How countlessly they congregate
O'er our tumultuous snow,
Which flows in shapes as tall as trees
When wintry winds do blow!--
As if with keenness for our fate,
Our faltering few steps on
To white rest, and a place of rest
Invisible at dawn,--
And yet with neither love nor hate,
Those stars like some snow-white
Minerva's snow-white marble eyes
Without the gift of sight.
✦
From the bookA Boy's WillFirst US edition, Henry Holt, 1915, in its dust jacket
Analysis
Stars: analysis
Introduction
This is a short lyric in three quatrains. A speaker looks at the stars crowded over a snowy, windswept landscape. The first two stanzas seem to credit the stars with an interest in human beings and their fate.
The last stanza takes that back. The stars watch "with neither love nor hate". They are compared to the blank marble eyes of a statue of Minerva. The poem sets human frailty, pictured as a few faltering steps through snow, against a sky that looks attentive but sees nothing.
Summary
The first stanza describes the stars. They gather in countless numbers over the snow. The snow is called "tumultuous". When the winter winds blow, it flows into shapes "as tall as trees". The stanza ends with an exclamation mark and a dash, so the sentence runs on.
The second stanza says the stars seem to watch with keen interest in "our fate". That fate is pictured as a few faltering steps. The steps lead on "To white rest, and a place of rest". That place is "Invisible at dawn". The stanza again ends with a dash, and the sentence continues into the next stanza.
The third stanza qualifies what came before. It opens with "And yet". The stars watch "with neither love nor hate". They are likened to the snow-white marble eyes of Minerva. Those eyes are "Without the gift of sight". The poem, punctuated as one long sentence, ends here on its only full stop.
Themes and meaning
The central idea is the indifference of the stars. Stanza two grants them a "keenness for our fate". But the words "As if" in line 5 mark that interest as only an appearance. Line 9 states it plainly: the stars feel "neither love nor hate". They are neither friends nor enemies of the people below.
A second theme is human frailty and death. Line 6 speaks of "Our faltering few steps". The word "few" sets a short human span against "countlessly" in line 1. The steps lead "To white rest", which can be read as death in the snow, or as death in general. The phrase "a place of rest" is a familiar way of naming a grave.
The phrase "Invisible at dawn" is ambiguous. It may describe the place of rest, hidden by drifting snow by morning. On that reading, the human trace simply vanishes. It may also glance back at the stars themselves, which fade from sight at dawn.
The poem also turns on the difference between looking and seeing. The stars have eyes of a kind, but they are "Minerva's snow-white marble eyes". Minerva is a goddess of wisdom, yet her statue cannot see. The closing line, "Without the gift of sight", empties the stars of the knowledge the speaker had half granted them.
The poem can be read as a comment on fate. Stars are traditionally tied to destiny, and line 5 names "our fate" directly. If the stars are blind, they cannot read or direct that fate. A gentler reading is also possible. The stars still preside over the "place of rest", even if they do so without feeling.
Whiteness links the whole poem. The snow of stanza one, the "white rest" of stanza two and the "snow-white marble" of stanza three share one colour. Earth and sky become one cold, blank surface.
Tone
The tone opens in wonder. "How countlessly they congregate" is an exclamation, and line 4 ends with "blow!". The storm and the crowded sky are presented with energy.
In stanza two the tone grows sombre. "As if" introduces doubt. The "faltering few steps" bring a note of pity for human weakness.
The final stanza is cool and plain. "And yet" marks the turn. The speaker states the stars' blindness without protest or grief. The calm of the ending can be read as acceptance. It can also be read as a quiet chill.
Form and structure
The poem has 12 lines in 3 stanzas of 4 lines each. Lines range from 6 to 8 syllables. The metre is iambic, mixing four-beat lines with three-beat lines such as "When wintry winds do blow". The pattern is loose rather than strict.
The rhyme scheme is ABCB ADEF AGHG. One rhyme sound opens every stanza: "congregate", "fate" and "hate". Within stanzas, "snow" rhymes with "blow" and "white" with "sight". The mechanical count finds no rhyme in stanza two, though on and "dawn" come close. Dashes at the ends of stanzas one and two carry the sentence across the breaks.
Poetic devices
personification line 1
How countlessly they congregate The stars gather like a crowd or a congregation. The verb gives them the look of beings assembled to watch, which the last stanza undoes.
simile line 3
in shapes as tall as trees The drifts are measured against trees. The comparison makes the wind-driven snow large and threatening beside the human figures of stanza two.
alliteration line 4
When wintry winds do blow The repeated w sound imitates the wind and ties the storm into one sound.
enjambment line 6
Our faltering few steps on The line breaks on on, so the reader must move forward into line 7, much as the steps move on toward rest.
repetition line 7
To white rest, and a place of rest "rest" is said twice. The second phrase restates the first more concretely and makes the ending of the journey feel final.
euphemism line 7
a place of rest The phrase can be read as a gentle name for a grave, so death is present without being named.
antithesis line 9
with neither love nor hate Two opposite feelings are both denied. The stars are placed outside human feeling altogether.
allusion line 11
Minerva's snow-white marble eyes The goddess of wisdom appears only as a statue. Her blank stone eyes become the image of stars that seem to see but do not.
irony line 12
Without the gift of sight The poem ends by denying sight to the things that seemed to watch over everything. The watchers are blind.
rhyme line 9
And yet with neither love nor hate "hate" completes the rhyme with "congregate" and "fate". The rhyme that opens every stanza lands on the word that states the stars' indifference.
Words worth knowing
O'er
A poetic contraction of 'over', said as one syllable.
tumultuous
Wildly agitated and disordered. Here it describes snow driven about by the wind.
faltering
Unsteady and stumbling, as of someone losing strength.
Minerva
The Roman goddess of wisdom. Here she stands for a statue of her with blank marble eyes.
congregate
To gather in a crowd. It can also recall a congregation assembled for worship.
Context
The poem appeared in Robert Frost's first book, A Boy's Will, published in 1913. It is the sixth poem in that book.
What readers have said
Anna read the poem as about the frailty of human life, with our "few steps" set against the stars, and identified Minerva as the goddess of wisdom. Anna, 2005
Scott took the stars as a symbol of fate and argued that calling them blind, above the chaos of the snow, shows scepticism about fate itself. Scott, 2006
Tevye saw the stars as calm, amoral observers linked to astrology, guiding people toward the grave without knowing their own function. Tevye, 2007
Melissa read the stars more hopefully, as guides through a chaotic life that promise a place of peace with God. MELISSA, 2006
Jocelyn objected that others were reading too deeply and took the poem as a literal description of countless stars clustered over a winter landscape. jocelyn, 2007
well, this poem was titled stars, and i love the stars. but i really didn't understand the poem, oh well
maddieUnited States
this poem is an amazing poem. i really got what he was trying to say about the stars.
Alvin HandelmanUnited States
There are two errors in the last stanza of the poem. "starts" should be stars and "somw" should be some.
CourtneyUnited States
They are countless have you ever wonder about them??
AnnaUnited States
"Stars" by Robert Frost is a poem about the frailty of human life. "Our faltering few steps" means that our lives are only a few steps compared to the stars. Minerva is the goddess of wisdom in Greek mythology and(as far as I can tell) the poem is talking about the first statue made of her (now in the Louvre) made of ivory.
I don't get it! I truely do not get this poem's meaning and what it is talking about.
LynnUnited States
It's about how frail life is. How countlessly they congregate - There's alot of people that die, and keep dying. O'er our tumultuous snow - Just talking about the earth and how unsteady it is. tumultuous means noisy and disorderly so it's prolly just talking about the human race on earth in general and how disorderly we are in our ways. Keen-ness for our fate - meaning greif for our fate. our faltering few steps on…
Read the whole comment
It's about how frail life is. How countlessly they congregate - There's alot of people that die, and keep dying. O'er our tumultuous snow - Just talking about the earth and how unsteady it is. tumultuous means noisy and disorderly so it's prolly just talking about the human race on earth in general and how disorderly we are in our ways. Keen-ness for our fate - meaning greif for our fate. our faltering few steps on - faltering is to be unsteady in purpose due to lack of courage or will.
And yet with neither love nor hate, [God doesn't help us to stay alive or anything, but he's never shown hate.] Those stars like some snow-white Minerva's snow-white marble eyes [Goddess of wisdom of course.] Without the gift of sight. [failure to see how precious our lives really are.]
It could be about human frailty, as already stated, but I actually think this about Frost's skepticism of fate. Often in poetry, "stars" are synonomous with fate. With this poem, Frost is calling the stars "blind." "How countlessly they congregate o'er the tumultuous snow." He sites the mad chaos (the tumultuous snow) of the world as proof against the existence of fate.
Dude! Lynn is a smart one! Thank you Lynn! I totally get this poem now! GENIUS!
MELISSAUnited States
stars help guide us through this chaotic life. they assure us of a place of peace (with God).
jocelynCanada
Jeepers! You guys are all thinking too deeply. Its just talking about the stars! frost is a pascal poet. he talks about the country side, nature, horses. stars countlessly they congregate- just look at the stars. There are too many to count and they are all clustered there, They congregate together. O'er the tumultuous snow-hes again describing them how theyre noisy and disorderly. Theyre not arrnged in some type of pattern. DISORDERLY. u can find shapes in them, some as tall as trees. Theyre invisible to us at dawn. they dont love or hate. they are as white as miinervas eyes.(ivory) and they of course cannot see!
i love it...mcdonalds! no i mean the poem stars by roberto froste
abu mohammad DECKERCzech Republic
i love the poem it is very exotic just like me, i like to dance in the meadow of daisies with my doggie berto he is my hero, i like long walks on the beach and i like listening to classical yoga music, i have my own bobblehead.
AMERICA!i live in america not canadaAustralia
this poem is about love not hate and about the snow and the stars combined...you are all wrong about what it is about!
Roberto accion!Italy
i think we should all direct our focus to what really matters...Jake and hannah accioning! thats right you know what im talking about and you know why its vital..so yea who wants arbys.
ADMINISTRATORUnited States
All comments will be reviewed before posting due to the inappropriate use of this site. You may not post anything including Nudity, Porfainity, or Gang Slogans. Thank you and please appreciate this site. Do not disobey these laws or we will be forced to shut this site down.
blubberUnited States
makes no sense
GeeCanada
This poem from Robert Frost is about humans and Minerva “the stars” and goddess of wisdom. How countlessly they congregate – There are so many gathered that it’s impossible to count them. Means they are present. O'er our tumultuous snow - Tumultuous means noisy and disorderly so he’s probably just talking about the humans on earth in general and how chaotic and disorderly they are. O’er means over, Minerva is over…
Read the whole comment
This poem from Robert Frost is about humans and Minerva “the stars” and goddess of wisdom. How countlessly they congregate – There are so many gathered that it’s impossible to count them. Means they are present. O'er our tumultuous snow - Tumultuous means noisy and disorderly so he’s probably just talking about the humans on earth in general and how chaotic and disorderly they are. O’er means over, Minerva is over us. Keenness for our fate - Meaning grief for our fate.
Our faltering few steps on - Faltering is to be unsteady in purpose due to lack of courage or will so It means that humans hesitate and are do unsteady actions.
And yet with neither love nor hate - Minerva “the stars” doesn’t help us to stay alive or anything, but he has never shown hate either, she is impartial.
Minerva's snow-white marble eyes – Minerva is the goddess of wisdom, she judges what is right and what has to happen. Without the gift of sight – She can’t see us to help us
this poem is bogus, if it is called stars then frikin talk about the stars dont go talkin bout the snow or whateva, who here thinks spongebob is awesome lol
TevyeUnited States
The poem clearly contrasts the placidity of the stars, blind observers of human conflict as well as a means of telling the future (Frost clearly references astrology ). The stars are amoral. They guide us into the ground by destiny without being aware of their higher function.
JackChile
This poem closely relates to Bubba Sparxx Song Miss New Booty-Check it out
nathanCzech Republic
this poem sucks!!!!!!
KAWALDEEPCHHABRAIndia
A GOOD POEM WRITTEN BY A GOOD PERSON.
Emily DuBreeUnited States
I love this poem
DGK*Cuba
This poem... Is the Biggest Crock of crap i have ever read!! I also agree it is alot like the song miss new booty DGK* 4 life
well, this poem was titled stars, and i love the stars. but i really didn't understand the poem, oh well
this poem is an amazing poem. i really got what he was trying to say about the stars.
There are two errors in the last stanza of the poem.
"starts" should be stars and "somw" should be some.
They are countless have you ever wonder about them??
"Stars" by Robert Frost is a poem about the frailty of human life. "Our faltering few steps" means that our lives are only a few steps compared to the stars. Minerva is the goddess of wisdom in Greek mythology and(as far as I can tell) the poem is talking about the first statue made of her (now in the Louvre) made of ivory.
I don't get it! I truely do not get this poem's meaning and what it is talking about.
It's about how frail life is. How countlessly they congregate - There's alot of people that die, and keep dying. O'er our tumultuous snow - Just talking about the earth and how unsteady it is. tumultuous means noisy and disorderly so it's prolly just talking about the human race on earth in general and how disorderly we are in our ways. Keen-ness for our fate - meaning greif for our fate. our faltering few steps on…
Read the whole commentIt's about how frail life is.
How countlessly they congregate - There's alot of people that die, and keep dying.
O'er our tumultuous snow - Just talking about the earth and how unsteady it is. tumultuous means noisy and disorderly so it's prolly just talking about the human race on earth in general and how disorderly we are in our ways.
Keen-ness for our fate - meaning greif for our fate.
our faltering few steps on - faltering is to be unsteady in purpose due to lack of courage or will.
And yet with neither love nor hate, [God doesn't help us to stay alive or anything, but he's never shown hate.]
Those stars like some snow-white
Minerva's snow-white marble eyes [Goddess of wisdom of course.]
Without the gift of sight. [failure to see how precious our lives really are.]
It could be about human frailty, as already stated, but I actually think this about Frost's skepticism of fate. Often in poetry, "stars" are synonomous with fate. With this poem, Frost is calling the stars "blind." "How countlessly they congregate o'er the tumultuous snow." He sites the mad chaos (the tumultuous snow) of the world as proof against the existence of fate.
Dude! Lynn is a smart one! Thank you Lynn! I totally get this poem now! GENIUS!
stars help guide us through this chaotic life. they assure us of a place of peace (with God).
Jeepers! You guys are all thinking too deeply. Its just talking about the stars! frost is a pascal poet. he talks about the country side, nature, horses. stars
countlessly they congregate- just look at the stars. There are too many to count and they are all clustered there, They congregate together.
O'er the tumultuous snow-hes again describing them how theyre noisy and disorderly. Theyre not arrnged in some type of pattern. DISORDERLY.
u can find shapes in them, some as tall as trees. Theyre invisible to us at dawn. they dont love or hate. they are as white as miinervas eyes.(ivory) and they of course cannot see!
i love it...mcdonalds! no i mean the poem stars by roberto froste
i love the poem it is very exotic just like me, i like to dance in the meadow of daisies with my doggie berto he is my hero, i like long walks on the beach and i like listening to classical yoga music, i have my own bobblehead.
this poem is about love not hate and about the snow and the stars combined...you are all wrong about what it is about!
i think we should all direct our focus to what really matters...Jake and hannah accioning! thats right you know what im talking about and you know why its vital..so yea who wants arbys.
All comments will be reviewed before posting due to the inappropriate use of this site. You may not post anything including Nudity, Porfainity, or Gang Slogans. Thank you and please appreciate this site. Do not disobey these laws or we will be forced to shut this site down.
makes no sense
This poem from Robert Frost is about humans and Minerva “the stars” and goddess of wisdom. How countlessly they congregate – There are so many gathered that it’s impossible to count them. Means they are present. O'er our tumultuous snow - Tumultuous means noisy and disorderly so he’s probably just talking about the humans on earth in general and how chaotic and disorderly they are. O’er means over, Minerva is over…
Read the whole commentThis poem from Robert Frost is about humans and Minerva “the stars” and goddess of wisdom.
How countlessly they congregate – There are so many gathered that it’s impossible to count them. Means they are present.
O'er our tumultuous snow - Tumultuous means noisy and disorderly so he’s probably just talking about the humans on earth in general and how chaotic and disorderly they are. O’er means over, Minerva is over us.
Keenness for our fate - Meaning grief for our fate.
Our faltering few steps on - Faltering is to be unsteady in purpose due to lack of courage or will so It means that humans hesitate and are do unsteady actions.
And yet with neither love nor hate - Minerva “the stars” doesn’t help us to stay alive or anything, but he has never shown hate either, she is impartial.
Minerva's snow-white marble eyes – Minerva is the goddess of wisdom, she judges what is right and what has to happen.
Without the gift of sight – She can’t see us to help us
i agree with that GEE guy~
this poem is bogus, if it is called stars then frikin talk about the stars dont go talkin bout the snow or whateva, who here thinks spongebob is awesome lol
The poem clearly contrasts the placidity of the stars, blind observers of human conflict as well as a means of telling the future (Frost clearly references astrology ). The stars are amoral. They guide us into the ground by destiny without being aware of their higher function.
This poem closely relates to Bubba Sparxx Song Miss New Booty-Check it out
this poem sucks!!!!!!
A GOOD POEM WRITTEN BY A GOOD PERSON.
I love this poem
This poem... Is the Biggest Crock of crap i have ever read!! I also agree it is alot like the song miss new booty DGK* 4 life