Cliff Klingenhagen had me in to dine
With him one day; and after soup and meat,
And all the other things there were to eat,
Cliff took two glasses and filled one with wine
And one with wormwood. Then, without a sign
For me to choose at all, he took the draught
Of bitterness himself, and lightly quaffed
It off, and said the other one was mine.
And when I asked him what the deuce he meant
By doing that, he only looked at me
And smiled, and said it was a way of his.
And though I know the fellow, I have spent
Long time a-wondering when I shall be
As happy as Cliff Klingenhagen is.
✦
Analysis
Cliff Klingenhagen: analysis
Introduction
"Cliff Klingenhagen" is a sonnet about a small, puzzling ritual after dinner. Cliff pours two glasses, one of wine and one of bitter wormwood. Without offering his guest a choice, he drinks the wormwood himself and gives the wine away.
Asked why, he only smiles and says "it was a way of his." The speaker, his guest, cannot explain it. He ends by wondering when he will be as happy as Cliff is. The poem suggests, without stating it, that Cliff's happiness is bound up with his choice to take the bitter share.
Summary
The speaker recalls that Cliff Klingenhagen invited him to dinner one day. After the soup, the meat and the rest of the meal, Cliff took two glasses. He filled one with wine and the other with wormwood, a bitter drink. Then, without giving the speaker any chance to choose, Cliff took "the draught / Of bitterness" for himself. He drank it off lightly, with no sign of effort, and said that the wine was the speaker's.
The speaker asked Cliff what on earth he meant by pouring the bitter glass and drinking it himself. Cliff did not explain but only looked at him, smiled and said "it was a way of his." The speaker says that he knows Cliff well. Even so, he has spent a long time wondering when he himself will be as happy as Cliff Klingenhagen is. The poem ends on that open question and gives no further explanation of the ritual.
Themes and meaning
The central theme is the link between self-denial and happiness. Cliff chooses "the draught / Of bitterness" and gives the sweeter wine away. He is the happy one. The poem can be read as suggesting that taking the harder share freely brings a contentment the speaker lacks.
A second theme is generosity. Cliff has fed his guest well, with "soup and meat" and "all the other things." His final act extends that hospitality. He spares the guest even the chance of drawing the bitter cup, "without a sign / For me to choose at all."
A third theme is the mystery of other people. The speaker says "I know the fellow," yet he cannot explain him. Cliff's only answer is a smile and "a way of his." The poem leaves his reasons hidden, and readers supply their own.
A fourth theme is the speaker's own discontent. The final lines turn from Cliff to the speaker's "Long time a-wondering." He does not say he is unhappy, but the question "when I shall be / As happy" implies that he is not yet. The small puzzle becomes a lesson he has not learned.
Tone
The tone is casual and conversational. The speaker tells the story like an anecdote among friends, with plain details of "soup and meat." His question "what the deuce he meant" is mildly exasperated and colloquial.
Cliff's manner, as described, is easy and unhurried. He "lightly quaffed" the wormwood and simply "smiled." This calm contrasts with the speaker's puzzlement.
In the last three lines the tone turns reflective and wistful. The speaker admits he has spent "Long time a-wondering." There may be a trace of envy in "As happy as Cliff Klingenhagen is." The poem ends in quiet admiration rather than explanation.
Form and structure
The poem is a sonnet of 14 lines in 2 stanzas of 8 and 6 lines, the Italian division into octave and sestet. The octave's computed scheme is ABBAACDA. Its lines 6 and 7 end on "draught" and "quaffed," which the computed scheme does not pair. The sestet rhymes EFGEFG.
The metre is iambic pentameter, with most lines at 10 syllables. The octave tells what Cliff did, and the sestet turns to the speaker's question and reflection. Sentences run over line ends, as in lines 4 to 8, which keeps the anecdote moving like speech.
Poetic devices
Symbolism line 5
And one with wormwood Wormwood stands for bitterness and hardship, as wine stands for pleasure. The two glasses offer a choice between them.
Alliteration line 4
filled one with wine The "w" of "wine" runs on into "wormwood" in the next line. The linked sound sets the two drinks side by side.
Metaphor line 6
he took the draught The line runs on into "Of bitterness himself." The drink becomes a portion of life's bitterness that Cliff takes on himself.
Enjambment line 7
and lightly quaffed The action spills into "It off" in line 8. The run-on mirrors the easy, quick way Cliff drinks.
Caesura line 5
wormwood. Then, without a sign The pause after "wormwood" marks the moment of choice. Cliff then acts before the guest can speak.
Colloquial diction line 9
what the deuce he meant The mild oath shows the speaker's bafflement. It keeps the poem in an everyday voice.
Understatement line 11
said it was a way of his Cliff's answer explains nothing. It turns a strange act into a mere habit and keeps his reasons private.
Archaism line 13
Long time a-wondering The old-fashioned form stretches the wondering out. It suggests a long, unresolved puzzle.
Paradox line 14
As happy as Cliff Klingenhagen is The man who drinks the bitter cup is the happy one. The ending turns the story into a riddle about contentment.
Polysyndeton line 3
And all the other things there were to eat The chain of "and" rushes through the meal. It leaves the weight of the poem on the two glasses.
Words worth knowing
wormwood
A very bitter herb, or a drink made from it; long a byword for bitterness.
draught
A drink or dose. It is pronounced like draft.
quaffed
Drank heartily, in a single swallow.
deuce
In "what the deuce," a mild oath meaning what on earth.
a-wondering
An old-fashioned form of wondering.
dine
To eat dinner; "had me in to dine" means invited me to dinner.
Context
Edwin Arlington Robinson lived from 1869 to 1935. "Cliff Klingenhagen" was the archive's Poem of the Day on March 5, 2006. Readers left 6 comments on it here between 2006 and 2024.
What readers have said
Teresa Jewell sees Cliff as a self-made martyr who relishes the bitterness he expects from life and is happy in it. teresa Jewell, 2006
Jt reads Cliff as happy because he is unselfish. The wormwood ritual reminds him that he is here for others. jt, 2009
Jim Nichols reads Cliff as a Christ figure who drinks the bitter cup so that others may drink the wine. Jim Nichols, 2012
Harry M. finds a hidden meaning in the name: Cliff clings and hangs on at the edge of a cliff. Harry M., 2019
Ellen suggests that the sweetness of friendship is strong enough to overpower the bitterness of the drink. Ellen, 2024
Keep reading
Discover more of Edwin Arlington Robinson’s poetry.
Poor Cliff Klingenhagen goes through life being the center of a pity party. He assumes and accepts that the darkest of clouds will continue to hang over his head for the rest of his life, and he relishes in it. He does not look for a happy outcome in life, instead he welcomes the bitterness life has to offer, after all, he deserves it, and becomes a martyr. He is different, thus is curious to others.Poor pityful Cliff. He is the cortex of bad luck, and is happy in the making of it.
jtUnited States
Cliff is happy because he is unselfish. I think the wormwood ritual is his way of reminding himself that he's here for others, and not the other way around.
Inta GulbisUnited States
Tedy Roosevelt
The author of the poem, Robinson, was a great admirer of Roosevelt. I think the poem shows his admiration of Teddy but does it indirectly by calling him Cliff in the poem. He says Teddy is willing to quaff a stiff, bitter drink for his friends such as himself. This shows the selfless character of Teddy Roosevelt.
Jim NicholsUnited States
Cliff Klingenhagen
I know who Cliff Klingenhagen is and why he was so happy. It was my Lord who drank the bitter cup so that you and I could taste from the Fruit of the Vine around His table. It was bringing us into glory that was His joy that allowed Him to endure the cross, despising its shame. This is why He rose up from the dust of the Garden and said, “Shall I not drink the cup the Father has given me?” -- Jn. 18:11. Christ figures abound in poetry. Why not here too?
Cliff Kligenhagen has an attitude that distinguishes himself from other people. Because the author, Edwin Robinson, likes to have hidden meanings in the names of his poems, he made a special one here. The character Cliff sees a cliff, and he CLINGS and HANGS ON. Cliff Kling-and-hang-on
Ellen
The draft of friendship is so sweet that it overpowers any notes of bitterness.
Poor Cliff Klingenhagen goes through life being the center of a pity party. He assumes and accepts that the darkest of clouds will continue to hang over his head for the rest of his life, and he relishes in it. He does not look for a happy outcome in life, instead he welcomes the bitterness life has to offer, after all, he deserves it, and becomes a martyr. He is different, thus is curious to others.Poor pityful Cliff. He is the cortex of bad luck, and is happy in the making of it.
Cliff is happy because he is unselfish. I think the wormwood ritual is his way of reminding himself that he's here for others, and not the other way around.
Tedy Roosevelt
The author of the poem, Robinson, was a great admirer of Roosevelt. I think the poem shows his admiration of Teddy but does it indirectly by calling him Cliff in the poem. He says Teddy is willing to quaff a stiff, bitter drink for his friends such as himself. This shows the selfless character of Teddy Roosevelt.
Cliff Klingenhagen
I know who Cliff Klingenhagen is and why he was so happy.
It was my Lord who drank the bitter cup so that you and I could taste from the Fruit of the Vine around His table.
It was bringing us into glory that was His joy that allowed Him to endure the cross, despising its shame. This is why He rose up from the dust of the Garden and said, “Shall I not drink the cup the Father has given me?” -- Jn. 18:11.
Christ figures abound in poetry. Why not here too?
Cliff Kligenhagen has an attitude that distinguishes himself from other people. Because the author, Edwin Robinson, likes to have hidden meanings in the names of his poems, he made a special one here. The character Cliff sees a cliff, and he CLINGS and HANGS ON. Cliff Kling-and-hang-on
The draft of friendship is so sweet that it overpowers any notes of bitterness.