They laid their hands upon my head,
They stroked my cheek and brow;
And time could heal a hurt, they said,
And time could dim a vow.
And they were pitiful and mild
Who whispered to me then,
"The heart that breaks in April, child,
Will mend in May again."
Oh, many a mended heart they knew.
So old they were, and wise.
And little did they have to do
To come to me with lies!
Who flings me silly talk of May
Shall meet a bitter soul;
For June was nearly spent away
Before my heart was whole.
✦
From the bookEnough RopeDust jacket, Boni & Liveright, 1926 design (a later printing)
Analysis
The False Friends: analysis
Introduction
"The False Friends" is a sixteen-line poem about the comfort older people offer to the heartbroken. They tell the speaker that time heals, and that a heart broken in April will mend in May. The speaker calls this a lie.
The joke comes in the last stanza. The heart did mend, but not until June was nearly over. The "lie" was wrong by only about a month. The poem mocks both the easy comforters and the speaker's own furious sense of injury.
Summary
In the first stanza, the comforters lay their hands on the speaker's head. They stroke cheek and brow. They say that time could heal a hurt and "dim a vow." The stanza reports their words indirectly, as something they "said."
In the second stanza, the comforters are "pitiful and mild." They whisper a saying to the speaker. "The heart that breaks in April, child, / Will mend in May again." The address "child" marks the speaker as young.
In the third stanza, the speaker reflects on them. They knew "many a mended heart," and they were old and wise. Yet, the speaker says, they had little to do but come with lies. The stanza ends in an exclamation.
In the fourth stanza, the speaker warns anyone who "flings me silly talk of May." Such a person "Shall meet a bitter soul." The reason follows. "June was nearly spent away / Before my heart was whole."
Themes and meaning
The first theme is the gap between general wisdom and private pain. The comforters speak from experience of "many a mended heart." Their saying about April and May is a neat rule. To the sufferer, a rule about hearts in general feels like a denial of this heart in particular. The poem shows how comfort can wound when it sounds too sure.
The second theme is the healing power of time. The comforters are in fact right. The speaker's heart does heal, as the last line admits. The only error is in the timing. The poem therefore confirms the comforters' wisdom while the speaker rages against it.
The third theme is the comedy of wounded pride. The speaker calls the old friends liars and promises a "bitter soul" to anyone who repeats their words. All this fury rests on a delay of some weeks. The poem can be read as mocking a young person's sense that their suffering is unique. It can also be read as defending the sufferer, since even one extra month of pain is real.
Tone
The first two stanzas are gentle and tender. The comforters are "pitiful and mild," and they whisper. The speaker describes their touch without complaint.
The third stanza turns sharply to scorn. "So old they were, and wise" sounds sarcastic in context. The exclamation "To come to me with lies!" is angry and indignant.
The last stanza is bitter and threatening. "Shall meet a bitter soul" has the ring of a curse. Then the final two lines give the game away. The reason for all this anger is that healing took until the end of June. The tone becomes comic in hindsight, as the speaker's indignation proves out of scale.
Form and structure
The poem has 16 lines in 4 stanzas of 4 lines each. Each stanza rhymes ABAB. The lines alternate between iambic tetrameter and iambic trimeter, mostly 8 and 6 syllables. This is ballad or common metre, the form of hymns and folk songs.
Line 9 has 9 syllables, one more than the other long lines. The phrase "many a mended heart" adds a light extra syllable. It does not add a stress, so the beat stays steady.
The simple, songlike form suits the folk saying at the poem's centre. The quoted proverb in lines 7–8 fits the metre exactly, as proverbs often do. The steady structure makes the final deflation all the neater.
Poetic devices
Imagery line 1
They laid their hands upon my head The comforters' touch is formal, almost like a blessing. It shows them as elders treating the speaker as a child.
Parallelism line 4
And time could dim a vow It repeats the pattern of line 3, where time could heal a hurt. The balanced lines sound like a proverb.
Metaphor line 7
The heart that breaks in April Heartbreak is a break that can mend. The months measure the healing like a timetable.
Direct address line 7
child The comforters call the speaker a child. The word shows their condescension and the speaker's youth.
Alliteration line 9
many a mended heart The repeated m sound gives the phrase a smooth, soothing feel. It echoes the comforters' easy manner.
Sarcasm line 10
So old they were, and wise In context the praise is ironic. The speaker mocks the age and wisdom that were meant to reassure.
Exclamation line 12
To come to me with lies! The outburst marks the turn to anger. The strong word "lies" is out of all proportion to the error.
Bathos line 15
For June was nearly spent away The grand grievance rests on a delay of a few weeks. The comic letdown shows the speaker's anger as overblown.
Words worth knowing
pitiful
Full of pity, compassionate. It does not mean pathetic here.
brow
The forehead.
flings
Throws carelessly, here of careless words.
spent
In "June was nearly spent away" it means used up or passed.
Context
The poem appears in Dorothy Parker's collection Enough Rope, published in 1926, as number 3 in the book. Parker lived from 1893 to 1967. The poem has been on americanpoems.com since February 2004. It was Poem of the Day on January 28, 2008. Readers left 15 comments on it between 2004 and 2006.
What readers have said
Jay Orin reads it as a poem about people who downplay another's pain, thinking they help when they do not. Jay Orin, 2005
Chelae thinks the extra time is a way of saying pain lasts longer than others allow. Those who do not feel it belittle it. Chelae, 2005
Fauna sees a sardonic, slightly funny poem. The speaker calls friends liars merely because healing took an extra month. Fauna, 2005
Lauren reads the extra month as showing how naive and immature the speaker is, not as a charge against the comforters. Lauren, 2005
Fili pairs it with Parker's poem Autumn Valentine, which says time heals a broken heart. This reader thinks the speaker unjustly blames the friends, and heals quickly at that. Fili, 2005
Ellie reads the false friends as friends who lie and talk behind one's back. Ellie, 2005
This poem holds a lot of meaning to me because this has happened to me a lot, unfortunatly! The idea and the meaning behind this is so true! I admire Mrs. Parker for the ability to write poetry that is so utterly true and meaningful for so many people in today's society.
LiFeUnited States
I felt EVERY SINGLE word of this poem, and it means the world to me!!!
laurenUnited States
pretty!
EllieUnited States
i knew what the poet meant. Every time i try to make friends, it happens to me. I trust them and they talk behind my back or lie to me. It hurts a lot.
FiliUnited States
This is a great companion poem to "Autumn Valentine," which essentially says that time heals a broken heart. This one claims that it takes longer than one might expect to heal a hurt, and the speaker (unjustly) blames her friends for being wrong. However, it's taken me a lot longer than 2 months to get over a love. Parker heals quickly if you ask me!
To me it seems she is talking of her childhood. The message to me people are telling her time will heal her grief over losses which she had so many of in childhood.Her rebuttal being she never really healed of her loss when her family died. Jerry
Rudy HernandezUnited States
people you think are your friends are really not
rudy hernandezUnited States
people you think are your freinds are really not.
Frank HernandezUnited States
It's a good poem cause it let you know people that you think are your friends are really not.
Jay OrinUnited States
It is about people that downplay another's pain, saying that "it will go away soon." They think that they are being helpful by telling a person that, but that really doesn't help a person when they are in pain.
FaunaUnited States
I think this poem isn't so much about "false friends" as it is a sardonic, slightly funny look at how she calls her friends liars merely because it took her an extra month to get over her last heartache.
wytiaUnited States
this poem is real nice becaues i see where you are caming from about your poems so if you need me just write me an e-mail because i am a poety myself
ChelaeAustralia
Two months is not the time it takes to end her grief. The fact that she takes one more month means that the pain takes longer then others give credit for. If you dont feel the same pain at the time you will belittle others and discount it as real as it holds no relevance to you. Two months is not an exact time its just a clever way of saying it takes longer. Dont you hate it when you dont feel well but others say "stop being silly you should."
LaurenUnited States
The fact that it took more than one month is just to show how naive and immature the speaker is. I don't believe it has anything to do with people underestimating your hurting.
PamSingapore
I read this once and was smitten by it ever since. Lovely.
This poem holds a lot of meaning to me because this has happened to me a lot, unfortunatly! The idea and the meaning behind this is so true! I admire Mrs. Parker for the ability to write poetry that is so utterly true and meaningful for so many people in today's society.
I felt EVERY SINGLE word of this poem, and it means the world to me!!!
pretty!
i knew what the poet meant. Every time i try to make friends, it happens to me. I trust them and they talk behind my back or lie to me. It hurts a lot.
This is a great companion poem to "Autumn Valentine," which essentially says that time heals a broken heart. This one claims that it takes longer than one might expect to heal a hurt, and the speaker (unjustly) blames her friends for being wrong. However, it's taken me a lot longer than 2 months to get over a love. Parker heals quickly if you ask me!
To me it seems she is talking of her childhood. The message to me people are telling her time will heal her grief over losses which she had so many of in childhood.Her rebuttal being she never really healed of her loss when her family died.
Jerry
people you think are your friends are really not
people you think are your freinds are really not.
It's a good poem cause it let you know people that you think are your friends are really not.
It is about people that downplay another's pain, saying that "it will go away soon." They think that they are being helpful by telling a person that, but that really doesn't help a person when they are in pain.
I think this poem isn't so much about "false friends" as it is a sardonic, slightly funny look at how she calls her friends liars merely because it took her an extra month to get over her last heartache.
this poem is real nice becaues i see where you are caming from about your poems so if you need me just write me an e-mail because i am a poety myself
Two months is not the time it takes to end her grief. The fact that she takes one more month means that the pain takes longer then others give credit for. If you dont feel the same pain at the time you will belittle others and discount it as real as it holds no relevance to you. Two months is not an exact time its just a clever way of saying it takes longer.
Dont you hate it when you dont feel well but others say "stop being silly you should."
The fact that it took more than one month is just to show how naive and immature the speaker is. I don't believe it has anything to do with people underestimating your hurting.
I read this once and was smitten by it ever since.
Lovely.