A stranger came to the door at eve,
And he spoke the bridegroom fair.
He bore a green-white stick in his hand,
And, for all burden, care.
He asked with the eyes more than the lips
For a shelter for the night,
And he turned and looked at the road afar
Without a window light.
The bridegroom came forth into the porch
With, 'Let us look at the sky,
And question what of the night to be,
Stranger, you and I.'
The woodbine leaves littered the yard,
The woodbine berries were blue,
Autumn, yes, winter was in the wind;
'Stranger, I wish I knew.'
Within, the bride in the dusk alone
Bent over the open fire,
Her face rose-red with the glowing coal
And the thought of the heart's desire.
The bridegroom looked at the weary road,
Yet saw but her within,
And wished her heart in a case of gold
And pinned with a silver pin.
The bridegroom thought it little to give
A dole of bread, a purse,
A heartfelt prayer for the poor of God,
Or for the rich a curse;
But whether or not a man was asked
To mar the love of two
By harboring woe in the bridal house,
The bridegroom wished he knew.
✦
From the bookA Boy's WillFirst US edition, Henry Holt, 1915, in its dust jacket
Analysis
Love and a Question: analysis
Introduction
A stranger asks for shelter at a house where a bride and bridegroom are alone together. The bridegroom recognizes the visitor's need, but hesitates over what admitting him would mean for the couple's private happiness. The poem ends with that hesitation unresolved.
The conflict is more difficult than a choice between generosity and obvious cruelty. The bridegroom can imagine giving food, money, or a prayer. What troubles him is the possibility of bringing another person's suffering inside the space of love. The poem asks where care for one person meets responsibility toward a stranger.
Summary
A stranger arrives at the door in the evening and addresses the bridegroom courteously. He carries a green-white stick, while care is described as his only burden. He asks for a night's shelter chiefly through his eyes. He also looks toward a distant road without a lighted window.
The bridegroom comes onto the porch and proposes that they examine the sky together. Autumn leaves and blue berries lie around the yard, and the wind suggests the approach of winter. The bridegroom says that he wishes he knew what the night would bring.
Inside the house, the bride bends over the fire. Her face is red from the glowing coal and her thoughts of desire. The bridegroom looks toward the road but sees her in his mind. He imagines preserving her heart in a precious case.
He regards bread, money, and prayer as comparatively small gifts. Yet he cannot decide whether a man must damage the love of two people by admitting sorrow into their bridal home. The final stanza repeats his wish to know.
Themes and meaning
The threshold gives the moral conflict a physical shape. The stranger stands outside, the bride remains inside, and the bridegroom moves onto the porch between them. The house promises intimacy and warmth. The road, fading light, and approaching cold make the visitor's need more pressing. Neither place can be considered without the other.
The poem distinguishes giving something away from sharing a protected space. Bread, money, and prayer can be offered while the giver's domestic life remains intact. Shelter requires a different intimacy with the person in need. The bridegroom's difficulty arises when charity might interrupt the happiness he wishes to guard.
His protective image of the bride's heart is itself complicated. Gold and silver suggest preciousness, but a heart enclosed and pinned might also seem constrained. Love's wish to preserve something can approach a wish to seal it off from other people. The poem does not explicitly condemn that wish, but lets its physical image carry tension.
The stranger can be read as a figure for sorrow, death, or an unforeseen obligation. The wording about harboring woe encourages a broader reading than the literal request alone. However, nothing identifies him conclusively as a supernatural being. The unresolved question retains its force whether he represents an abstraction or is simply a person needing a bed.
Tone
The tone is quiet, courteous, and increasingly troubled. The visitor's restrained request does not produce an argument. Instead, the bridegroom talks about the weather and the night. His uncertainty is expressed indirectly through the scene before it becomes an explicit question about obligation.
The firelit description of the bride is tender and intimate. It makes the happiness at stake understandable. The contrast with the weary road prevents that warmth from settling the matter. At the close, the repeated wish to know sounds troubled rather than triumphant. The narrator withholds a verdict, leaving readers within the bridegroom's hesitation.
Form and structure
The poem has thirty-two lines arranged in six stanzas. The first two stanzas have eight lines each, and the remaining four have four lines each. Within successive four-line units, second and fourth lines regularly rhyme. These repetitions give the narrative a ballad-like movement.
Longer and shorter lines alternate broadly, with variation in syllable count and stress. The first stanzas establish the visitor and the setting before the later quatrains narrow attention to the bridegroom's thoughts. The repeated wished-to-know phrasing links the question about the night with the unresolved question about love and duty.
Poetic devices
Diction line 4
And, for all burden, care. The traveler’s burden is named as an emotional condition rather than luggage. The phrasing introduces suffering as something that may enter the house with him.
Metonymy line 5
He asked with the eyes more than the lips The eyes carry the request without a full reported speech. This emphasis makes need visible while keeping the stranger’s personal story unstated.
Visual contrast line 8
Without a window light. The unlighted road contrasts with the fire inside. The difference makes shelter materially important before the bridegroom considers its moral cost.
Seasonal imagery line 15
Autumn, yes, winter was in the wind; The correction from autumn toward winter intensifies the prospect of cold. It raises the stakes of leaving the stranger outdoors.
Color imagery line 19
Her face rose-red with the glowing coal The warm color joins the bride to the interior fire. This image gives the protected domestic world an immediate physical attraction.
Metaphor line 23
And wished her heart in a case of gold The heart becomes a precious object that might be enclosed. The wish can suggest tenderness, but also the limiting effects of excessive protection.
Listing line 26
A dole of bread, a purse, Material gifts are set beside spiritual gestures in the surrounding lines. The list distinguishes manageable charity from allowing another person inside.
Abstract personification line 31
By harboring woe in the bridal house, The visitor’s suffering becomes something that can be housed. The phrasing brings the literal request into contact with the couple’s emotional life.
Words worth knowing
eve
Evening.
fair
Courteously or pleasantly, describing the stranger’s manner of speaking.
woodbine
A climbing plant, supplying leaves and berries in the yard.
dole
A small charitable portion or gift.
harboring
Giving shelter to or allowing something to remain within.
What readers have said
Lisbet reads a conflict over shelter and revises an earlier interpretation that the couple do not love one another. Lisbet, 2005
Whitney interprets the stranger as death and the evening and winter imagery as signs of old age. Whitney, 2005
Terry Berg reads the visitor as a disruptive opportunity or life-changing possibility confronting a man who has established a safe domestic life. Terry Berg, 2005
it is not a stor and it ia aout how two poeple are forced tobe together when really they love eachother not
LisbetUnited States
The title automatically says something about the story. Obviously, the first word, "love" is understood for its meaning but then it says AND a question..so there might be doubts in the relationship which is what this narrative poem is about, 2 people who really don't know a lot about each other and they regret getting married.
KateUnited States
I like this poem a lot. I do no tknow what it means, exactly but I think that the people who are married are not exactly in love. Maybe that is what Robert Frost meant but, if not, we will never know.
LisbetUnited States
first of all i take back what i commented b/c because i was wrong. It is a narrative poem(obviously) and it IS NOT ABOUT TWO PEOPLE WHO DON'T LOVE EACH OTHER. The starnger goes to the door and asks the bridegroom for shelter because all of the other houses in the town turned their lights off on him meaning they wouldn't help him. So the bridegroom told him to step outside with him and as they did he was having an…
Read the whole comment
first of all i take back what i commented b/c because i was wrong. It is a narrative poem(obviously) and it IS NOT ABOUT TWO PEOPLE WHO DON'T LOVE EACH OTHER. The starnger goes to the door and asks the bridegroom for shelter because all of the other houses in the town turned their lights off on him meaning they wouldn't help him. So the bridegroom told him to step outside with him and as they did he was having an internal conflict of whether to help this homeless stranger or turn his lights off on him like the others did so that he could be with his new wife. That's why he says, " with in the bride in the dusk alone bent over the open fire her face rose red with the glowing coal and the thought of the hearts desire" so the bridegroom is watching from the porch his new wife and he has a great desire to be with her so he (as mentioned before) struggles and does not know what to do. At the end of the poem when it says, " the bridegroom wished he knew" is when you realize that there is no denouement to this poem or no resolution.
It is not a story except in the sense of being an allegory. The young man faces an overwhelming internal conflict between the simple life he has established and the opportunity or life-changing experience that has symbolically presented itself as a stranger seeking "shelter" in the bridegroom's life. The new wife and the fire represent warmth and safety. He tries to go out on the porch to see if this different life…
Read the whole comment
It is not a story except in the sense of being an allegory. The young man faces an overwhelming internal conflict between the simple life he has established and the opportunity or life-changing experience that has symbolically presented itself as a stranger seeking "shelter" in the bridegroom's life. The new wife and the fire represent warmth and safety. He tries to go out on the porch to see if this different life might be accepted by someone else,but his talents or gifts render it tailor-made for him alone. He is both afraid of it and drawn to it. He wishes he could pack his treasured safe life into a "gold case" and take it with him so that he might have both. There is no pat answer to this eternal question because it is different for every man and woman. We all have monumental choices to make that affect our whole lives. One might infer from reading "The Road Not Taken," Frost's signature later poem, that he chose to cast his lot with the stranger.
WhitneyUnited States
this is about an old couple (bridegroom and bride doesn't necessarily mean newly weds) the stranger is death at the bridegroom's "door". it says it came at eve which symbolizes old age (morning symbolizes birth, noon symbolizes middle age, etc...). the bridegroom wonders what would happen when he dies with the "stranger" near- and it says "autumn, yes, winter was in the wind" symbolizing death and once again old…
Read the whole comment
this is about an old couple (bridegroom and bride doesn't necessarily mean newly weds) the stranger is death at the bridegroom's "door". it says it came at eve which symbolizes old age (morning symbolizes birth, noon symbolizes middle age, etc...). the bridegroom wonders what would happen when he dies with the "stranger" near- and it says "autumn, yes, winter was in the wind" symbolizing death and once again old age. he sees his wife inside, safe, warm, healthy, and wonders again what it would be like to leave her and thinks about his life as the "weary road" but only sees her because she was his life and then he wishes her to remain safe and wishes her heart in a "case of gold". he then goes on to think that he cannot give her enough if he would die... and he curses the rich (meaning the healthy and happy) because he is no longer rich with life. the "woe" in the bridal house is death and separation.
this is a unique poem in that there is much symbolizm and there is internal conflict. the bridegroom is not just fighting with the thought of having to take in the stranger when he wants to be with his new wife, but he also has to think about the fact that all the other people in the town have turned him down. he looks at him with sorrowful eyes and doesn't even need to speak to show how desperate he is. at the end, the bridegroom has not made the tough decision, as is obvious by the line,"the bridegroom wished he knew." this poem was written with a lot of emphasis on love and internal conflict
I love this poem. It says alot!!! i love all the details he puts into just a simple poem. i think that durng this time that he wrote this poem he was thinking about depressing times. it show when this man has no where to go and no one will not be kind enough to open there house to him when he is in needing. But the only house with a lamp on considering to let stay the night. This poem might be confusing but it depends on the way you look at it. just simplify it!! and youl get it it just takes a little amount of time. Good luck!!
StephenUnited States
In LOve and a Question he blatantly uses words twice within a very short period. For example woodbine leaves. A woodbine is a green plant that produces blue inedible berries. He even makes a comment that the berries were blue, maybe there was something in that house that one of them could just not have. Somethine was just out of reach. A true analysis of the poem is hard to come by because Frost leaves the reader with a question, just like the title.
This poem presents a classic case of how poetry is interpereted differently based on the perception of the reader. While all see the same subject, very different meanings come from it. Frost was such a complex and intricate poet, that I believe to better understand the poem's meaning, one would have to learn more about Frost himself.
Nereyda HinojosaUnited States
Shall I let a stranger in my house while my bride awaits impatiently? That is the understanding of this poem when first read ; but ofcourse, it's from Robert Frost. Read it again and analyze it. It says much more.
a hhhhhh crikeyAustralia
man this poem blew me away i was so happy to hear such an inteeligant man speach his mind it was absolutely astonishing to this performance of lierature.
robinUnited States
The conflict that the bridegroom faces in Frost's Love and a Question is between his pity for the stranger and fear of his wife's desire for the stranger. Although he would like to be hospitable, he would risk his wife cheating on him, as she was rose-red upon looking at the stranger. If the bride's heart were encased in gold and pinned with a silver pin, the bridegroom would welcome the stranger. The question would be whether the stranger was asked to destroy their love by inciting desire in the bride.
Among many others things depicted in "Love and a Question", the poem illustrates someone who is torn between his love for his wife and his love for poetry- Seeing the world through the poet's eyes so to speak. Can one who is so passionate about the poetic exploration of truth "harbor" that love (or care) in the bridle house without marring both loves? Will both loves suffer for his "inability to choose"? You'll find the same concept in Keat's poem "Bright Star"- Robert Frost was an avid disciple of Keats and found much inspiration and solice in his poetry.
LizUnited States
The fact that the poem ends on a questionable note, meaning that the reader still has to answer the question for themselves, reflects to how people have many problems in their lives and how it is up to them to figure out the best answers.
ea
This is a metaphorical poem about the bridegroom's own anxiety about his bride's expectations of their first night together. He wants nothing to mar their love - yet he himself is the stranger with the green stick. Get it? He is inexperienced and she is a young rose, not some fixture of jewelry that will remain unchanged by the event that lays before them on that dark, windowless road of life.
JessicaUnited States
So does the man allow the stranger to stay the night or not?
leeloo johnstonUnited States
this poem is a perfect form of pure art.
RachelUnited States
this is such a beautiful poem
Donain CamarenaPanama
Just a master piece!
I really love this poem. I teach Literature in Panama and I have found this as a great source to my students. Thanks Frost for this marvelous gift
Lekuru Hellen EkuleUganda
Literature
This is a very interesting poem and it is contemporary. The bribegroom has to choose between expressing love to the bride or giving attention to the stranger. he chooses the former, which is the best option.
EngerbethGeorgia, Republic of
I first saw a pic of
I first saw a pic of you and Whitesnake, then I read your poem and thought - this cnoant be autobiographical; they look so happy together! Sad poem, but lots of us have been there.....
i think this is more of a story than a poem
it is not a stor and it ia aout how two poeple are forced tobe together when really they love eachother not
The title automatically says something about the story. Obviously, the first word, "love" is understood for its meaning but then it says AND a question..so there might be doubts in the relationship which is what this narrative poem is about, 2 people who really don't know a lot about each other and they regret getting married.
I like this poem a lot. I do no tknow what it means, exactly but I think that the people who are married are not exactly in love. Maybe that is what Robert Frost meant but, if not, we will never know.
first of all i take back what i commented b/c because i was wrong. It is a narrative poem(obviously) and it IS NOT ABOUT TWO PEOPLE WHO DON'T LOVE EACH OTHER. The starnger goes to the door and asks the bridegroom for shelter because all of the other houses in the town turned their lights off on him meaning they wouldn't help him. So the bridegroom told him to step outside with him and as they did he was having an…
Read the whole commentfirst of all i take back what i commented b/c because i was wrong. It is a narrative poem(obviously) and it IS NOT ABOUT TWO PEOPLE WHO DON'T LOVE EACH OTHER. The starnger goes to the door and asks the bridegroom for shelter because all of the other houses in the town turned their lights off on him meaning they wouldn't help him. So the bridegroom told him to step outside with him and as they did he was having an internal conflict of whether to help this homeless stranger or turn his lights off on him like the others did so that he could be with his new wife. That's why he says, " with in the bride in the dusk alone bent over the open fire her face rose red with the glowing coal and the thought of the hearts desire" so the bridegroom is watching from the porch his new wife and he has a great desire to be with her so he (as mentioned before) struggles and does not know what to do. At the end of the poem when it says, " the bridegroom wished he knew" is when you realize that there is no denouement to this poem or no resolution.
It is not a story except in the sense of being an allegory. The young man faces an overwhelming internal conflict between the simple life he has established and the opportunity or life-changing experience that has symbolically presented itself as a stranger seeking "shelter" in the bridegroom's life. The new wife and the fire represent warmth and safety. He tries to go out on the porch to see if this different life…
Read the whole commentIt is not a story except in the sense of being an allegory. The young man faces an overwhelming internal conflict between the simple life he has established and the opportunity or life-changing experience that has symbolically presented itself as a stranger seeking "shelter" in the bridegroom's life. The new wife and the fire represent warmth and safety. He tries to go out on the porch to see if this different life might be accepted by someone else,but his talents or gifts render it tailor-made for him alone. He is both afraid of it and drawn to it. He wishes he could pack his treasured safe life into a "gold case" and take it with him so that he might have both. There is no pat answer to this eternal question because it is different for every man and woman. We all have monumental choices to make that affect our whole lives. One might infer from reading "The Road Not Taken," Frost's signature later poem, that he chose to cast his lot with the stranger.
this is about an old couple (bridegroom and bride doesn't necessarily mean newly weds) the stranger is death at the bridegroom's "door". it says it came at eve which symbolizes old age (morning symbolizes birth, noon symbolizes middle age, etc...). the bridegroom wonders what would happen when he dies with the "stranger" near- and it says "autumn, yes, winter was in the wind" symbolizing death and once again old…
Read the whole commentthis is about an old couple (bridegroom and bride doesn't necessarily mean newly weds) the stranger is death at the bridegroom's "door". it says it came at eve which symbolizes old age (morning symbolizes birth, noon symbolizes middle age, etc...). the bridegroom wonders what would happen when he dies with the "stranger" near- and it says "autumn, yes, winter was in the wind" symbolizing death and once again old age. he sees his wife inside, safe, warm, healthy, and wonders again what it would be like to leave her and thinks about his life as the "weary road" but only sees her because she was his life and then he wishes her to remain safe and wishes her heart in a "case of gold". he then goes on to think that he cannot give her enough if he would die... and he curses the rich (meaning the healthy and happy) because he is no longer rich with life. the "woe" in the bridal house is death and separation.
this is a unique poem in that there is much symbolizm and there is internal conflict. the bridegroom is not just fighting with the thought of having to take in the stranger when he wants to be with his new wife, but he also has to think about the fact that all the other people in the town have turned him down. he looks at him with sorrowful eyes and doesn't even need to speak to show how desperate he is. at the end, the bridegroom has not made the tough decision, as is obvious by the line,"the bridegroom wished he knew." this poem was written with a lot of emphasis on love and internal conflict
I love this poem. It says alot!!! i love all the details he puts into just a simple poem. i think that durng this time that he wrote this poem he was thinking about depressing times. it show when this man has no where to go and no one will not be kind enough to open there house to him when he is in needing. But the only house with a lamp on considering to let stay the night. This poem might be confusing but it depends on the way you look at it. just simplify it!! and youl get it it just takes a little amount of time.
Good luck!!
In LOve and a Question he blatantly uses words twice within a very short period. For example woodbine leaves. A woodbine is a green plant that produces blue inedible berries. He even makes a comment that the berries were blue, maybe there was something in that house that one of them could just not have. Somethine was just out of reach. A true analysis of the poem is hard to come by because Frost leaves the reader with a question, just like the title.
This poem presents a classic case of how poetry is interpereted differently based on the perception of the reader. While all see the same subject, very different meanings come from it. Frost was such a complex and intricate poet, that I believe to better understand the poem's meaning, one would have to learn more about Frost himself.
Shall I let a stranger in my house while my bride awaits impatiently? That is the understanding of this poem when first read ; but ofcourse, it's from Robert Frost. Read it again and analyze it. It says much more.
man this poem blew me away i was so happy to hear such an inteeligant man speach his mind it was absolutely astonishing to this performance of lierature.
The conflict that the bridegroom faces in Frost's Love and a Question is between his pity for the stranger and fear of his wife's desire for the stranger. Although he would like to be hospitable, he would risk his wife cheating on him, as she was rose-red upon looking at the stranger. If the bride's heart were encased in gold and pinned with a silver pin, the bridegroom would welcome the stranger. The question would be whether the stranger was asked to destroy their love by inciting desire in the bride.
Among many others things depicted in "Love and a Question", the poem illustrates someone who is torn between his love for his wife and his love for poetry- Seeing the world through the poet's eyes so to speak. Can one who is so passionate about the poetic exploration of truth "harbor" that love (or care) in the bridle house without marring both loves? Will both loves suffer for his "inability to choose"? You'll find the same concept in Keat's poem "Bright Star"- Robert Frost was an avid disciple of Keats and found much inspiration and solice in his poetry.
The fact that the poem ends on a questionable note, meaning that the reader still has to answer the question for themselves, reflects to how people have many problems in their lives and how it is up to them to figure out the best answers.
This is a metaphorical poem about the bridegroom's own anxiety about his bride's expectations of their first night together. He wants nothing to mar their love - yet he himself is the stranger with the green stick. Get it? He is inexperienced and she is a young rose, not some fixture of jewelry that will remain unchanged by the event that lays before them on that dark, windowless road of life.
So does the man allow the stranger to stay the night or not?
this poem is a perfect form of pure art.
this is such a beautiful poem
Just a master piece!
I really love this poem. I teach Literature in Panama and I have found this as a great source to my students. Thanks Frost for this marvelous gift
Literature
This is a very interesting poem and it is contemporary. The bribegroom has to choose between expressing love to the bride or giving attention to the stranger. he chooses the former, which is the best option.
I first saw a pic of
I first saw a pic of you and Whitesnake, then I read your poem and thought - this cnoant be autobiographical; they look so happy together! Sad poem, but lots of us have been there.....