My friend says I was not a good son
you understand
I say yes I understand
he says I did not go
to see my parents very often you know
and I say yes I know
even when I was living in the same city he says
maybe I would go there once
a month or maybe even less
I say oh yes
he says the last time I went to see my father
I say the last time I saw my father
he says the last time I saw my father
he was asking me about my life
how I was making out and he
went into the next room
to get something to give me
oh I say
feeling again the cold
of my father's hand the last time
he says and my father turned
in the doorway and saw me
look at my wristwatch and he
said you know I would like you to stay
and talk with me
oh yes I say
but if you are busy he said
I don't want you to feel that you
have to
just because I'm here
I say nothing
he says my father
said maybe
you have important work you are doing
or maybe you should be seeing
somebody I don't want to keep you
I look out the window
my friend is older than I am
he says and I told my father it was so
and I got up and left him then
you know
though there was nowhere I had to go
and nothing I had to do
✦
Analysis
Yesterday: analysis
Introduction
In W.S. Merwin's poem a friend confesses that he was not a good son. He tells the speaker about the last time he visited his father. The father asked how he was doing, offered him a gift, and asked him to stay. The son looked at his watch and left, though he had nowhere to be.
The speaker mostly answers with "yes" and "oh". His own memory of his father keeps breaking in. The poem is about guilt, about listening, and about how one person's story can turn out to be another's.
Summary
The poem opens with the friend saying he was not a good son. The speaker says he understands.
The friend says he did not go to see his parents often. The speaker says he knows.
Even living in the same city, the friend went perhaps once a month or less. The speaker says oh yes.
The friend begins to tell of the last time he went to see his father. The speaker says the last time he saw his father.
The friend goes on. His father asked how things were going and how he was making out. Then his father went into the next room to get something to give him.
The speaker says oh. He feels again the cold of his own father's hand the last time.
The friend says his father turned in the doorway and saw him look at his watch. The father said he would like him to stay and talk.
The speaker says oh yes.
The father added that if his son was busy, he did not want him to feel he had to stay.
The speaker says nothing.
The father said that perhaps his son had important work. Perhaps he should be seeing someone. He did not want to keep him.
The speaker looks out of the window and notes that the friend is older than he is. The friend says he told his father that was so, and got up and left him.
The poem ends with the admission that there was nowhere he had to go and nothing he had to do.
Themes and meaning
Guilt toward a parent is the poem's first subject. The friend opens with it: "I was not a good son". The story he tells proves the point. The worst moment is small, a glance at a wristwatch.
The poem is also about how stories double. The speaker interrupts with "the last time I saw my father". He feels again "the cold" of his own father's hand. The friend's confession seems to be the speaker's own, or close to it. The listener may be quietly remembering a failure of his own.
Silence and evasion run through the poem. The speaker's replies shrink from "yes I understand" to "oh" and then to "I say nothing". He looks out of the window rather than speak. His reticence mirrors the son's failure to stay and talk.
The father's gentleness sharpens the pain. He makes excuses for his son: "you have important work". He does not want to "keep" him. His kindness makes the son's departure harder to forgive.
The title points to time and loss. The title word can mean the recent past or all that cannot be recovered. The last lines show the choice was not forced: "nowhere I had to go". The regret lies in how easily it could have been different.
Tone
The tone is flat, quiet and conversational. There is no punctuation, and speech is reported without quotation marks. The flatness makes the story sound like ordinary talk.
The speaker's replies are short and polite at first. They grow fainter as the story touches him. The one-line stanzas, "oh yes I say" and "I say nothing", mark rising discomfort.
The father's words are gentle and self-effacing. Their kindness gives the poem its ache. The final two lines are stated simply. That plainness makes the confession land hard, with no comment from the speaker.
Form and structure
The poem is in free verse, with 43 lines in 13 stanzas. The stanzas range from one to five lines. Lines run from two to fourteen syllables, and there is no metre or rhyme scheme.
The poem uses no punctuation apart from apostrophes. Speakers are marked only by "he says" and "I say". The single-line stanzas isolate the speaker's brief responses. The short, broken lines follow the pauses of real conversation.
Poetic devices
Absence of punctuation line 1
My friend says I was not a good son The poem runs without commas or quotation marks. Voices blur together, which suits a story that belongs to both men.
Echo line 3
I say yes I understand The speaker repeats the friend's phrase back to him. The echo hints that he understands from experience.
Repetition with variation line 12
I say the last time I saw my father The speaker almost repeats the friend's line but changes went to see to saw. His own memory breaks into the friend's story.
Tactile imagery line 19
feeling again the cold The cold hand is the poem's only physical sensation for the speaker. It suggests a final parting, perhaps a death.
Symbol line 23
look at my wristwatch The glance at the watch stands for impatience and neglect. It is the small act the son cannot forget.
Enjambment line 28
I don't want you to feel that you The line breaks before have to. The pause mimics the father's hesitant, careful speech.
Isolated line line 31
I say nothing This one-line stanza shows the speaker falling silent. The silence carries what he cannot say.
Irony line 43
and nothing I had to do The son left for no reason at all. The plain ending exposes the excuse the father gave him.
Words worth knowing
making out
Getting on or managing in life. An informal phrase for how someone is doing.
What readers have said
This reader finds the meaning plain, with no guessing needed, but thinks the poem could have taken a different form. Victoria W Kline, 2005
This reader thinks anyone who has lost a parent would understand it, and sees guilt over the small part held back in any relationship. ilene novick, 2007
This reader focuses on the title and on the speaker's brief attempt to interrupt in stanza 4, before he falls back on saying oh. Danny Hocken, 2007
After hearing Merwin read it on the radio, this reader found it a heartfelt expression of losing a parent. Sheila Dory, 2010
While reading the poem you don't have to guess what the writer is trying to say. I do think that the writer could have wrote it in a different form.
ilene novickUnited States
is there anyone who has lost a parent who wouldn't understand this poem's meaning? it goes beyond the parent/child relationship and probably applies to relationships in general especially the familial...if we give 99% to a relationship, we feel guilty about the 1% we saved for ourselves...even if we were given another chance our actions would not be different...it speaks of a universal emotion...guilt is inherent in man's nature...simply said, it's "inherited"...i've always doubted those who never "owned" this emotion...
alexandriaPhilippines
you know this poem is related to my life now i usually see my father
(I always feel inadequate to comment on great poems like this! Ah, now I'm experiencing de ja vu.) The only aspect of this poem I don't understand, and therefore will write about that: is the title. I want to write about why it's called 'Yesterday'. The speaker of the poem tries in a brief, courageous moment to interrupt his friend 'I say the last time I saw my father' in stanza 4. But soon he is back to just saying…
Read the whole comment
(I always feel inadequate to comment on great poems like this! Ah, now I'm experiencing de ja vu.)
The only aspect of this poem I don't understand, and therefore will write about that: is the title. I want to write about why it's called 'Yesterday'.
The speaker of the poem tries in a brief, courageous moment to interrupt his friend 'I say the last time I saw my father' in stanza 4. But soon he is back to just saying 'oh I say' in stanza 6.
I interpret that the speaker, although not capable of speaking of his father, has lost his father. He says 'feeling again the cold/of my fathers hand the last time' stanza 6.
The death of his father and I suppose the sadness and guilt he experiences as he listens to the story by his friend who 'is older than I am'. Here, the speaker is even more distant because he just looks 'out the window'.
So all this time, the speaker is thinking of Yesterday, the day he lost his father. I suppose that's why his friend is talking to him about his father and maybe wants to learn something about relationships from the speaker, like how to talk to his father, but the speaker has nothing to say, or if he does, he's too sad to say it. This lack of communication from the speaker to the friend symbolizes or is a metaphor for the lack of communication between the speaker or the friend and their fathers.
I was moved on hearing W.S. Merwin reciting this poem on the radio this morning and later found it on your website. It is truly a beautiful and heartfelt expression of how one feels after losing a parent. I so appreciate the comments of Danny Hocken in clarifying the stanza 4, which at first glance was not clear to me.
While reading the poem you don't have to guess what the writer is trying to say. I do think that the writer could have wrote it in a different form.
is there anyone who has lost a parent who wouldn't understand this poem's meaning? it goes beyond the parent/child relationship and probably applies to relationships in general especially the familial...if we give 99% to a relationship, we feel guilty about the 1% we saved for ourselves...even if we were given another chance our actions would not be different...it speaks of a universal emotion...guilt is inherent in man's nature...simply said, it's "inherited"...i've always doubted those who never "owned" this emotion...
you know this poem is related to my life now i usually see my father
(I always feel inadequate to comment on great poems like this! Ah, now I'm experiencing de ja vu.) The only aspect of this poem I don't understand, and therefore will write about that: is the title. I want to write about why it's called 'Yesterday'. The speaker of the poem tries in a brief, courageous moment to interrupt his friend 'I say the last time I saw my father' in stanza 4. But soon he is back to just saying…
Read the whole comment(I always feel inadequate to comment on great poems like this! Ah, now I'm experiencing de ja vu.)
The only aspect of this poem I don't understand, and therefore will write about that: is the title. I want to write about why it's called 'Yesterday'.
The speaker of the poem tries in a brief, courageous moment to interrupt his friend 'I say the last time I saw my father' in stanza 4. But soon he is back to just saying 'oh I say' in stanza 6.
I interpret that the speaker, although not capable of speaking of his father, has lost his father. He says 'feeling again the cold/of my fathers hand the last time' stanza 6.
The death of his father and I suppose the sadness and guilt he experiences as he listens to the story by his friend who 'is older than I am'. Here, the speaker is even more distant because he just looks 'out the window'.
So all this time, the speaker is thinking of Yesterday, the day he lost his father. I suppose that's why his friend is talking to him about his father and maybe wants to learn something about relationships from the speaker, like how to talk to his father, but the speaker has nothing to say, or if he does, he's too sad to say it. This lack of communication from the speaker to the friend symbolizes or is a metaphor for the lack of communication between the speaker or the friend and their fathers.
Yesterday
I was moved on hearing W.S. Merwin reciting this poem on the radio this morning and later found it on your website. It is truly a beautiful and heartfelt expression of how one feels after losing a parent. I so appreciate the comments of Danny Hocken in clarifying the stanza 4, which at first glance was not clear to me.