between the breasts
of bestial
Marj lie large
men who praise
Marj's cleancornered strokable
body these men's
fingers toss trunks
shuffle sacks spin kegs they
curl
loving
around
beers
the world has
these men's hands but their
bodies big and boozing
belong to
Marj
the greenslim purse of whose
face opens
on a fatgold
grin
hooray
hoorah for the large
men who lie
between the breasts
of bestial Marj
for the strong men
who
sleep between the legs of Lil
✦
Analysis
between the breasts: analysis
Introduction
"between the breasts" is a short, mocking poem about a group of working men and a woman called Marj. The men appear to handle cargo. They spend their strength on beer and in bed with her. The poem says that the world owns their hands but Marj owns their bodies. It describes her in hard, commercial images, and it ends with a cheer for the men. A last line brings in a second woman, Lil. Praise and contempt are hard to separate throughout.
Summary
The poem opens by placing large men "between the breasts / of bestial" Marj. These men praise her.
What they praise is her "cleancornered strokable / body". The poem then turns to their work. Their fingers "toss trunks" and "shuffle sacks spin kegs".
Those fingers then go off the job. They curl around beers, and the word for how they curl is "loving".
Next comes a division. The world has the men's hands. Their "bodies big and boozing" belong elsewhere, and the stanza ends on "belong to".
The following stanza completes the sentence with "Marj". It describes her face as a "greenslim purse". The purse "opens / on a fatgold", and the next stanza supplies the noun.
That noun is "grin". The speaker then cheers with "hooray". The cheer is for the large "men who lie" where the poem began.
The opening words come back: the men lie "between the breasts / of bestial Marj". The cheer extends "for the strong men", and the stanza ends on the single word "who".
The last line completes that sentence. These men "sleep between the legs of Lil". Lil appears only here, and the poem ends on her name.
Themes and meaning
Work and appetite divide these men. The poem states it outright: the world has "these men's hands". Those hands earn their keep with trunks, sacks and kegs. Their bodies "belong to" Marj. Ownership runs through this language, so the men seem to have nothing left for themselves.
Money runs through the imagery. Marj's face is a "greenslim purse" opening on a "fatgold" grin. Green and gold are colours of cash, and a purse is where it goes. The likeliest reading is that the men pay for sex here, and that their wages end up with her.
Marj's body is treated as goods. The word "cleancornered" could describe a crate as easily as a woman. It puts her in the same list as the cargo the men handle. Calling her "bestial" is an insult, yet the men are the ones "big and boozing". The insult fits them at least as well as it fits her.
Strength ends in bed. The men are "large" and "strong", but they end the poem lying down. Both closing images are sexual: the men lie on one woman's breasts and sleep between another's legs. That position makes these grown men look helpless and dependent. The cheer of "hooray" therefore sounds mock-heroic. The move from "lie" to "sleep", and from Marj to Lil, gives them another woman. Sleep may also hint at death, though nothing in the poem confirms this.
Tone
The voice is brisk and unsentimental. It reports the men's work in hard, quick verbs. "toss trunks" and "spin kegs" sound almost admiring.
The word "loving" brings a small shock, because it is given to beers. That comic misplacement sets the attitude: fond, but scornful of what these men love.
The description of Marj is the harshest part. "bestial", "greenslim" and "fatgold" are not flattering, and the grin looks greedy. The speaker's distance from her is plain, though the speaker also seems to enjoy the performance.
The cheer near the end is the hardest thing to judge. "hooray" has barroom good humour in it. But the men it cheers have just been shown as owned, so it reads as sarcasm with some fondness left. The cheer runs on into the last line, which completes it. With no exclamation left in it, the line about Lil is quieter, and the poem closes without comment.
Form and structure
The poem is free verse with no regular metre. Its stanzas are short blocks, most of them about four lines. The lines are short, so the column stays narrow.
The regular block shape contrasts with sentences that run freely across it. Stanzas often end in mid-phrase, as with "belong to" and "on a fatgold". End rhyme plays no part, and line endings match mostly through repeated words such as "breasts". The opening words return near the end, which works like a refrain. The single final line breaks the pattern and isolates Lil.
Poetic devices
Alliteration line 1
between the breasts The b sounds carry on into bestial on the next line and bind the body to the insult. The opening is loud and blunt.
Epithet line 2
of bestial The adjective is the poem's first judgement of Marj. Because it is repeated later, it comes to work like a fixed title.
Coinage line 5
Marj's cleancornered strokable The compound makes her body sound squared off like a box. Strokable then adds touch, and the two together suggest an object for handling.
Alliteration line 7
fingers toss trunks The hard t sounds give the labour a physical thump. The verbs come quickly and the men seem capable.
Asyndeton line 8
shuffle sacks spin kegs With no joining words, the actions pile up like a shift's repeated work.
Transferred epithet line 10
loving The feeling belongs to the men, but the word goes to their fingers curling around beers. The drink as object of love turns it comic.
Synecdoche line 14
these men's hands Hands stand for the labour the world buys. The next lines set them apart from the body that belongs to Marj.
Alliteration line 15
bodies big and boozing The heavy b sounds return from the opening, and they tie the men's size to their drinking.
Metaphor line 18
the greenslim purse of whose Her face becomes a purse, which brings in money without a word about payment. The colour and the shape are both unflattering.
Irony line 22
hooray The cheer celebrates men whose largeness has just been shown as owned and dependent. Its enthusiasm reads as mockery.
Pun line 24
men who lie At the end of the line, lie can briefly mean tell untruths. The next line restores the physical sense, but both can stay in mind, since these are men who praise her.
Parallelism line 29
sleep between the legs of Lil The line copies the shape of the opening and shifts each term. Lie becomes sleep, breasts become legs, and Marj becomes Lil.
Words worth knowing
bestial
Like a beast: coarse and animal, with a sexual suggestion.
trunks
Large travelling chests or luggage, not tree trunks or swimwear.
cleancornered
A coined compound: having neat, square corners, as a crate might.
strokable
A coined or rare word: inviting a stroke of the hand.
greenslim
A coined compound: both green and thin, which here can suggest banknotes as well as an unwell face.
fatgold
A coined compound: fat and golden. It describes the grin, and may suggest gold teeth or wealth.
Context
This poem was the site's Poem of the Day on March 25, 2016.
What readers have said
Bee denies that cummings meant a put-down of women or their bodies, and reads the poem as a compliment to women's ways and curves. Bee, 2005
innosents 'volved w/decadence i am you n a back'ards glimpse flowering countenance cannot hide THAT you... are Me out and out deplorable they question we as if we is any different than me or them or all us gathered our forces drive everywhere deny? the pigs of men the she they strap snouts in plastic2 why coward in side of a mountain the pebble is the true disgust... when all so admit the strings are on tight
katieQT69Canada
i like it between the breasts.....
AliceBulgaria
breasts are boobs sitting on a shoulder boobs are breasts only getting older breasts oh my, boobs oh why? between the breasts of mathen jects there lies a secret you can only guess by having sex
courtUnited States
props to KatieQT69sexmaniac...ect. - that's the best comment I've found in this forum and probably the only one cummings would've enjoyed reading.
BeeUnited States
This poem in my opinion is just descring that men with bug hands can be more pleasurable. I don't believe cummings ever intended this to be a put down of women or their bodies, but instead complememting us on our ways, our curves. Cummings only intends his poem to spark some intrest, to spark a grain of thought out of the ordinary individual!
erik elijah cummingsNew Zealand
E.E. Cummings is a maniac
kaleb penleyUnited States
very nice poem. i love the details and the way he slept between lil's legs
bottness bill-aegnisIraq
between my breasts is right. ... right where my firm connection with this poem has been established. yes. oh yes. established is right. yes. firm. hot. and firm.
innosents 'volved w/decadence
i am you n a back'ards glimpse
flowering countenance
cannot hide THAT you...
are Me
out and out deplorable
they question we
as if we is any different
than me or them or all us gathered
our forces drive everywhere
deny? the pigs of men
the she they
strap snouts in plastic2
why coward in
side of a mountain
the pebble is the true
disgust...
when all so admit
the strings are on tight
i like it between the breasts.....
breasts are boobs sitting on a shoulder
boobs are breasts only getting older
breasts oh my, boobs oh why?
between the breasts of mathen jects there lies a secret you can only guess by having sex
props to KatieQT69sexmaniac...ect. - that's the best comment I've found in this forum and probably the only one cummings would've enjoyed reading.
This poem in my opinion is just descring that men with bug hands can be more pleasurable. I don't believe cummings ever intended this to be a put down of women or their bodies, but instead complememting us on our ways, our curves. Cummings only intends his poem to spark some intrest, to spark a grain of thought out of the ordinary individual!
E.E. Cummings is a maniac
very nice poem. i love the details and the way he slept between lil's legs
between my breasts is right. ... right where my firm connection with this poem has been established. yes. oh yes. established is right. yes. firm. hot. and firm.
"very nice poem. i love the details and the way he slept between lil's legs"
I agree Kaleb.
love it between the breast to
he never fails to disappoint us with his content
I like this poem very much. I like the detail