes the poem on the place where the self is found.
Words worth knowing
stranded
Left on the shore by the tide, unable to get back to the water. It also carries the wider sense of being stuck or abandoned.
star
Here a starfish, as the 'five languid fingers' of line 7 show.
languid
Slow, limp and lacking energy, as a starfish out of water would be.
alone
Normally an adjective, used in line 11 as if it were a measure of size.
a you or a me
The pronouns are used as nouns, so they mean 'a person' or 'a self' that can be lost.
What readers have said
JWLuikart reads the poem as the growing up of four girls, or four types of people, rather than as a poem about losing a loved one. The sea is the great wide world, and what they learn about themselves is what they bring back. JWLuikart, 2005
Beth reads the four girls as one woman's different moods and ways of coping: maggie with stress, milly as her friendly side, molly as her fear, and may as her feeling of being alone. Beth, 2006
Emily, preparing a dance piece, sees four separate girls who each deal with problems differently. She reads the poem as about grief and its stages: ignoring it, running from it, confronting it and getting through it. Emily, 2006
Eileen points to words within words, such as "beach" broken into 'be each', and notes that the phrases inside the brackets are nearly interchangeable. Eileen, 2004
meryl reads the poem as each girl discovering a personality trait. She takes may's stone to mean that however big the world, and however many people love someone, that person can still be lonely. meryl, 2005
Daniel asks whether the four girls might be one person, and whether the poem speaks from a child's point of view. He points to "and molly was chased by a horrible thing" as something an adult would not say. Daniel, 2006
this poem has a very deep meaning...this poem shows that it has been written by a person who learnt so many things from this world..who is very much experienced and mature...
Elaine Kaminsky
This poem speaks of friendship, caring, sharing and self while the sea provides a blanket of cover. A very powerful message.
AngelaUnited States
This poem has been a favorite of mine for over 25 years. I feel it expresses the fact we are attracted to those things that reflect our personalities. We all face similiar emotions. What better place to ponder and find ourselves than by the sea shore?
EileenUnited States
Characteristic of Cummings, there are words within words in this poem. For example, "beach" can be broken down into "be each." And notice that the phrases within the parentheses are virtually interchangeable.
JJ DynamiteCanada
The author uses alliteration very effectively throughout the poem. “Maggie and milly and molly and may,” is an obvious example of this. The opening line in which this alliteration appears, sets the tone for the rest of the poem. The similiarities in the four girls names create an image of four sisters, even quadruplets, who head to the beach to spend a summer day together. Alliteration is also used in the second stanza, “a shell that sang so sweetly she.” This is effective because it uses the softness of the “s” to portray to the reader the sound of singing that maggie found inside her shell.
I don't understand why it's necessary to completely dissect every bit of this poem. I think it speaks well for itself.
AnnaUnited Kingdom
Cummings uses the two little girls as a tableu for life. The sea side is something we have all experienced as children and so the poet uses a nursery rhyme like tone to suggest this. The poet seems to suggest that as a child all our problems were non exsistent. We were satisfied with exploring the world around us. But as adults we end up having much more to worry about. Cummings seems to be saying that we could recapture our problemless childhood by returning to the sea, and uses alliteration and soft rolling words to echo the sound of the sea ,mainly through worlds with the letter S like stone. Just discovered Cumming and still trying to get my head around him, but I LIKE.
whitneyUnited States
i think one aspect of this poem is the fact that maggie and milly and molly and may are all seperate people who are different, but are drawn together by certain things, much like the sea and the sand and the rocks and the shells are all very different but connected by one thing
MichelleUnited States
The poem had a very in depth meaning. Shows true character.
eesha ahmadPakistan
This poem has a very deep meaning & really made me think.I think E.E.Cumming is just great.
denaUnited States
the poem says to me we can't escape who we are. and in my opinion "as small as a world and as large as alone" is the greatest line of poetry ever written.
This is one of the best poems i have ever read. It is in Adventures for Readers, and anthology. I first read it in 6th grade, and i loved it right away. I wish that the punctuation was not included, like the way e.e. cummings had originaly written it.
Certified Gangsta
wow yall r 2 obssesed wit poems.....its just a poem
amanaSouth Africa
Here Cummings beautifully portrays how significant and creatively inspiring even the smallest of things can be. Sometimes, it is necessary to see that which is right in front of u, as poets we often delve to deeply...
frozen furyUnited States
this poem isn't actually all that deep the last line tells you what the poem means as a whole all of the things that the girls found depicted thier character. thats it what the heck is there to think about. but i think the poem is very funny and smart
1. Many of you really need to improve your grammar. 2. I don't really know what this poem is saying, but I think it is saying that everyone discovers something different every day, whether that is good or bad. 3. I also think that Anna from the U.K. has provided a plausible explination, but forgot about the crab.
Heather GoschUnited States
I think that this poem is the best poem that I had ever read. Usually I read Walt Whitman. I think that e.e cummings is good at writing the poems he writes, this poem is my favorite because of the assonance and alliteration in the poem.I think that he is better at writing poems than other poets. But that's only my opinion.
Hatsumiyo-chanUnited States
wow! i had no clue this poem was by ee cummings! i read this poem in...the fourth grade, i think...and i had absolutely NO CLUE it was by the one and only great poet ee cummings! maggie and milly and mollie and may is one of my favorite poems! -_^
Richard Wright IIIUnited States
anyways...let me explain to u what this poem means. In the title the girls names arent capitalized meaning he wants us to focus more on the subject matter rather than the people. Second Maggie is spelled differently than the rest telling us to focus on what she finds which takes her troubles away so the poem is about troubles. The Last stanza is telling us that we are not the only ones on this earth who have bad days or are feeling bad and that we can always find something or someone to ease our troubles.
Actually it is to my working knowledge, Richard, since I am pracitcally an expert on this poet, that Cummings does not captialize the names of the girls because part of his unique style is that he makes typical typographical errors. He seldom captitalizes anything.
Jamie, I think that Richard is correct. He uses caps for emphisisum. In the poem "anyone lived in a pretty how town", one of my favorites, Cummings capitalizes the word Woman twice. So in this poem, the names aren’t important. The subject is. But you're right to Jamie. He doesn't oftenly capitalize. That's all I wanted to say.
I have always thought that this poem was written about how different people react to the loss of loved ones in different ways. Some recover and some never truly do. I think that he used the alliteration of the names to show how alike the four subjects were and yet they all dealt with their loss in their own way. I do agree with Richard about the capitalization. ee cummings doesn't want us to focus on their names but on what they discovered down at the beach.
SarahUnited States
what does as small as a world and as large as alone mean?
maggie and milly and molly and may is a very good poem writen by e.e. cummings. i think the poem is a little confusing in the begging. i am doing a bio sketch about e.e. cummings for my english class and i needed to choose 2 poems by a poet, i choose e.e. cummings. the poems i choose were maggie and milly and molly and may, and anyone live in a pretty how town. i don't understand anyone live in a pretty how town but…
Read the whole comment
maggie and milly and molly and may is a very good poem writen by e.e. cummings. i think the poem is a little confusing in the begging. i am doing a bio sketch about e.e. cummings for my english class and i needed to choose 2 poems by a poet, i choose e.e. cummings. the poems i choose were maggie and milly and molly and may, and anyone live in a pretty how town. i don't understand anyone live in a pretty how town but i understand maggie and milly and molly and may more than i understand anyone live in a pretty how town. but i still need to understand both of them more than i do now. i do understand the first part of the poem maggie and milly and molly and may, but the last couple of stanzas make barely any sence to me. i know i am stupid but i still don't understand them. i need to understand them by tomorrow, because that is when my bio sketch is due, and i need to do that stupid bio sketch that is due tomorrow. but still even though e.e. cummings poems can be very confusing, he is still a wonderful very exellent poet, but i still need to do my bio sketch on e.e. cummings, and then i have to do a essay on maggie and milly and molly and may, and anyone live ina pretty how town, one essay for each poem, so that is one bio sketch on e.e. cummings, one essay on maggie and milly and molly and may, and one essay on anyone live in a pretty how town, so i need some help by tomorrow.
AlenBosnia and Herzegovina
thIs PoEm ArE the GreaTeSt EvAr!
JWLuikartUnited States
I have never thought of it as a poem about how we deal with loss of a loved one, but rather as the growing up of the four girls or four types of people rather. They go down to the sea which seems to me to be the great wide world. They leave home, go out into the world and what they learn of themselves is what they bring back. It is just a thought. The "small as a world and as large as alone" part is about the stone may finds as her mind or state of mind. Each of us carries around a little world in our heads, but for those of us who have felt loneliness, it is a state of mind, but it can feel so vast. The may type is a thinker/imaginer.
"may came home with a smooth round stone as small as a world and as large as alone.
For whatever we lose(like a you or a me) it's always ourselves we find in the sea"
^These lines are what the poem is mostly about. I agree with Dena from the U.S. that the line "as small as a world and as large as alone." Is one of the best lines of poetry ever written (maybe not THE best). The second to last line of this poem was also very strong, it is saying that if we lose our way in life (followed by the last line) that says we can always confide in the ocean. E e cummings is my favorite poet ever, my brother likes T.S. Elliot, but I dunno I think Cummings owns.
I have thoroughly enjoyed reading these comments about the poem. I am about to give a vocal recital this comming February and am doing research on my pieces. One of the pieces I am singing is "Seashore Girls" which is a musical setting of this poem by Richard Hundley. If any of you get a chance, you should find a copy of it. I found a few online, but they aren't the best in terms of quality.
I just thought I'd share. It's a beautiful setting. Hundley really captured what cummings wanted to say. Thanks again for the insight.
Sunny
e.e. cummings rocks. This is one of my all-time favorite peoms in the world. And I believe that- 'may came home with a smooth round stone as small as a world and as large as alone.' is the most memorable line is this poem, and perhaps at LEAST the second best piece of a poem in the world. It comes off as meaning many different things to everyone, but no matter what it means, it always has a GREAT meaning. To be able to do that with just two lines of poetry is a wonderous thing. It speaks to the soul, and all that.
ok so i'm not a poetry buff or anything, but i understood this poem as a discovery of personality traits. each girl finds out something different about themselves. i think that "may came home with a smooth round stone as small as a world and as large as alone." can be interpreted as how no matter how big the world is, or how many people someone has that love and care about that person, he or she could still be very lonely.
Wow! I love that poem! It makes lots of sense and makes really good connections. Where do you get these ideas.
Lucy MooreUnited Kingdom
I think that this poem is about 4 different personalities of one woman. the light language contrasts with the deep meaning. It is about lonliness, isolation and inner self. Life can sem perfect on the outside, but inside, you are crying out and need to escaoe from your problems.
chelseyUnited Kingdom
i think this poem has a brilliant message about personality and finding yourself. In this case a beach, where many years ago you would have found yourself with not as many troubles. I agree with the ccomment on looking at what Maggie found at the beach, as she is significant and should be a symbol/idol in what we all should hopefully find in ourselves. Very moving piece!
KristieUnited States
I believe the true genius of this poem is the mystery that radiates from it. At first it seems like a meaningless doodle, yet, as the vaugeness of it sinks in, you realize you don't REALLY know what he ment. cummings left us in the dark to discover our own opinions at the seashore.
kellyUnited Kingdom
I am doing my alevel dance and we have to produce a dance on this poem, im finding it hard to realise the inner feelings within the poem and wondering if you could help as its hard to put the feelings into the dance or what actions 2 use thanks x
HarrietteUnited Kingdom
I have just read the poem and my initial reactions were that it reminded me of old ladys staggering up to the bach, but once the get there they find their younger persona once again; which in tern makes them come alive! Sorry, I'm a dance student so i see everything in a sense of movement and colour! please comment on my interpretation- for i have no idea and cant find what he actually said! lol
laurie and lauraUnited Kingdom
please can anyone advise us in translating the meaning of the poem we are both studying a level dance and are doing a dance on the poem can anyone help???
Vickie MitchellUnited Kingdom
I understand that the poem is represented in many ways about young girls and their differences in how they experience life. They all recieve different expectations of life.They have all grown up and become independant and faced different challenges and in the end they only have theirselves.
melissaUnited Kingdom
this poem is about 4 girls not really characters jst examples of everyday people it is about the journey of life startin off as children as in childhood we hang out in groups n play and there is alot of togertherness in youth. each character discovers something different from the sea {the sea is a metaphor for adult life} so as they grow up they discover thier own path in life ie maggie becomes a troubled individual…
Read the whole comment
this poem is about 4 girls not really characters jst examples of everyday people it is about the journey of life startin off as children as in childhood we hang out in groups n play and there is alot of togertherness in youth. each character discovers something different from the sea {the sea is a metaphor for adult life} so as they grow up they discover thier own path in life ie maggie becomes a troubled individual as she must {have troubles 2 be able 2 forget them} milly is a curious nuturing individual molly comes across to me as an active person very loud, and may comes across as the lonley indivdual. as small as aworld and as large as alone 2 me is the way we look at life u either see the world as a small place that u know of and are comfortable with or u see it as a big place that u r alone in and are scared of entering.the poem concludes with "for whatever we lose a you or a me it is always ourselfs we find in the sea" meaning as you grow up you find yourself your path in life u become an individual and you enter life |{the sea} on your own
i am also doing this for a level dance thats my interpretation id show togertherness and a childishness in begining growing into different independent characters {could show differences through different motifs for each character} think of life individuality and whatever comes to mind
sarahUnited Kingdom
I am also studying a level dance and have to produce a dance on the poem. i feel that the poem is about one person who finds many different personalities at the seaside. i feel this person would be quite old and find their inner, much younger selves!!
TashaUnited Kingdom
Im taking As-level dance and this poem sounded stupid to me as i read it without an open mind i just saw that it didnt rhyme and thought it was stupid but i guess looking at other peoples views on the poem makes me understand it more! i wasnt reali impressed with the questions we were given on the paper but i think i need to look more deeply into them to get a good full understanding on them. Thanks for ur opinions they reali have made me think!!
SJBUnited Kingdom
Basically I do AS level dance and I have to create a solo piece reflecting what the poem is trying to portrait. It seems to me to symbolise a persons search to find who they are in a world where its too easy to imitate others and conform. But I would like someone to further aliterate the depths of the poem aswell as give me and idea of how I could create a contemporary piece on the poem.
"Just discovered Cumming and still trying to get my head around him, but I LIKE."
Anna from United Kingdom
sarahUnited Kingdom
i have to study this poem for dance as level and i need some help from other dancers as to how they would portray each character and what motifs they might use. thank you dancers!!!
EmmaUnited Kingdom
I am also doing AS dance and was drawn to this poem whereas other members of my class thought it was silly and has chosen other stimuli to use. i think that this could be quite a difficult one to do but could be done as a narrtive rather than abstract piece. dont no how i couold represent all four girls tho? any ideas?
KathrynUnited Kingdom
I'm doing AS dance. You could try a split personality, try portraying all the 4 girls separately. Then you could say that it is like how the poem is structured, with set sections surrounding each girl? Kx
colleen robinsonUnited Kingdom
i am studing this pome for as dance and would like to no the meaning behind this pome and some motifs i could use to help me with this pome please!!!
charlotteUnited Kingdom
another person studying as dance...... silly exam boads eh?? asking silly questions
this is one of the harest bur=t easiet question to do out of the ones we were given other then using the sign language.....
i have been asked to research all the questions this is possibley the hardest to research plaese if you have any way you can help
[email removed]
RavikTurks and Caicos Islands
I am an AS Dance student at the TAD (Turkish Association of Dance)
im doing AS dance, as most people, we too have been told to research all questions and this is the only one i have had trouble with. To Sarah, we were told that you would be better not trying to represent each character separatly but rather the story in depth and what you think the meaning of the overall poem might be. for example i thought it could be one person, and the different aspects of their personality.
jesneyUnited Kingdom
like many of the other poeple who have commmented on this poem i am an AS dance student and have found some of the comments on this site very useful in my research as i felt it was important to find out other people's opinions on the poem. though i have found that no one has actually commmented on the fact that e e cummings does not use capital letters and puntuation in his writing which was due to his strong feeling against capitalism which delves into a whole other kettle of fish, i think u'll find!! i hope that this will add another dynamic to help your peice.... and good luck to every one!
BethUnited Kingdom
i think th poem is about one woman who has diffrent moods and feelings and how she copes. the first (maggie) is her simple way of cope ing with stress and troubles. the seconed (milly)shows her frendly side and how she has no predudice. the 3rd (molly)shows how she is easily scared and runs from her problems and fears. the 4th (may) shows how no matter what she shows on the out side she allways feels alone and trapped as the sea is stopping her. the last bit to me means what eva we do or show on the outside within is very diffrent. thnx 4 reading xx
EmmaUnited Kingdom
the idea of the whole four different personalities is brilliant and the way cummings refers to the beach because it is mainly everyones childhood memories. Can anyone think of a starting point for a motif because here i am totally lost? Thanks
EmilyUnited Kingdom
hey i'm the same as everyone else i'm researching this poem for as dance, everyones comments have actually been helpful, but i think i might do the quote.
NLRUnited Kingdom
When I first looked at this question, I cried! But when I looked a little deeper, I came up with my own interpretation. I feel that the characters are just pretending that they are playing on the beach - a child-like game. The way the poem is written also suggests that it is meant to be read as if a child is telling a story without taking any breaths as 'and' is used to link every stanza!
nikkiUnited Kingdom
like the last 10 comments i am also an as student of dance and studing the question i think that the girls are different personalites of one person and deal with different themes within the poem like childhood, loniness and the nusery style shows that going back to childhood can help you with your problems which is illustrated by the last two lines. the beach is a repersentative of the childhood and movement motifs could stat with beach play!
beckyUnited Kingdom
again...an AS stunent! no surprise there. the style of this poem is child like so the movements and motifs should represent that, but in the second half of the poem, the tone changes. it becomes more subdued and fearful. possibly showing a different aspect to her personality. she seems connected to the sea in some way, saying that she goes there to find herself.
cheers for reading this. its only my opinion, theres probably a million different interprataitons of it...
ElodieUnited Kingdom
I just thought i'd share with you some of the ideas i have been looking at... the star personality could involve a motif using the hand "five languid fingers" so the hand would be the focus point Also Cummings experimented with Synta, which in this poem evidently creates a very strong rhythm!! so i have created a motif using that rhythm as the initial point... Well, thats my input... hope it helps =) Good luck y'all!! Elodie
Hi, i just wanted to say how useful all these comments have been! I would like toknow if any of you know wether there are any other discussions going on on the other questions of the paper... Many thanks! Elodie.
LoreliBulgaria
This poem rocks my socks!
AbigailUnited Kingdom
Youve probli guessed but I am also a dance AS student theres some realli great ideas here which are really helpful, does anybody know any websites for the other questions?...
Thanx and Good Luck.....
LozUnited Kingdom
Hi. I am another AS student that is looking at this question for the final piece. My idea of the poem is that they could be all one person with different personalities or feelings. The beach is the most important thing. It's a place to make new friends however it is a place where there are troubles. Cheers for reading this. Loz
tylaUnited States
i dont really like your poem. does it even matter if i am typing it is not like you are going to read it anyways!!!!! if you do type back send me a way better poem PLEASE!!!!!!!
ZoeUnited Kingdom
Hi, Yeh i am another AS dance student, and i really like the idea of choreographing a dance to this poem. I thought maybe that this poem has a number of people, for example sisters or close friends, all going on an adventure.. and where it says "may comes home with a smooth round stone" im thinking this person likes to keep memory to where she has been. I also feel that this poem is very relaxing and has a particular message for the reader.. but i am currently trying to find that out!! GD LUCK ALL THE AS DANCERS CHOOSING THIS QUESTION FOR THEIR EXAM PIECE xx
Heya, i am aother dance student making a solo to this poem and have spent hours trying to find inspiring yet practical music that relates to the poem. Ive heard that a song was actually composed about this poem but i cant get hold of it. I was jst wondering what other people's music choices are like? Thanks for your help...
michelleUnited Kingdom
hya i have chosen the poem question as well and i am struggling on a piece of music to go with the poem i dont have a clue.my thoughts are that you will always stay friends with close ones but as long as your find yourslf with time alone such as thy go down to the beach together but have thier own adventures become themselves and showing thier difrent intrests.if any1 can help me with my problem please email me or sometihing.thank youxx
NicolaUnited Kingdom
im studying this question 4 my AS dance but am really stuck on movements and action, weve been given some useful information about the poem, saying that there were a number of topics it could have been based upon. I want to ask what others feel it is based on as we have been told it's about aliens, love/ sex, schkitophrenia, war or growing up and remembering loved ones that have passed on. so plz could ppl tell me wot they think its bout as i dnt really no wot topic 2 chose Thanx nicola
JemimaUnited Kingdom
I really like the thought of doing this poem for as dance but would really appreciate a little background on it and some suggestions for some music as iam also finding this quite hard to find! thank you very much! jemima x
lynn
hi,i am a dance student too and i am thinking about doing this question. But id like some more information on its backround, and what sort of music should i play? x
DanielUnited Kingdom
maggie and milly and molly and may.... could they be four people or could they be just one person. Another point, the names maggie and miller etc are never written in capital letters as they should do, so has Cummings wrote this poem from a childs point of view, an example of this is on stanza four when Cummings writes "and molly was chased by a horrible thing" Adults generally would'nt say this so was this poem…
Read the whole comment
maggie and milly and molly and may.... could they be four people or could they be just one person.
Another point, the names maggie and miller etc are never written in capital letters as they should do, so has Cummings wrote this poem from a childs point of view, an example of this is on stanza four when Cummings writes "and molly was chased by a horrible thing" Adults generally would'nt say this so was this poem written from a childs point of view.
Is this poem based on memories or lonliness?
As for music i have no idea, although myself and two other people have suggested a song by Norah Jones
This was probably no help to anybody but anyway happy dancing and good luck with the exam in April
im doin alevel dance aswell n coniderin this question. i love it n was the 1st thing that jumped out at me. theres summit twited about it but i cant figure out what. xx
ClaireIreland
hiya. im studying A level dance aswell and i think this poem is a great option. Cummings life is very complex and his style of writing is so unique. i was considering using a piece of music based on the sea as each character shows their emotions or relationships with the sea and what they get from it. i think there are alot of hidden meanings and i was an excellent stimulus for my choreography.
EmilyUnited Kingdom
hi yes once again i am an A level dance student too! i am going to use the poem as my stimulus and i am hoping to use american hifi, its not easy being me. but not sure because the music has lyrics in it. i interpreted the poem as being about someone who doesnt want to let go of their chilhood and liked the idea of structuring the dance like a song,A B A C D structure. wat do you think mail me! happy moving.
DollyUnited Kingdom
Hey, I am a AS Dance student, I have piked this poem but I am stuck on weather Maggie and Milly and Molly and May are 4 girls or only 1 with different personalites. Plus does any1 know the real meaning to this poem?
Maimoona PeartUnited Kingdom
I am doing this 4 AS level dance and so far enjoy it we have only just started and am finding it really to come up the music.
ellenUnited Kingdom
im doing this poem for my AS DANCE too, has anyone made a start on it yet? Ive got quite a few ideas, motifs and steps and thought we could exchange ideas.
monicaUnited States
My interpretaion of this poem is that the speaker has lost herself. maggie, milly, molly, and may are the speakers attempts to find herself. In Maggie the speaker tried to drown out her troubles with a sweet song, which I take to mean that instead of dealing with her issues she igonored them and only payed attention to the things she could deal with. In Milly the speaker finds a star that is not where it belongs and…
Read the whole comment
My interpretaion of this poem is that the speaker has lost herself. maggie, milly, molly, and may are the speakers attempts to find herself. In Maggie the speaker tried to drown out her troubles with a sweet song, which I take to mean that instead of dealing with her issues she igonored them and only payed attention to the things she could deal with. In Milly the speaker finds a star that is not where it belongs and it has lost its spirit; it has become weak. I think this is how the speaker feels, stuck somewhere she doesn't belong and unable to do anything about it. In Molly the speaker's worst fear comes true: that she cannot solve her problem, that it will destroy her. What sticks out to me the most is that May is the only one that "came home". In May, the speaker figures it out. She "came home with a smooth round stone". Stones become smooth and round after years of being hit by water. She has found herself! She is a product of all her experiences, she was molded over time. However, this "her" she found is alone, and that feeling makes the size of the world seem like nothing. She found herself at the sea, the sea being her thinking over her experinces and her life as a whole. That's why she went to the beach in the first place. The beach is a place where she can think about her life (represented by the sea) and find her answer.
WEll...........HELP!!!!! me and jen cant find any research on this damn poem, it just tells us the poem, and gives us no information on the structurew themes and main ideas etc... But overal, a lovely poem which can b well interpretated into an A* Dance...LOL!!!!!!!!!!!! good luck with yours love jen and jen x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
EmilyUnited Kingdom
Hey yup as level dance student and i have chosen this poem. I think there are four separate girls each who deal with theair problems in a different way. I got stressed out too and my teacher just told me to go and paddle in the sea! It really helped. I am trying to come up with a motif for "and" because I think it is significant. I also think this poem is about death and grief and getting through the different stages, ignoring it, running away from it, confronting it and finally getting through it. I have made some of my movements very childlike, eg head tilts focus down, etc. I would be grateful for anyone else's help. Thanks
hey peeps, i chose this one 2. i couldn't decide what 2 make of this poem + my latest idea is that the 1 speaker is in turmoil with herself and how she endeavours to cope with these strong, almost sctizophrenic (soz spelling!) trates of personality but im totally baffled by the end line what do you think peeps? ps monica think your interpretations are tres good :) xxxx
Sarah
obviously another dancer, thought id give my input. basically what im doing, is taking each character and giving them a different personality, so scared, happy, sad etc. and portraying these personalities through movement. the sea, being a recurring theme in the poem will be a recurring theme in the dance. I am going to make up a section for the sea, and repeat it after every character, so the dance will be in…
Read the whole comment
obviously another dancer, thought id give my input. basically what im doing, is taking each character and giving them a different personality, so scared, happy, sad etc. and portraying these personalities through movement. the sea, being a recurring theme in the poem will be a recurring theme in the dance. I am going to make up a section for the sea, and repeat it after every character, so the dance will be in rondeaux form - a b a c a d e etc... i have also got one motif which i start off with, and then repeat it in every section with developments...for instance my character for may is a sad one, so i will perform the phrase maybe more slowly and with smaller movements, maybe floorwork. this is such a hard question to put into movement, obviously there are lots of ideas about what the poem means, but to put it into movement is a different matter. this probably hasn't helped anybody...but i guess its a good idea to know how other people are handling the question....good luck everyone! xxxxx
EmiilyUnited Kingdom
Hi I'm doing this question for AS dance as well but I'm finding it really hard to find the right music. Does anyone have any idea what music to use? Thanks
rajniNew Zealand
This is a great poem commenting on what life has to offer us. Here cummings has taken the example of the sea to tell us it's worth. The sea has so much to offer. It is a place to relax for some while for others it's a 'dangerous' place. However, through the children characters, cummings is trying to explain that exploration is the answer to a lot of questions regarding life. Life is to be lived fully and we need to work out reasons for the way we think and behave. Life isn't always 'rosey' as milly and molly experience but it could be funful according to maggie and may. Your concept of life is based on your emotions and experiences-good or bad.
HollieUnited Kingdom
iv choosen the poem as my AS dance stimulus. Having completed my dance i now have the task of fitting music to it iv found that a good song is hold tight by the chemical brothers, it has an underlying beat and a solo voice, you can change the dynamics of your dance very easily by switchiing between following the rhythm of the beat or the solo voice. might be some help to you. good luck! hollie x
Sam ScottUnited States
This is one of my favorite poems. It was my dad's favorite poem, and he passed away a little while back, so this poem has burrowed itself like a clam in my chest, and each time I read it I feel the sea swell into my eyes, and my heart breaks a million times over...
Paul SolomonNew Zealand
I love this poem. For me it shows how our inner emotional world creates the world we find outside ourself. Knowing this gives us choice and freedom: we choose what kind of worlds we create, both inside our deepest self and with other people.
NattyUnited Kingdom
We as a class have started really late on ours and i mean like last week! Everyones comments have been so good, as it has given me an insight into what i can do! But has anyone else found the questions this year really random and hard to do? I do like this poem and after looking at it for longer, i apresheate what it means. For example my ideas is that two of the girls are like children and how they view the world, and the other two are more like the adults point of view on the world, so i am going to focus on this in my dance
ShortyUnited Kingdom
Hey im a AS studen too.. and ive been lookin at your comments n thanku..it's given me the confidence to carry on with the question..i hav'nt done much at all yet as i jus changed my question to this poem. But i hav chosen some music which i think will work..it's by Alsaints- pure shores..i think thats what it's called. it's from that movie..the Beach. hope dats ok. Thnx guys! XxXxX
DaniUnited Kingdom
hey im also i A level student and chose to do this poem as my option, i have figured out a couple of motifs which i could do but i am nt sure of the music that i could use any body got any sugestions?? plz help!! x x x
me :D
again another dancer!- i just want to wish every one the very best of luck for their exam and i hope whateva question u all decide to choose i reli hope it goes well :> dont let nerves get the better of you-go for it-show the world that the 16/17/18 year old dancers are going to be the next big thing :) go dancers go!!! xxxx
LizUnited Kingdom
Im also doing this dance for AS solo and am having real trouble with the music because my teacher wont let us use anything with a beat or lyrics or anything that sounds remotely good! im just wondering if anyone at other schools is allowed to do whatever music they like?
MikiUnited Kingdom
i'm doing this poem for my as solo! does any one know n e good web sites i can find more information on it or any suggestions for music ect.
katyUnited Kingdom
hey our question paper had the option maggie milly molly may but i chose bahrata natyam and i really had a hard time fifnding music for that also i have just perofrmed it to the examiner it was 4 counts to fat at the end which made me angry but i tried to improvise hehe !
kate
When was this poem written??
frankie gUnited States
this poem is amazing. it is beutifully written about 4 girls and a philosophy at the end. it is beutiful!
Homie JUnited States
I think that its great I think that it shows what we do to release stress what do you think? I also like it because of the philosophy at the end.
HannahUnited Kingdom
Hye i'm also doing this poem for my As Dance level and i did some research about this poem and think it may be about a lonely schizophrenic girl. Hope thats helpful. Good Luck everyone
BeccaUnited Kingdom
I've jsut done the poem for my AS level Dance (just this second finished the coursework =]). Love this poem, it was great to do the work on it. For everyone doing the exam, good luck! And for everyone who's already done it, I hope it went wel for you!
BrittanyUnited States
I am doing a research paper on this poem, and i need to find literary criticisms on it. I love this poem, but i have to find out what others think of it. Any suggestions
charlotteUnited Kingdom
i did the exam yesterday and i totally blagged it made half of it up and i think it went ok actually lol. can some one tell me what you think each chid means im stuck thanks
MOLLYUnited States
I LOVE THIS POEM!!! IT IS MY FAVORITE OF YOURS!!!!
PeterUnited Kingdom
Good to see that this amazing program is actually being taught, but there are clearly some who don't see the main point of the poem: what each girl finds is a reflection of herself. And isn't that what we all find in life?
strawberry shortcakeBulgaria
this poem helps you to realize that you can get lost at sea, and still enjoy yourself. this poem is a great way to share that people can have different sides of themselves, and that everyone has a part of them that is a kid. great job Mr. Cummings!!!
dynamyteUnited States
this poem showed me how to relive the good times and forget the bad times. it went deep
AlyssaUnited States
In my Literature Honors class we're studying poetry and this poem was in our textbook. When we first read it, we immediately thought, "Oh, it's just a poem about four girls having fun at the sea." However, once the teacher went over it in depth, lightbulbs began to flash.
I thoroughly enjoyed this poem, because it gave me a glimmmer of hope when I was having such a horrible day.
(:
Erika RoybalUnited States
This poem was very touching. It was a little bit on the confusing side, so I had to read it a few times. To me this poem shows that even if you are having a bad day, it is the little things in life that matter, it is not always the big things. Even the smallest things can help brighten your day,like for Maggie it was a shell that sang.
the ocean symbolizes a persons own mind and emotions and how you only have to look into your own soul to truely find yourself. cummings says, "as small as a world and as large as alone" to specify the complexities of the human soul.
This poem is about molly drowning at the beach. The horrible thing that chased her was a wave. What the other girls found is their reaction to the death of molly.
yassinMorocco
this poem is so interesting.it reveals the reality of our world in a poetique way.thanks cummings
LydiaUnited Kingdom
the more i research this dance for my AS level, there more i am growing to love it im basing each section aound each of the girls personalities, i cannt wait to get started.
i am the only person in my class doing the poem! almost everyone is doing the music. my only problem now is trying to get some music to fit in with how i want the dance to come out! has anyone got any advise on music they would like to tell me? it would be greatly appreciated!
x x x
coloChile
what is this poem about? why aren't the lines and the names of the pople capatilized and what does the last stanza mean?
coco**United States
this poem is really cool!! i LOOOOOVVVVEEE how it rhymes! irs so unique i love it!
AnnaUnited States
This is by far my favorite poem!
alan peanutsUnited States
na
this poem makes no sense to me at alll. I HATE IT!!!!
SharoUnited States
maggie and millie and molly and may
Learned of this poem when i was a little girl and it always seemed a little sad to me. Given the environmental desaster of the gusher in our Gulf, this poem has another layer of meaning and makes me even more sad when i read it today.
GuidoUnited Kingdom
Natalie Merchant has put this beautiful poem to music in her extraordinary album "Leave your Sleep". Well worth a listen.
KatyAustralia
Such a great poem with a great meaning.I just love it:)
this poem has a very deep meaning...this poem shows that it has been written by a person who learnt so many things from this world..who is very much experienced and mature...
This poem speaks of friendship, caring, sharing and self while the sea provides a blanket of cover. A very powerful message.
This poem has been a favorite of mine for over 25 years. I feel it expresses the fact we are attracted to those things that reflect our personalities. We all face similiar emotions. What better place to ponder and find ourselves than by the sea shore?
Characteristic of Cummings, there are words within words in this poem. For example, "beach" can be broken down into "be each." And notice that the phrases within the parentheses are virtually interchangeable.
The author uses alliteration very effectively throughout the poem. “Maggie and milly and molly and may,” is an obvious example of this. The opening line in which this alliteration appears, sets the tone for the rest of the poem. The similiarities in the four girls names create an image of four sisters, even quadruplets, who head to the beach to spend a summer day together. Alliteration is also used in the second stanza, “a shell that sang so sweetly she.” This is effective because it uses the softness of the “s” to portray to the reader the sound of singing that maggie found inside her shell.
This poem is so beautiful it comments for itself
I don't understand why it's necessary to completely dissect every bit of this poem. I think it speaks well for itself.
Cummings uses the two little girls as a tableu for life. The sea side is something we have all experienced as children and so the poet uses a nursery rhyme like tone to suggest this. The poet seems to suggest that as a child all our problems were non exsistent. We were satisfied with exploring the world around us. But as adults we end up having much more to worry about. Cummings seems to be saying that we could recapture our problemless childhood by returning to the sea, and uses alliteration and soft rolling words to echo the sound of the sea ,mainly through worlds with the letter S like stone.
Just discovered Cumming and still trying to get my head around him, but I LIKE.
i think one aspect of this poem is the fact that maggie and milly and molly and may are all seperate people who are different, but are drawn together by certain things, much like the sea and the sand and the rocks and the shells are all very different but connected by one thing
The poem had a very in depth meaning. Shows true character.
This poem has a very deep meaning & really made me think.I think E.E.Cumming is just great.
the poem says to me we can't escape who we are. and in my opinion "as small as a world and as large as alone" is the greatest line of poetry ever written.
This is one of the best poems i have ever read. It is in Adventures for Readers, and anthology. I first read it in 6th grade, and i loved it right away. I wish that the punctuation was not included, like the way e.e. cummings had originaly written it.
wow yall r 2 obssesed wit poems.....its just a poem
Here Cummings beautifully portrays how significant and creatively inspiring even the smallest of things can be. Sometimes, it is necessary to see that which is right in front of u, as poets we often delve to deeply...
this poem isn't actually all that deep
the last line tells you what the poem means as a whole
all of the things that the girls found depicted thier character. thats it what the heck is there to think about. but i think the poem is very funny and smart
this poem really starts on line 11
1. Many of you really need to improve your grammar.
2. I don't really know what this poem is saying, but I think it is saying that everyone discovers something different every day, whether that is good or bad.
3. I also think that Anna from the U.K. has provided a plausible explination, but forgot about the crab.
I think that this poem is the best poem that I had ever read. Usually I read Walt Whitman. I think that e.e cummings is good at writing the poems he writes, this poem is my favorite because of the assonance and alliteration in the poem.I think that he is better at writing poems than other poets. But that's only my opinion.
wow! i had no clue this poem was by ee cummings! i read this poem in...the fourth grade, i think...and i had absolutely NO CLUE it was by the one and only great poet ee cummings! maggie and milly and mollie and may is one of my favorite poems! -_^
anyways...let me explain to u what this poem means. In the title the girls names arent capitalized meaning he wants us to focus more on the subject matter rather than the people. Second Maggie is spelled differently than the rest telling us to focus on what she finds which takes her troubles away so the poem is about troubles. The Last stanza is telling us that we are not the only ones on this earth who have bad days or are feeling bad and that we can always find something or someone to ease our troubles.
Actually it is to my working knowledge, Richard, since I am pracitcally an expert on this poet, that Cummings does not captialize the names of the girls because part of his unique style is that he makes typical typographical errors. He seldom captitalizes anything.
Jamie, I think that Richard is correct. He uses caps for emphisisum. In the poem
"anyone lived in a pretty how town", one of my favorites, Cummings capitalizes
the word Woman twice. So in this poem, the names aren’t important. The
subject is. But you're right to Jamie. He doesn't oftenly capitalize. That's all I
wanted to say.
I have always thought that this poem was written about how different people react to the loss of loved ones in different ways. Some recover and some never truly do. I think that he used the alliteration of the names to show how alike the four subjects were and yet they all dealt with their loss in their own way. I do agree with Richard about the capitalization. ee cummings doesn't want us to focus on their names but on what they discovered down at the beach.
what does as small as a world and as large as alone mean?
maggie and milly and molly and may is a very good poem writen by e.e. cummings. i think the poem is a little confusing in the begging. i am doing a bio sketch about e.e. cummings for my english class and i needed to choose 2 poems by a poet, i choose e.e. cummings. the poems i choose were maggie and milly and molly and may, and anyone live in a pretty how town. i don't understand anyone live in a pretty how town but…
Read the whole commentmaggie and milly and molly and may is a very good poem writen by e.e. cummings. i think the poem is a little confusing in the begging. i am doing a bio sketch about e.e. cummings for my english class and i needed to choose 2 poems by a poet, i choose e.e. cummings. the poems i choose were maggie and milly and molly and may, and anyone live in a pretty how town. i don't understand anyone live in a pretty how town but i understand maggie and milly and molly and may more than i understand anyone live in a pretty how town. but i still need to understand both of them more than i do now. i do understand the first part of the poem maggie and milly and molly and may, but the last couple of stanzas make barely any sence to me. i know i am stupid but i still don't understand them. i need to understand them by tomorrow, because that is when my bio sketch is due, and i need to do that stupid bio sketch that is due tomorrow. but still even though e.e. cummings poems can be very confusing, he is still a wonderful very exellent poet, but i still need to do my bio sketch on e.e. cummings, and then i have to do a essay on maggie and milly and molly and may, and anyone live ina pretty how town, one essay for each poem, so that is one bio sketch on e.e. cummings, one essay on maggie and milly and molly and may, and one essay on anyone live in a pretty how town, so i need some help by tomorrow.
thIs PoEm ArE the GreaTeSt EvAr!
I have never thought of it as a poem about how we deal with loss of a loved one, but rather as the growing up of the four girls or four types of people rather. They go down to the sea which seems to me to be the great wide world. They leave home, go out into the world and what they learn of themselves is what they bring back. It is just a thought. The "small as a world and as large as alone" part is about the stone may finds as her mind or state of mind. Each of us carries around a little world in our heads, but for those of us who have felt loneliness, it is a state of mind, but it can feel so vast. The may type is a thinker/imaginer.
Does anyone remember this poem as a choral song? I sang it in 6th grade, back in 1970. I wonder who wrote the music?
i really liked this poem its pretty much about what u can find about yourself in unexpected places.
"may came home with a smooth round stone
as small as a world and as large as alone.
For whatever we lose(like a you or a me)
it's always ourselves we find in the sea"
^These lines are what the poem is mostly about. I agree with Dena from the U.S. that the line "as small as a world and as large as alone." Is one of the best lines of poetry ever written (maybe not THE best). The second to last line of this poem was also very strong, it is saying that if we lose our way in life (followed by the last line) that says we can always confide in the ocean.
E e cummings is my favorite poet ever, my brother likes T.S. Elliot, but I dunno I think Cummings owns.
a perfect poem about chidhood, loss and childhood
of course I meant childhood,loss and friendship
its one of E.E cummings better poems its positivly wonder
I have thoroughly enjoyed reading these comments about the poem. I am about to give a vocal recital this comming February and am doing research on my pieces. One of the pieces I am singing is "Seashore Girls" which is a musical setting of this poem by Richard Hundley. If any of you get a chance, you should find a copy of it. I found a few online, but they aren't the best in terms of quality.
I just thought I'd share. It's a beautiful setting. Hundley really captured what cummings wanted to say. Thanks again for the insight.
e.e. cummings rocks. This is one of my all-time favorite peoms in the world. And I believe that-
'may came home with a smooth round stone
as small as a world and as large as alone.' is the most memorable line is this poem, and perhaps at LEAST the second best piece of a poem in the world.
It comes off as meaning many different things to everyone, but no matter what it means, it always has a GREAT meaning. To be able to do that with just two lines of poetry is a wonderous thing. It speaks to the soul, and all that.
I think I read this poem in 7th grade!!!
ok so i'm not a poetry buff or anything, but i understood this poem as a discovery of personality traits. each girl finds out something different about themselves. i think that
"may came home with a smooth round stone
as small as a world and as large as alone."
can be interpreted as how no matter how big the world is, or how many people someone has that love and care about that person, he or she could still be very lonely.
Wow! I love that poem! It makes lots of sense and makes really good connections. Where do you get these ideas.
I think that this poem is about 4 different personalities of one woman. the light language contrasts with the deep meaning. It is about lonliness, isolation and inner self. Life can sem perfect on the outside, but inside, you are crying out and need to escaoe from your problems.
i think this poem has a brilliant message about personality and finding yourself. In this case a beach, where many years ago you would have found yourself with not as many troubles. I agree with the ccomment on looking at what Maggie found at the beach, as she is significant and should be a symbol/idol in what we all should hopefully find in ourselves. Very moving piece!
I believe the true genius of this poem is the mystery that radiates from it. At first it seems like a meaningless doodle, yet, as the vaugeness of it sinks in, you realize you don't REALLY know what he ment. cummings left us in the dark to discover our own opinions at the seashore.
I am doing my alevel dance and we have to produce a dance on this poem, im finding it hard to realise the inner feelings within the poem and wondering if you could help as its hard to put the feelings into the dance or what actions 2 use thanks x
I have just read the poem and my initial reactions were that it reminded me of old ladys staggering up to the bach, but once the get there they find their younger persona once again; which in tern makes them come alive! Sorry, I'm a dance student so i see everything in a sense of movement and colour! please comment on my interpretation- for i have no idea and cant find what he actually said! lol
please can anyone advise us in translating the meaning of the poem
we are both studying a level dance and are doing a dance on the poem
can anyone help???
I understand that the poem is represented in many ways about young girls and their differences in how they experience life. They all recieve different expectations of life.They have all grown up and become independant and faced different challenges and in the end they only have theirselves.
this poem is about 4 girls not really characters jst examples of everyday people it is about the journey of life startin off as children as in childhood we hang out in groups n play and there is alot of togertherness in youth. each character discovers something different from the sea {the sea is a metaphor for adult life} so as they grow up they discover thier own path in life ie maggie becomes a troubled individual…
Read the whole commentthis poem is about 4 girls not really characters jst examples of everyday people it is about the journey of life startin off as children as in childhood we hang out in groups n play and there is alot of togertherness in youth. each character discovers something different from the sea {the sea is a metaphor for adult life} so as they grow up they discover thier own path in life ie maggie becomes a troubled individual as she must {have troubles 2 be able 2 forget them} milly is a curious nuturing individual molly comes across to me as an active person very loud, and may comes across as the lonley indivdual. as small as aworld and as large as alone 2 me is the way we look at life u either see the world as a small place that u know of and are comfortable with or u see it as a big place that u r alone in and are scared of entering.the poem concludes with "for whatever we lose a you or a me it is always ourselfs we find in the sea" meaning as you grow up you find yourself your path in life u become an individual and you enter life |{the sea} on your own
i am also doing this for a level dance thats my interpretation id show togertherness and a childishness in begining growing into different independent characters {could show differences through different motifs for each character} think of life individuality and whatever comes to mind
I am also studying a level dance and have to produce a dance on the poem. i feel that the poem is about one person who finds many different personalities at the seaside. i feel this person would be quite old and find their inner, much younger selves!!
Im taking As-level dance and this poem sounded stupid to me as i read it without an open mind i just saw that it didnt rhyme and thought it was stupid but i guess looking at other peoples views on the poem makes me understand it more! i wasnt reali impressed with the questions we were given on the paper but i think i need to look more deeply into them to get a good full understanding on them. Thanks for ur opinions they reali have made me think!!
Basically I do AS level dance and I have to create a solo piece reflecting what the poem is trying to portrait. It seems to me to symbolise a persons search to find who they are in a world where its too easy to imitate others and conform. But I would like someone to further aliterate the depths of the poem aswell as give me and idea of how I could create a contemporary piece on the poem.
"Just discovered Cumming and still trying to get my head around him, but I LIKE."
Anna from United Kingdom
i have to study this poem for dance as level and i need some help from other dancers as to how they would portray each character and what motifs they might use. thank you dancers!!!
I am also doing AS dance and was drawn to this poem whereas other members of my class thought it was silly and has chosen other stimuli to use. i think that this could be quite a difficult one to do but could be done as a narrtive rather than abstract piece. dont no how i couold represent all four girls tho? any ideas?
I'm doing AS dance. You could try a split personality, try portraying all the 4 girls separately. Then you could say that it is like how the poem is structured, with set sections surrounding each girl?
Kx
i am studing this pome for as dance and would like to no the meaning behind this pome and some motifs i could use to help me with this pome please!!!
another person studying as dance......
silly exam boads eh??
asking silly questions
this is one of the harest bur=t easiet question to do out of the ones we were given other then using the sign language.....
i have been asked to research all the questions this is possibley the hardest to research plaese if you have any way you can help
[email removed]
I am an AS Dance student at the TAD (Turkish Association of Dance)
im doing AS dance, as most people, we too have been told to research all questions and this is the only one i have had trouble with. To Sarah, we were told that you would be better not trying to represent each character separatly but rather the story in depth and what you think the meaning of the overall poem might be. for example i thought it could be one person, and the different aspects of their personality.
like many of the other poeple who have commmented on this poem i am an AS dance student and have found some of the comments on this site very useful in my research as i felt it was important to find out other people's opinions on the poem. though i have found that no one has actually commmented on the fact that e e cummings does not use capital letters and puntuation in his writing which was due to his strong feeling against capitalism which delves into a whole other kettle of fish, i think u'll find!! i hope that this will add another dynamic to help your peice.... and good luck to every one!
i think th poem is about one woman who has diffrent moods and feelings and how she copes. the first (maggie) is her simple way of cope ing with stress and troubles. the seconed (milly)shows her frendly side and how she has no predudice. the 3rd (molly)shows how she is easily scared and runs from her problems and fears. the 4th (may) shows how no matter what she shows on the out side she allways feels alone and trapped as the sea is stopping her. the last bit to me means what eva we do or show on the outside within is very diffrent. thnx 4 reading xx
the idea of the whole four different personalities is brilliant and the way cummings refers to the beach because it is mainly everyones childhood memories. Can anyone think of a starting point for a motif because here i am totally lost? Thanks
hey i'm the same as everyone else i'm researching this poem for as dance, everyones comments have actually been helpful, but i think i might do the quote.
When I first looked at this question, I cried! But when I looked a little deeper, I came up with my own interpretation. I feel that the characters are just pretending that they are playing on the beach - a child-like game. The way the poem is written also suggests that it is meant to be read as if a child is telling a story without taking any breaths as 'and' is used to link every stanza!
like the last 10 comments i am also an as student of dance and studing the question i think that the girls are different personalites of one person and deal with different themes within the poem like childhood, loniness and the nusery style shows that going back to childhood can help you with your problems which is illustrated by the last two lines. the beach is a repersentative of the childhood and movement motifs could stat with beach play!
again...an AS stunent! no surprise there.
the style of this poem is child like so the movements and motifs should represent that, but in the second half of the poem, the tone changes. it becomes more subdued and fearful. possibly showing a different aspect to her personality.
she seems connected to the sea in some way, saying that she goes there to find herself.
cheers for reading this. its only my opinion, theres probably a million different interprataitons of it...
I just thought i'd share with you some of the ideas i have been looking at...
the star personality could involve a motif using the hand "five languid fingers" so the hand would be the focus point
Also Cummings experimented with Synta, which in this poem evidently creates a very strong rhythm!! so i have created a motif using that rhythm as the initial point...
Well, thats my input... hope it helps =)
Good luck y'all!!
Elodie
Hi, i just wanted to say how useful all these comments have been! I would like toknow if any of you know wether there are any other discussions going on on the other questions of the paper...
Many thanks!
Elodie.
This poem rocks my socks!
Youve probli guessed but I am also a dance AS student theres some realli great ideas here which are really helpful, does anybody know any websites for the other questions?...
Thanx and Good Luck.....
Hi. I am another AS student that is looking at this question for the final piece. My idea of the poem is that they could be all one person with different personalities or feelings. The beach is the most important thing. It's a place to make new friends however it is a place where there are troubles.
Cheers for reading this.
Loz
i dont really like your poem.
does it even matter if i am typing it is not like you are going to read it anyways!!!!!
if you do type back send me a way better poem PLEASE!!!!!!!
Hi, Yeh i am another AS dance student, and i really like the idea of choreographing a dance to this poem. I thought maybe that this poem has a number of people, for example sisters or close friends, all going on an adventure.. and where it says "may comes home with a smooth round stone" im thinking this person likes to keep memory to where she has been. I also feel that this poem is very relaxing and has a particular message for the reader.. but i am currently trying to find that out!! GD LUCK ALL THE AS DANCERS CHOOSING THIS QUESTION FOR THEIR EXAM PIECE xx
Heya, i am aother dance student making a solo to this poem and have spent hours trying to find inspiring yet practical music that relates to the poem. Ive heard that a song was actually composed about this poem but i cant get hold of it. I was jst wondering what other people's music choices are like? Thanks for your help...
hya i have chosen the poem question as well and i am struggling on a piece of music to go with the poem i dont have a clue.my thoughts are that you will always stay friends with close ones but as long as your find yourslf with time alone such as thy go down to the beach together but have thier own adventures become themselves and showing thier difrent intrests.if any1 can help me with my problem please email me or sometihing.thank youxx
im studying this question 4 my AS dance but am really stuck on movements and action, weve been given some useful information about the poem, saying that there were a number of topics it could have been based upon. I want to ask what others feel it is based on as we have been told it's about aliens, love/ sex, schkitophrenia, war or growing up and remembering loved ones that have passed on.
so plz could ppl tell me wot they think its bout as i dnt really no wot topic 2 chose
Thanx nicola
I really like the thought of doing this poem for as dance but would really appreciate a little background on it and some suggestions for some music as iam also finding this quite hard to find! thank you very much! jemima x
hi,i am a dance student too and i am thinking about doing this question. But id like some more information on its backround, and what sort of music should i play? x
maggie and milly and molly and may.... could they be four people or could they be just one person. Another point, the names maggie and miller etc are never written in capital letters as they should do, so has Cummings wrote this poem from a childs point of view, an example of this is on stanza four when Cummings writes "and molly was chased by a horrible thing" Adults generally would'nt say this so was this poem…
Read the whole commentmaggie and milly and molly and may.... could they be four people or could they be just one person.
Another point, the names maggie and miller etc are never written in capital letters as they should do, so has Cummings wrote this poem from a childs point of view, an example of this is on stanza four when Cummings writes "and molly was chased by a horrible thing" Adults generally would'nt say this so was this poem written from a childs point of view.
Is this poem based on memories or lonliness?
As for music i have no idea, although myself and two other people have suggested a song by Norah Jones
This was probably no help to anybody but anyway happy dancing and good luck with the exam in April
im doin alevel dance aswell n coniderin this question. i love it n was the 1st thing that jumped out at me. theres summit twited about it but i cant figure out what. xx
hiya. im studying A level dance aswell and i think this poem is a great option. Cummings life is very complex and his style of writing is so unique. i was considering using a piece of music based on the sea as each character shows their emotions or relationships with the sea and what they get from it. i think there are alot of hidden meanings and i was an excellent stimulus for my choreography.
hi
yes once again i am an A level dance student too! i am going to use the poem as my stimulus and i am hoping to use american hifi, its not easy being me. but not sure because the music has lyrics in it. i interpreted the poem as being about someone who doesnt want to let go of their chilhood and liked the idea of structuring the dance like a song,A B A C D structure. wat do you think mail me!
happy moving.
Hey, I am a AS Dance student, I have piked this poem but I am stuck on weather Maggie and Milly and Molly and May are 4 girls or only 1 with different personalites. Plus does any1 know the real meaning to this poem?
I am doing this 4 AS level dance and so far enjoy it we have only just started and am finding it really to come up the music.
im doing this poem for my AS DANCE too, has anyone made a start on it yet? Ive got quite a few ideas, motifs and steps and thought we could exchange ideas.
My interpretaion of this poem is that the speaker has lost herself. maggie, milly, molly, and may are the speakers attempts to find herself. In Maggie the speaker tried to drown out her troubles with a sweet song, which I take to mean that instead of dealing with her issues she igonored them and only payed attention to the things she could deal with. In Milly the speaker finds a star that is not where it belongs and…
Read the whole commentMy interpretaion of this poem is that the speaker has lost herself. maggie, milly, molly, and may are the speakers attempts to find herself. In Maggie the speaker tried to drown out her troubles with a sweet song, which I take to mean that instead of dealing with her issues she igonored them and only payed attention to the things she could deal with. In Milly the speaker finds a star that is not where it belongs and it has lost its spirit; it has become weak. I think this is how the speaker feels, stuck somewhere she doesn't belong and unable to do anything about it. In Molly the speaker's worst fear comes true: that she cannot solve her problem, that it will destroy her. What sticks out to me the most is that May is the only one that "came home". In May, the speaker figures it out. She "came home with a smooth round stone". Stones become smooth and round after years of being hit by water. She has found herself! She is a product of all her experiences, she was molded over time. However, this "her" she found is alone, and that feeling makes the size of the world seem like nothing. She found herself at the sea, the sea being her thinking over her experinces and her life as a whole. That's why she went to the beach in the first place. The beach is a place where she can think about her life (represented by the sea) and find her answer.
WEll...........HELP!!!!!
me and jen cant find any research on this damn poem, it just tells us the poem, and gives us no information on the structurew themes and main ideas etc...
But overal, a lovely poem which can b well interpretated into an A* Dance...LOL!!!!!!!!!!!!
good luck with yours
love jen and jen
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
Hey yup as level dance student and i have chosen this poem. I think there are four separate girls each who deal with theair problems in a different way. I got stressed out too and my teacher just told me to go and paddle in the sea! It really helped. I am trying to come up with a motif for "and" because I think it is significant. I also think this poem is about death and grief and getting through the different stages, ignoring it, running away from it, confronting it and finally getting through it. I have made some of my movements very childlike, eg head tilts focus down, etc. I would be grateful for anyone else's help. Thanks
hey peeps,
i chose this one 2. i couldn't decide what 2 make of this poem + my latest idea is that the 1 speaker is in turmoil with herself and how she endeavours to cope with these strong, almost sctizophrenic (soz spelling!) trates of personality but im totally baffled by the end line what do you think peeps? ps monica think your interpretations are tres good :) xxxx
obviously another dancer, thought id give my input. basically what im doing, is taking each character and giving them a different personality, so scared, happy, sad etc. and portraying these personalities through movement. the sea, being a recurring theme in the poem will be a recurring theme in the dance. I am going to make up a section for the sea, and repeat it after every character, so the dance will be in…
Read the whole commentobviously another dancer, thought id give my input. basically what im doing, is taking each character and giving them a different personality, so scared, happy, sad etc. and portraying these personalities through movement. the sea, being a recurring theme in the poem will be a recurring theme in the dance. I am going to make up a section for the sea, and repeat it after every character, so the dance will be in rondeaux form - a b a c a d e etc... i have also got one motif which i start off with, and then repeat it in every section with developments...for instance my character for may is a sad one, so i will perform the phrase maybe more slowly and with smaller movements, maybe floorwork.
this is such a hard question to put into movement, obviously there are lots of ideas about what the poem means, but to put it into movement is a different matter. this probably hasn't helped anybody...but i guess its a good idea to know how other people are handling the question....good luck everyone!
xxxxx
Hi
I'm doing this question for AS dance as well but I'm finding it really hard to find the right music. Does anyone have any idea what music to use?
Thanks
This is a great poem commenting on what life has to offer us. Here cummings has taken the example of the sea to tell us it's worth. The sea has so much to offer. It is a place to relax for some while for others it's a 'dangerous' place. However, through the children characters, cummings is trying to explain that exploration is the answer to a lot of questions regarding life. Life is to be lived fully and we need to work out reasons for the way we think and behave. Life isn't always 'rosey' as milly and molly experience but it could be funful according to maggie and may. Your concept of life is based on your emotions and experiences-good or bad.
iv choosen the poem as my AS dance stimulus. Having completed my dance i now have the task of fitting music to it iv found that a good song is hold tight by the chemical brothers, it has an underlying beat and a solo voice, you can change the dynamics of your dance very easily by switchiing between following the rhythm of the beat or the solo voice. might be some help to you.
good luck!
hollie x
This is one of my favorite poems. It was my dad's favorite poem, and he passed away a little while back, so this poem has burrowed itself like a clam in my chest, and each time I read it I feel the sea swell into my eyes, and my heart breaks a million times over...
I love this poem. For me it shows how our inner emotional world creates the world we find outside ourself. Knowing this gives us choice and freedom: we choose what kind of worlds we create, both inside our deepest self and with other people.
We as a class have started really late on ours and i mean like last week! Everyones comments have been so good, as it has given me an insight into what i can do! But has anyone else found the questions this year really random and hard to do? I do like this poem and after looking at it for longer, i apresheate what it means. For example my ideas is that two of the girls are like children and how they view the world, and the other two are more like the adults point of view on the world, so i am going to focus on this in my dance
Hey im a AS studen too.. and ive been lookin at your comments n thanku..it's given me the confidence to carry on with the question..i hav'nt done much at all yet as i jus changed my question to this poem. But i hav chosen some music which i think will work..it's by Alsaints- pure shores..i think thats what it's called. it's from that movie..the Beach. hope dats ok. Thnx guys! XxXxX
hey im also i A level student and chose to do this poem as my option, i have figured out a couple of motifs which i could do but i am nt sure of the music that i could use any body got any sugestions?? plz help!! x x x
again another dancer!- i just want to wish every one the very best of luck for their exam and i hope whateva question u all decide to choose i reli hope it goes well :> dont let nerves get the better of you-go for it-show the world that the 16/17/18 year old dancers are going to be the next big thing :) go dancers go!!! xxxx
Im also doing this dance for AS solo and am having real trouble with the music because my teacher wont let us use anything with a beat or lyrics or anything that sounds remotely good! im just wondering if anyone at other schools is allowed to do whatever music they like?
i'm doing this poem for my as solo! does any one know n e good web sites i can find more information on it or any suggestions for music ect.
hey our question paper had the option maggie milly molly may but i chose bahrata natyam and i really had a hard time fifnding music for that also i have just perofrmed it to the examiner it was 4 counts to fat at the end which made me angry but i tried to improvise hehe !
When was this poem written??
this poem is amazing. it is beutifully written about 4 girls and a philosophy at the end. it is beutiful!
I think that its great I think that it shows what we do to release stress what do you think? I also like it because of the philosophy at the end.
Hye i'm also doing this poem for my As Dance level and i did some research about this poem and think it may be about a lonely schizophrenic girl. Hope thats helpful. Good Luck everyone
I've jsut done the poem for my AS level Dance (just this second finished the coursework =]). Love this poem, it was great to do the work on it. For everyone doing the exam, good luck! And for everyone who's already done it, I hope it went wel for you!
I am doing a research paper on this poem, and i need to find literary criticisms on it. I love this poem, but i have to find out what others think of it. Any suggestions
i did the exam yesterday and i totally blagged it made half of it up and i think it went ok actually lol. can some one tell me what you think each chid means im stuck
thanks
I LOVE THIS POEM!!! IT IS MY FAVORITE OF YOURS!!!!
Good to see that this amazing program is actually being taught, but there are clearly some who don't see the main point of the poem: what each girl finds is a reflection of herself. And isn't that what we all find in life?
this poem helps you to realize that you can get lost at sea, and still enjoy yourself. this poem is a great way to share that people can have different sides of themselves, and that everyone has a part of them that is a kid. great job Mr. Cummings!!!
this poem showed me how to relive the good times and forget the bad times. it went deep
In my Literature Honors class we're studying poetry and this poem was in our textbook. When we first read it, we immediately thought, "Oh, it's just a poem about four girls having fun at the sea." However, once the teacher went over it in depth, lightbulbs began to flash.
I thoroughly enjoyed this poem, because it gave me a glimmmer of hope when I was having such a horrible day.
(:
This poem was very touching. It was a little bit on the confusing side, so I had to read it a few times. To me this poem shows that even if you are having a bad day, it is the little things in life that matter, it is not always the big things. Even the smallest things can help brighten your day,like for Maggie it was a shell that sang.
the ocean symbolizes a persons own mind and emotions and how you only have to look into your own soul to truely find yourself. cummings says, "as small as a world and as large as alone" to specify the complexities of the human soul.
This poem is about molly drowning at the beach. The horrible thing that chased her was a wave. What the other girls found is their reaction to the death of molly.
this poem is so interesting.it reveals the reality of our world in a poetique way.thanks cummings
the more i research this dance for my AS level, there more i am growing to love it
im basing each section aound each of the girls personalities, i cannt wait to get started.
i am the only person in my class doing the poem! almost everyone is doing the music.
my only problem now is trying to get some music to fit in with how i want the dance to come out!
has anyone got any advise on music they would like to tell me? it would be greatly appreciated!
x x x
what is this poem about? why aren't the lines and the names of the pople capatilized and what does the last stanza mean?
this poem is really cool!! i LOOOOOVVVVEEE how it rhymes! irs so unique i love it!
This is by far my favorite poem!
na
this poem makes no sense to me at alll. I HATE IT!!!!
maggie and millie and molly and may
Learned of this poem when i was a little girl and it always seemed a little sad to me. Given the environmental desaster of the gusher in our Gulf, this poem has another layer of meaning and makes me even more sad when i read it today.
Natalie Merchant has put this beautiful poem to music in her extraordinary album "Leave your Sleep". Well worth a listen.
Such a great poem with a great meaning.I just love it:)
Yes molly, we hear you.