there is enough treachery, hatred violence absurdity in the average
human being to supply any given army on any given day
and the best at murder are those who preach against it
and the best at hate are those who preach love
and the best at war finally are those who preach peace
those who preach god, need god
those who preach peace do not have peace
those who preach peace do not have love
beware the preachers
beware the knowers
beware those who are always reading books
beware those who either detest poverty
or are proud of it
beware those quick to praise
for they need praise in return
beware those who are quick to censor
they are afraid of what they do not know
beware those who seek constant crowds for
they are nothing alone
beware the average man the average woman
beware their love, their love is average
seeks average
but there is genius in their hatred
there is enough genius in their hatred to kill you
to kill anybody
not wanting solitude
not understanding solitude
they will attempt to destroy anything
that differs from their own
not being able to create art
they will not understand art
they will consider their failure as creators
only as a failure of the world
not being able to love fully
they will believe your love incomplete
and then they will hate you
and their hatred will be perfect
like a shining diamond
like a knife
like a mountain
like a tiger
like hemlock
their finest art
✦
Analysis
The Genius Of The Crowd: analysis
Introduction
"The Genius Of The Crowd" is a free-verse warning against the average person and the crowd. It opens by claiming that ordinary people hold enough hatred and violence to supply any army. It then turns on preachers of love and peace, who are said to be best at hate and war.
A long list of warnings follows, each beginning "beware". The poem ends by praising the crowd's hatred in bitter terms. That hatred is "perfect", like a diamond or hemlock, and it is "their finest art".
Summary
The first stanza makes a claim about "the average / human being". Such a person holds enough "treachery, hatred violence absurdity" to supply an army. This is true "on any given day", not only in wartime.
The second stanza has three lines on the same pattern. The best at murder are those who "preach against it". The best at hate are those who "preach love". The best at war "finally" are those who "preach peace".
The third stanza stays with preaching. It states that "those who preach god, need god". Those who preach peace "do not have peace". The last line adds that they "do not have love".
The fourth stanza is a list of warnings, each beginning "beware". It warns against "the preachers", "the knowers" and "those who are always reading books". It warns against those who "either detest poverty / or are proud of it". Some warnings give reasons, such as "they are nothing alone". The list ends with "the average man the average woman" and their "average" love.
The fifth stanza turns: "but there is genius in their hatred". That hatred is enough "to kill you / to kill anybody". Not understanding solitude, they will try to destroy what differs from them. Unable to create art or love fully, they will blame the world and find "your love incomplete". Then "their hatred will be perfect".
The last two stanzas are taken together here. The sixth compares the hatred to "a shining diamond", "a knife", "a mountain", "a tiger" and "hemlock". The single-line seventh stanza calls it "their finest art".
Themes and meaning
Hypocrisy is the first theme. The poem claims that the best at hate "preach love" and the best at war "preach peace". What people preach reveals what they lack: "those who preach god, need god". This can be read as a claim about projection, or simply as distrust of anyone who preaches.
The average and the crowd form a second theme. The word "average" recurs, ending in "their love is average". The crowd's ordinariness is not harmless. The opening says the average person could supply "any given army".
Hatred of difference is a third theme. The crowd is "not wanting solitude / not understanding solitude". Those who "seek constant crowds" are "nothing alone". So they "will attempt to destroy anything / that differs from their own". The person who stands apart is the target.
A fourth theme is failure turned into blame. Those who cannot create art "will not understand art". They treat their failure "as a failure of the world". Those who cannot love fully will think "your love incomplete". Here the poem shifts to "you", the one who differs.
The title is ironic. "genius" and "art" are words of praise, but here they belong to hatred. The similes make that hatred beautiful and deadly at once. The poem also contains its own paradox. It is itself a list of warnings, close to the preaching it tells readers to beware.
Tone
The tone is cold and certain. The opening claims are stated as facts, with no "I" and no argument. The short lines of the second and third stanzas sound like proverbs.
The list of warnings has the rhythm of a sermon. Its repeated "beware" grows insistent and contemptuous, above all toward "the average". Some items are sweeping enough to surprise, such as the warning against readers of books.
In the fifth stanza the tone becomes grim and almost fearful. The crowd's hatred is "enough" to kill. The close shifts to bitter admiration. The similes, from "a shining diamond" to "hemlock", praise the hatred in order to condemn it.
Form and structure
The poem is free verse, with no rhyme scheme and no regular metre. The archive's text has 43 lines in 7 stanzas of 2, 3, 3, 14, 15, 5 and 1 lines. Lines range from 3 to 21 syllables. The opening lines are the longest, and the poem narrows to short lines at the end.
Its structure rests on repetition. "and the best at" opens each line of the second stanza. "beware" begins 9 lines of the fourth. The fifth stanza repeats "not" and "they will", and the sixth repeats "like a".
The stanzas move from claim to warning to prediction to image. The one-line last stanza stands alone like a verdict. Punctuation is sparse, and the first line lacks a comma after "hatred".
Poetic devices
Hyperbole line 2
to supply any given army on any given day The claim is deliberately huge. It makes violence a constant supply in ordinary people, not an exception.
Paradox line 3
the best at murder are those who preach against it Opponents of murder are named its experts. The contradiction sets up the charge of hypocrisy.
Anaphora line 5
and the best at war finally The third use of the same opening completes a pattern. The word finally makes war the last and largest case.
Epistrophe line 6
those who preach god, need god The line ends on the word it began with. The echo suggests preaching is a sign of need.
Anaphora line 9
beware the preachers The first of the warnings in the fourth stanza. Beware repeats down the stanza like a sermon's refrain.
Coinage line 10
beware the knowers Knowers is an unusual noun. It mocks people who are sure they know.
Repetition line 21
their love is average Average is repeated until it becomes an insult. Even the crowd's love is mediocre.
Irony line 23
but there is genius in their hatred The word genius is given to hatred. The line explains the title's bitter praise.
Parallelism line 30
not being able to create art This matches the pattern of line 34. Each lack leads to a hostile response.
Simile line 38
like a shining diamond The hatred is compared to something hard, bright and valuable. It is admired as a perfect object.
Allusion line 42
like hemlock Hemlock is a poison. It can recall the death of Socrates, condemned by a vote of his fellow citizens.
Metaphor line 43
their finest art Hatred is called the crowd's art. Unable to create, the crowd makes hatred its one achievement.
Words worth knowing
knowers
People who know, or claim to know. Here it suggests know-it-alls and people too sure of themselves.
hemlock
A poisonous plant, and the poison made from it.
Context
Charles Bukowski lived from 1920 to 1994. "The Genius Of The Crowd" has been on americanpoems.com since February 2003. Readers left 20 comments on it between 2005 and 2022.
What readers have said
Laura likes the hypocrisy lines and the simile stanza but cannot see why readers of books or those who detest poverty should be feared. Laura, 2007
L. reads the books line as a warning against people who are book smart but not street smart. The poverty line, for L., targets those in high places who look down on the poor. L., 2020
Brittany McKallagat argues the poem does not condemn people but asks readers to question others, such as why someone detests poverty. brittany McKallagat, 2008
Alison reads it as disgust at mob mentality, not a message of love, and cites peace protesters who use violence. Alison, 2008
Ez points out a paradox: the poem preaches against preachers, like a sentence telling you not to believe what you read. Ez, 2021
Jim heard the poem in a documentary and applies its ending to the comments that attack the poet, calling them the crowd's finest art. jim, 2007
simly put, there is an ammount of truth inside the poem 'The Genius of the Crowd' that Bukowski had realized and figured out. This is not some drunken poem or a Laytonesque prophecy.
The words of this poem speak a truth that has needed to be said for a long time. (ie: those who preech god, need god) that statement alone isn't saying anything negative or 'anti' anyone, he is merely pointing out a fact, ergo, The Genius of Bukwoski for doing so in this talented way.
His crudity and shame and disgusting attitudes, all the cranky stuff that he has done in his life, and all the filth that he would have done if he were still alive is not enough to hide neither His genious nor his romance
MikeUnited States
I saw a Bukowski novel in a bookstore 20 years ago and did not buy it because it looked mindlessly vulgar and negative. Finally, after really looking at his work now it looks completely honest and unpretentious. Almost coolly objective about a guy who refused to conform....
jimUnited States
watched a documentary on B. last night. heard part of this poem read during it. i had never heard or read anything by him before although i was familiar with his name. it blew me away, truth wielded like a razor in the hand of a madman. then i heard Bluebird. i plan to read everything i can find by him. i want to shout the genius of the crowd from the rooftops because it describes the world we live in. the posts here that discredit the man and his art are committing "their finest art" for all of us to see how right B. was.
I wholeheartedly agree with you, Jim. I've loved this poem and the genius who wrote the poem since I was first introduced. I would definitely shout it from rooftops to remind the people of ourselves.
LauraUnited States
To be fair, there are things I like about this poem. Though it isn't always the case, there are indeed many hypocrites who don't practice what they preach; and I thought the next-to-last stanza (starts with "like") was beautifully worded. However, I just don't like this poem. "Beware those who are always reading books?" That makes no sense to me. Neither does bewaring "those who detest poverty;" is poverty a good thing now? Perhaps I'm missing something, and all the poetry experts reading this will laugh at me, but this poem seems as hateful and vitriolic as those it condemns.
I adore this poem. I think that this poem speaks of the lack of control we have as people of our emotions and therefore actions. we can be extremely unpredictable. the preacher of peace is the best at war because he knows how damaging it is. The preacher of love is so good at hate because he understands how important love is to survive. average hate is stronger than the average love because for most people its so much easier to hate. People who detest poverty understand how such little money can be so useful to people, and can therfore take it away. The people who are always reading books are probably those who want to learn more. and with knowledge comes more power. beware the knowers.
bukowksi is not condemning people in this poem, he is telling people to beware, or question their surroundings. by saying beware of people who detest poverty he is saying question them-- why do they detest poverty? i think bukowski is saying that we must QUESTION things, not take them for their surface value. most people are filled with hate because they don't understand other people or where they are coming from. this is why we must beware of others so we don't end up surrounded by a bunch of average people who hate their lives doing a bunch of average things.
mariUnited States
those who detest poverty will never do anything to fix the problem and those proud of it are just, well, twisted.
bukowski is poetry. the best kind of poetry.
AlisonSingapore
This is not a message of love, as some have interpreted, but one of disgust. He's talking about the horror of mob metality and warning us against it. Those who preach peae and love yet have none of it themselves are those who protest something and hypcritically support it simultaneously. An example would be 'peace protesters' using violent means to make an example. They are so angry at what they stand for,they…
Read the whole comment
This is not a message of love, as some have interpreted, but one of disgust. He's talking about the horror of mob metality and warning us against it. Those who preach peae and love yet have none of it themselves are those who protest something and hypcritically support it simultaneously. An example would be 'peace protesters' using violent means to make an example. They are so angry at what they stand for,they gather in crowds and together their hate disturbs them and makes them best at war. The line about bewaring those who read books and detest/are proud of poverty means that the narrow-minded mass of semi-educated people merely demonstrate their lack of involvement with the real world- the tough, no-nonsense world of Bukowski. The goes on to condemn that middle class crowd of the average and describes the tyranny of the masses, the hatred of those who group together "not wanting solitutde not understanding solitude" and blaming the world for their failures when truly, they are the incomplete ones. The majority is tempting like a shining diamond, and large as a mountain, and as dangerous as the knife, tiger, and hemlock he concludes the poem with. It is their hatred that is their "finest art".
I absolutely love this poem. I have never read anything more real in my life.
Heather
I believe this poem echoes Ralph Waldo Emerson, who said something along the lines of “Who you are speaks so loudly I can’t hear what you’re saying.” In other words, you can preach peace & Love, but if you do not demonstrate those virtues, your words are BS. Like the people who gang up to attack & humiliate people while preaching they “deserve” it for some perceived moral lapse, etc. I believe Bukowski would be revolted by the dogmatism of many on both sides of today’s political spectrum but perhaps most disgusted by those who call themselves “against hate” while spending their lives hating.
I've always taken the line “Beware those who are always reading books" to mean be wary of people who lack experience and are simply "book smart" rather than "street smart". As for “those who detest poverty;” I think he means those in high places who disregard the needy or look down upon the poor.
This is a phenomenal poem, I really resonated with the message of anti-radicalization and anti-"well we're the good guys here because we're fighting the bad guys/things". One thing I just found kind of funny though is that Bukowski is kinda hypocritical. He is preaching to beware of the preachers... Thats boarderline a paradox analogous to reading "don't believe what you read" or "this statement is a lie" lol. If we shouldn't follow preachers just because they put up this world peace facade, how, then, should we feel about following a preacher just because they seem educated and poetic on the surface?
This man got it all right. Cheers, Buk!
Bukowski isn't poetry.
..and your are not poetry either,arent you..
simly put, there is an ammount of truth inside the poem 'The Genius of the Crowd' that Bukowski had realized and figured out. This is not some drunken poem or a Laytonesque prophecy.
The words of this poem speak a truth that has needed to be said for a long time. (ie: those who preech god, need god) that statement alone isn't saying anything negative or 'anti' anyone, he is merely pointing out a fact, ergo, The Genius of Bukwoski for doing so in this talented way.
His crudity and shame and disgusting attitudes, all the cranky stuff that he has done in his life, and all the filth that he would have done if he were still alive is not enough to hide neither His genious nor his romance
I saw a Bukowski novel in a bookstore 20 years ago and did not buy it because it looked mindlessly vulgar and negative. Finally, after really looking at his work now it looks completely honest and unpretentious. Almost coolly objective about a guy who refused to conform....
watched a documentary on B. last night. heard part of this poem read during it. i had never heard or read anything by him before although i was familiar with his name. it blew me away, truth wielded like a razor in the hand of a madman. then i heard Bluebird. i plan to read everything i can find by him. i want to shout the genius of the crowd from the rooftops because it describes the world we live in. the posts here that discredit the man and his art are committing "their finest art" for all of us to see how right B. was.
I wholeheartedly agree with you, Jim. I've loved this poem and the genius who wrote the poem since I was first introduced. I would definitely shout it from rooftops to remind the people of ourselves.
To be fair, there are things I like about this poem. Though it isn't always the case, there are indeed many hypocrites who don't practice what they preach; and I thought the next-to-last stanza (starts with "like") was beautifully worded. However, I just don't like this poem. "Beware those who are always reading books?" That makes no sense to me. Neither does bewaring "those who detest poverty;" is poverty a good thing now? Perhaps I'm missing something, and all the poetry experts reading this will laugh at me, but this poem seems as hateful and vitriolic as those it condemns.
I adore this poem.
I think that this poem speaks of the lack of control we have as people of our emotions and therefore actions. we can be extremely unpredictable.
the preacher of peace is the best at war because he knows how damaging it is. The preacher of love is so good at hate because he understands how important love is to survive.
average hate is stronger than the average love because for most people its so much easier to hate.
People who detest poverty understand how such little money can be so useful to people, and can therfore take it away. The people who are always reading books are probably those who want to learn more. and with knowledge comes more power.
beware the knowers.
bukowksi is not condemning people in this poem, he is telling people to beware, or question their surroundings. by saying beware of people who detest poverty he is saying question them-- why do they detest poverty? i think bukowski is saying that we must QUESTION things, not take them for their surface value. most people are filled with hate because they don't understand other people or where they are coming from. this is why we must beware of others so we don't end up surrounded by a bunch of average people who hate their lives doing a bunch of average things.
those who detest poverty will never do anything to fix the problem and those proud of it are just, well, twisted.
bukowski is poetry. the best kind of poetry.
This is not a message of love, as some have interpreted, but one of disgust. He's talking about the horror of mob metality and warning us against it. Those who preach peae and love yet have none of it themselves are those who protest something and hypcritically support it simultaneously. An example would be 'peace protesters' using violent means to make an example. They are so angry at what they stand for,they…
Read the whole commentThis is not a message of love, as some have interpreted, but one of disgust. He's talking about the horror of mob metality and warning us against it. Those who preach peae and love yet have none of it themselves are those who protest something and hypcritically support it simultaneously. An example would be 'peace protesters' using violent means to make an example. They are so angry at what they stand for,they gather in crowds and together their hate disturbs them and makes them best at war. The line about bewaring those who read books and detest/are proud of poverty means that the narrow-minded mass of semi-educated people merely demonstrate their lack of involvement with the real world- the tough, no-nonsense world of Bukowski. The goes on to condemn that middle class crowd of the average and describes the tyranny of the masses, the hatred of those who group together "not wanting solitutde not understanding solitude" and blaming the world for their failures when truly, they are the incomplete ones. The majority is tempting like a shining diamond, and large as a mountain, and as dangerous as the knife, tiger, and hemlock he concludes the poem with. It is their hatred that is their "finest art".
I absolutely love this poem. I have never read anything more real in my life.
I believe this poem echoes Ralph Waldo Emerson, who said something along the lines of “Who you are speaks so loudly I can’t hear what you’re saying.” In other words, you can preach peace & Love, but if you do not demonstrate those virtues, your words are BS. Like the people who gang up to attack & humiliate people while preaching they “deserve” it for some perceived moral lapse, etc. I believe Bukowski would be revolted by the dogmatism of many on both sides of today’s political spectrum but perhaps most disgusted by those who call themselves “against hate” while spending their lives hating.
100& AGREE
I've always taken the line “Beware those who are always reading books" to mean be wary of people who lack experience and are simply "book smart" rather than "street smart". As for “those who detest poverty;” I think he means those in high places who disregard the needy or look down upon the poor.
This is a phenomenal poem, I really resonated with the message of anti-radicalization and anti-"well we're the good guys here because we're fighting the bad guys/things". One thing I just found kind of funny though is that Bukowski is kinda hypocritical. He is preaching to beware of the preachers... Thats boarderline a paradox analogous to reading "don't believe what you read" or "this statement is a lie" lol. If we shouldn't follow preachers just because they put up this world peace facade, how, then, should we feel about following a preacher just because they seem educated and poetic on the surface?
no, he is a poet.
lol i was born during this year. Why are you up reading this confusing poem at 2:36 am ...