There is another sky

Portrait of Emily Dickinson
Emily Dickinson 1830–1886
2Complete Poems of Emily Dickinson

There is another sky, Ever serene and fair, And there is another sunshine, Though it be darkness there; Never mind faded forests, Austin, Never mind silent fields - Here is a little forest, Whose leaf is ever green; Here is a brighter garden, Where not a frost has been; In its unfading flowers I hear the bright bee hum: Prithee, my brother, Into my garden come!

From the bookComplete Poems of Emily DickinsonEdited by Thomas H. Johnson (Little, Brown)

There is another sky: analysis

Introduction

"There is another sky" is a short lyric addressed to a brother named Austin. The speaker sets a world of decline against another world that never fades. That other world is first a sky and a sunshine, then a forest and a garden. By the end the speaker calls it "my garden" and invites the brother in.

The poem stands second in the Complete Poems of Emily Dickinson (1955). Its subject is consolation. It offers comfort against loss, but it leaves open where the comfort is found. The other sky may be a heaven, or it may be the speaker's own inner world.

Summary

The poem opens with a plain statement. There is "another sky", always "serene and fair". There is also "another sunshine", even though there is darkness there. The speaker does not yet say where this sky is.

In line 5 the speaker turns to the listener and names him, Austin. Twice the speaker tells him "Never mind". He is to pay no attention to "faded forests" or to "silent fields". A dash at the end of line 6 marks a pause before the next move.

Now the speaker points to something close at hand. "Here is a little forest", and its leaf is always green. "Here is a brighter garden", where frost has never fallen. The flowers in this garden do not fade. Among them the speaker can hear "the bright bee hum".

The last two lines are a request. The speaker addresses the listener as "my brother". The speaker asks him to come into the garden. The poem closes on an exclamation mark, with the invitation still open and no reply given.

Themes and meaning

Consolation against decay is the main theme. The poem sets two worlds side by side. One is marked by loss, with "faded forests" and "silent fields". The other is marked by permanence: a leaf "ever green", "unfading flowers" and a garden "Where not a frost has been". The repeated "Never mind" implies the brother is dwelling on the first world, and the speaker wants to turn him away from it.

The nature of the other world is left open. The first four lines speak of "another sky" that stays bright "Though it be darkness there". This can be read as heaven, a light that survives death.

The second half moves the place nearer. "There is" in line 1 becomes "Here is" in line 7. That shift suggests a refuge available now, perhaps imagination, memory or poetry itself. The text supports both readings, and the ambiguity lives in that change of word.

Kinship and invitation form a third theme. The poem is an appeal from one sibling to another. It uses the name "Austin" and the phrase "my brother", and "my garden" makes the refuge personal. The speaker does not only describe a better place but offers to share it. The comfort depends on the brother choosing to come.

Light within darkness is a fourth idea. The poem joins opposites without explaining them. Sunshine exists where there is darkness. A garden is "brighter" while the fields outside are "silent". The poem asks the reader to accept that brightness and loss can exist together.

Tone

The poem opens calm and assured. "There is another sky" is stated as fact, with no argument offered. Line 4 admits darkness, but the admission does not shake the speaker's confidence.

With "Never mind" in lines 5 and 6 the tone becomes coaxing. It is gentle, but it also brushes aside the brother's sadness. The name "Austin" makes the address direct and familiar.

From line 7 the tone warms. The speaker points with "Here is" twice, as if showing a visitor round. The sound of "the bright bee hum" adds cheerfulness.

The close is affectionate and pleading. "Prithee" is old-fashioned and courtly, which can be read as tender or as playful. The final exclamation mark ends the poem on eager hope.

Form and structure

The poem is a single stanza of 14 lines. It has the length of a sonnet but none of its rhyme or structure. Lines run from 4 to 9 syllables, and most have six.

The metre is a loose iambic trimeter. Lines such as "Whose leaf is ever green" and "I hear the bright bee hum" are regular. Others add a light ending or open on a stress, as "Ever serene and fair" does. Line 13 is shortest, with only two stresses.

Rhyme is sparse. Line 2 and line 4 rhyme on "fair" and "there". Line 12 and line 14 rhyme on "hum" and "come". This gives the opening and the close a firm ending, while the middle runs unrhymed.

Poetic devices

Anaphora line 1
There is another sky The opening "There is" returns in line 3. The repetition makes the other world sound certain, as a fact rather than a wish.
Paradox line 4
Though it be darkness there Sunshine is placed where there is darkness. The contradiction suggests a light that does not depend on ordinary daylight, such as faith or inner vision.
Apostrophe line 5
Never mind faded forests, Austin, The speaker names the listener directly. The poem turns from statement to personal address.
Alliteration line 5
faded forests The repeated f sound links the two words and gives the image of decline a soft, falling sound.
Repetition line 6
Never mind silent fields The second "Never mind" presses the point. It shows the speaker working to draw the brother away from what saddens him.
Anaphora line 9
Here is a brighter garden "Here is" repeats from line 7 and answers the earlier "There is". The refuge moves from far away to close at hand.
Imagery line 8
Whose leaf is ever green The evergreen leaf contrasts with the faded forests of line 5. The single leaf stands for foliage that never dies.
Auditory imagery line 12
I hear the bright bee hum Sound answers the silent fields of line 6. The humming bee makes the garden alive and busy.
Alliteration line 12
bright bee The paired b sounds add lightness and energy to the garden scene.
Inversion line 14
Into my garden come! The verb is moved to the end. This places "come" on the rhyme with "hum" and makes the invitation the poem's last word.

Words worth knowing

Prithee
An old contraction of 'I pray thee', meaning 'please'. It was already archaic, and it lends the request a formal or playful courtesy.
fair
Here 'clear and bright', as of weather, not 'just' or 'pale'.
serene
'Calm and cloudless', a sense used of skies and weather.
ever green
Written as two words, 'always green'. It also plays on 'evergreen', a tree that keeps its leaves through winter.
Though it be
An old subjunctive form, meaning 'even though it is'.

What readers have said

  • Robert Mahlstedt read the poem as a call to a brother serving in the Union Army. In his view the brother was either in service or dead, and the speaker summons him in thought. Robert Mahlstedt, 2004
  • Min Yee rejected that reading, arguing that the poem predates the Civil War and that Austin outlived the poet. Min Yee, 2005
  • Rachael read the speaker as already dead, telling the brother that heaven is better and asking him to join her there. rachael, 2005
  • Jon saw jealousy in the poem. He read the faded forests as the world the brother entered by marrying, and the garden as the sister's world she wants him back in. Jon, 2005
  • Jude noticed the contrasting adjectives, bright and fair against darkness and faded, and a gentle possessiveness in the words my and here. Jude, 2005
  • Juan read the poem as sisterly support for a brother in hard times, or as an invitation to share a world of art and imagination. Juan, 2007

This analysis was drafted from the poem’s text, the records of American Poems and the readers’ comments. Every quotation and line number was checked against the poem, scanned for unsupported claims, and the editor read and revised it before publication. Facts about the poet’s life appear only when a source is given. Corrections are welcome through the contact page.

Revised in September 2026.

Keep reading

Discover more of Emily Dickinson’s poetry.

Explore all poems

Readers

Reader discussion 141 comments

Add your reading ↓
Readers
124
Stanzas quoted
1of 1
Most quoted
“There is another sky”8 readers
Longest reading
Lily431 words
  1. danike Australia

    I think your poem is absolutely gorgeous hun! youv done well with your work and i hope your continuing on with your poetry! well dont girl! xox

  2. Lucas Newton Australia

    I actually used this poem for and essay because I thought this was inspirational!

  3. jessie New Zealand

    i dont no wat its about and i have an iq of 146 so that can't be good, it should have a clear message but it doesn't

  4. Robert Mahlstedt United States

    The poem is to her brother who has seen service in the Union Army. At its writing he is either in the army or dead. She is mentally calling him to her.

  5. LP Taiwan

    What a beautiful poem!
    *o*

  6. Monica India

    It's a good poem having an under current of spirtuality.She wants to meet hert brother but realizes that he is somewhere in a different world having a different sky ,sun ,forests. World which is free from frost symbolising coldness of the hearts of the people

  7. Audren Glass United States

    R. Mahlstedt is right, I think. But perhaps she is also consoling the brother, if he is dead. Somehow this poem projects a very high level of comfort.

  8. Adamu Ibrahim Nigeria

    I really enjoy this poem because, this poet Emily is not only talking about her brother or what.Due to the fact that poem can mean different thin to people,but for me it means that when you fall down in life and there is a long way to go, just dust your self and start again.

  9. pia China

    I always take her garden in this poem as her poetry. The whole poem is an invitation to read her writing, her OTHER self other than her actual one in life. She has a real garden,but this garden in this poem is an artistic garden. For her, art lasts forever.

  10. Kelsey United States

    I could be way off. But i think this poem is written to a person close to her. I believe she is calling to him to say that there is no other place she would rather be then with him. It is a great poem!

  11. Dawn United States

    I really think that Emily Dickinson wanted to symbolize love as saying "its flowers never die" I think that the name "Austin" may have been her lover. I could be wrong but its my oppinion! This is really great poem! Her choice of words was amazing....!!!!!!!!!

  12. Tatum United States

    I'm probably off coarse here, but I believe that Emily is speaking to a lover. I think she is inviting him to be with her because she has alot to offer. Although, this is at first glance. I really have no back up info.

  13. belinda United States

    i think she was talking to a brother or close friend that she loves to be with. it is very beautiful...

  14. Michelle United States

    I think this is a very beautiful poem. I believe it talks about that she is very sad that a loved one is leaving her but that she will see him in a better place. That her loved one will never see sadness or darkness there. I really loved this poem and I chose it for my homework in theatre !!

  15. Lindsey United States

    i love your poems...i thought they are really emotional...i liked all poems you do they are just so entertaining!

  16. Michelle United States

    If one thinks about what Emily Dickinson means when she writes there is another sky, then maybe one can get a better understanding and interpretation of a true meaning. Now obviously, no one can actually say this is exactly what the poem means, because we didn't write it, these words only came from the hands of Emily's - no one elses'. However, we can develop some sort of interest in this poem because Emily's words…

    Read the whole comment

    If one thinks about what Emily Dickinson means when she writes there is another sky, then maybe one can get a better understanding and interpretation of a true meaning. Now obviously, no one can actually say this is exactly what the poem means, because we didn't write it, these words only came from the hands of Emily's - no one elses'. However, we can develop some sort of interest in this poem because Emily's words capture the light and want to bring forth a true defining identity of the poem's meaning. What I believe the poem means is that there is another place somewhere in this world that is so serene and fair, a place that treats people with respect and dignity, no fighting, no harsh feelings, no humiliating actions, no decieving individuals - a place where there is another sunshine - another atmosphere- another envrionment for people to live about although there may be darkness there- although some bad may occur and yet she is talking to someone as most of us noticed. His name is Austin. Could he be her long-lost husband? A friend? A soulmate?And where is he? Maybe he is lost or in another place. But then later on in the poem she says "Prithee, my brother, Into my garden come!" Maybe she is talking to her brother .... who knows? ONly she.

  17. Macey United States

    I think she is talking about is wherever there is darkness their is light, and wherever there is light
    their is hope for her brother. Well like saying "We
    fall down but we get up".

  18. amanda Hindahl United States

    I love this poem cause she always has a way with words when it comes to poems.I mean she talks about her brother and all that stuff I think that it is really neat that you can turn your feelings into a wonderful poem and what not

  19. kell United States

    SWEET!

  20. Alexis United States

    i think that this poem means that there is another world waiting for us

  21. Dunia Canada

    i really like this poem. it means a lot to me. i thnk Emily Dickinson is the best.

  22. Natalia Chile

    this is a great poem for all ages and, depending on how old you are, it holds a different meaning for everyone. Even though Emily Dickinson is dead, her soul lives on through her poetry.

  23. isadora quiñonez Mexico

    I think Emily Dickinson is the best poet of all times but I really try hard to understand her poems and this poem I think she is talking to her brother telling that there is another world.

  24. S. Schuhmacher

    I use tihs poem for my essay, I think the content is very nice!

  25. harlan United States

    This was to her older brother Austin one of the few close people who was not taken from her. She was trying to comfort him. One of her not so mysterious poems actually rather straight forward, still great.

  26. Unknown Hero United States

    well to each his own. What it means to you is what it means to you. To me, looking into her past, this poem still focuses on death/life after death. All the things mentioned in the poem seems to me to be refering to heaven. So more or less what i got out of it summorized is this life his hard heaven awaits you dont get down you'll get your reward.

    If any of you feel this is what she is saying say so if not say no. Get back to me thanks for reading: Unknown Hero

  27. Lindsay United States

    I think this a great poem! I also think its talking about her brother.

  28. Lacy United States

    i liked this poem i think it was to show her brother that theres alwasy a better day and something to look forward to in the future

  29. Jude India

    what caught my attention in this poem was the use of contradictory adjectives and words: fair/bright
    x darkness/faded; sunshine x frost. The reference to skies and gentle yet firm hint of possessiveness with my and here and a note of allurement with "Here is a little forest". Dickinson's father had built an extensive garden and conservatory for her.Nextdoor lived Austin in a house built by their father, the two houses seperated by a narrow path "just wide enough for two who love". The poem, to me reads like a supplication against isolation and alienation.

  30. Jon United States

    During the time area where she could have possibly written this poem, Emily Dickenson's brother Ausin married her best friend. Now, after this fact the analysis of this poem differs from person to person but here is mine: she does not like that her brother is with another woman, and that she has left her in her own world, or "forest." That is what I see withiin the first 6 lines of the poem, the "faded forests" and…

    Read the whole comment

    During the time area where she could have possibly written this poem, Emily Dickenson's brother Ausin married her best friend. Now, after this fact the analysis of this poem differs from person to person but here is mine: she does not like that her brother is with another woman, and that she has left her in her own world, or "forest." That is what I see withiin the first 6 lines of the poem, the "faded forests" and "silent fields." She wants him to come back to her forest, or world, where they can be happy forever in a perfect world. This perfect world is with her, and it is a "brighter garden, where not a frost has been, in its unfading flowers." The last two lines finish the poem with a plead that her brother leave her traitorous best friend for her instead.

    It's a beautiful poem, written in loneliness, jealousy, and sadness.

  31. jon United States

    And also, Emily Dickenson is DEAD. So, she can't write any more poems or read your encouragements. LOL!

  32. Rachel Winter United States

    Many of you, as I have noticed, seem to think that the person Austin mentioned in the poem "There is Another Sky" is some sort of soulmate or lover or long- lost friend. If any of the people who mentioned something like this, then you should have read at least the first couple of paragraphs on her biography presented on the home page. It tells of her family and of how she just so happened to have one older brother.…

    Read the whole comment

    Many of you, as I have noticed, seem to think that the person Austin mentioned in the poem "There is Another Sky" is some sort of soulmate or lover or long- lost friend. If any of the people who mentioned something like this, then you should have read at least the first couple of paragraphs on her biography presented on the home page. It tells of her family and of how she just so happened to have one older brother. Guess what his name was? Austin. Yes, that's right, Austin. As Jon (below) has also mentioned, it is her brother. I think that she may have missed her brother terribly when he left to start his own life and family, so it is like a plea to get him to come visit more or to move back in.

  33. taylor United States

    i think this poem is fabulous!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!for some strange reason!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!but it's ausome!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! i don't know why!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! but i love it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  34. neen n kt United States

    These poems by this wonderful lady just touch our hearts and souls. We have never read such astounding work. And yet, we haven't even read the damn poem! Oh, dear. I joke, I joke with you. I hope she will write more of theses gorgeous masterpieces.

  35. Andy

    I think Emily Dickinson is way overrated and i can't believe that I found a poem of hers that makes a little sense. When you look at it, she lived a pathetic life and in my opinion is a worhtless piece of gothic trash

  36. Lasah Georgia, Republic of

    Oh! this is vey dramatic, mysterious poem, it touched my heart very much, I loved it, because it's so clear describing her feelings, which were so sad, nice and thoughtful. I think it's one of the best American poems.

  37. Sabrina United States

    I like this poem. I cant discribe it, but I think it is beautiful.

  38. rachelle Bulgaria

    nice poem realy has a deep meaning

  39. othusitse Botswana ↩ replying to Jude

    am also caught by the use of contradictory adjectives used in this poem,just as Jude from India poited them out.otherwise the poem is a marvell to read.

  40. well Barbados

    well i think that the poem is just like other ordinary poem, not like what people said...

  41. Tiffany Dunham United States

    this poem is great your a great wrighter.... And i want to be just like you..... thanks

  42. Barboxacon Australia ↩ replying to well

    Well. A. Austin is Emily's brother. B. Yes. Emily Dickison is dead. Anyway, these are my thoughts - "There is another sky, Ever serene and fair, And there is another sunshine, Though it be darkness there;" - Austin, Emily's brother, married one of her friends, Sue. I am quite certain that Sue is being refered to, as the other sky. "Never mind faded forests, Austin, Never mind silent fields - Here is a little forest,…

    Read the whole comment

    Well. A. Austin is Emily's brother. B. Yes. Emily Dickison is dead. Anyway, these are my thoughts -

    "There is another sky,
    Ever serene and fair,
    And there is another sunshine,
    Though it be darkness there;" - Austin, Emily's brother, married one of her friends, Sue. I am quite certain that Sue is being refered to, as the other sky.

    "Never mind faded forests, Austin,
    Never mind silent fields -
    Here is a little forest,
    Whose leaf is ever green;" - Emily's plea to Austin, to not care so much about Sue, to come back to her, and her garden, evergreen, as is her love, as he is family.

    "Here is a brighter garden,
    Where not a frost has been;
    In its unfading flowers
    I hear the bright bee hum:
    Prithee, my brother,
    Into my garden come!" - No frost there has been, Emily and Austin appear to have had a loving brother/sister relationship. Emily cared alot about her brother, and misses him not being about.

  43. Callie Canada

    i love this poem. so totally cool

  44. rachael United States

    emily wrote this poem as if she were all ready dead telling her brother that heven is better and he should come and be with her.

  45. stephanie hernandez United States

    i thought the poem was really great

  46. Greg New Zealand

    she built a world for him with her words, after his death, that is so powerful wow

  47. Laura Iceland

    People who can't spell should not comment on the works of an intelligent, emotional women.

  48. Daisy United States

    i like the fact that everyone who commented (postivly) actully enjoy reading and interpetating the poems. i partiuculy dont like to read, or interpert poems, yet i am on this site because i have to read/interpert a poem everyweek and write 2 pages on it! basically wut i wannted to say wass that good for the peaople who actully care about poems and stuff.......and ur comments really help me with figureing out the poem cuz all i care about is skateing,music, friends, and guyz ;)

    i got A on my last one with you guyzez help!!
    thanks so much!!

    -Daisy

  49. joe Barbados

    i think this peom incourages death

  50. Brittany United States

    I interpreted this poem as Emily Pleading with her brother and society as a whole to learn to think out of the box and not conform to what society/media tells you to think. However I have only read a brief biography on her so I'm sure it could be interpreted any number of ways.All in all i think it served its purpose.

  51. sarah Canada

    i think that this is quite a lovely poem and i am doing a school project on her and this is one of the best poems i've read so far.

  52. sammmm United States

    this poem is really encouraging. its really helped me to make some desicions in my life. :/ :)

  53. Andy United States

    Emily Dickinson was a complete waste of space. OK maybe she came up with some good poems, but I think I would be able to think up some good lines if I was a hermit and stared at a wall for days on end. She was a depressing load of junk and I can't stand to even think of how boring her life was.

  54. Min Yee

    You wrote: 'I think Emily Dickinson is way overrated and i can't believe that I found a poem of hers that makes a little sense. When you look at it, she lived a pathetic life and in my opinion is a worhtless piece of gothic trash'

    Amazing, since most of the literate world would probably agree that Emily Dickinson is the greatest female poet -- at least in the English language.

  55. Min Yee United States

    "During the time area where she could have possibly written this poem, Emily Dickenson's brother Ausin married her best friend."

    This poem was written about 1851. Austin and Sue became engaged in 1853, were married in 1856.

  56. Min Yee United States

    This was written about 10 years before the Civil War started. Also, her brother Austin outlived Emily, so Austin is neither in the army nor dead.

  57. emily United States

    i thought the peom said alot about garden and it was very postive and it had nothing to do with death it was happy and colorful and it helped me oven my eyes to knew things in life.

  58. leah Chile

    this poem rocks its pimpin yeaha partner im a redneck!!!

  59. Dave Rogers United Kingdom

    i love this piece, as i do all Dickinson's work

    This maybe a tad cliche ...
    but what about 'There is another sky' at a postmodern electra complex?

    lonely recluse, misses her brother, but to what extent?

    Here is a little forest,
    Whose leaf is ever green;
    Here is a brighter garden,
    Where not a frost has been;
    In its unfading flowers
    I hear the bright bee hum:
    Prithee, my brother,
    Into my garden come!

    massive ammounts of sexual undertones here ...

    or maybe im just being smutty!

  60. [email removed] Israel

    "...Ophelia:
    So are we shepherding a flock of silly words and thoughts seeking to get off the eminence?
    Is that the gist? - to keep both of your flesh and mind exalted?
    Along with feelings and words? Just words... and words... and words..."

  61. Julie Canada

    After my first reading of this poem, I thought she was speaking of death. Entering a brighter forest, where the leaves are always green and no frost has come.
    Just a thought....

  62. Mason

    I dislike this poem greatly

  63. R. Smith United States

    There are several comments that would not even qualify to grace the walls of the world's sorest latrines.

  64. Bobby

    this poem blowses

  65. T-sizzle Bahamas ↩ replying to emily

    this is ny favorite poem I have ever heard, I love emily dickinson and she is my idol so good luck

  66. Jane Austin United States

    THis Poem is so wonderful.It's in my belief that she's talking about death and entering a new world,a spiritual world.And since around the time she wrote this there was a religous debate happening it probilly written to show HER beliefs.This poem is so deep i abostly love it!

  67. sfiawong United States

    I like this piece of poem, because it looks so simple but with full of sexual love. Why most of us can't write such simple poems can express freely with our mood?

  68. Gulzor Nazarova Uzbekistan ↩ replying to emily

    I think that peopel shoud lissen to Emily when she was life now nowbodu really can tell what is her poems about. But she is really good writer and every person that rides this poem think that Emily thoud execly the same way as they do.
    But shi is still good poet.

  69. paul United States ↩ replying to Bobby

    i agree with bobby and mason, this poem sucks, maybe if someone would explain it to me it would be better

  70. emily United States ↩ replying to Bobby

    i aggree with bobby, mason, and paul
    i want to make out with you and have a 4 way i'm so horny!

  71. emily United States ↩ replying to emily

    i am 18 annd i am doing a report about emily it is very boring!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    love ya paul,mason and bobby!!

  72. Suada Numanovich Turkey

    I like this poem very much "There is another sky".
    Her poems are absolutely GORGEUS.I think she is talking here about heaven by symbolising her LOVE and SADNESS.
    Please be kind while making your comments about her....

  73. Megan Smith United States

    This poem expresses how much one person can think of the world being different. She sees it through her eyes

  74. penguin poems United States ↩ replying to emily

    emily dickinson is a great poet, and anyone who mocks is a bastard that doesn't know what they're talking about. go to hell pual emily and bobby!!

  75. Jaqueline United States ↩ replying to emily

    i think that this is a great poem...it shows that different peple have a different point of view...emily dickinson has some really great poems, u just have to understand them!

  76. alyssa lucido United States

    i really thaught this peom had meaning, i write peoms myself and my peoms meant alot to me and i am sure they could mean alot to her and the funni thing is im only 15.

  77. Marlene United States

    I just love this poem it has such meaning in a hidden sence. Its beautiful!!!

  78. Stephanie United States ↩ replying to emily

    Umm... the comments made on this site are very rude. I hope emily dickinson is cursing you from her grave! Sorry, but this poem is pretty straighforward if you have any smarts whatsoever. Whoever said they dont get this poem is pretty damn stupid.... to disrespect such a renowned poet is pretty immature and shameful...like you could write a better poem... HA! yeah right...obviously your just too damn stupid to do anything

  79. Gary United States ↩ replying to stephanie hernandez

    Stephanie, before you get so high and mighty about those of us who don't appreciate Dickinson poems, you might want to address your own shortcomings. For example, there are rules of capitalization for proper names and there is a very distinct difference between "your" and "you're". Personally, I'd rather be "damn" stupid than either damned illiterate or damned self-righteous . . . or worse, both!

  80. Wyatt United States ↩ replying to stephanie hernandez

    Stephanie,
    Who are you to talk to the people in such a way. Opinions are one thing, and everyone is entitled to them, but who are you to call people "stupid" (and that has to be the most ignorant and simple use ever. Get a thesaurus!). Emily Dickinson is famous, yes, and she does have talent, but she is overglorified. I bet there are some people in this forum that can write a better poem than Dickinson. Poetry is an art, fame is relative.

  81. OMG

    THIS POEM JUST GOTS IT ALL (I think) CUZ IMMA GANGSTA

  82. michelle United States ↩ replying to emily

    wow, emily is one of my favorite poets! and i absolutely adore this one, since i am in a hurry, i better memorize this poem for my poem recital at school.

  83. Mick Netherlands

    The garden must be the garden of Eden...

  84. john Andorra

    this poem is really bad and boring

  85. Tessica United States

    i love this poem so much it is so good

  86. dively China ↩ replying to emily

    oi think Emily is just using this poem to encourage her little brother to be optimistic and always look things on the bright side.

  87. Morgan United Kingdom

    I love Emilies poems. I just move to the UK from Cal. I really miss talking about great american poems in school.

  88. Angelica Canada

    I think this poems is weird. I don't get it....

  89. Megan United States

    ok look, Austin, yeah its her OLDER BROTHER. and there were no sexual inuendos in this poem either. this was not a romance interest. Keep in mind when reading her poetry that most of it was found on napkins, grocery list, in letters and on other random things and was only published after she died by her family. (which is a shame because they changed lots of it) Oh yeah, and one other thing. SHE IS DEAD. so stop trying to encourage her and stop saying stupid things like "keep it up" or "You rock" because she won't be reading it. I mean really, she died before the internet was even imagined.

  90. sfiawong United States ↩ replying to sfiawong

    *** Starry Night *** By: sfiawong 4/10/2006 Trinkle, trinkle little stars How many there are in the sky! Let the children try to count! I remember this starry night. Trinkle, trinkle little stars, Seven children we sit on a bench. Our little fingers point and count. Sit close friendly and talk. Trinkle trinkle little stars, Talk about cowboy and a weaver stars. They're lovely meeting once a year. On many birds built…

    Read the whole comment

    *** Starry Night ***
    By: sfiawong
    4/10/2006

    Trinkle, trinkle little stars
    How many there are in the sky!
    Let the children try to count!
    I remember this starry night.

    Trinkle, trinkle little stars,
    Seven children we sit on a bench.
    Our little fingers point and count.
    Sit close friendly and talk.

    Trinkle trinkle little stars,
    Talk about cowboy and a weaver stars.
    They're lovely meeting once a year.
    On many birds built bridge sing with quitar.

    Trinkle, trinkle little stars,
    At a quiet night only with stars.
    Seven we sit on the stone bench.
    Our little fingers point and count.

    Trinkle, trinkle little stars,
    Oh honey, For your Love,
    Mother can tell you different stars;
    Your lover can swear towards stars and seas.

    Trinkle, trinkle little stars,
    Mom or beloved may talk with you.
    Tell how many different stars,
    For an ever love your honey can swear.

    Trinkle, trinkle little stars,
    How great you are helping love?

  91. alyssa United States

    OH MY GOODNESS....this poem is gross and stupid. i think she molested her brother....how sad.

  92. ok United States

    this makes me think of me and my brother and how i reashure him that soon one day everything will be ok

  93. Katelyn United States

    i think this poem is beautiful....it really has a hidden meaning...and it really reminds me of myself, because i think she is trying to tell someone how she sees the world through her eyes and how beautiful it is to her. but no one can see the world the same way you do....

  94. Tawnee United States

    i think this poem is so beautiful!I really didnt expect to understand any of her poems since she was from in the 1800's most kids my age arent interested in this stuff. i really like her poems. i was looking for my favorite one in the world i memorized it. "i shall not live in vian" that one has the most meaning to me. i think the whole purpose of this poem is to teach other people and childeren my age that there is a imaginary garden to escape to and it will always be there when things arent so great. and for you guys that r being very rude i though adults were more mature than that. wow i guess i was wronge! sry didnt mean n e thing bi that.

  95. Lily United States ↩ replying to emily

    I'm on here for a project on Emily Dickinson. Though I've been known to have a lewd and disgusting sense of humor, I don't understand the hatred on this site. People saying that this poem "blows" and "sucks" and whatnot just furthers Emily's view on life and publication. People could not appreciate her poetry in her own time period, for she was too ahead of her time. Now, more than a century later, society has…

    Read the whole comment

    I'm on here for a project on Emily Dickinson. Though I've been known to have a lewd and disgusting sense of humor, I don't understand the hatred on this site. People saying that this poem "blows" and "sucks" and whatnot just furthers Emily's view on life and publication. People could not appreciate her poetry in her own time period, for she was too ahead of her time. Now, more than a century later, society has become too ignorant to accept her poetry. As for the sexual overtones, they were obviously not intended since Emily addressed her brother, Austin. These perversions were simply conjugated through your own mind dosed and poisoned by the over-sexed media. "Into my garden come!" could mean "Come into my garden." and nothing more or less. In addition to that, while i skimmed through the previous comments, I found many people called her a "depressing goth" or something of that nature. It is unfair to label her (or anyone else) that, because, under the circumstances, it was almost mandatory to be paranoid of death. Women and children always tended for the ill and dying, and they were taught that there were little graves in the graveyards because little children died as well. She watched people around her die, mostly from comsumption (better known now as tuberculosis). Every funeral in town passed her house as well - so, naturally, death was something she pondered excessively, and she incorporated it into her poetry. Death is something we all wonder about at one point in our lives, and the occurence is something none of us fully understand. All in all, death is a perfectly reasonable topic to write or think about. As for this poem, it is clever, yet simplistic and easy to understand. My interpretation is that yes, there's misery and darkness in the world, but she wants to turn her older brother's head away from that, and escape to a surreal little forest of purity. For people of modern times, it may be a lover, but it can be anyone.

    As for the rude remarks, even I've toned down the immaturity and opened my mind to accurately understand Emily's writing. I'm 12 years old, I listen to rap music, I have a foul mouth - I'm a parent's worst nightmare! - yet I understand everything she says, about life, death, and love, as well as other topics. Her writing is truly universal.

    P. S. whoever is regulating these comments is slacking off... some random girl is begging for an orgy on here somewhere and they haven't done anything yet.

  96. juliet United States

    i really like that poem. it made me see things a diffresnt way.

  97. Natsuki Japan

    what is the "hidden message"?

  98. Natsuki Japan

    if you are looking for a good poem to analyze, i suggest you do "Im Nobody" if you are in 5th-7th grade.

  99. yasmine United States ↩ replying to emily

    I think Emily was a great poem writer I LOVE this poem

  100. megan Botswana

    yeh! poems rule. And this one rules them all

  101. EMILY ↩ replying to emily

    Hello my name is Emily tellin
    Hey we hav the same name
    well anyways i am writting you because i LOVE YOUR POEM

    ♥emily

  102. zippy Philippines

    ilike this poem.ive used it on my project thank you!!!!1!1!1!111

  103. NORma United States

    Hey this poem is tight yo!!
    I gots to tell all of my homies all about it!!
    I want to make a shout-out to LUgo!!

  104. Emily United States ↩ replying to emily

    I really like the poems that emily wrote because they kind of explain life and they dont make you feel so lonly because you realize that you do have somthing in commen with someone else.

  105. alma United States

    this poem was amazing!!
    i'm going to use it for a project!

  106. Whitney Sellers United States ↩ replying to emily

    This poem is just amazing and it really seems to reach out to people. I mean just look at how many comments there are on this one poem. But i mean every poem has a great or magnificient poet behind it and this one awesome poem has one really wonderful poet behind it. And of course its Emily Dickenson.

    Whitney...

  107. Monica Saint Vincent and the Grenadin ↩ replying to emily

    Emily's poem is nice and a little boring, and my friends said that too.

  108. starburst* United States

    This Poem Is Beautiful*

  109. Bob United States

    This poem is terrible

  110. sfiawong United States

    In her 'There is another sky", I like her last four sentences:

    In its unfading flowers
    I hear the bright bee hum:
    Prithee, my brother,
    Into my garden come!

    She heard the bee voice of humming..... so nice to express her feeling.

  111. Jesse New Zealand

    THIS POEM BLOWS LIKE MY EX!!

  112. chicken butt United States ↩ replying to emily

    I chose Emily Dickenson for my project at school. I would have to read it agian to understand it ,but I feel it is a really good poem. She wrote a lot of Poems!

  113. Emi United States ↩ replying to emily

    It should be noted that, in "The Complete Poems Of Emily Dickinson," as edited by Thomas H. Johnson, this is the second poem in chronological order. Obviously, it's not as complex and interesting to dissect as some of her other, later works, but it's certainly a sweet poem that is especially important in establishing the themes that run throughout the rest of her poetry. There is the concept of platonic…

    Read the whole comment

    It should be noted that, in "The Complete Poems Of Emily Dickinson," as edited by Thomas H. Johnson, this is the second poem in chronological order. Obviously, it's not as complex and interesting to dissect as some of her other, later works, but it's certainly a sweet poem that is especially important in establishing the themes that run throughout the rest of her poetry. There is the concept of platonic relationships (Austin Dickinson was actually her brother) and the importance of males and females interacting on an equal level, something she found especially important as a woman who wanted to be an active member of society but was restricted by societal norms. She deals with this in other poems, ranging from "My Life had stood--a Loaded gun" to "I died for Beauty--but was scarce."
    Biographically, it is also important to establish the connections she had to her family, between her, her brother, and her sister-in-law.
    While this may not be a great work of hers, it is certainly an important thing for anyone to read before reading any large amount of her poetry.

  114. Kate Australia

    I just love those lines "nevermind faded forests Austin,nevermind silent fields" as someone else said this poem provides a high level of comfort and was probably meant to comfort her brother.

  115. lily United States ↩ replying to emily

    I understand Emily wanted to tell her brother that although there is pain in this life, there is also beauty in it as well. She offers her brother insight,by sharing her optimism in the midst of this sometimes mad world, extending him some hope. I pray the same for all of us in this world. That true peace enter our hearts and our mind. focus on the goodness, focus on the beauty within yourselves, we all have a light…

    Read the whole comment

    I understand Emily wanted to tell her brother that although there is pain in this life, there is also beauty in it as well. She offers her brother insight,by sharing her optimism in the midst of this sometimes mad world, extending him some hope. I pray the same for all of us in this world. That true peace enter our hearts and our mind. focus on the goodness, focus on the beauty within yourselves, we all have a light inside, we just need to silence our minds and reach deep inside. get in touch with our sacred selves. Then all hostility will disappear. It is better to be kind, than it is to be right. Love not war. Love not hate....I dream of world peace...and so I pray. I do not know you and yet I love you still.

  116. emma United Kingdom

    This poem is perfect for a project!!!

  117. Vanja Yugoslavia

    I could cry.This is magnificent.She is my favorite poet in english language.This is pure religion in verses.Like Marina Cvetaeva but softer.

  118. Chris Australia ↩ replying to well

    Very well written.Everyone needs a peaceful "garden"

  119. Ellie Australia

    This poem is fanatastic! I'm working on it for an essay with a mate :D

  120. Juan Spain ↩ replying to well

    To my mind, in this poem Dickinson is offering all her support and sisterly love to her elder brother Austin. She is obviously trying to boost his morale. Maybe he was going through difficult times when she wrote this. Or who knows? Maybe this was an invitation to share her world of art and imagination. That was certainly a good way to escape routine! He being a lawyer he may have been more matter-of-fact than she…

    Read the whole comment

    To my mind, in this poem Dickinson is offering all her support and sisterly love to her elder brother Austin. She is obviously trying to boost his morale. Maybe he was going through difficult times when she wrote this. Or who knows? Maybe this was an invitation to share her world of art and imagination. That was certainly a good way to escape routine! He being a lawyer he may have been more matter-of-fact than she was or his life was just too hectic and through the images in this simple and beautiful poem she wants to bring him loads of optimism and hope for a better future.
    and maybe build up on his confidence at a rough time. She might also be referring to the Garden of Eden. You can never forget religion and spirituality when reading Dickinson. And in the Garden of Eden, unlike in our world, everything is supposed to be perfect. She, as a believer, knew that very well.

  121. Genc Yugoslavia

    First of all, Im from Kosovo and not Yugoslavia. I ask the administrator to put Albania and Kosovo as a country. Thank you for your understanding!
    Now, let me explain my feelings about this poem. Personally, I think that she is writing to someone she loved or a relative. She is buried next to him or her.

  122. Adrian United States

    What does Kosovo and Albania have anything to do with this poem?

  123. James United States

    I think this is a high quality poem

  124. Megan United States

    I think this poem deserves some recognition! It's /beautiful/!

  125. Isabel United States

    Wow.This poem is absoulty amazing! I love the type of poem you'll think about after you read it and it makes you want to read it over again and again. She is such an amazing writer. Aboustly B-E-A-utiful.

  126. story United States

    i love that this poem talks about our world around us and nature.its lovely

  127. natalie

    i love this poem because it's just great. i love the way she includes her brother in this one

  128. sima yari Iran ↩ replying to emily

    I think that Emily Dickinson is the best poet,in English Literature.

  129. Timothy United Kingdom ↩ replying to emily

    In this sweetly charming poem Emily Dickinson is declaring -- albeit to herself -- that the incompatibility her brother discovered with his wife should be put into perspective. "... another sky" and "... another sunshine, Though it be darknesss there" means the Universe and the insignificance of our problems. "... faded forests" and "... silent fields" suggests thoughtful lonely walks her brother took in his anxiety. Then she concludes by stating that he can always find true loving solace and understanding with her his sister.

    I would very much like to thank qirobin for the highly kind Chinese translation so that many others can read this remarkable poem!

  130. mastepoc United States

    warez portal

    I learn English and copy writing from blogging. :D

  131. Bbw Belly Videos United States

    hmm. luv it..

    hm. amazing text )

  132. christina China

    so sweet

    i just want to say it's so sweet

  133. Bbw Staxx United States

    hmm... amazing

    huh... attractive ))

  134. Emile Moelich South Africa ↩ replying to emily

    "There ia another sky."
    Emily Dickinson was a great poet.

  135. Liu Xiaoling China

    I like this poem. And I was impressed by the poem when I read it at first sight. I hope there is really another quiet sky ,where people can have a spritual rest.

  136. filippo Italy

    nice finding

    emimly, always the best... never read this poem before.. now... just found it by chance... I have a book but it was not in... stupid biographer .-p

  137. Arman Najmi ↩ replying to sima yari

    Yes the poem of Emily Dickinson appeals to all of us.it has got a universal elements embedded in its word fibre.She has always touched a deep cord inside me.But dear Sima Hari your poems so simple and somuch in it that they can not be explained fully.if I am a great fan of yours it is your creative genius that has mismerzed me. Arman Najmi

  138. jacob

    i think i fell asleep doing reading the poems

  139. Riley

    yo anyone know what the theme of this poem is? Because I need to write a paper on it.

Your turn

Shown with your comment.

Never published. Only so we can reach you.

Comments are read before they appear. See our terms.