"The Soul selects her own Society" is a short poem by Emily Dickinson (1830–1886). It describes a soul that picks its company and then closes itself to everyone else. The soul is pictured as a woman in a house, with a door, a gate and a mat.
Chariots and an emperor arrive at her gate, and she is not moved. In the last stanza a speaker says she has watched the soul choose one from a whole nation. Then the soul shuts her attention "Like Stone". The poem is about choice, exclusion and the firmness of a decision once it is made. It leaves open whether that firmness is loyalty, strength or coldness.
Summary
The first stanza states what the Soul does, in the present tense. She "selects her own Society", meaning she chooses her own company. Then she "shuts the Door". Line 3 adds the phrase "To her divine Majority". Line 4 ends the stanza with "Present no more".
The second stanza shows grand visitors arriving at her house. She notes the Chariots pausing at her "low Gate" and stays "Unmoved". An emperor kneels "Upon her Mat", at her doorstep. She stays unmoved by him as well. The word "Unmoved" opens both line 5 and line 7.
The third stanza brings in a speaker, who says I for the first time. The speaker has known the Soul to pick from "an ample nation", a large population. From it she chooses a single person, "One". After choosing, she closes "the Valves of her attention". The poem ends with a comparison of that closing to stone, in the words "Like Stone".
Themes and meaning
The first theme is choice and its finality. The Soul does not wait to be chosen but "selects". The choice is followed at once by "Then -- shuts the Door". The last stanza repeats the same pattern: she will "Choose One" and "Then" close. The poem treats choosing and excluding as one motion.
A second theme is indifference to rank and display. In stanza two, chariots stop at her gate and an emperor kneels on her mat. Neither changes anything. The gate is "low", yet the powerful humble themselves before it. The poem suggests that worldly status has no claim on the soul's choice.
A third theme is the soul's own sovereignty. The Soul has her "Society" and her "divine Majority". These are words of public life, applied to a private inner state. The soul behaves like a ruler, receiving or refusing callers. In this reading the self is its own court and needs no outside approval.
The poem does not say what the chosen "One" is. It can be read as a lover, a friend, a faith, or the self alone. The house imagery suits a love poem, with suitors at the gate. Words like "divine" and "Chariots" allow a spiritual reading. The poem supports each and settles none.
A last theme is the cost of such firmness. The ending, "Like Stone", is hard and cold. "Valves" suggests something mechanical or bodily that simply stops. The same act that shows loyalty also shows a refusal to feel. The poem can be read as praise of steadiness or as a quiet warning about hardness.
Tone
The opening tone is calm and declarative. "The Soul selects her own Society" is stated as a general truth, with no hedging. The dashes slow the lines and give each act its own weight.
In the second stanza the tone becomes cool and faintly ironic. An emperor kneeling on a doormat is an almost comic picture. The repeated "Unmoved" is flat and unimpressed. The soul's refusal is shown without anger, which makes it more absolute.
The third stanza grows more personal. "I've known her" sounds like a witness who has watched this happen. The speaker may admire the Soul, or may be uneasy about her. The short lines "Choose One" and "Like Stone" land hard. The poem ends on a note of finality, and its warmth, if any, is withheld.
Form and structure
The poem has 12 lines in 3 stanzas of 4 lines each. The lines alternate long and short. The odd lines run from eight to ten syllables. The even lines have four syllables in the first two stanzas and only two in the last. The syllables range from 2 to 10 per line.
The metre is loosely iambic. Line 1 and line 5 come close to iambic pentameter. Line 3 is iambic tetrameter. The short lines are dimeter, and lines 10 and 12 shrink to single blunt feet. This shrinking mimics the closing the poem describes.
The computed scheme finds one full rhyme, Door and more in stanza one. The other stanzas have no full rhymes. Pairs such as Gate and Mat, or One and Stone, can be heard as slant rhymes. Dashes break the lines, and many nouns are capitalised.
Poetic devices
Personification line 1
The Soul selects The soul is made a woman who chooses her company. This turns an inner state into a scene with a person, a house and callers.
Alliteration line 1
Soul selects her own Society The repeated s sounds bind the subject, the act and the object together. The line sounds smooth and settled, like a rule.
Metaphor line 2
shuts the Door Closing a door stands for ending openness to others. The image is simple and final, and it sets up the house imagery of stanza two.
Pun line 3
divine Majority Majority can mean the greater number, or the age of full adulthood. It can also be heard as a title, close to Majesty. Each sense changes who or what is shut out.
Repetition line 7
Unmoved The word opens both line 5 and line 7. The echo makes the soul's refusal steady and unchanging, whatever the visitor's rank.
Irony line 7
an Emperor be kneeling The most powerful figure kneels, and the soul is the one who stays unmoved. The usual order of power is reversed.
Imagery line 8
Upon her Mat A doormat is a humble, domestic object. Placing an emperor on it shrinks his grandeur and keeps him outside the door.
Shift in point of view line 9
I've known her A first-person speaker appears for the first time. The general statement becomes testimony, as if the speaker has watched this happen.
Metaphor line 11
close the Valves of her attention Attention is pictured as something with valves that can be shut. The word suggests a heart, a shell or a hinged door, and it makes the closing physical and complete.
Simile line 12
Like Stone The closing is compared to stone, hard and unfeeling. As the last words, it leaves the poem on a note of cold finality.
Words worth knowing
Society
Here 'company' or 'companionship', the people one chooses to be with, not society at large.
Majority
Can mean 'the greater number of people', or 'full legal age', adulthood. It may also echo 'Majesty', a royal title.
Present
Can be read as a verb, 'offer' or 'bring forward', as in presenting a visitor. It can also be read as 'here', meaning the soul is no longer available.
Mat
A 'doormat' at the entrance of a house.
ample
'Large' or 'plentiful'. An ample nation is a great number of people to choose from.
Valves
Parts that open and shut to control flow, as in the heart. An older sense is 'the leaves of a folding door', and a shell also closes by its valves.
What readers have said
Raven found the second stanza somewhat ironic and condescending, a soul that will not open herself to just anyone, whatever their rank. Raven, 2004
Richard read it as a love poem about choosing a soul mate, who becomes a society of one, after which the heart is closed to other suitors. Richard, 2006
evilpanda found the poem darker than other readers allowed, and read the last stanza as the voice of someone hurt by too many broken hearts. evilpanda, 2005
Brianna pointed out that majority can mean full legal age, so the mature soul is free to choose her own company, and noted the house imagery of door, gate and mat. Brianna, 2006
Zachkoren Torres rejected the love reading and took the shut door as a refusal of religion, the divine Majority being the faith of the many. Zachkoren Torres, 2010
Ellie argued that the closing words hint at the speaker's own pain at rejection, and that the poem could loop back and begin again. Ellie, 2005
this poem is a great poem that was writin by a strange dauthor with mental isues. she is inside looking at the emporer at her lower gate now wouldn't you normaly go down and meet the emporer at the gate. that does not seem right. i am doing a paper on this poem for english class and i have alot of things to say about it that i wont -samantha miller
RavenCanada
This is one of my favorites by Emily. I like her somewhat ironic and condescending second stanza, about how her soul will not open herself to just anyone, no matter their rank. It's true, too--no one can like everyone, and one only feels close to few.
KarianneUnited States
I believe this is one of Emily Dickinson's more emotional poems. It tells of true love either for a friend or soulmate. When choosing a friend or soulmate you have the entire world to choose from, or an ample nation, and a person doesn't worry about their status when choosing a friend (The soul remains unmoved even while the emperor is kneeling at her gate). This is such a well written poem. It accurately describes the soul's unaltered decision while choosing a companion in life.
I feel that this poem should not be taken at face value. It is clear that Dickinson has exprienced a love which even an 'Emperor' can not penetrate. Her 'low gate' is humble in his wake. However the concluding dash, 'Like Stone-' hints that this may not be such an exlusive relionship, in fact the poem could begin again with 'I've known her' indicating that this happened before. The harsh capital in 'Stone' maybe her own feelings at being on the recieving end of rejection. The isolated '-shuts the Door-' evokes similer feelings. Dickinson mingles rejection and exclusive love to this poem, wheather souls 'Valves of.. attention' are closed for ever is debatable
comments 1-4, all have some validity. comment 2, CONDESCENDING-key word not meeting the emperor is noted, In life, when the king or emperor comes calling, you (we common folk) go out to meet him-why does emily stay in the house (it is not the 'stonem not yet anyway) okay, more hints, the emperor is kneeling (isn't that peculiar? why, would an emperor be kneeling (condescending? perhaps, what circumstance would…
Read the whole comment
comments 1-4, all have some validity. comment 2, CONDESCENDING-key word not meeting the emperor is noted, In life, when the king or emperor comes calling, you (we common folk) go out to meet him-why does emily stay in the house (it is not the 'stonem not yet anyway) okay, more hints, the emperor is kneeling (isn't that peculiar? why, would an emperor be kneeling (condescending? perhaps, what circumstance would require an emperor to bow? What personage would requie the Queen of England to bow? (same deal) You, the reader, have a seat at an event, what is the event. don't seek an answer, let it come without pressure.
It took me years to figure this out, after reading many of emily's bio. come on, stretch that gray machine.
This is a well-thought out poem. Emily Dickinson is an amazing writer. The use of persona tells how the soul is feeling and that it doesn't matter if you are in the higher society or the lower society, the soul will choose who can enter the door.
evilpandaUnited States
I find this poem to be darker and more condescending that what the comments on this board might suggest. From my perspective, the poem comes across to me as the narrator being victim of one too many broken hearts, especially with the last stanza. She has become very selective of the individuals she allows in her life. She's "unmoved" to so many- even an emperor!
But this is one man's evaluation.
amandaUnited States
On the surface this poem does appear to be a poem of opening her heart, but I believe that it has a different meaning then this. "divine Majority" "Chariots" ect. these are all words of the heavens. The concept of faith and doubt arises in this poem. In this time it was wrong to have doubt that god really existed, but this issue had just started to arise in her time period. I think that this poem is telling about…
Read the whole comment
On the surface this poem does appear to be a poem of opening her heart, but I believe that it has a different meaning then this. "divine Majority" "Chariots" ect. these are all words of the heavens. The concept of faith and doubt arises in this poem. In this time it was wrong to have doubt that god really existed, but this issue had just started to arise in her time period. I think that this poem is telling about her struggle to be like everyone else but everything that people say to her and present to her so that she would believe in god has no effect. She is "Unmoved" but she also knows that she must "Choose One" or the other to believe or not. I think that she is choosing not to believe in this poem.
senorita annPhilippines
Her writings are mostly about love, every person either boy or girl must be careful in choosing a person he/she will love... it doesnt matter her/his looks or status...like what Dickinson is emphazing....
i feel that she is getting numb that time of her life with love.._ LIKE STONE__
irishPhilippines
i had hard time on figuring out what could really have been the meaning of this poem, but upon reading the comments of the other reader i have thought that this might imply to LOVE,, now can you please elaborate more, i will report this in class.. :)
courtUnited States
i think LIKE STONE could mean that her soul feels trapped, like inside the stone prison walls. she could be pursuing the idea that the soul is separate and chooses its passion.
AshesUnited States
this is one of my favorite poems by no "snikindy lime" in this poem she is the dame being approached by the suitors and she does not care because her heart her soul has chosen the ONE person that it loves and has closed the door permanently to everyone else. Kinda like a first love kind of thing.i think she is almost questioning why they soul chooses just one
AllieUnited States
I like this poem. THis poem has a lot of feeling in it. This whole poem i think means have a seat at an event, what is the event. don't seek an answer, let it come without pressure. soul has chosen the ONE person that it loves and has closed the door permanently to everyone else. Kinda like a first love kind of thing.i think she is almost questioning why they soul chooses just one.
I love this poet and her points of views.
~~~****Allie of Illinois****~~~
Sara WeigandUnited States
This poem is how she shuts everyone out. The emporer is apart of her imagination and what she wants life to be like. The last part is that she wants to find someone and get them to love her and then turn her back on them like someone else has done to her. (close the valves of her attention=stop showing that person you love them and dont talk to them and make them hurt)
Majority actually has another meaning: "the state or time of being of full legal age" (Webster). The Soul, having achieved majority, or maturity, is now able to make her own decisions, and choose her own company. "The Soul selects her own Society - Then shuts the Door[.] To her divine Majority - Present no more -". Think of "present" as in "to offer or deliver." Note the house imagery with door, low gate, mat, and…
Read the whole comment
Majority actually has another meaning: "the state or time of being of full legal age" (Webster). The Soul, having achieved majority, or maturity, is now able to make her own decisions, and choose her own company. "The Soul selects her own Society - Then shuts the Door[.] To her divine Majority - Present no more -". Think of "present" as in "to offer or deliver."
Note the house imagery with door, low gate, mat, and also "valves"; Valves, much like "majority," carries multiple meanings, in addition to a mechanical valve: checking the dictionary, it seems to describe pieces of shell or else "one of the leaves of a double or folding door" (Webster).
[analysis assisted by text "Elements of Poetry" (Ch. 13, pg. 576-7), author unknown - from a course packet.]
This poem is a love poem. It is about selecting a soul mate, someone who becomes a "society of one" to the individual who does the selecting. Emily choose her society of one, and then "closed the valves (her heart) to any futher suitors. She made her heart "like stone" to any and all who came to her "low Gate" to impress her. When she found her true love, she had no room in her society for anyone else. Anyone who has ever really been in love knows this is the case of those who find the "society" of the one they choose to be enough and turns the valves of attention to stone so that no one else can be addmitted to her society. It is a beautiful love poem.
In this poem ,emily refors "King",a person who has appeared ih some of her poems.So,why "king"is present for many times ?
DerinUnited States
One poem that really caught my attention was poem #303. In my opinion the speaker of the poem, “ The Soul selects her own Society,” refers to a person who decides to close the door of her heart eternally to others because the person he/she truly loves (her society of one person) is gone, not longer by her side, perhaps dead. Therefore he/she wants to embrace that prior lover and let no other replace it. “Unmoved…
Read the whole comment
One poem that really caught my attention was poem #303. In my opinion the speaker of the poem, “ The Soul selects her own Society,” refers to a person who decides to close the door of her heart eternally to others because the person he/she truly loves (her society of one person) is gone, not longer by her side, perhaps dead. Therefore he/she wants to embrace that prior lover and let no other replace it. “Unmoved she- notes the Chariots- pausing” here the speaker perchance means that many will come at her door but none will have the privilege to enter only to stand by. The “Emperor” possibly means those waiting to have a chance for her door to unlock. But indifferent of the pain she might cause others and herself she decides to eternally “then-close the Valves of her attention Like Stone” and to continue with her life.
In this particular poem, Dickinson is commenting on how selective humans tend to be with the people and situations they associate themselves with. In the first quatrain, Dickinson makes note on how once the soul "selects her own society" (line 1), the rest of the world is shut out and the soul refuses to dance with any other groups. In the second quatrain, Dickinson writes on how even when incredible circumstances come upon one, the soul remains "unmoved" (line 7). Dickinson concludes the poem by reiterating the theme that the soul has the ability to choose whatever domain or friends they want; it's getting the soul to allow change that's difficult.
RitaUnited States
This poem is really cool.The mary-kate and ashley movie uses this poem in Holiday in the Sun.
nathaniel smithUnited States
this poem is very complicated. very very very very very very very very very VERY hard to understand but i still got it
iknoweverything
In my opinion some of you guys are really bad at interpreting. This is poem is not even about love! It is about religion, faith, and transcendenality...whatever i dont know what the word is. Think about her father and how religious he was and how he forced her to be religious.
kristenUnited States
I like this poem its kind of diffucult too understand. An thats what i like about it, And some of you other comment posters are conceited an dumb, sorry but you sound like idiots.
William BoydUnited Kingdom
Titled 'Exclusion' in the 1890 edition cf (source Wikipedia note the beautiful cover and flowers) but suspect editors and not Emily. There are significant textual variation in the surviving manuscript (source Respresentative Poetry Online) and in particular the first stanza would read 'The soul selects her own society / Then shuts the door / To her divine majority / Present no more' which reads quite differently!…
Read the whole comment
Titled 'Exclusion' in the 1890 edition cf (source Wikipedia note the beautiful cover and flowers) but suspect editors and not Emily. There are significant textual variation in the surviving manuscript (source Respresentative Poetry Online) and in particular the first stanza would read 'The soul selects her own society / Then shuts the door / To her divine majority / Present no more' which reads quite differently!
One comment here calls it a beautiful love poem and I think that it is a love poem might well be so: it's certainly miraculously beautiful and extraordinarily evocative in its imagery.
I do read it as 'Exclusion' myself though not quite exactly that. Last verse has been suggested read as oyster (bivalve) clamming shut and on the whole agree but note also that 'valves' can also be the valves of the heart thus heart turned to stone supporting love poem reading. The whole point of poetry of course is you are allowed to read it as both ...
Note door/more was a half ryhme in Emily's time.
Enterprising students looking for a theme for a term paper might like to track down a somewhat obscure comment in Kierkegaard's diary (?) I noted 30 years back but can't find now. The idea is of stigma as a personal choice accepting isolation as a sacrifice to preserve quite what I can't remember presumably self-authenticity sort thing i.e. in analogy to the botanical function of the stigma [OED 6]. Also idolatry / narcissism in the frame there I think. Good luck no need to cite but do PLEASE email me the source if you can find it!
Love this poem. Looked at it again after long time away on reading "Arcturus" and it was just as fresh as always.
ms dickinson was also very non-religious. so ask she suggests that the "Soul" keeps herself form the "divine majority" means she excludes gods also.
this is a very ambiguous poem; there is more than one meaning.
KaylaUnited States
when it was written.
this poem was not written in the 1950's. It was written in the 1860's. She was not even alive in the 1900's.
Zachkoren TorresUnited States
This is about religion
If you read Emily Dickinson's biography you see that religion is seen in the majority of her works only because she was rejected by it. She was never able to chose a religion and thats why when she states " Then- shuts the door- To her divine Majority" it means that she is shutting the door to religion. She was a writer in the 19th century and relgion had a huge impact in that time period. This poem is definitely not about love.
I think her poems are obtuse. The voice in them is hard to define. I have had this problem with interpretation since I was a fifth grader trying to read her poetry. Who is being talked to is not clear. I guess that is why it is "ambiguous". I usually read it personally, but then it is on a big American flag waving piece of html, but I guess I still see it as calculating rejection of rejectors, in the name of personal integrity. Self-selectivity?
A.B.United States
woops
I meant abstruse, as in hard to understand, not obtuse, as in not quick or alert in perception.
victoriaUnited States
This poem i believe it is about Emily and how she defines the meaning of her own life. her soul meaning her, as an individual, in what she thinks decides where she wants to go and how is she going to get there. Although she is describing about herself it also seems like she is reflecting among all people.
mrttreedUnited States
relgious disapointment
I believe she is expressing having different spiritual ideas than the majority of people, and she chooses to blend, conversate, associate, interact,etc. With like minded people, shutting the door on those who refuse to accept her perspective. Even though she know there may be a God watching her, the God watching is not the God of the main religion of that country, so that government is watching too. But she hold her ground. Christianity is of ample nations- pick one- but i still will follow my soul/gut/heart and remain unmoving.
Joe DiMattioUnited States
United States
. Dickinson is suggesting that for her, the soul was fixed at some point in her life and remained so.
Joe DiMattio
United States
The soul selects her own society ... #303 The soul (or in a more modern reference -The brain) chooses its soul- mate, friend or lover as the case may be and then closes shut the door. The choice is made and is irrevocable. Dickinson is suggesting that for her, the soul became fixed at some point in her life and remained so. From a physiological point of view, neural cells are hard wired at birth and as we live, as…
Read the whole comment
The soul selects her own society ... #303
The soul (or in a more modern reference -The brain) chooses its soul- mate, friend or lover as the case may be and then closes shut the door. The choice is made and is irrevocable. Dickinson is suggesting that for her, the soul became fixed at some point in her life and remained so. From a physiological point of view, neural cells are hard wired at birth and as we live, as we experience, input causes them to form structural connections that last for an indefinite period of time Physiology did not exist as a science during her lifetime. We only learned that the brain is composed of cells in 1922 and how the individual nerve cell conducts signals in 1949 and are only now exploring what brain cells do - their individual and collective functions. Emily is suggesting that brain function becomes fixed. We now see a more complex situation. The divorce rate attests to the fact that people change their mind. Love may have some constancy, but it is also plastic. New connections are made or at least modified by new input. It is somewhat like a stone house; the structure, the stones remains, but the interior does get altered.
Things change-hardly anything ever remains completely unchanged. From another point of view, the concept of time suggests that events, decisions get made and then become part of the past- they become history and cannot be changed. We can, however, make new decisions that counteract old decisions.
Anyway, Emily is a bit ahead of herself or of the physiology of her time. Dickinson is suggesting that for her, the soul was fixed at some point in her life and remained so.
yep, she's at it again: teasing your mind for HER MEANING. No, your meaning obtained from the poem is as valid as Emily's intent. She had no idea her poems would be so perplexing, mystifying...Remember, this is how she felt one night in particular-yes she was a recluse, felt rejected, but the fault lay within her. However, the ultimate results was the production of many titillating poems. Yes, the little lady from Amherst was a mess, but look at what she accomplished in spite of her many problems.
Yep, right scholarly, but don't forget the answers are often found in simplicity. No, Emily was not a simple person, very complex. We can interrupt most of her work, but not all. thus poem in a statement of self. Strange how such a person so cloistered with her cognitive/emotive feelings, could pour her heart out when dealing with her personal life.
this poem is a great poem that was writin by a strange dauthor with mental isues. she is inside looking at the emporer at her lower gate now wouldn't you normaly go down and meet the emporer at the gate. that does not seem right. i am doing a paper on this poem for english class and i have alot of things to say about it that i wont
-samantha miller
This is one of my favorites by Emily. I like her somewhat ironic and condescending second stanza, about how her soul will not open herself to just anyone, no matter their rank. It's true, too--no one can like everyone, and one only feels close to few.
I believe this is one of Emily Dickinson's more emotional poems. It tells of true love either for a friend or soulmate. When choosing a friend or soulmate you have the entire world to choose from, or an ample nation, and a person doesn't worry about their status when choosing a friend (The soul remains unmoved even while the emperor is kneeling at her gate). This is such a well written poem. It accurately describes the soul's unaltered decision while choosing a companion in life.
I feel that this poem should not be taken at face value. It is clear that Dickinson has exprienced a love which even an 'Emperor' can not penetrate. Her 'low gate' is humble in his wake. However the concluding dash, 'Like Stone-' hints that this may not be such an exlusive relionship, in fact the poem could begin again with 'I've known her' indicating that this happened before. The harsh capital in 'Stone' maybe her own feelings at being on the recieving end of rejection. The isolated '-shuts the Door-'
evokes similer feelings. Dickinson mingles rejection and exclusive love to this poem, wheather souls 'Valves of.. attention' are closed for ever is debatable
comments 1-4, all have some validity. comment 2, CONDESCENDING-key word not meeting the emperor is noted, In life, when the king or emperor comes calling, you (we common folk) go out to meet him-why does emily stay in the house (it is not the 'stonem not yet anyway) okay, more hints, the emperor is kneeling (isn't that peculiar? why, would an emperor be kneeling (condescending? perhaps, what circumstance would…
Read the whole commentcomments 1-4, all have some validity.
comment 2, CONDESCENDING-key word
not meeting the emperor is noted, In life, when the
king or emperor comes calling, you (we common folk) go
out to meet him-why does emily stay in the house (it is
not the 'stonem not yet anyway)
okay, more hints, the emperor is kneeling (isn't that
peculiar? why, would an emperor be kneeling (condescending? perhaps, what circumstance would require an emperor to bow?
What personage would requie the Queen of England to bow?
(same deal)
You, the reader, have a seat at an event, what is the event.
don't seek an answer, let it come without pressure.
It took me years to figure this out, after reading many
of emily's bio. come on, stretch that gray machine.
This is a well-thought out poem. Emily Dickinson is an amazing writer. The use of persona tells how the soul is feeling and that it doesn't matter if you are in the higher society or the lower society, the soul will choose who can enter the door.
I find this poem to be darker and more condescending that what the comments on this board might suggest. From my perspective, the poem comes across to me as the narrator being victim of one too many broken hearts, especially with the last stanza. She has become very selective of the individuals she allows in her life. She's "unmoved" to so many- even an emperor!
But this is one man's evaluation.
On the surface this poem does appear to be a poem of opening her heart, but I believe that it has a different meaning then this. "divine Majority" "Chariots" ect. these are all words of the heavens. The concept of faith and doubt arises in this poem. In this time it was wrong to have doubt that god really existed, but this issue had just started to arise in her time period. I think that this poem is telling about…
Read the whole commentOn the surface this poem does appear to be a poem of opening her heart, but I believe that it has a different meaning then this. "divine Majority" "Chariots" ect. these are all words of the heavens. The concept of faith and doubt arises in this poem. In this time it was wrong to have doubt that god really existed, but this issue had just started to arise in her time period. I think that this poem is telling about her struggle to be like everyone else but everything that people say to her and present to her so that she would believe in god has no effect. She is "Unmoved" but she also knows that she must "Choose One" or the other to believe or not. I think that she is choosing not to believe in this poem.
Her writings are mostly about love, every person either boy or girl must be careful in choosing a person he/she will love... it doesnt matter her/his looks or status...like what Dickinson is emphazing....
i feel that she is getting numb that time of her life with love.._ LIKE STONE__
i had hard time on figuring out what could really have been the meaning of this poem, but upon reading the comments of the other reader i have thought that this might imply to LOVE,,
now can you please elaborate more, i will report this in class.. :)
i think LIKE STONE could mean that her soul feels trapped, like inside the stone prison walls. she could be pursuing the idea that the soul is separate and chooses its passion.
this is one of my favorite poems by no "snikindy lime"
in this poem she is the dame being approached by the suitors and she does not care because her heart her soul has chosen the ONE person that it loves and has closed the door permanently to everyone else. Kinda like a first love kind of thing.i think she is almost questioning why they soul chooses just one
I like this poem. THis poem has a lot of feeling in it. This whole poem i think means have a seat at an event, what is the event.
don't seek an answer, let it come without pressure. soul has chosen the ONE person that it loves and has closed the door permanently to everyone else. Kinda like a first love kind of thing.i think she is almost questioning why they soul chooses just one.
I love this poet and her points of views.
~~~****Allie of Illinois****~~~
This poem is how she shuts everyone out. The emporer is apart of her imagination and what she wants life to be like. The last part is that she wants to find someone and get them to love her and then turn her back on them like someone else has done to her. (close the valves of her attention=stop showing that person you love them and dont talk to them and make them hurt)
Majority actually has another meaning: "the state or time of being of full legal age" (Webster). The Soul, having achieved majority, or maturity, is now able to make her own decisions, and choose her own company. "The Soul selects her own Society - Then shuts the Door[.] To her divine Majority - Present no more -". Think of "present" as in "to offer or deliver." Note the house imagery with door, low gate, mat, and…
Read the whole commentMajority actually has another meaning: "the state or time of being of full legal age" (Webster). The Soul, having achieved majority, or maturity, is now able to make her own decisions, and choose her own company. "The Soul selects her own Society - Then shuts the Door[.] To her divine Majority - Present no more -". Think of "present" as in "to offer or deliver."
Note the house imagery with door, low gate, mat, and also "valves"; Valves, much like "majority," carries multiple meanings, in addition to a mechanical valve: checking the dictionary, it seems to describe pieces of shell or else "one of the leaves of a double or folding door" (Webster).
[analysis assisted by text "Elements of Poetry" (Ch. 13, pg. 576-7), author unknown - from a course packet.]
This poem is a love poem. It is about selecting a soul mate, someone who becomes a "society of one" to the individual who does the selecting. Emily choose her society of one, and then "closed the valves (her heart) to any futher suitors. She made her heart "like stone" to any and all who came to her "low Gate" to impress her. When she found her true love, she had no room in her society for anyone else. Anyone who has ever really been in love knows this is the case of those who find the "society" of the one they choose to be enough and turns the valves of attention to stone so that no one else can be addmitted to her society. It is a beautiful love poem.
In this poem ,emily refors "King",a person who has appeared ih some of her poems.So,why "king"is present for many times ?
One poem that really caught my attention was poem #303. In my opinion the speaker of the poem, “ The Soul selects her own Society,” refers to a person who decides to close the door of her heart eternally to others because the person he/she truly loves (her society of one person) is gone, not longer by her side, perhaps dead. Therefore he/she wants to embrace that prior lover and let no other replace it. “Unmoved…
Read the whole commentOne poem that really caught my attention was poem #303. In my opinion the speaker of the poem, “ The Soul selects her own Society,” refers to a person who decides to close the door of her heart eternally to others because the person he/she truly loves (her society of one person) is gone, not longer by her side, perhaps dead. Therefore he/she wants to embrace that prior lover and let no other replace it. “Unmoved she- notes the Chariots- pausing” here the speaker perchance means that many will come at her door but none will have the privilege to enter only to stand by. The “Emperor” possibly means those waiting to have a chance for her door to unlock. But indifferent of the pain she might cause others and herself she decides to eternally “then-close the Valves of her attention Like Stone” and to continue with her life.
In this particular poem, Dickinson is commenting on how selective humans tend to be with the people and situations they associate themselves with. In the first quatrain, Dickinson makes note on how once the soul "selects her own society" (line 1), the rest of the world is shut out and the soul refuses to dance with any other groups. In the second quatrain, Dickinson writes on how even when incredible circumstances come upon one, the soul remains "unmoved" (line 7). Dickinson concludes the poem by reiterating the theme that the soul has the ability to choose whatever domain or friends they want; it's getting the soul to allow change that's difficult.
This poem is really cool.The mary-kate and ashley movie uses this poem in Holiday in the Sun.
this poem is very complicated. very very very very very very very very very VERY hard to understand but i still got it
In my opinion some of you guys are really bad at interpreting. This is poem is not even about love! It is about religion, faith, and transcendenality...whatever i dont know what the word is. Think about her father and how religious he was and how he forced her to be religious.
I like this poem its kind of diffucult too understand. An thats what i like about it, And some of you other comment posters are conceited an dumb, sorry but you sound like idiots.
Titled 'Exclusion' in the 1890 edition cf (source Wikipedia note the beautiful cover and flowers) but suspect editors and not Emily. There are significant textual variation in the surviving manuscript (source Respresentative Poetry Online) and in particular the first stanza would read 'The soul selects her own society / Then shuts the door / To her divine majority / Present no more' which reads quite differently!…
Read the whole commentTitled 'Exclusion' in the 1890 edition cf
(source Wikipedia note the beautiful cover and flowers) but suspect editors and not Emily. There are significant textual variation in the surviving manuscript (source Respresentative Poetry Online) and in particular the first stanza would read 'The soul selects her own society / Then shuts the door / To her divine majority / Present no more' which reads quite differently!
One comment here calls it a beautiful love poem and I think that it is a love poem might well be so: it's certainly miraculously beautiful and extraordinarily evocative in its imagery.
I do read it as 'Exclusion' myself though not quite exactly that. Last verse has been suggested read as oyster (bivalve) clamming shut and on the whole agree but note also that 'valves' can also be the valves of the heart thus heart turned to stone supporting love poem reading. The whole point of poetry of course is you are allowed to read it as both ...
Note door/more was a half ryhme in Emily's time.
Enterprising students looking for a theme for a term paper might like to track down a somewhat obscure comment in Kierkegaard's diary (?) I noted 30 years back but can't find now. The idea is of stigma as a personal choice accepting isolation as a sacrifice to preserve quite what I can't remember presumably self-authenticity sort thing i.e. in analogy to the botanical function of the stigma [OED 6]. Also idolatry / narcissism in the frame there I think. Good luck no need to cite but do PLEASE email me the source if you can find it!
Love this poem. Looked at it again after long time away on reading "Arcturus" and it was just as fresh as always.
to sherri,
ms dickinson was also very non-religious. so ask she suggests that the "Soul" keeps herself form the "divine majority" means she excludes gods also.
this is a very ambiguous poem; there is more than one meaning.
when it was written.
this poem was not written in the 1950's. It was written in the 1860's. She was not even alive in the 1900's.
This is about religion
If you read Emily Dickinson's biography you see that religion is seen in the majority of her works only because she was rejected by it. She was never able to chose a religion and thats why when she states " Then- shuts the door- To her divine Majority" it means that she is shutting the door to religion. She was a writer in the 19th century and relgion had a huge impact in that time period. This poem is definitely not about love.
We can be sovereign in our choice of friends.
what over all is she saying?
I think her poems are obtuse. The voice in them is hard to define. I have had this problem with interpretation since I was a fifth grader trying to read her poetry. Who is being talked to is not clear. I guess that is why it is "ambiguous". I usually read it personally, but then it is on a big American flag waving piece of html, but I guess I still see it as calculating rejection of rejectors, in the name of personal integrity. Self-selectivity?
woops
I meant abstruse, as in hard to understand, not obtuse, as in not quick or alert in perception.
This poem i believe it is about Emily and how she defines the meaning of her own life. her soul meaning her, as an individual, in what she thinks decides where she wants to go and how is she going to get there. Although she is describing about herself it also seems like she is reflecting among all people.
relgious disapointment
I believe she is expressing having different spiritual ideas than the majority of people, and she chooses to blend, conversate, associate, interact,etc. With like minded people, shutting the door on those who refuse to accept her perspective. Even though she know there may be a God watching her, the God watching is not the God of the main religion of that country, so that government is watching too. But she hold her ground. Christianity is of ample nations- pick one- but i still will follow my soul/gut/heart and remain unmoving.
United States
. Dickinson is suggesting that for her, the soul was fixed at some point in her life and remained so.
United States
The soul selects her own society ... #303 The soul (or in a more modern reference -The brain) chooses its soul- mate, friend or lover as the case may be and then closes shut the door. The choice is made and is irrevocable. Dickinson is suggesting that for her, the soul became fixed at some point in her life and remained so. From a physiological point of view, neural cells are hard wired at birth and as we live, as…
Read the whole commentThe soul selects her own society ... #303
The soul (or in a more modern reference -The brain) chooses its soul- mate, friend or lover as the case may be and then closes shut the door. The choice is made and is irrevocable. Dickinson is suggesting that for her, the soul became fixed at some point in her life and remained so. From a physiological point of view, neural cells are hard wired at birth and as we live, as we experience, input causes them to form structural connections that last for an indefinite period of time Physiology did not exist as a science during her lifetime. We only learned that the brain is composed of cells in 1922 and how the individual nerve cell conducts signals in 1949 and are only now exploring what brain cells do - their individual and collective functions. Emily is suggesting that brain function becomes fixed. We now see a more complex situation. The divorce rate attests to the fact that people change their mind. Love may have some constancy, but it is also plastic.
New connections are made or at least modified by new input. It is somewhat like a stone house; the structure, the stones remains, but the interior does get altered.
Things change-hardly anything ever remains completely unchanged.
From another point of view, the concept of time suggests that events, decisions get made and then become part of the past- they become history and cannot be changed. We can, however, make new decisions that counteract old decisions.
Anyway, Emily is a bit ahead of herself or of the physiology of her time.
Dickinson is suggesting that for her, the soul was fixed at some point in her life and remained so.
yep, she's at it again: teasing your mind for HER MEANING. No, your meaning obtained from the poem is as valid as Emily's intent.
She had no idea her poems would be so perplexing, mystifying...Remember, this is how she felt one night in particular-yes she was a recluse,
felt rejected, but the fault lay within her. However, the ultimate results was the production of many titillating poems.
Yes, the little lady from Amherst was a mess, but look at what she accomplished in spite of her many problems.
Yep, right scholarly, but don't forget the answers are often found in simplicity.
No, Emily was not a simple person, very complex. We can interrupt most of her
work, but not all. thus poem in a statement of self. Strange how such a person so
cloistered with her cognitive/emotive feelings, could pour her heart out when dealing
with her personal life.