I shall not sing a May song.
A May song should be gay.
I'll wait until November
And sing a song of gray.
I'll wait until November
That is the time for me.
I'll go out in the frosty dark
And sing most terribly.
And all the little people
Will stare at me and say,
"That is the Crazy Woman
Who would not sing in May."
✦
Analysis
The Crazy Woman: analysis
Introduction
This short poem in three quatrains is spoken by a woman who refuses to sing in spring. She says a May song should be cheerful, and she will wait for November instead. There she will sing a song of gray, out in the dark.
The poem is about refusing what is expected. It sets a private, darker truth against public cheer. Its sing-song form, like a nursery rhyme, makes the refusal both playful and unsettling.
Summary
In the first stanza the speaker states plainly that she will not sing a May song. A May song, she says, should be "gay", meaning cheerful and light. She will wait instead until November, late in the autumn. Then she will "sing a song of gray", a song to match the season.
In the second stanza she repeats that she will wait for November. That month, she says, "is the time for me". She pictures herself going out alone in the "frosty dark" of a cold night. There she will "sing most terribly", in a voice that suits the darkness.
In the third stanza she imagines how others will react to her singing. The "little people" will stare at her and then talk among themselves about what they have seen. They will name her "the Crazy Woman", in words she quotes directly. Their only reason will be that she "would not sing in May".
Themes and meaning
The central theme is refusal of expected feeling. Spring calls for joy, and a May song "should be gay". The speaker declines this rule. She chooses a season that matches her own mood instead. The poem treats this choice as deliberate, not as a loss of control.
A second theme is authenticity. The speaker says November "is the time for me". Her song of "gray" belongs to her. Singing a cheerful song in May would be false. The poem can be read as valuing an honest, dark song over a dishonest bright one.
The poem also considers how society labels those who differ. The "little people" stare and call her crazy. Their only evidence is that she broke a seasonal custom. The title takes up their label, but the poem lets us hear her reasons first. This invites the reader to question the word "Crazy".
The phrase "little people" carries an edge. It may mean ordinary townsfolk, or children. It may also suggest people of small understanding. The ambiguity lets the speaker look down on her judges.
Finally, the poem links the seasons with inner states. May stands for brightness and youth. November, "frosty" and "dark", stands for grief or age. The speaker's choice of November can be read as an acceptance of sorrow, or of her own darker nature.
Tone
The tone is calm and firm. The opening "I shall not" is a clear refusal, stated without apology. The speaker sounds certain of her own mind.
In the second stanza the tone grows darker and more defiant. She will go out in the "frosty dark". She will sing "most terribly", a phrase that is almost gleeful. It could mean badly, or in a way that inspires terror.
The last stanza adds irony. The speaker imagines her own label and quotes it without protest. She seems unbothered by being called crazy. The light nursery-rhyme rhythm sits against the dark content throughout. That mismatch gives the poem its slightly eerie edge.
Form and structure
The poem has 12 lines in three quatrains. Lines alternate between 7 and 6 syllables, with one 8-syllable line. Each line carries three stresses, so the metre is a loose trimeter. The rhythm is close to a ballad or nursery song.
The computed scheme shows the second and fourth lines rhyming in the first and third stanzas: "gay" and "gray", "say" and "May". These are the same sound, which binds the poem's opening and close. The second stanza has no full rhyme. Its repeated "I'll wait until November" links it to the first stanza instead.
Poetic devices
Rhyme line 4
And sing a song of gray. The rhyme of "gray" with "gay" in line 2 sets the two moods side by side in sound.
Repetition line 5
I'll wait until November Repeating line 3 shows how firmly the speaker holds to her choice.
Symbol line 3
November The late, cold month stands for darkness, sorrow or age, set against bright May.
Imagery line 7
the frosty dark Cold and darkness give the speaker's chosen setting a bleak, wintry feel.
Ambiguity line 8
sing most terribly The phrase can mean singing badly or singing something terrible, and the poem allows both.
Alliteration line 1
sing a May song The repeated s sound adds a song-like lilt to the refusal.
Irony line 11
That is the Crazy Woman The crowd's label is given in their own words, but the poem has shown her reasons are clear.
Diction line 9
all the little people The phrase may mean children or townsfolk, but also hints at small minds.
Words worth knowing
gay
Cheerful, merry. This is the older, general sense of the word.
May song
A song for spring, the season of celebration and new growth.
terribly
Can mean very badly, or in a way that causes terror.
What readers have said
Jacqueline Amos hears the poem as revealing the inner soul of darkness and answers it with her own lines about light rising from the dark. Jacqueline Amos, 2005
Morgan, researching the poet for an English project, calls it an amazing poem. Morgan, 2007
Liindsay, also researching the poet for a school project, finds the poem very interesting. liindsay, 2008
I think poem is very good. I especially like how it rymes.
Jacqueline AmosUnited States
Oh but the crazy lady a wait for the gray, not much happiness for de' month of may, in de mist of darkness, the night shall be dark, the pain that sits upon the gloomy heart, oh shall the soul live upon the dark, one day de' lord shall show me the sun, I cry upon the gloomy night, daughter of the sun shall bring me light. In de' dark shall bring forth light.
This poem crazy lady reveals the inner soul of darkness, It inspires the soul to speak, this is excellent.
wildcatUnited States
i heard this once and memorized it. this is wonderful!
jessicaUnited States
this poem was spectacular for me and im 13 years old.
MorganUnited States
I am currently researching Gwendolyn Brooks for an English project and I came upon this poem. This is an amazing poem and I love it. : )
liindsayUnited States
i to am researching about gwendolyn brooks for my english project. i find this poem very interesting.
OkaforUnited States
The Crazy Woman
if anyone would be able to tell me when the poem was published...that would be great
I think poem is very good. I especially like how it rymes.
Oh but the crazy lady a wait for the gray, not much happiness for de' month of may, in de mist of darkness, the night shall be dark, the pain that sits upon the gloomy heart, oh shall the soul live upon the dark, one day de' lord shall show me the sun, I cry upon the gloomy night, daughter of the sun shall bring me light. In de' dark shall bring forth light.
This poem crazy lady reveals the inner soul of darkness, It inspires the soul to speak, this is excellent.
i heard this once and memorized it. this is wonderful!
this poem was spectacular for me and im 13 years old.
I am currently researching Gwendolyn Brooks for an English project and I came upon this poem. This is an amazing poem and I love it. : )
i to am researching about gwendolyn brooks for my english project. i find this poem very interesting.
The Crazy Woman
if anyone would be able to tell me when the poem was published...that would be great