An Empty Threat

Portrait of Robert Frost
Robert Frost 1874–1963
13New Hampshire

I stay; But it isn't as if There wasn't always Hudson's Bay And the fur trade, A small skiff And a paddle blade.

I can just see my tent pegged, And me on the floor, Cross-legged, And a trapper looking in at the door With furs to sell.

His name's Joe, Alias John, And between what he doesn't know And won't tell About where Henry Hudson's gone, I can't say he's much help; But we get on.

The seal yelp On an ice cake. It's not men by some mistake? No, There's not a soul For a windbreak Between me and the North Pole-

Except always John-Joe, My French Indian Esquimaux, And he's off setting traps In one himself perhaps.

Give a headshake Over so much bay Thrown away In snow and mist That doesn't exist,

I was going to say, For God, man, or beast's sake, Yet does perhaps for all three.

Don't ask Joe What it is to him. It's sometimes dim What it is to me, Unless it be It's the old captain's dark fate Who failed to find or force a strait In its two-thousand-mile coast; And his crew left him where be failed, And nothing came of all be sailed.

It's to say, "You and I-" To such a ghost- You and I Off here With the dead race of the Great Auk!" And, "Better defeat almost, If seen clear, Than life's victories of doubt That need endless talk-talk To make them out."

From the bookNew HampshireFrontispiece woodcut by J. J. Lankes, first edition, Henry Holt, 1923

Keep reading

Discover more of Robert Frost’s poetry.

Explore all poems

Readers

Reader discussion 3 comments

Add your reading ↓
Readers
3
Stanzas quoted
7of 9
Most quoted
“I stay”1 reader
Longest reading
Dr. Zik633 words
  1. rob New Zealand

    it was good but then bad

    not

  2. robert n gutsell United Kingdom

    an empty threat

    This is the first time I've read "An empty threat" but I am a Robert Frost enthusiast and I can spot some if his trademark patterns. He developped a style in which people living close to their land (farmers, woodworkers etc) would converse in a down to earth, but surprisingly insightful way. These conversational and reflective pieces were often long; so this is a shorter piece. The main character recalls his…

    Read the whole comment

    This is the first time I've read "An empty threat" but I am a Robert Frost enthusiast and I can spot some if his trademark patterns.

    He developped a style in which people living close to their land (farmers, woodworkers etc) would converse in a down to earth, but surprisingly insightful way. These conversational and reflective pieces were often long; so this is a shorter piece.

    The main character recalls his conversation with another in Hudson Bay. It starts in the outside "political" world, and seems clear, then suddnely you find yourself wondering about the increasing depth of the lines. It clearly is not political; its personal and reflective and about transience and impermanence. (In my opinion!)It also suddenly gets communicative with the reader; "you" comes into the poem, and RF is suddenly talking to you.

  3. Dr. Zik ↩ replying to robert n gutsell

    Robert Frost is known for his realistic depictions of rural life and musical lines full of the musical effect that soothes the reader and listener of his poetry. He used Ziket’s taste in several poems. As it was the time when Ziket was not specified or invented, to show the specific name and rules for its structure. It came to the poets’ minds and hearts through the wonderful musical waves that they felt during the…

    Read the whole comment

    Robert Frost is known for his realistic depictions of rural life and musical lines full of the musical effect that soothes the reader and listener of his poetry.
    He used Ziket’s taste in several poems. As it was the time when Ziket was not specified or invented, to show the specific name and rules for its structure. It came to the poets’ minds and hearts through the wonderful musical waves that they felt during the revelation of poetry and they found its fantastic flow for their poetic lines and then adopted.
    Frost used whatever meter in a poem. After all, this style attracted the flow of poetry like a magnet to itself.
    My research has shown that if Frost were alive today, he would be a Ziket writer. In other words, Robert Frost used this style in many poems and its ratio varies from poem to poem. Frost started a poem in It is as if a traveler, seeing the beautiful scenery of nature, suddenly stops at a place where a new color of serenity and fun begins to amuse his heart. Traditional poets felt a new color and spirit from this place.
    In the poem “An Empty Threat”, when we see it, the 34 lines out of 57 have the Ziket’s color. In this way, Robert Frost irrigated 57 % of his poetic field, regarding this poem, with this canal water. (commented by Dr. Zik inventor of Zik Genres "Ziket & Zinet")

    Examples are given below:

    Line # 1 and 2.

    I stay;
    But it isn’t as if

    First line: 2 syllables and 2nd Line: 5 syllables

    ----------------------------------------------------------------

    Line # 3 and 4.

    There wasn't always Hudson's Bay
    And the fur trade

    First line: 7 syllables and 2nd Line: 4 syllables

    ----------------------------------------------------------------

    Line # 7 and 8.

    I can just see my tent pegged,
    And me on the floor

    First line: 7 syllables and 2nd Line: 5 syllables

    ----------------------------------------------------------------

    Line # 10 and 11.

    And a trapper looking in at the door
    With furs to sell

    First line: 10 syllables and 2nd Line: 4 syllables

    ----------------------------------------------------------------

    Line # 12 and 13.

    His name's Joe,
    Alias John

    First line: 3 syllables and 2nd Line: 4 syllables

    ----------------------------------------------------------------

    Line # 14 and 15.

    And between what he doesn't know
    And won't tell

    First line:7 syllables and 2nd Line: 3 syllables

    ----------------------------------------------------------------

    Line # 17 and 18.

    I can't say he's much help;
    But we get on

    First line: 6 syllables and 2nd Line: 4 syllables

    ----------------------------------------------------------------

    Line # 19 and 20.

    The seal yelp
    On an ice cake.

    First line: 3 syllables and 2nd Line: 4 syllables

    ----------------------------------------------------------------

    Line # 21 and 22.

    It's not men by some mistake?
    No.

    First line: 7 syllables and 2nd Line: 1 syllable
    ----------------------------------------------------------------

    Line # 23 and 24.

    There's not a soul
    For a windbreak.

    First line: 4 syllables and 2nd Line: 4 syllables

    ----------------------------------------------------------------

    Line # 30 and 31.

    Give a headshake
    Over so much bay.

    First line: syllables and 2nd Line: syllables

    ----------------------------------------------------------------

    Line # 38 and 39.

    Don't ask Joe
    What it is to him.

    First line: 3 syllables and 2nd Line: 5 syllables

    ----------------------------------------------------------------

    Line # 40 and 41.

    It's sometimes dim
    What it is to me.

    First line: 4 syllables and 2nd Line: 5 syllables

    ----------------------------------------------------------------

    Line # 48 and 49.

    It's to say, 'You and I—'
    To such a ghost

    First line: 6 syllables and 2nd Line: 4 syllables

    ----------------------------------------------------------------

    Line # 50 and 51.

    You and I
    Off here.

    First line: 3 syllables and 2nd Line: 2 syllables

    ----------------------------------------------------------------

    Line # 53 and 54.

    And, 'Better defeat almost,
    If seen clear.

    First line: syllables and 2nd Line: syllables

    ----------------------------------------------------------------

    Line # 56 and 57.

    That need endless talk-talk
    To make them out

    First line: syllables and 2nd Line: syllables

    ----------------------------------------------------------------

Your turn

Shown with your comment.

Never published. Only so we can reach you.

Comments are read before they appear. See our terms.