Snow

Portrait of David Berman
David Berman 1967–2019

Walking through a field with my little brother Seth

I pointed to a place where kids had made angels in the snow. For some reason, I told him that a troop of angels had been shot and dissolved when they hit the ground.

He asked who had shot them and I said a farmer.

Then we were on the roof of the lake. The ice looked like a photograph of water.

Why he asked. Why did he shoot them.

I didn't know where I was going with this.

They were on his property, I said.

When it's snowing, the outdoors seem like a room.

Today I traded hellos with my neighbor. Our voices hung close in the new acoustics. A room with the walls blasted to shreds and falling.

We returned to our shoveling, working side by side in silence.

But why were they on his property, he asked.

Snow: analysis

Introduction

Snow is a 16-line poem by David Berman, from his book Actual Air. The speaker remembers walking through a snowy field with his little brother Seth. Seeing snow angels, he invents a story: a troop of angels was shot by a farmer and dissolved when they hit the ground. Seth keeps asking why.

The poem then cuts to the present, to the speaker shoveling snow beside a neighbour. It closes on Seth's question, still unanswered. The poem is about a careless story that turns violent, and about questions an older person cannot answer.

Summary

Lines 1 to 5: the speaker walks through a field with "my little brother Seth." He points to a place where kids made snow angels. For no clear reason, he tells Seth that a troop of angels was shot and "dissolved when they hit the ground." Seth asks who shot them, and the speaker says a farmer.

Lines 6 to 10: the brothers are now "on the roof of the lake," the frozen surface. The ice looks "like a photograph of water." Seth asks why the farmer shot them. The speaker admits, "I didn't know where I was going with this." He answers that the angels were on the farmer's property.

Lines 11 to 15: the scene shifts to the present. When it snows, the speaker says, "the outdoors seem like a room." Today he exchanged hellos with his neighbour, and their voices hung close. He describes the room again, as one "with the walls blasted to shreds and falling." He and the neighbour return to shoveling, side by side, in silence.

Line 16 stands alone. It returns to Seth, who asks, "But why were they on his property." The poem gives no answer.

Themes and meaning

The first theme is the power of an idle story. The speaker invents the shooting "For some reason," with no plan. He admits he "didn't know where I was going with this." Yet the story has weight, since angels, a farmer and a gun introduce death into a child's winter walk. The poem shows how easily an older sibling's improvisation becomes a younger one's reality.

A second theme is innocence and violence. Snow angels are a children's game, and the speaker turns them into victims. Words like "troop" and "shot" bring war into the field. Later the snowfall itself becomes a room with walls "blasted to shreds." The gentle snow keeps carrying images of destruction.

A third theme is the logic of ownership. The speaker justifies the killing with "They were on his property." The answer is absurd, but it echoes a real way adults explain violence. Seth does not accept it. His final question pushes past the excuse to ask why they were there at all.

A fourth theme is the unanswered question. The poem ends with Seth's question, with no question mark and no reply. It can be read as a memory that still troubles the speaker years later, as he shovels in silence. The silence beside his neighbour mirrors his silence toward his brother.

Tone

The tone is quiet, wry and faintly uneasy. The speaker tells the story plainly, without explaining himself. "For some reason" and "I didn't know where I was going with this" sound honest and a little sheepish.

The images are calm and strange: the "roof of the lake," the ice "like a photograph of water." These soften the violent story with wonder. The speaker notices beauty even while inventing a killing.

The present-day section turns more solitary. The voices hang close, then the men return to work "in silence." The last line brings back the child's insistence. The poem closes on a note of unease rather than humour.

Form and structure

The poem has 16 lines spread over 11 stanzas, most of them single lines. The form facts give stanza lengths of 1, 3, 1, 2, 1, 1, 1, 1, 3, 1 and 1. Lines run from 8 to 16 syllables. There is no metre and no rhyme.

The many single-line stanzas leave white space around each statement, like snow. Wider gaps after lines 5, 10 and 15 split the poem into sections, the last of which is a single line. Speech is reported without quotation marks, so Seth's questions blend into the narration.

Poetic devices

Diction line 3
a troop of angels Troop is a military word. It turns the snow angels into soldiers and prepares for the shooting.
Metaphor line 6
the roof of the lake The frozen surface becomes a roof over the water below. The image makes the familiar lake strange.
Simile line 7
The ice looked like a photograph of water. Frozen water looks like a still picture of moving water. The image fits a poem about memory.
Unmarked dialogue line 8
Why he asked. Why did he shoot them. The questions lack quotation marks and question marks. Seth's voice sounds flat and insistent, as if remembered.
Simile line 11
the outdoors seem like a room Falling snow closes in the space and muffles it. The outdoors feels enclosed.
Imagery line 13
Our voices hung close in the new acoustics. Sound is described as hanging in the air. The snow changes how the world sounds.
Metaphor line 14
A room with the walls blasted to shreds and falling. The snowfall becomes a room's walls exploding. The image brings violence back into the peaceful scene.
Repetition line 16
But why were they on his property, he asked. Seth's question returns to the farmer's excuse from line 10. Ending on it leaves the poem unresolved.

Words worth knowing

troop
A group of soldiers. Here it gives the angels a military cast.
acoustics
The way sound behaves in a space. The snow has changed them outdoors.
roof of the lake
The frozen surface of the lake, which the brothers walk on.

What readers have said

  • Kayla objects to calling the poem weird and finds it amazing and moving. Kayla, 2008
  • Cary Walker reads it as a poem about conflict, linking Seth to the biblical brother of Cain and Abel and pointing to its war words. Cary Walker, 2011
  • hope reads it as the little brother losing his innocence because of the story the older brother told. hope, 2012
  • angel killer finds the poem interesting but calls the kid nuts, asking why he would kill the angels. angel killer, 2019

This analysis was drafted from the poem’s text, the records of American Poems and the readers’ comments. Every quotation and line number was checked against the poem, scanned for unsupported claims, and the editor read and revised it before publication. Facts about the poet’s life appear only when a source is given. Corrections are welcome through the contact page.

Revised in October 2026.

Keep reading

Discover more of David Berman’s poetry.

Explore all poems

Readers

Reader discussion 8 comments

Add your reading ↓
Readers
8
Stanzas quoted
2of 11
Most quoted
“I pointed to a place where kids had made angels in the snow.”2 readers
Longest reading
Cary Walker161 words
  1. cs United States

    his band is good too.

  2. Katherin Canada

    it cinda wierd. but ok i geus.

  3. Kayla United States

    This poem is not "kinda weird"
    different maybe, but "weird" is more of a negative connotation
    this poem evokes though and emotion
    it is amazing like all of his poetry and music

  4. empoy United States

    I love his poem "snow"
    and his band 2

  5. Cary Walker United States

    Conflict

    I believe the poem is about conflict. Perhaps it is as specific as Israel and Palestine, but that I cannot tell. Seth is the brother of Cain and Abel and the biblical father of all mankind. If the little brother is Seth, then the narrator is Cain or Abel. The narrator refers to war references in the following: "a 'troop' of angels", "shot and dissolved...", and the most obvious "a room with the walls blasted to…

    Read the whole comment

    I believe the poem is about conflict. Perhaps it is as specific as Israel and Palestine, but that I cannot tell.

    Seth is the brother of Cain and Abel and the biblical father of all mankind. If the little brother is Seth, then the narrator is Cain or Abel.

    The narrator refers to war references in the following: "a 'troop' of angels", "shot and dissolved...", and the most obvious "a room with the walls blasted to shreds and falling."

    Since Seth is the father of all people, then the people fighting must be his children, making the questions he asks come from a very different perspective with that in mind. Ultimately, why are his children fighting over property? That is, why do people fight at all?

    I find it interesting that the older brother appears to have a good, if mostly silent relationship with his neighbor (i.e. another country). Perhaps the narrator is suggesting that is the way countries should behave.

  6. hope United States

    the poem "snow" is about the little brother loosing his innocents because the bigger brother had told him that a farmer had killed the snow angels. the poem is actually very sad if you understand it correctly.

  7. Sophia Lowe Canada

    English

    Can anyone give me a theme about this poem? Thank you.

  8. angel killer

    Interesting poem. I would say that the kid is nuts. Why would he kill the angels?

Your turn

Shown with your comment.

Never published. Only so we can reach you.

Comments are read before they appear. See our terms.