You are the bread and the knife,
The crystal goblet and the wine...
-Jacques Crickillon
You are the bread and the knife,
the crystal goblet and the wine.
You are the dew on the morning grass
and the burning wheel of the sun.
You are the white apron of the baker,
and the marsh birds suddenly in flight.
However, you are not the wind in the orchard,
the plums on the counter,
or the house of cards.
And you are certainly not the pine-scented air.
There is just no way that you are the pine-scented air.
It is possible that you are the fish under the bridge,
maybe even the pigeon on the general's head,
but you are not even close
to being the field of cornflowers at dusk.
And a quick look in the mirror will show
that you are neither the boots in the corner
nor the boat asleep in its boathouse.
It might interest you to know,
speaking of the plentiful imagery of the world,
that I am the sound of rain on the roof.
I also happen to be the shooting star,
the evening paper blowing down an alley
and the basket of chestnuts on the kitchen table.
I am also the moon in the trees
and the blind woman's tea cup.
But don't worry, I'm not the bread and the knife.
You are still the bread and the knife.
You will always be the bread and the knife,
not to mention the crystal goblet and--somehow--the wine.
✦
Analysis
Litany: analysis
Introduction
"Litany" is a comic love poem built as a list of metaphors. It opens with a two-line epigraph from another writer that calls someone "the bread and the knife". The speaker repeats those lines and adds more flattering images for "you".
Then the speaker starts saying what the addressee is not. Halfway through, the speaker turns to his or her own claims and lists everything "I am". The poem ends by handing the original images back. It is a poem about the language of love poetry as much as about love itself.
Summary
The poem begins with an epigraph set apart from the text. It quotes two lines: "You are the bread and the knife, / The crystal goblet and the wine...". A dash and the name of another writer follow.
The first stanza repeats the epigraph's two lines as the speaker's own. It then adds four more images for "you". The addressee is the dew, the sun, the baker's apron and birds taking off from a marsh.
The second stanza turns with "However". The addressee is not the wind in the orchard, the plums, or "the house of cards". The speaker insists twice that the addressee is not "the pine-scented air".
The third stanza allows some possibilities. The addressee might be "the fish under the bridge" or the pigeon on a general's head. But the addressee is "not even close" to being a field of cornflowers at dusk.
The fourth stanza tells the addressee to check a mirror. That look will show the addressee is not the boots in the corner. Nor is the addressee the boat "asleep in its boathouse".
In the fifth stanza the speaker changes subject. Mentioning "the plentiful imagery of the world", the speaker announces a new claim. The speaker is "the sound of rain on the roof".
The sixth stanza continues the speaker's list. The speaker is also a shooting star and an evening paper blowing down an alley. The speaker is the basket of chestnuts on the kitchen table as well.
The last stanza adds "the moon in the trees" and a blind woman's tea cup. Then the speaker reassures the addressee. The speaker is not the bread and the knife. The addressee still is, and "will always be", along with the goblet and "somehow" the wine.
Themes and meaning
The poem's first subject is the love poem itself. The epigraph offers the old habit of praising someone through metaphor. The speaker takes that habit literally and starts checking each image for accuracy. Line 23 names the raw material directly as "the plentiful imagery of the world". The joke is that such images are endless and interchangeable, so any of them could be handed to anyone.
A second idea is praise mixed with teasing. The addressee keeps the fine images of stanza one, but loses others with mock severity. "There is just no way that you are the pine-scented air" sounds like a playful argument between intimates. The negations can be read as affectionate ribbing rather than insult. They also show how a list of compliments can turn into a list of limits.
A third idea is the speaker's vanity. From line 24 the attention shifts from "you" to "I". The speaker claims rain, a shooting star, the moon and chestnuts with growing confidence. The phrase "It might interest you to know" makes the boast sound offhand. One reading is that every love poem is partly about the poet.
The ending raises the question of constancy. "You will always be the bread and the knife" sounds like a vow. Yet it comes after a long game of taking images away and giving them out. The word "somehow" in line 33 leaves a small doubt about the wine. The close can be read as sincere devotion or as one last joke, and the text supports both.
Tone
The tone at the start is ceremonial. The repeated "You are" in lines 4 to 9 sounds like a hymn or prayer, which suits the title. The images are warm and generous.
With "However" in line 10 the voice becomes conversational and mock-judicial. Phrases like "certainly not" and "not even close" belong to argument, not devotion. The humour is deadpan, since absurd images such as "the pigeon on the general's head" are weighed with a straight face.
In the later stanzas the speaker sounds smug and theatrical. "I also happen to be" is boasting dressed as modesty. The final stanza softens into reassurance with "But don't worry". That comfort is affectionate, though it can also be heard as gently condescending.
Form and structure
The poem has 33 lines in 8 stanzas, counting the epigraph as the first. The stanza lengths are 3, 6, 5, 4, 3, 3, 3 and 6 lines. It is free verse with no regular metre. Line lengths range from 3 to 14 syllables.
There is no rhyme scheme. The only sound links come from repeated words. The word "knife" closes line 1, line 4 and lines 30–32, and "air" closes lines 13–14.
The title names a form of prayer built on repeated invocations. The poem imitates it with the anaphora of "You are" and later "I am". The last line echoes line 5, so the poem ends where it began.
Poetic devices
Metaphor line 4
You are the bread and the knife The addressee is equated with both nourishment and the tool that cuts it. The pairing suggests someone both comforting and sharp.
Anaphora line 6
You are the dew on the morning grass The repeated opening "You are" gives the first stanza the rhythm of a litany. It sets up the pattern the poem later breaks.
Imagery line 7
the burning wheel of the sun A grand, heated image stands beside small domestic ones. The range shows how loosely such metaphors can be chosen.
Irony line 14
There is just no way that you are the pine-scented air The emphatic denial treats an arbitrary image as a matter of fact. The overstatement is the joke.
Incongruity line 16
the pigeon on the general's head A slightly ridiculous image is offered as a possible compliment. It mocks the solemnity of love-poem comparisons.
Personification line 21
the boat asleep in its boathouse The boat is given sleep. The image is peaceful, yet it is one the addressee is denied.
Self-reference line 23
speaking of the plentiful imagery of the world The speaker names the poem's own method. The line admits that the images are a stock anyone can draw from.
Alliteration line 25
the shooting star The repeated sibilants give the speaker's boast a smooth, pleased sound.
Caesura line 33
the crystal goblet and--somehow--the wine The dashes interrupt the final line. The pause around "somehow" suggests puzzlement or a last flicker of teasing.
Refrain line 32
You will always be the bread and the knife The phrase from line 4 returns as a promise. The repetition closes the circle begun by the epigraph.
Words worth knowing
Litany
A form of prayer made of a series of invocations and repeated responses. It is also used loosely for any long, repetitive list.
general's
A military commander's. The pigeon image most likely refers to a statue of a general, though the poem does not say so.
cornflowers
Small blue wildflowers that grow in grain fields.
house of cards
Literally a fragile stack of playing cards. As an idiom it means any structure or plan likely to collapse.
Context
The archive's records name Harpers as the poem's source. The poem has been on americanpoems.com since 2003. It was the site's Poem of the Day on October 19, 2012. Readers have left comments on it from 2007 to 2023.
What readers have said
This reader first remembered the poem as humorous, with the poet teasing that the addressee was not the bread. Coming back to it, ea laughed and insisted the addressee plainly is the bread. ea, 2007
Carol read the poem as a contrast between the speaker's life with a spouse and an earlier great love who first taught the speaker to love. Carol, 2010
funny, I was thinking this was a more humorous poem because I remembered it as Billy Collins teasing that she was not the bread and I came back to laugh and say, You know damn well she is the bread, Billy Collins! But how she went from a salty little laugenbrötchen to a crusty old baguette, God only knows.
I got the impression that he was contrasting life with his spouse, with that of the other great love of his life--the one who first taught him how to truly love, even if sometimes by default.
funny, I was thinking this was a more humorous poem because I remembered it as Billy Collins teasing that she was not the bread and I came back to laugh and say, You know damn well she is the bread, Billy Collins! But how she went from a salty little laugenbrötchen to a crusty old baguette, God only knows.
Billy Collins' "Litany"
I got the impression that he was contrasting life with his spouse, with that of the other great love of his life--the one who first taught him how to truly love, even if sometimes by default.
It does sounds like he's critisizing someone.
It does sounds like that
yeah it does, the poem was nice though.