It was not dying: everybody died.
It was not dying: we had died before
In the routine crashes-- and our fields
Called up the papers, wrote home to our folks,
And the rates rose, all because of us.
We died on the wrong page of the almanac,
Scattered on mountains fifty miles away;
Diving on haystacks, fighting with a friend,
We blazed up on the lines we never saw.
We died like aunts or pets or foreigners.
(When we left high school nothing else had died
For us to figure we had died like.)
In our new planes, with our new crews, we bombed
The ranges by the desert or the shore,
Fired at towed targets, waited for our scores--
And turned into replacements and woke up
One morning, over England, operational.
It wasn't different: but if we died
It was not an accident but a mistake
(But an easy one for anyone to make.)
We read our mail and counted up our missions--
In bombers named for girls, we burned
The cities we had learned about in school--
Till our lives wore out; our bodies lay among
The people we had killed and never seen.
When we lasted long enough they gave us medals;
When we died they said, "Our casualties were low."
They said, "Here are the maps"; we burned the cities.
It was not dying --no, not ever dying;
But the night I died I dreamed that I was dead,
And the cities said to me: "Why are you dying?
We are satisfied, if you are; but why did I die?"
✦
Analysis
Losses: analysis
Introduction
Losses is a 32-line poem by Randall Jarrell, spoken by young airmen in a bombing war. The "we" of the poem trained in America, flew over England and burned cities. They died in training crashes and on missions, and their deaths were counted as statistics.
The poem keeps insisting "It was not dying," as if their deaths were too routine to deserve the word. It ends in a dream in which the burned cities question the dead speaker. The poem is about death made ordinary, killing at a distance, and a guilt the speaker cannot settle.
Summary
Stanza 1 (lines 1 to 12) opens with a refrain: "It was not dying." The speakers had died before, in routine crashes, and their fields wrote home to their families. They died far off, "Scattered on mountains," diving on haystacks or in collisions. They "died like aunts or pets or foreigners." In a closing parenthesis, they say nothing had died around them before high school to compare it with.
Stanza 2 (lines 13 to 17) describes training. In new planes with new crews, they bombed ranges by the desert or shore and fired at towed targets. Then they became replacements and woke one morning "over England, operational."
Stanza 3 (lines 18 to 27) says it was no different there. If they died, "It was not an accident but a mistake," and an easy one. They read their mail and counted their missions, and in bombers "named for girls," they burned cities they had learned about in school. Their bodies lay among people they had killed and never seen. Survivors got medals, and of the dead it was said, "Our casualties were low."
Stanza 4 (line 28) is a single line. An unnamed they said, "Here are the maps." The speakers "burned the cities."
Stanza 5 (lines 29 to 32) repeats that "It was not dying." But the speaker, now singular, dreamed on the night he died that he was dead. In the dream the cities speak to him. They ask why he is dying, say they are satisfied if he is, and ask, "but why did I die?"
Themes and meaning
The main theme is death made routine. The refrain "It was not dying" denies that these deaths had the weight the word implies. The airmen died in crashes, collisions and training, and the "rates rose." Their deaths become entries in an "almanac" and figures in a report. The bureaucratic line "Our casualties were low" shows how official language erases each death.
A second theme is youth and inexperience. The speakers are just out of "high school," where nothing they knew had died. The cities they bomb are ones "we had learned about in school." The bombers are "named for girls." These details show boys handed lethal power before they understood death at all.
A third theme is killing at a distance. The airmen blaze up "on the lines we never saw." Their bodies lie among "The people we had killed and never seen." Bombing lets them destroy without witnessing. The single-line stanza reduces the act to an order and its result: the maps, then the burning.
A fourth theme is guilt and the unanswered question. In the last stanza the "we" becomes "I," and the cities speak. Their question, "why did I die?," can be read in two ways. The "I" may be the cities themselves, asking why they were destroyed, or the cities may voice the dead airman's own question. The ambiguity joins killer and killed in one unanswerable why.
Tone
The tone is flat, ironic and numbed. The speakers report deaths in a level voice, like a list of facts. The comparisons to "aunts or pets or foreigners" sound almost offhand, which makes them chilling.
Irony sharpens in stanza 3. The distinction between "an accident" and "a mistake" is bitterly thin. The quoted official line about low casualties exposes the gap between experience and report.
The final stanza shifts into dream and doubt. The repeated "not ever dying" sounds like a protest that is failing. The cities' calm, strange speech leaves the poem on a note of guilt and bewilderment rather than resolution.
Form and structure
The poem has 32 lines in five stanzas of 12, 5, 10, 1 and 4 lines. Most lines have 10 to 12 syllables. The metre is a loose iambic pentameter, regular in places, such as line 1, and stretched elsewhere.
Rhyme is occasional, not patterned. Three lines end on "died," and the third stanza holds a couplet on "mistake" and "make." With "dying" closing two lines of the last stanza, these echoes make death the poem's recurring sound. Dashes and parentheses give the voice the hesitations of speech. The one-line fourth stanza isolates the poem's bluntest statement.
Poetic devices
Refrain line 2
It was not dying Repeated from line 1 and again at line 29, the denial becomes a refrain. Each return makes it less believable.
Metaphor line 6
We died on the wrong page of the almanac Deaths become entries in a book of dates and statistics. Wrong page suggests a death at a random, unfitting time.
Simile line 10
We died like aunts or pets or foreigners. The airmen compare their deaths to distant, minor losses. The offhand list shows how little death meant to them yet.
Diction line 17
operational A military word ends the stanza. The boys are now defined as working parts of a machine.
Rhyme line 20
But an easy one for anyone to make. It rhymes with mistake in line 19, a rare couplet. The neat sound mocks the casual way deadly errors are excused.
Irony line 22
In bombers named for girls, we burned Affectionate names on bombers sit beside the burning of cities. The innocence of youth is set against destruction.
Euphemism line 27
Our casualties were low. The official phrase reduces deaths to a figure. It shows how institutions talk about loss.
Paradox line 30
the night I died I dreamed that I was dead The dead speaker dreams of being dead. The line blurs life, death and dream.
Personification line 31
And the cities said to me The bombed cities speak. They become witnesses and questioners of the man who destroyed them.
Words worth knowing
almanac
A yearly book of calendars, dates and statistics. Here it suggests death recorded as a routine entry.
towed targets
Targets pulled behind another aircraft for gunnery practice.
replacements
Crews sent to fill the places of those lost.
operational
In military use, ready for active combat missions.
the rates rose
Most likely the figures for accidents or insurance went up. The poem does not say which.
What readers have said
Richard Begin reads the poem as being about the inevitability of loss and the absurdity of war, and hears the irregular rhyme as mocking that randomness. Richard Begin, 2005
Melanie, aged 14, feels sad and lonely reading it, and notes how the deaths are reduced to statistics. Melanie, 14yrs old, 2005
Peter Koning reads it as a reply to John Steinbeck's Bombs Away, setting its plain voice against that book's promotional language. Peter Koning, 2022
latese, preparing to perform the poem for an English class, asks other readers to explain it in full. latese, 2005
i would i like act out this poem for english class because we have to do a project on this poem so i need help setting this poem up please tell me what the poem is really talken about i know like some of it but i need to know all so that i can put this all together i really need help real bad so if you can help me in any way please do so
Richard BeginUnited States
To me, this poem talks about both the inevitibility of loss and the absurdity of war. Invisible tears sprinkle the pages the poem is written on. How do we reconcile tragic and needless loss of life? We don't. Lives sacrificed for nothing. What do you get? A ribbon? A medal? The poem leaves us, like billions before and after, to ponder folly of political power and the price for it. The irregular rhyme scheme mocks…
Read the whole comment
To me, this poem talks about both the inevitibility of loss and the absurdity of war. Invisible tears sprinkle the pages the poem is written on. How do we reconcile tragic and needless loss of life? We don't. Lives sacrificed for nothing. What do you get? A ribbon? A medal? The poem leaves us, like billions before and after, to ponder folly of political power and the price for it. The irregular rhyme scheme mocks this randomness, like the unspeakably mundane and disconnected acts of killing, acts that are rehearsed on depersonified "targets" till boredom, then carried out against "targets" not people, over "cities" who ask questions, not people.It's "war" not murder. It's justified so that makes it all OK doesn't it? Doesn't it? "Acts" or war aren't really "acts." There is no "acting." It's real. Real people die and for what? Acts of war. Nothing is in our control. Let this poem sink in, let it penetrate you. Go ahead, I dare you.
--Richie Begin, Santa Cruz
Melanie, 14yrs oldAustralia
This poem makes me feel sad and lonely…The subject is on young men going away to fight in the war. The theme is death. I think one of the reasons which makes you feel after you’ve read the poem is the reason of the young boy's death, and how like the many others who were killed in the war, their deaths are only viewed as statistics which we read about in books and see on tv. This particular death was just too quick,…
Read the whole comment
This poem makes me feel sad and lonely…The subject is on young men going away to fight in the war. The theme is death. I think one of the reasons which makes you feel after you’ve read the poem is the reason of the young boy's death, and how like the many others who were killed in the war, their deaths are only viewed as statistics which we read about in books and see on tv. This particular death was just too quick, too simple…a life of hopes and dreams wasted. It questions the meaning of life and the reason of war. Some people want to die, and commit suicide; giving away their life. Whereas this poem on a deeper level is about committing suicide; knowing it but not wanting it. Like it was all a big risk and then suddenly a mistake is made….and it’s all gone; a life. Dying for a cause: but in the end what was the point in it?
Oliver Brown
On line 16 in the poem losses it says ''and worke up'' while in other copies of the poem it says woke up so I think this should be addressed and changed
Peter Koning
I think, this poem can be read as a reply to John Steinbeck’s Bombs Away. Steinbeck wrote this pamflet early 1942 to promote the building of the USAF. Randall was one of many who joined the USAF in 1942. This poem is a hard contrast with the advertising language in Bombs Away.
i would i like act out this poem for english class because we have to do a project on this poem so i need help setting this poem up please tell me what the poem is really talken about i know like some of it but i need to know all so that i can put this all together i really need help real bad so if you can help me in any way please do so
To me, this poem talks about both the inevitibility of loss and the absurdity of war. Invisible tears sprinkle the pages the poem is written on. How do we reconcile tragic and needless loss of life? We don't. Lives sacrificed for nothing. What do you get? A ribbon? A medal? The poem leaves us, like billions before and after, to ponder folly of political power and the price for it. The irregular rhyme scheme mocks…
Read the whole commentTo me, this poem talks about both the inevitibility of loss and the absurdity of war. Invisible tears sprinkle the pages the poem is written on. How do we reconcile tragic and needless loss of life? We don't. Lives sacrificed for nothing. What do you get? A ribbon? A medal? The poem leaves us, like billions before and after, to ponder folly of political power and the price for it. The irregular rhyme scheme mocks this randomness, like the unspeakably mundane and disconnected acts of killing, acts that are rehearsed on depersonified "targets" till boredom, then carried out against "targets" not people, over "cities" who ask questions, not people.It's "war" not murder. It's justified so that makes it all OK doesn't it? Doesn't it? "Acts" or war aren't really "acts." There is no "acting." It's real. Real people die and for what? Acts of war. Nothing is in our control. Let this poem sink in, let it penetrate you.
Go ahead, I dare you.
--Richie Begin, Santa Cruz
This poem makes me feel sad and lonely…The subject is on young men going away to fight in the war. The theme is death. I think one of the reasons which makes you feel after you’ve read the poem is the reason of the young boy's death, and how like the many others who were killed in the war, their deaths are only viewed as statistics which we read about in books and see on tv. This particular death was just too quick,…
Read the whole commentThis poem makes me feel sad and lonely…The subject is on young men going away to fight in the war. The theme is death. I think one of the reasons which makes you feel after you’ve read the poem is the reason of the young boy's death, and how like the many others who were killed in the war, their deaths are only viewed as statistics which we read about in books and see on tv. This particular death was just too quick, too simple…a life of hopes and dreams wasted. It questions the meaning of life and the reason of war. Some people want to die, and commit suicide; giving away their life. Whereas this poem on a deeper level is about committing suicide; knowing it but not wanting it. Like it was all a big risk and then suddenly a mistake is made….and it’s all gone; a life. Dying for a cause: but in the end what was the point in it?
On line 16 in the poem losses it says ''and worke up'' while in other copies of the poem it says woke up so I think this should be addressed and changed
I think, this poem can be read as a reply to John Steinbeck’s Bombs Away. Steinbeck wrote this pamflet early 1942 to promote the building of the USAF. Randall was one of many who joined the USAF in 1942. This poem is a hard contrast with the advertising language in Bombs Away.
Peter Koning
Netherlands