Let the snake wait under
his weed
and the writing
be of words, slow and quick, sharp
to strike, quiet to wait,
sleepless.
—through metaphor to reconcile
the people and the stones.
Compose. (No ideas
but in things) Invent!
Saxifrage is my flower that splits
the rocks.
✦
Analysis
A Sort Of A Song: analysis
Introduction
"A Sort Of A Song" is a twelve-line poem about how poems should be written. It gives its advice through two images from nature. A snake waits in the weeds, ready to strike, and a flower splits rock.
Between them the poem states its method in plain commands. The writing should work "through metaphor" and find its ideas in things. The title is modest, calling the poem only a sort of song. Yet the poem ends with a claim for the force of small, living things.
Summary
Lines 1–2 open with a command: "Let the snake wait under / his weed". The speaker sets a snake in hiding and lets it be. No reason is given yet for starting with a snake.
Lines 3–6 turn to writing. The speaker asks that the writing "be of words" with the snake's qualities. The words are to be "slow and quick", "sharp / to strike", "quiet to wait". The list ends on the single word "sleepless" in line 6.
Lines 7–8 give the purpose of such writing. It is to work "through metaphor to reconcile / the people and the stones". The line begins with a dash, as if continuing the thought after a pause. People and stones are named side by side.
Lines 9–10 are a string of short commands. The speaker says "Compose" and then "Invent!" Between them, inside brackets, comes the phrase "No ideas / but in things". The brackets make it sound like a rule the speaker keeps close at hand.
Lines 11–12 close with a statement about the speaker. "Saxifrage is my flower", the speaker says. It is the flower "that splits / the rocks". The last line is the short phrase "the rocks", ending the poem with a full stop.
Themes and meaning
The poem is about writing, and it takes the snake as its model. The snake waits under its weed, still and alert. The words the speaker wants are both "quiet to wait" and "sharp / to strike". Good writing, on this reading, holds its force in reserve until the right moment. "sleepless" adds that it must stay watchful.
A second idea is that metaphor joins things that seem apart. Line 7 says the writing should "reconcile / the people and the stones". People are alive and stones are inert. Metaphor, in this reading, finds the link between human life and the hard physical world. The poem itself does this when it makes a snake stand for a way of writing.
The bracketed phrase "No ideas / but in things" states a principle. Ideas are to be found in concrete objects, not in abstract statement. The poem follows its own rule. It gives no argument, only a snake, stones and a flower. Its meaning has to be drawn from those things.
The last theme is the power of small living things over hard ones. Saxifrage is a small plant, yet it "splits / the rocks". The speaker claims it as "my flower". The image can be read as a picture of poetry itself. Quiet, patient growth can break what seems unbreakable.
Tone
The tone is confident and direct. Most of the poem is in the imperative: "Let", "Compose", "Invent!" The speaker gives orders, perhaps to himself, perhaps to any writer. The commands are brisk and short.
The title undercuts this confidence a little. "A Sort Of A Song" is casual and modest, as if the speaker will not claim too much. The poem's lines are also rough and broken rather than songlike. The ending rises to a quiet boast. "Saxifrage is my flower" is a statement of identity, and the image that follows is one of strength.
Form and structure
The poem has 12 lines in 2 stanzas of 6 lines each, in free verse. None of the lines rhyme. Line lengths vary widely, from 2 to 8 syllables, and there is no regular metre.
Three lines have only 2 syllables: "his weed", "sleepless." and "the rocks." These short lines give weight to single images. The syntax is broken up by commas, a dash, brackets and an exclamation mark. The stanza break falls before the dash that opens line 7. The line breaks often cut across phrases, as in "sharp / to strike" and "splits / the rocks".
Poetic devices
personification line 2
his weed The snake is given "his" own weed. The small possessive makes the snake a character with a place of its own.
antithesis line 4
slow and quick Opposites are joined. The writing is to have both patience and speed, like the snake.
implied metaphor line 5
to strike, quiet to wait, These are the snake's actions, now given to words. Writing is compared to a snake without the comparison being stated.
isolated word line 6
sleepless. A single word forms the whole line. It adds constant alertness to the list of qualities and stops it with a full stop.
juxtaposition line 8
the people and the stones. The living and the inert are set side by side. Metaphor is the means to bring them together.
imperative line 9
Compose. A one-word command. It tells the writer to set to work, and it is followed by "Invent!" in line 10.
parenthesis line 9
(No ideas The brackets set the principle apart from the commands around it. It reads like an aside or a rule to remember.
metaphor line 11
Saxifrage is my flower that splits The speaker adopts the rock-splitting flower as an emblem. Its quiet power stands for the kind of writing the poem asks for.
alliteration line 11
Saxifrage is my flower that splits The "s" sounds at both ends of the line link the flower's name to what it does.
Words worth knowing
saxifrage
A small flowering plant that often grows in cracks in rock. The name comes from Latin words meaning stone-breaker, which the last line puts to use.
compose
To write or put together. The word is also used for making music, which fits a poem called a song.
reconcile
To bring into agreement or harmony things that seem opposed.
Context
"A Sort Of A Song" is by William Carlos Williams (1883–1963). It has been on americanpoems.com since 2003. Readers have left nine comments on it, from 2004 to 2024.
What readers have said
B.E. sums the poem up as an invitation to let the song strike the reader, picking up the snake's strike. B.E., 2004
Farzaneh reads the poem as showing the power of poetry against solid life. farzaneh, 2005
Vargas focuses on the rock, which is solid, while living things are more powerful because they split it sooner or later. Vargas, 2007
ılker reads it as a song about writing, with the snake's slow motion like ink moving across paper. ılker, 2007
Val reads the whole poem as a metaphor for how a poet responds to evil, and notes the snake as a symbol of wisdom. Val, 2024
Keep reading
Discover more of William Carlos Williams’s poetry.
Let the song strike you, is what he is saying. Take my word for it, (or not)
P.Germany
The poem talks about life and opportunities in life. Someone should not be afraid of trying something new and just enjoy everything.
farzanehIran
I feel the poet is showing the power of poetry versus solid life.
VargasChina
a great image that rock is solid but the animated are much powerful as they split the rock sooner or later. is that a idea for the breakthrough of everything concerned?
JoeUnited States
The Poem is about the power of slow moving things. The flower, and the snake waiting to strike. The lantern illuminates the world
ılkerTurkey
I think this poem is about writing.ıt ıs a sort of a song about wrıtıng.the snake is a book at the begınnıng of the poem.the ınk goes on the paper lıke a snkae slowşy goes on the gorund. slowly and snakelıke motıon ıs attrıbuted to wrıtıng
anahitIran
I think the poet is advising the other poets to wait till the aspirations to write a piece of poem comes to them and make the outcome sth great and fascinating.
georgia
hi
i dont like this it is not my typ can ou put samething els aboy girls whould like a lot please
Val
The poem itself is the whole metaphor. Life is full of evil and poet have to decide how to react on it. He can't be like a snake, but to be like a stone means to be like one of a crowd: there is a saying that living with wolfs, one should react on everything as a wolf too. A word is a poet's brand, so he is above evil and full of patience. A snake also is known as a symbol of wisdom. So a poet studies snake's behavior, but his word are like flowers. May be the poem is about it, who knows.
Let the song strike you, is what he is saying. Take my word for it, (or not)
The poem talks about life and opportunities in life. Someone should not be afraid of trying something new and just enjoy everything.
I feel the poet is showing the power of poetry versus
solid life.
a great image that rock is solid but the animated are much powerful as they split the rock sooner or later.
is that a idea for the breakthrough of everything concerned?
The Poem is about the power of slow moving things. The flower, and the snake waiting to strike. The lantern illuminates the world
I think this poem is about writing.ıt ıs a sort of a song about wrıtıng.the snake is a book at the begınnıng of the poem.the ınk goes on the paper lıke a snkae slowşy goes on the gorund. slowly and snakelıke motıon ıs attrıbuted to wrıtıng
I think the poet is advising the other poets to wait till the aspirations to write a piece of poem comes to them and make the outcome sth great and fascinating.
hi
i dont like this it is not my typ can ou put samething els aboy girls whould like a lot please
The poem itself is the whole metaphor.
Life is full of evil
and poet have to decide how to react on it.
He can't be like a snake,
but to be like a stone means to be
like one of a crowd:
there is a saying that living with wolfs,
one should react on everything as a wolf too.
A word is a poet's brand, so
he is above evil and full of patience.
A snake also is known as a symbol of wisdom.
So a poet studies snake's behavior,
but his word are like flowers.
May be the poem is about it, who knows.