Go to the western gate, Luke Havergal, --
There where the vines cling crimson on the wall, --
And in the twilight wait for what will come.
The wind will moan, the leaves will whisper some --
Whisper of her, and strike you as they fall;
But go, and if you trust her she will call.
Go to the western gate, Luke Havergal --
Luke Havergal.
No, there is not a dawn in eastern skies
To rift the fiery night that's in your eyes;
But there, where western glooms are gathering,
The dark will end the dark, if anything:
God slays Himself with every leaf that flies,
And hell is more than half of paradise.
No, there is not a dawn in eastern skies --
In eastern skies.
Out of a grave I come to tell you this, --
Out of a grave I come to quench the kiss
That flames upon your forehead with a glow
That blinds you to the way that you must go.
Yes, there is yet one way to where she is, --
Bitter, but one that faith can never miss.
Out of a grave I come to tell you this --
To tell you this.
There is the western gate, Luke Havergal,
There are the crimson leaves upon the wall.
Go, -- for the winds are tearing them away, --
Nor think to riddle the dead words they say,
Nor any more to feel them as they fall;
But go! and if you trust her she will call.
There is the western gate, Luke Havergal --
Luke Havergal.
✦
Analysis
Luke Havergal: analysis
Introduction
"Luke Havergal" is a dark, incantatory poem in four eight-line stanzas. A voice speaks to a grieving man, Luke Havergal, whose love seems to be dead. The voice urges him again and again to "Go to the western gate" at twilight, where "she will call."
In stanza 3 the speaker reveals that it comes "Out of a grave." It promises "one way to where she is," but calls that way "Bitter." The poem never says plainly what the way is. Many readers take it as death, and the poem leaves open whether the voice is offering comfort or luring Luke toward suicide.
Summary
The speaker tells Luke Havergal to go to the western gate, where crimson vines cling to the wall. There he must wait in the twilight "for what will come." The wind will moan, and the falling leaves will whisper of "her" and strike him. The speaker insists that he go, and promises that if he trusts her, "she will call."
The second stanza denies all hope from the east. No dawn is there to break "the fiery night" in Luke's eyes. Instead, in the gathering western gloom, "The dark will end the dark, if anything." The speaker adds two riddling claims: God "slays Himself" with every falling leaf, and "hell is more than half of paradise."
The speaker now says it has come "Out of a grave" to tell him this. It comes to "quench the kiss" that burns on his forehead and blinds him to the way he must go. There is still "one way to where she is." It is "Bitter," but faith cannot miss it.
The last stanza returns to the gate and the crimson leaves on the wall. The speaker urges Luke to go, because the winds are tearing the leaves away. He must not try to "riddle the dead words they say," or feel them fall any longer. The poem ends as it began, with the promise that "she will call" and the repeated name "Luke Havergal."
Themes and meaning
The central theme is grief for a lost love. The lost woman is only "her" and "she," never named. Luke's pain is "the fiery night that's in your eyes." The "kiss / That flames upon your forehead" can be read as the memory of her that still burns and blinds him.
A second theme is death as the way to reunion. The west, where the sun sets and "glooms are gathering," is the direction the voice commands. "The dark will end the dark" suggests that death may end the darkness of grief. The "one way to where she is" is "Bitter." Many readers take this as suicide, though the poem never says so.
A third theme is the uncertain authority of the speaker. It comes "Out of a grave," but whose grave is not said. It could be the dead woman, another ghost, or a voice within Luke himself. Because we cannot tell, we cannot tell whether its counsel is loving or deadly.
A fourth theme is the paradox of faith. "God slays Himself with every leaf that flies" suggests a God who shares in every loss. The claim that "hell is more than half of paradise" suggests that suffering is part of the way to bliss. The voice calls the bitter way one "that faith can never miss." Faith here points toward the dark, not away from it.
Tone
The tone is solemn, hypnotic and urgent. The speaker gives commands: "Go," "wait," "go!" The repeated lines and name create an incantation, as if the voice were casting a spell. The long vowels of "moan" and "glooms" add to the heavy mood.
The second stanza turns stern and bleak. Its "No" shuts off any hope from the east. Its paradoxes are stated flatly, as certainties.
In stanza 3 the voice becomes intimate and eerie as it reveals it comes "Out of a grave." The word "Yes" in line 21 offers a grim kind of comfort. By the last stanza the voice is pressing hard, with an exclamation mark in line 30. The final, fading "Luke Havergal" sounds like a summons and a farewell at once.
Form and structure
The poem has 32 lines in 4 stanzas of 8 lines each. The metre is iambic pentameter, with the eighth line of each stanza cut to a short echo. The first line of each stanza returns as its seventh, and part of it forms the eighth. This refrain gives each stanza a closed, circling shape.
The rhyme is dense. In stanzas 2 and 3 one rhyme sound returns in 5 of the 8 lines. The computed scheme leaves the name "Havergal" unmatched, but it echoes "wall," "fall" and "call." Line 10 and line 13 have 11 syllables. The dashes after many lines slow the reading.
Poetic devices
Refrain line 7
Go to the western gate, Luke Havergal Line 1 returns as line 7 and is cut to the name alone in line 8. The repetition makes the command insistent and spell-like.
Symbolism line 9
No, there is not a dawn in eastern skies East and dawn stand for hope and new life, which the voice denies. The west, where the sun sets, becomes the way to go.
Imagery line 2
the vines cling crimson on the wall The red vines suggest autumn, blood and dying. The color returns with the "crimson leaves" of line 26.
Personification line 4
The wind will moan, the leaves will whisper Nature seems to grieve and to speak of the lost woman. The world itself joins the call to the western gate.
Metaphor line 10
the fiery night that's in your eyes Luke's grief is a burning darkness in his eyes. Fire and night combine pain with blindness.
Paradox line 12
The dark will end the dark, if anything One darkness, perhaps death, will end another, the darkness of grief. The added "if anything" leaves even this uncertain.
Paradox line 13
God slays Himself with every leaf that flies Each falling leaf is a death that God shares. The line is one of the poem's hardest and is open to several readings.
Anaphora line 18
Out of a grave I come to quench the kiss Lines 17, 18 and 23 begin the same way. The repetition keeps the speaker's ghostly origin in front of the reader.
Metaphor line 19
That flames upon your forehead with a glow The kiss burns like a flame and blinds him. Love's memory is shown as both bright and harmful.
Alliteration line 11
western glooms are gathering The repeated "g" sounds slow the line. They mirror the slow gathering of darkness in the west.
Ambiguity line 22
Bitter, but one that faith can never miss The way is never named. "Bitter" hints at death, while "faith" suggests a sure path, so the line holds both readings.
Words worth knowing
rift
To split open; a dawn that would break through the night.
glooms
Darknesses; the plural makes the dusk thicken in layers.
quench
To put out, as a fire; here, to put out the burning kiss.
riddle
Used as a verb: to solve or make out, as one solves a riddle.
some
In line 4, "whisper some" means whisper a little, before the line runs on into "Whisper of her."
Context
Edwin Arlington Robinson lived from 1869 to 1935. "Luke Havergal" has drawn 14 comments on this site between 2005 and 2020. Many of them argue over who the speaker is and what the western gate means.
What readers have said
Gloria reads the speaker as clearly dead and suggests that the western gate is heaven and the eastern skies are hell. Gloria, 2005
Justin disagrees about east and west: the setting sun stands for death, and the only way to reach the dead woman is to die. Justin, 2005
Laurie reads the western gate as death and the crimson leaves as autumn leading to winter. This reader hears the speaker as the part of Luke that wishes to die. laurie, 2005
Jenny argues that the speaker is the devil, taking advantage of Luke's grief to persuade him into suicide. Jenny, 2005
Brandon breaks the name into haver, taken as companion, and gall, taken as bitterness, and links it to the "Bitter" way of line 22. Brandon, 2007
John Wheater, reading Robinson for the first time, values the poem's elegiac music and pictures and warns that close analysis might spoil them. John Wheater, 2006
Keep reading
Discover more of Edwin Arlington Robinson’s poetry.
When I first read this poem I completely got lost. After reading it about forty times I began to catch on a little, but I am not sure what it all means, or who is the speaker.Well the speaker is clearly dead and telling Luke Havergal to go to the western gate because the eastern skies do not have a dawn. I think that maybe the western gate is heaven and the eastern skies is hell. In the third stanza (line 20)it implies that when Luke reaches a certain point they will tell him to go to hell or go to heaven.
i agree with Gloria on the east/west heaven and hell deal, but i'm confused about the "crimson leaves." they sound like fire, but their on the heaven side? i dunno. i really like this poem because it confuses me and makes me think, but i just can't figure it out completely. if you have any thoughts on this poem that you might want to share with me, email me. thanks!
I mean no disrespect, but I totally disagree with the comments on east and west. The sun sets in the west, thus representing death. The sun rises in the east, thus representing hope and life. Luke's love is dead, and the only way to her is to die. Even if there is no way to get to her, "the dark will end the dark." If death does not bring him to her, at least he will not have to suffer through life anymore. The "one way to where she is" that's "bitter" and that "faith can never miss" is death. The speaker (I don't know who) is pointing Luke to where his lover is, and the only way to get there is to die.
The western gate is death. The sun rises in the east-life and youth, and sets in the west-death. The crimson leaves represent the fall of his life, leaning towards winter(death). I think the speaker is Luke havergal's consious, or at least the part of him that wishes to die to be with his lover again. Perhaps the speaker is the voice that represents his desent into madness(perhaps) and death. When the speaker says…
Read the whole comment
The western gate is death. The sun rises in the east-life and youth, and sets in the west-death. The crimson leaves represent the fall of his life, leaning towards winter(death). I think the speaker is Luke havergal's consious, or at least the part of him that wishes to die to be with his lover again. Perhaps the speaker is the voice that represents his desent into madness(perhaps) and death. When the speaker says "out of a grave I come to tell you this" i believe he is pretending to be luke havergal's dead lover, to convince him more to kill himself. The speaker believes the only way for luke havergal to be happy again is to die(go to the western gate). The "dead words (the crimson leaves) say" are any reasons Luke Havergal might have not to kill himself.
This is a poet about Robinson's futileness of life. This poem clearly expresses death and the loss of love. It shows Robinsons loss of love - indeed he did lose love. And it talks about death - a Romantic aspect. In this poem we see Romantic aspects such as loss of love and death but we also see a realistic aspect of the futileness of love(or so it seems in Robinsons eyes). Rather interesting poem. It was published with other poems about his fictional Tillbury town characters who mirrored his experiences and feelings. This poem appeared with poems such as Richard Cory and Miniver Cheevy. Those are good reads to further understand Robinsons style and experience
lisaUnited States
I believe the crimson (red) leaves on the door represent hell. Anyone who kills themself is going to hell. Not the point though, he wants to either be with his dead lover or be dead and out of his misery. "God slays himself with every leaf that flies"- God is hurt everytime one of his sons (represented possibly by leaves?) falls (commits suicide). Which is why there are crimson leaves on the gate to hell.
It took me a while to full understand this poem and after reading about 20 times, I think I finally have a grasp on it. The speaker in this poem is the devil. He sees that Luke Havergal is heartbroken and lonely and greif-stricken and he wants to take advantage of this. Luke's love is dead and the only way Luke can ever be with her again is to die. The devil is trying to pursuade Luke into taking his own life, which…
Read the whole comment
It took me a while to full understand this poem and after reading about 20 times, I think I finally have a grasp on it. The speaker in this poem is the devil. He sees that Luke Havergal is heartbroken and lonely and greif-stricken and he wants to take advantage of this. Luke's love is dead and the only way Luke can ever be with her again is to die. The devil is trying to pursuade Luke into taking his own life, which would mean he is going against the Lord's Will, thus Luke would end up in hell. You can come to understand by the use of color and choice of words that EA uses. Crimson is mentioned many times throughout the poem. Crimson, or any other red color, usually respresents evil, or hell. The word 'fall' suggests defeat Luke's life. 'Fall' also represents a downward motion, and we all know that hell below heaven. Lastly, God doesn't need to convince people to come to heaven, nor would God ever slay himself. Suicide and God should never be used in the same sentence. That alone suggests sinister acts.
BenUnited States
I would suggest everyone listen to this, and other E.A. Robinson poems set to music by John Duke. Although I understand and find truth in all your interpretations, I feel that when singing this song Luke is moving towards hope, even if that hope is death. Life is all about moving forward.
John WheaterUnited Kingdom
Friends, let us consider the wise words of Mr Housman:
" Even when poetry has a meaning, as it usually has, it may be inadvisable to draw it out . . . Perfect understanding will sometimes almost extinguish pleasure "
I'd say, as one reading Mr Robinson for the first time, that this applied here particularly. There's a strong elegaic feeling, melodically expressed, with potent pictures - but I feel it would crumble under plodding analysis.
On another tack, this is a great site, but plagued by pesky popups. Any chance of an ad-free subscription service?
MatthewUnited States
I thought that the title might have a little meaning because LUKE IS IN THE bible and i thought that maby Havergal might be something of a meaning but i cant find any thing of this.
BrandonUnited States
If one continues with the idea of Luke being a reference to the apostle, then, one must consider the etymological roots of Havergal. Really - haver|gal. Haver comes from Hebrew with a Biblical meaning of "companion." Gal - derived from Gall - has multiple meanings, here, I think it may refer to the "bitterness of spirit, bitterness." A.E. Robinson even writes "Bitter, but one..." so this offers an even stronger connection between what is bitter (death, suicide) and a Haver (companion): a bitter (death, dead) companion. Just a thought! :)
I absolutely adore poetry. If I could, I would be a professor of poetry at a university. I love to analyze and decipher the meanings of poems. However, when I read this, I am not filled with images of apostles, gods, or hells. I am overwhelmed with the melancholy image of a man searching for his love, who waits for him in the setting sun of life. Their star crossed love can be resurrected only in death. I believe the speaker is the man's inner concience. However, I could be totally oblivious and off course. It seems though that poetry, as reality, is naught but perception. The beauty of this poem and its eloquence lies in the mind of the reader.
Crimson = blood = death; vine = longing; wall = boundary between life and death = obstacle between Luke and lover --> Luke's longing for his lover made him embark on his suicidal journey to reunite with her, crossing the boundaries between life and death --> Luke's unwillingness to let go is the reason behind his lack of choice (apart from killing himself, aka the reason he must die and cannot live any longer) as he couldn't live without his lover --> Luke's nonacceptance of his lover's death is deadly
When I first read this poem I completely got lost. After reading it about forty times I began to catch on a little, but I am not sure what it all means, or who is the speaker.Well the speaker is clearly dead and telling Luke Havergal to go to the western gate because the eastern skies do not have a dawn. I think that maybe the western gate is heaven and the eastern skies is hell. In the third stanza (line 20)it implies that when Luke reaches a certain point they will tell him to go to hell or go to heaven.
i agree with Gloria on the east/west heaven and hell deal, but i'm confused about the "crimson leaves." they sound like fire, but their on the heaven side? i dunno. i really like this poem because it confuses me and makes me think, but i just can't figure it out completely. if you have any thoughts on this poem that you might want to share with me, email me. thanks!
I mean no disrespect, but I totally disagree with the comments on east and west. The sun sets in the west, thus representing death. The sun rises in the east, thus representing hope and life. Luke's love is dead, and the only way to her is to die. Even if there is no way to get to her, "the dark will end the dark." If death does not bring him to her, at least he will not have to suffer through life anymore. The "one way to where she is" that's "bitter" and that "faith can never miss" is death. The speaker (I don't know who) is pointing Luke to where his lover is, and the only way to get there is to die.
The western gate is death. The sun rises in the east-life and youth, and sets in the west-death. The crimson leaves represent the fall of his life, leaning towards winter(death). I think the speaker is Luke havergal's consious, or at least the part of him that wishes to die to be with his lover again. Perhaps the speaker is the voice that represents his desent into madness(perhaps) and death. When the speaker says…
Read the whole commentThe western gate is death. The sun rises in the east-life and youth, and sets in the west-death. The crimson leaves represent the fall of his life, leaning towards winter(death). I think the speaker is Luke havergal's consious, or at least the part of him that wishes to die to be with his lover again. Perhaps the speaker is the voice that represents his desent into madness(perhaps) and death. When the speaker says "out of a grave I come to tell you this" i believe he is pretending to be luke havergal's dead lover, to convince him more to kill himself. The speaker believes the only way for luke havergal to be happy again is to die(go to the western gate). The "dead words (the crimson leaves) say" are any reasons Luke Havergal might have not to kill himself.
This is a poet about Robinson's futileness of life. This poem clearly expresses death and the loss of love. It shows Robinsons loss of love - indeed he did lose love. And it talks about death - a Romantic aspect. In this poem we see Romantic aspects such as loss of love and death but we also see a realistic aspect of the futileness of love(or so it seems in Robinsons eyes). Rather interesting poem. It was published with other poems about his fictional Tillbury town characters who mirrored his experiences and feelings. This poem appeared with poems such as Richard Cory and Miniver Cheevy. Those are good reads to further understand Robinsons style and experience
I believe the crimson (red) leaves on the door represent hell. Anyone who kills themself is going to hell. Not the point though, he wants to either be with his dead lover or be dead and out of his misery. "God slays himself with every leaf that flies"- God is hurt everytime one of his sons (represented possibly by leaves?) falls (commits suicide). Which is why there are crimson leaves on the gate to hell.
It took me a while to full understand this poem and after reading about 20 times, I think I finally have a grasp on it. The speaker in this poem is the devil. He sees that Luke Havergal is heartbroken and lonely and greif-stricken and he wants to take advantage of this. Luke's love is dead and the only way Luke can ever be with her again is to die. The devil is trying to pursuade Luke into taking his own life, which…
Read the whole commentIt took me a while to full understand this poem and after reading about 20 times, I think I finally have a grasp on it. The speaker in this poem is the devil. He sees that Luke Havergal is heartbroken and lonely and greif-stricken and he wants to take advantage of this. Luke's love is dead and the only way Luke can ever be with her again is to die. The devil is trying to pursuade Luke into taking his own life, which would mean he is going against the Lord's Will, thus Luke would end up in hell. You can come to understand by the use of color and choice of words that EA uses. Crimson is mentioned many times throughout the poem. Crimson, or any other red color, usually respresents evil, or hell. The word 'fall' suggests defeat Luke's life. 'Fall' also represents a downward motion, and we all know that hell below heaven. Lastly, God doesn't need to convince people to come to heaven, nor would God ever slay himself. Suicide and God should never be used in the same sentence. That alone suggests sinister acts.
I would suggest everyone listen to this, and other E.A. Robinson poems set to music by John Duke. Although I understand and find truth in all your interpretations, I feel that when singing this song Luke is moving towards hope, even if that hope is death. Life is all about moving forward.
Friends, let us consider the wise words of Mr Housman:
"
Even when poetry has a meaning, as it usually has, it may be inadvisable to draw it out . . . Perfect understanding will sometimes almost extinguish pleasure
"
I'd say, as one reading Mr Robinson for the first time, that this applied here particularly. There's a strong elegaic feeling, melodically expressed, with potent pictures - but I feel it would crumble under plodding analysis.
On another tack, this is a great site, but plagued by pesky popups. Any chance of an ad-free subscription service?
I thought that the title might have a little meaning because LUKE IS IN THE bible and i thought that maby Havergal might be something of a meaning but i cant find any thing of this.
If one continues with the idea of Luke being a reference to the apostle, then, one must consider the etymological roots of Havergal. Really - haver|gal. Haver comes from Hebrew with a Biblical meaning of "companion." Gal - derived from Gall - has multiple meanings, here, I think it may refer to the "bitterness of spirit, bitterness." A.E. Robinson even writes "Bitter, but one..." so this offers an even stronger connection between what is bitter (death, suicide) and a Haver (companion): a bitter (death, dead) companion. Just a thought! :)
I absolutely adore poetry. If I could, I would be a professor of poetry at a university. I love to analyze and decipher the meanings of poems. However, when I read this, I am not filled with images of apostles, gods, or hells. I am overwhelmed with the melancholy image of a man searching for his love, who waits for him in the setting sun of life. Their star crossed love can be resurrected only in death. I believe the speaker is the man's inner concience. However, I could be totally oblivious and off course. It seems though that poetry, as reality, is naught but perception. The beauty of this poem and its eloquence lies in the mind of the reader.
Luke Havergal = "(Look), Have a go"?
Crimson = blood = death; vine = longing; wall = boundary between life and death = obstacle between Luke and lover
--> Luke's longing for his lover made him embark on his suicidal journey to reunite with her, crossing the boundaries between life and death
--> Luke's unwillingness to let go is the reason behind his lack of choice (apart from killing himself, aka the reason he must die and cannot live any longer) as he couldn't live without his lover
--> Luke's nonacceptance of his lover's death is deadly