After great pain, a formal feeling comes --
The Nerves sit ceremonious, like Tombs --
The stiff Heart questions was it He, that bore,
And Yesterday, or Centuries before?
The Feet, mechanical, go round --
Of Ground, or Air, or Ought --
A Wooden way
Regardless grown,
A Quartz contentment, like a stone --
This is the Hour of Lead --
Remembered, if outlived,
As Freezing persons, recollect the Snow --
First -- Chill -- then Stupor -- then the letting go --
After great pain, a formal feeling comes: analysis
Introduction
"After great pain, a formal feeling comes" describes what happens in the body and mind once a great pain has passed its peak. It does not name the pain or its cause. It shows the aftermath instead: nerves like tombs, a stiff heart, feet that walk by habit. The last stanza calls this state "the Hour of Lead" and compares remembering it to freezing. The poem ends on a phrase, "the letting go", that can mean death or release.
Summary
The first stanza states a general rule. After great pain, a formal feeling comes. The Nerves sit in ceremony and are compared to Tombs. The Heart, called stiff, then asks a question. It asks whether "He" was the one who bore the pain, and whether that was "Yesterday, or Centuries before".
The second stanza turns to the Feet. They are "mechanical" and they "go round". They walk on "Ground, or Air, or Ought", and it makes no difference which. Their path is "A Wooden way", and it has become indifferent, "Regardless grown". The stanza ends on a further phrase, "A Quartz contentment, like a stone".
The third stanza names this state: "This is the Hour of Lead". It says the hour is remembered only "if outlived". The remembering is then compared to the way freezing people recollect snow. The last line lists the order of that freezing. First comes chill, then stupor, then "the letting go".
Themes and meaning
Extreme pain is followed by order, not by tears. "formal" and "ceremonious" are words for manners and public ritual. Applied to nerves, they suggest a body going through correct motions with nothing behind them. The comparison "like Tombs" turns that ceremony into a funeral. The sufferer becomes a monument to the pain.
Pain also comes loose from its owner and its date. The stiff Heart cannot say who suffered or when. "was it He, that bore" shows the heart failing to recognise its own pain. The word "bore" and the phrase "Centuries before" also bring in Christ, who bore suffering long ago. "He" has no clear antecedent, so both senses stay in the line.
The body turns into material. The poem moves through tomb, wood, quartz, stone and lead. Each one is harder or heavier than flesh. "A Quartz contentment" is the strangest of these. This contentment is not happiness but the stillness of a mineral that feels nothing.
Survival stays in doubt to the end. "Remembered, if outlived" admits that some people do not get through this hour. Yet the freezing persons of line 12 "recollect the Snow", so they came through. For someone who freezes to death, "the letting go" is the last surrender. For a survivor, it is release from the grip of the pain. The phrase holds both, and that is why the poem can stop on it.
Tone
The tone is controlled and almost clinical. There is no first person anywhere in the poem. Pain is described as a general law, in the present tense, as in "a formal feeling comes". The speaker reports symptoms and does not ask for sympathy.
The flatness is itself part of the effect. "Regardless grown" and "A Quartz contentment" name a state with no feeling in it, and the voice seems to share that state. The third stanza grows more urgent. "This is the Hour of Lead" is a plain pointing statement, as if the speaker has arrived at the worst of it. "if outlived" brings in quiet dread.
The last line breaks into pieces. The dashes in "First -- Chill -- then Stupor" slow the voice down, step by step. The tone there is calm, but it is the calm of someone losing consciousness.
Form and structure
The poem has 13 lines in 3 stanzas, of 4, 5 and 4 lines. Line lengths vary widely, from 4 syllables to 10. The first stanza is iambic pentameter. The second keeps the iambic beat but shortens the lines, to four, three, two, two and four beats. Line 7 and line 8 are the shortest, and they match the numb walking they describe. The third stanza opens on two three-beat lines, and its last two lines return to pentameter.
Each stanza closes on a rhymed pair: "bore" and "before", "grown" and "stone", "Snow" and "go". The earlier lines of each stanza do not rhyme, though "comes" and "Tombs" come close, and "Lead" and "outlived" share a final sound. The rhymed endings give each stanza a small, formal shutting.
Poetic devices
diction line 1
a formal feeling Pairs a word for etiquette with a word for emotion, so the feeling arrives as a kind of protocol. The repeated f sound ties the two words together.
simile and personification line 2
The Nerves sit ceremonious, like Tombs The nerves sit like guests at a rite, yet they are as still as graves. The body is both mourner and burial place.
personification line 3
The stiff Heart questions The heart is given a voice, but it is stiff, like a dead body. It can only ask a dazed question.
ambiguity line 3
was it He, that bore The pronoun has no clear antecedent. It can point to the heart's own self or, in another reading, to Christ.
synecdoche line 5
The Feet, mechanical, go round The feet stand in for a whole person moving without will. The circling goes nowhere.
repetition line 6
Of Ground, or Air, or Ought The repeated or lists surfaces as though they make no difference. The walker no longer knows or cares what lies underfoot.
metaphor line 7
A Wooden way Describes the walk as stiff and unfeeling, like wood. It also recalls the coffin behind the earlier word Tombs.
metaphor line 9
A Quartz contentment Contentment normally implies warmth. Joined to a hard mineral, it means only the absence of feeling.
metaphor line 10
the Hour of Lead Gives time the weight and dullness of a heavy metal. The hour becomes something that presses down and will not move.
understatement line 11
Remembered, if outlived The small phrase if outlived admits that the sufferer may not survive. The conditional carries the threat without raising the voice.
simile line 12
As Freezing persons, recollect the Snow Compares the memory of pain to the memory of the thing that nearly killed you. It also implies the rememberer got out alive.
caesura line 13
First -- Chill -- then Stupor -- then the letting go Dashes split the line into stages, so the reader goes through the slowing-down in order. The last phrase runs longer, as if finally loosened.
Words worth knowing
formal
Stiff and following set forms, as at a ceremony, not simply polite.
bore
Endured. It can also mean carried, which helps the reading that points to Christ.
Ought
Here most likely aught, meaning anything at all. The spelling also lets in the sense of duty.
Regardless
Heedless, paying no attention to anything, not its modern sense of in any case.
Stupor
A dazed state in which the senses are nearly shut down.
Context
It is number 341 in the Complete Poems of Emily Dickinson. It was the site's Poem of the Day on November 8, 2003.
What readers have said
jean dalloway says the poem rings true when past traumas invade again, and that after the pain she tries to minimize it and catalog it. jean dalloway, 2004
Maya argues it holds for great physical pain too, and recalls lying too quiet and unresponsive in a recovery room. Maya, 2004
Joanna Merrell sees stages of grief: numbness and mechanical funeral planning first, then a later point of letting go and actually dealing with the pain. Joanna Merrell, 2004
JehJar says the poem is about dying, and glosses the last line as chill for pain, stupor for unconsciousness and letting go for death. JehJar, 2006
Anna objects that limiting the poem to death rules out all the other possible reasons for the pain. Anna, 2008
HAli takes it as a shooting, with the numbness of being shot, marching army feet, and the "Hour of Lead" as the moment the bullet struck. HAli, 2005
This has been a favorite poem of mine when I am feeling distressed by past traumas invading my life again. It rings so true to what I experience, time and again. After the pain, I attempt to minimize it, catalog it, "...then the letting go."
Such a great poet and her use of image is so contemporary, although written in the middle 1800s. Dickinson describes the physical/emotional states of grief or other deep emotion. It is the extremity of such emotional states and the searing honesty and clarity of description which gives power to this writing. The line, 'After great pain, a formal feeling comes - the nerves sit ceremonious, like Tombs - ', lyrically…
Read the whole comment
Such a great poet and her use of image is so contemporary, although written in the middle 1800s. Dickinson describes the physical/emotional states of grief or other deep emotion. It is the extremity of such emotional states and the searing honesty and clarity of description which gives power to this writing. The line, 'After great pain, a formal feeling comes - the nerves sit ceremonious, like Tombs - ', lyrically tells of the held in retraction after an outpouring of pain. This is sustained by words and phrases such as, 'stiff Heart', 'mechanical', 'Wooden way', 'like a stone'. This state is then followed with the inevitable 'freezing' that comes with depression, a shutting down, described as 'A Quartz contentment, like a stone'. I saw 'contentment' as the welcome numbness after searing pain. This is furthered with 'Chill', 'Stupor', 'then the letting go', which I saw as resignation and a sense of defeat, the emotional cut-off of depression.
We all know that Dickinson grappled with depression and to me, the last line is a mild reference to Death or (a death) itself; continuing to live as if it's an out-of-body experience. "The Feet, mechanical, go round"; as if there's no Purpose to living one's Life or steps that we take are just a "formality" -- in a Zombie (tomb) like state (going through the "motions") because it's so frightening to actually end one's own life; hence she goes on living with this "formal" feeling as in -- NO feeling, whatsoever.
I think Emily's insight about pain rings equally true for a great physical pain, which can be quite traumatizing to the psyche. While in the recovery room after a very long, rough childbirth experience, I heard the nurses comment to each other with concern, that I seemed too quiet and unresponsive. I felt just exactly like what Emily describes in this poem.
Joanna MerrellUnited States
I think Emily Dickinson depicts a few aspects of the grieiving process. When grieving, one goes through a phase of numbness. This could also be seen as denial. Your actions are so mechanical. In the immediate days follwing a death of a loved one, you seem the strongest in order to help you get through the funeral. You plan the music, order flowers, write the obituary. After the funeral, you come to the point of "snapping out of it" or "letting go" and having to acutally deal with your pain. This is when the difficult grieiving process really begins.
JAYCanada
i agree with what everyone has said about this poem. it haas to do with her-self or a person that has just went through a trouble lost. The emotional scaring/pain that the person is goin through is causeing so much agony to that the person, that they begin to lose all feeling and is left with nothing but a lost and transfixed mental state. the one thing that i do not understand is what the significanc of the hour lead has to do with anything. if anyone can fill me in on that, it would be most appreciated.
HAliUnited States
I think this poem is about a shooting of some kind. The numbness you feel after being shot. The mechanical feet go round sounds and what I picture is an armys feet all going at the same time, looking mechanical. I think the hour of lead is symbolizeing when the bullet struck.
i feel she is an inspirational poet who deserves to be reconigsed for her great works
Dustin MartensCanada
Dickinson is a master of brevity. Just look at the comments on it, there is scarcely one shorter than the actual poem. This reminds me of Sonnet 73 in the way it lays down the last line. The "Chill" is the first paragraph, The "Stupor" of the mechanical feet and the rock like "Quartz contentment of "the letting go"
When I try to Briefly describe Dickinson it is usually in three letters: Wow. That shows mt tact compared to hers.
I think this poem is about dying. First, after 'great pain, a formal feeling comes' means that nothing is felt after the endured pain. Then 'The Nerves sit ceremonious, like Tombs' and echoes lifelessness. This is comparable to the last stanza when 'As Freezing persons, recollect the Snow-- First--Chill(pain)--then Stupor(unconsciousness)--then letting go(death)--'
Emily Dickinson’s poem After a Great Pain is about how to deal with the emotional pain of someone’s death. During her life, Dickinson saw many of her friends die and had to go through the pain of losing people that she loved. In this poem, Dickinson, using imagery, metaphors and diction, explain the “great pain” she felt and how to get through it. One of the things that Dickinson notice about people is that even…
Read the whole comment
Emily Dickinson’s poem After a Great Pain is about how to deal with the emotional pain of someone’s death. During her life, Dickinson saw many of her friends die and had to go through the pain of losing people that she loved. In this poem, Dickinson, using imagery, metaphors and diction, explain the “great pain” she felt and how to get through it. One of the things that Dickinson notice about people is that even though they have gone through that pain, they still go through their daily lives as if nothings ever happened. That even though we feel great pain and suffering, we do not show any signs of affecting our lives. Dickinson says “The Feet, mechanical, go round –” to explain what she and other has done, that like machines we will keep on going and going. They will question G-d, life and “The stiff Heart questions was it He, that bore”. They will keep on asking questions of why this happened to them. Dickinson knows that life can be a “wooden way regardless grown”. In other words life is full of obstacles and great emotional pain. Looking closely at the diction one even hears the “groan” of her pain in the word grown. However sad this experience is people will bottle up this feeling inside of them. The people will become “A Quartz contentment like stone—“, they don’t want anybody to tell them that it will be alright. Although this is the “Hour of Lead”, one of our hardest times on our lives, people want to be alone. She knows that great emotional pain is not for the weak and that it will be hard to survive it and some will not make it. For those that survived she says they will become like “As Freezing persons recollect the Snow—First—Chill—then Stupor—then the letting go”. She explains using this sentence that in order to survive such a great emotional pain that part of you will die.
This has many different meanings for me,death can be more than physical death as others have commented.Dealing with a serious physical condition it reminds me of first knowledge of time limits on life.Then it also brings the pain of other loss,losing someone not in body but maybe in soul. Watching as the real person dissappears and becomes a stranger. I hope this is understood very intense and difficult to place in words.
janet morcosoPhilippines
i think this poem is about the pain that has been suffered after a broke up with someone you truly love.she is now on the process of letting go.
AnnaUnited States
by limiting this poem to just "death", we are eliminating all the other possible reasons for the "pain".
While I agree this poem is indeed about death, I don't believe that it is from the standpoint of those who have lost a loved one, but rather of the apparent pronouns Emily creates out of words that are regularly nouns- "Heart", "Nerves", "Air" etcetera. If you read it like these objects and feelings are beings themselves, your outlook on the poem shifts.
fanjatiana
i think this poem is about death
AlvaroBrazil
The day my father died this poem came to my mind. Sure it can be about many kinds of "pain". However, the death of a beloved calls stronger for it.
brittany aka starUnited States
Emily D
can yall tell me more about her!!!!!!
frumpoUnited States
What great pain (physical or emotional) feels like over time.
This has been a favorite poem of mine when I am feeling distressed by past traumas invading my life again. It rings so true to what I experience, time and again. After the pain, I attempt to minimize it, catalog it, "...then the letting go."
Such a great poet and her use of image is so contemporary, although written in the middle 1800s. Dickinson describes the physical/emotional states of grief or other deep emotion. It is the extremity of such emotional states and the searing honesty and clarity of description which gives power to this writing. The line, 'After great pain, a formal feeling comes - the nerves sit ceremonious, like Tombs - ', lyrically…
Read the whole commentSuch a great poet and her use of image is so contemporary, although written in the middle 1800s. Dickinson describes the physical/emotional states of grief or other deep emotion. It is the extremity of such emotional states and the searing honesty and clarity of description which gives power to this writing.
The line, 'After great pain, a formal feeling comes - the nerves sit ceremonious, like Tombs - ', lyrically tells of the held in retraction after an outpouring of pain. This is sustained by words and phrases such as, 'stiff Heart', 'mechanical', 'Wooden way', 'like a stone'. This state is then followed with the inevitable 'freezing' that comes with depression, a shutting down, described as 'A Quartz contentment, like a stone'. I saw 'contentment' as the welcome numbness after searing pain. This is furthered with 'Chill', 'Stupor', 'then the letting go', which I saw as resignation and a sense of defeat, the emotional cut-off of depression.
We all know that Dickinson grappled with depression and to me, the last line is a mild reference to Death or (a death) itself; continuing to live as if it's an out-of-body experience. "The Feet, mechanical, go round"; as if there's no Purpose to living one's Life or steps that we take are just a "formality" -- in a Zombie (tomb) like state (going through the "motions") because it's so frightening to actually end one's own life; hence she goes on living with this "formal" feeling as in -- NO feeling, whatsoever.
I think Emily's insight about pain rings equally true for a great physical pain, which can be quite traumatizing to the psyche. While in the recovery room after a very long, rough childbirth experience, I heard the nurses comment to each other with concern, that I seemed too quiet and unresponsive. I felt just exactly like what Emily describes in this poem.
I think Emily Dickinson depicts a few aspects of the grieiving process. When grieving, one goes through a phase of numbness. This could also be seen as denial. Your actions are so mechanical. In the immediate days follwing a death of a loved one, you seem the strongest in order to help you get through the funeral. You plan the music, order flowers, write the obituary. After the funeral, you come to the point of "snapping out of it" or "letting go" and having to acutally deal with your pain. This is when the difficult grieiving process really begins.
i agree with what everyone has said about this poem. it haas to do with her-self or a person that has just went through a trouble lost. The emotional scaring/pain that the person is goin through is causeing so much agony to that the person, that they begin to lose all feeling and is left with nothing but a lost and transfixed mental state. the one thing that i do not understand is what the significanc of the hour lead has to do with anything. if anyone can fill me in on that, it would be most appreciated.
I think this poem is about a shooting of some kind. The numbness you feel after being shot. The mechanical feet go round sounds and what I picture is an armys feet all going at the same time, looking mechanical. I think the hour of lead is symbolizeing when the bullet struck.
i feel she is an inspirational poet who deserves to be reconigsed for her great works
Dickinson is a master of brevity. Just look at the comments on it, there is scarcely one shorter than the actual poem. This reminds me of Sonnet 73 in the way it lays down the last line. The "Chill" is the first paragraph, The "Stupor" of the mechanical feet and the rock like "Quartz contentment of "the letting go"
When I try to Briefly describe Dickinson it is usually in three letters: Wow. That shows mt tact compared to hers.
I think this poem is about dying. First, after 'great pain, a formal feeling comes' means that nothing is felt after the endured pain. Then 'The Nerves sit ceremonious, like Tombs' and echoes lifelessness. This is comparable to the last stanza when 'As Freezing persons, recollect the Snow-- First--Chill(pain)--then Stupor(unconsciousness)--then letting go(death)--'
Emily Dickinson’s poem After a Great Pain is about how to deal with the emotional pain of someone’s death. During her life, Dickinson saw many of her friends die and had to go through the pain of losing people that she loved. In this poem, Dickinson, using imagery, metaphors and diction, explain the “great pain” she felt and how to get through it. One of the things that Dickinson notice about people is that even…
Read the whole commentEmily Dickinson’s poem After a Great Pain is about how to deal with the emotional pain of someone’s death. During her life, Dickinson saw many of her friends die and had to go through the pain of losing people that she loved. In this poem, Dickinson, using imagery, metaphors and diction, explain the “great pain” she felt and how to get through it.
One of the things that Dickinson notice about people is that even though they have gone through that pain, they still go through their daily lives as if nothings ever happened. That even though we feel great pain and suffering, we do not show any signs of affecting our lives. Dickinson says “The Feet, mechanical, go round –” to explain what she and other has done, that like machines we will keep on going and going. They will question G-d, life and “The stiff Heart questions was it He, that bore”. They will keep on asking questions of why this happened to them.
Dickinson knows that life can be a “wooden way regardless grown”. In other words life is full of obstacles and great emotional pain. Looking closely at the diction one even hears the “groan” of her pain in the word grown. However sad this experience is people will bottle up this feeling inside of them. The people will become “A Quartz contentment like stone—“, they don’t want anybody to tell them that it will be alright. Although this is the “Hour of Lead”, one of our hardest times on our lives, people want to be alone. She knows that great emotional pain is not for the weak and that it will be hard to survive it and some will not make it. For those that survived she says they will become like “As Freezing persons recollect the Snow—First—Chill—then Stupor—then the letting go”. She explains using this sentence that in order to survive such a great emotional pain that part of you will die.
This has many different meanings for me,death can be more than physical death as others have commented.Dealing with a serious physical condition it reminds me of first knowledge of time limits on life.Then it also brings the pain of other loss,losing someone not in body but maybe in soul. Watching as the real person dissappears and becomes a stranger. I hope this is understood very intense and difficult to place in words.
i think this poem is about the pain that has been suffered after a broke up with someone you truly love.she is now on the process of letting go.
by limiting this poem to just "death", we are eliminating all the other possible reasons for the "pain".
While I agree this poem is indeed about death, I don't believe that it is from the standpoint of those who have lost a loved one, but rather of the apparent pronouns Emily creates out of words that are regularly nouns- "Heart", "Nerves", "Air" etcetera. If you read it like these objects and feelings are beings themselves, your outlook on the poem shifts.
i think this poem is about death
The day my father died this poem came to my mind. Sure it can be about many kinds of "pain". However, the death of a beloved calls stronger for it.
Emily D
can yall tell me more about her!!!!!!
What great pain (physical or emotional) feels like over time.
want help in this poem
i want help in critical the poem After great pain