That does not keep me from having a terrible need of -- shall I say the word -- religion. Then
I go out at night to paint the stars.
--Vincent Van Gogh in a letter to his brother
The town does not exist
except where one black-haired tree slips
up like a drowned woman into the hot sky.
The town is silent. The night boils with eleven stars.
Oh starry starry night! This is how
I want to die.
It moves. They are all alive.
Even the moon bulges in its orange irons
to push children, like a god, from its eye.
The old unseen serpent swallows up the stars.
Oh starry starry night! This is how
I want to die:
into that rushing beast of the night,
sucked up by that great dragon, to split
from my life with no flag,
no belly,
no cry.
✦
Analysis
The Starry Night: analysis
Introduction
Anne Sexton's "The Starry Night" opens with words from a letter by Vincent Van Gogh, then turns to a night sky that moves, boils and swallows. The town below hardly exists. Twice the speaker looks up and says, "This is how / I want to die."
The last stanza says how: pulled up into the night by a great beast, leaving no sign behind. The poem is short, loud and strange. It sets a wish for death directly beneath the painter's stated need for religion.
Summary
The poem opens with words in italics and a line of attribution. The words are credited to Vincent Van Gogh, in a letter to his brother. He admits a terrible need of something, pauses over the word, and names it: "religion". Then he says he goes out at night to paint the stars.
The first stanza says the town does not exist, apart from one place. There a "black-haired tree" slips up into a hot sky, like a drowned woman. The town is silent, and the night "boils with eleven stars". The speaker cries out to the starry night and says, "This is how / I want to die."
The second stanza says, "It moves. They are all alive." The moon bulges in "its orange irons" and pushes children from its eye, "like a god". An old, unseen serpent swallows up the stars. The speaker repeats the cry from the first stanza, this time ending on a colon.
The third stanza continues from that colon and finishes the sentence. The speaker wants to go "into that rushing beast of the night". The beast is then called a "great dragon", and it sucks the speaker up. The speaker would then "split / from my life with no flag". Two very short lines close the list: "no belly," and "no cry."
Themes and meaning
The wish for death is stated twice, in the same words. The poem gives no reason for it and makes no case for it. The phrase "This is how" answers the question of manner, and it treats the wish itself as settled. The final stanza then gives that manner, and the verbs are violent: "rushing", "sucked up", "split".
The stars stand in for the religion the epigraph needs. The epigraph names a "terrible need" and then moves straight to painting stars. The poem follows that movement, and its sky is full of religious figures. The moon acts "like a god". The serpent and the dragon are both old figures of evil. So the last stanza reads as a bleak salvation: the speaker is taken up, but by a beast.
The town is dead and the sky is alive. The human world is dismissed at once: "The town does not exist". It is also "silent". All the energy sits overhead, where "They are all alive." The one link between ground and sky is the tree, and it is compared to a drowned woman. That simile puts death into the landscape before the speaker mentions dying.
The speaker wants to leave without a trace, and the last lines are a list of absences. A flag is a public sign, so "no flag" means no cause, no surrender and no announcement. The phrase "no belly" removes the body and its hungers. It also answers the moon's pushed-out children and the serpent's swallowing. The phrase "no cry" removes the last sound a person could make.
Terror and rapture share the refrain. "Oh starry starry night!" is a cry of wonder, and "I want to die" is flat. Shawn and Juliana take the refrain as a plain statement of suicidal feeling. V hears a response to the brilliance of the stars. On the reading offered here, the poem needs both: the speaker wants death because the night is so magnificent. Nothing in the text requires the speaker to be the poet.
Tone
The tone is ecstatic and frightening at once. The refrain "Oh starry starry night!" sounds like delight, yet a flat statement follows it straight away. The first stanza sets plain sentences such as "The town is silent." against the verb "boils".
The second stanza grows more menacing. The words "Even the moon" suggest surprise at how far the strangeness reaches. The moon in irons and the swallowing serpent are nightmare images, yet the speaker does not recoil. The speaker wants to go to them.
The last stanza drops the exclamation. Its lines get shorter, and the poem ends on a refusal to make any noise. The voice there sounds calm, not despairing. That calm is the most unsettling thing in the poem.
Form and structure
The poem is free verse with no regular metre. An epigraph and its credit line stand above three stanzas of 6, 6 and 5 lines.
Within the stanzas, line lengths vary widely, from 13 syllables in the line about the boiling night down to 2 in the closing "no cry." Rhyme is sparse but carefully placed. The sounds of "sky", "die" and "eye" return until "cry" closes the poem. The word "stars" ends a line in each of the first two stanzas. The refrain gives those two stanzas nearly the same ending, a full stop in the first and a colon in the second. The colon carries straight into the third stanza, which replaces the refrain with a list.
Poetic devices
Refrain line 8
Oh starry starry night! This is how The cry returns in the second stanza, joining wonder to the wish that follows it and giving the two stanzas one ending.
Personification line 5
black-haired tree The tree is given a person's hair, which prepares for the drowned woman in the next line.
Simile line 6
like a drowned woman The upward motion of the tree is tied to death by water, so the first image of rising is already an image of dying.
Metaphor line 7
The night boils The night is treated as a heated liquid, turning a still sky into violent motion above the silent town.
Imagery line 11
the moon bulges in its orange irons The moon is both swollen and held in fetters, a strained and trapped body rather than a calm light.
Simile line 12
to push children, like a god, from its eye A birth comes from the wrong organ, and the comparison to a god makes creation look grotesque.
Alliteration line 13
serpent swallows up the stars The repeated s sound suits a snake and gives the line a hiss as the lights disappear.
Metaphor line 16
that rushing beast of the night The whole night becomes one animal, gathering the moving sky of the earlier stanzas into a single creature.
Enjambment line 17
to split The verb ends its line and breaks from the next, so the layout acts out the separation it describes.
Anaphora line 19
no belly, The repeated no strips things away one at a time, and each line gets shorter until only "no cry" is left.
Words worth knowing
irons
Fetters or shackles, as on a prisoner. The moon appears chained as well as coloured by its orange glow.
split
To tear apart or break away. The word also carries a sense of abrupt departure.
flag
A banner or signal. Here it stands for surrender, allegiance or any public sign of going.
belly
The stomach, and by extension the body and its hungers.
Context
The poem is from Anne Sexton's book All My Pretty Ones.
What readers have said
Cole finds the poem very dark and about death, perhaps an afterlife, with a speaker who feels unseen by a town full of living people and wants to die. cole, 2005
Shawn, writing after a thesis on the poem, calls it intensely autobiographical and, by Shawn's account of the poet's life, a clear prediction of her suicide. Shawn, 2005
Juliana agrees with Shawn, recalling a first reading at school that left a sense the speaker wanted to die, and says it was as if the poet were speaking in code about her own life. Juliana, 2010
V, having seen Van Gogh's painting, rejects the dark reading. For V the wish states how brilliant the painted stars are, and that being sucked up into them would be the chosen way to die. V, 2006
Mila finds the night both beautiful and terrifying, and says Sexton did not want to die meekly but would rather lunge headlong into her fate. Mila, 2005
Ben is struck most by the first stanza, where the lone tree in a town without existence expresses isolation, which Ben calls the bitter loneliness of any true artist. Ben, 2005
THE POEM TO ME IS CONSIDERD TO BE A PLEA OF DEATH, HE SEES NO POINT OF LIVING, AFTER HOURS NO ONE CARES THAT HE EXISTS...ALL HE HAS TO DEPEND ON IS THE STARS AND THE DARK NIGHT. HE COULD COUNT ON THE MOON, BUT THE MOON HAS OTHER PRORITIES,AND HIS EXISTENCE IS NOT ONE.
coleUnited States
This poem to me seems very dark. I feel that its about death possible an after life. He is living in a town where he feels he doesnt exist everyone in this town is alive but doesnt acknowledge his existanceand he wants to die.
ShawnUnited States
actually, this poem (written in 1961) is a clear prediction of her impending suicide in october of 1974. the whole thing is riddled with details hinting at how she actually did eventually kill herself...read her bio thoroughly, find out how she dies, then read the poem again. i just did my thesis on this poem, i couldn't believe my eyes when i realized what i'd stumbled across. i thought it was just going to be a run-o-the-mill sexton depression piece relating to her impressions of the painting by van gogh. but it was anything but that. it is intensely autobiographical. later ya'll and keep reading and writing! don't let the poetry fade!
Breck A. CoxUnited States
I believe the exellent writer Anne Sexton wrote this poem to confirm that she had a great appreciation for art.She wanted to know how Van Gogh felt and she knew exactly what it was like for him.She composed this but could not find it within herself to live.Her imagery and symbolism are exellent.She is dearly missed. Sincerly Bc
MilaUnited States
Brilliant description of Van Gogh's famous painting. She makes the night scene seem both beautiful and terrifying. I find it fascinating how Anne was able to convey her passion for life within the context of her death. She didn't want to die meekly, but would rather lunge headlong into her fate, unburdened by ideologies and the base desires of humanity.
The first stanza really does it for me. The town does not exist, she says. And in the painting that is so true as well. Except, she continues, where the lone tree projects upward. That image of this immense faceless town that in truth has no existence outside of that one lone tree. And the isolation which that implies. The bitter loneliness that to some extent is the lot of any true artist is so beautifully expressed in this absolutely wonderful poem.
i think this poem is absolutely brilliant. i love anne sexton's writing. i admire how she wrote about a work of art, and it was all about her observations and opinions about the poem. brilliant.
VCanada
I think Sexton produces incredible imagery in this poem. If one had never seen Van Gogh's painting, it would still be as captivating. Having seen the painting however, I understand the "this is how I want to die" comment. It is not a depressing thought, or even that dark of a comment. It is purely the statement of the brilliance of the stars in the painting, and how if she could choose how to die, it would be to be sucked up into these fantastic stars. Incredible and wonderful.
When I read that a person has allowed themselves to die I think (shall I say? as Anne questioned in her poem) ...I think of Xt. He too allowed others to murder Him, and for no reason. Or was there a reason? We observers from the outside are once again led by (shall I say it...religion)?? yes led into Mystery again and again. Shall I say it Divine Mystery. Can the cause of death be birth? ..for Nicole presently, for Magdeline distantly, for Anne 40+ years past. The sorrowing mother Maria's mother was Anne, over 2000 years past. Now I read the deep and beautiful insights of another Anne whom I find most profound. gratias agamus Domino Deo nostro...
I have to agree with Shawn. The first time I ever read this poem (in tenth grade), I was struck with the sense that the speaker herself wanted to die. I immediately got the feeling that Anne Sexton was suicidal. And then my teacher confirmed it. About her battle with depression, her suicide attempts, her hospitalization, and eventual death. It really is quite amazing how much this poem and Anne Sexton's life go hand-in-hand. It's as if she was speaking in code about her own life, daring someone to figure out the riddle and know the dreadful fate she wished for herself.
human lol
I am currenly annalysing this poem for English class and it's so sad for some reason to see comments a few months older than me. I wonder how these people are doing now after 15 years lol. Anyways take care everybody, you got this :)
THE POEM TO ME IS CONSIDERD TO BE A PLEA OF DEATH, HE SEES NO POINT OF LIVING, AFTER HOURS NO ONE CARES THAT HE EXISTS...ALL HE HAS TO DEPEND ON IS THE STARS AND THE DARK NIGHT. HE COULD COUNT ON THE MOON, BUT THE MOON HAS OTHER PRORITIES,AND HIS EXISTENCE IS NOT ONE.
This poem to me seems very dark. I feel that its about death possible an after life. He is living in a town where he feels he doesnt exist everyone in this town is alive but doesnt acknowledge his existanceand he wants to die.
actually, this poem (written in 1961) is a clear prediction of her impending suicide in october of 1974. the whole thing is riddled with details hinting at how she actually did eventually kill herself...read her bio thoroughly, find out how she dies, then read the poem again. i just did my thesis on this poem, i couldn't believe my eyes when i realized what i'd stumbled across. i thought it was just going to be a run-o-the-mill sexton depression piece relating to her impressions of the painting by van gogh. but it was anything but that. it is intensely autobiographical. later ya'll and keep reading and writing! don't let the poetry fade!
I believe the exellent writer Anne Sexton wrote this poem to confirm that she had a great appreciation for art.She wanted to know how Van Gogh felt and she knew exactly what it was like for him.She composed this but could not find it within herself to live.Her imagery and symbolism are exellent.She is dearly missed.
Sincerly
Bc
Brilliant description of Van Gogh's famous painting. She makes the night scene seem both beautiful and terrifying. I find it fascinating how Anne was able to convey her passion for life within the context of her death. She didn't want to die meekly, but would rather lunge headlong into her fate, unburdened by ideologies and the base desires of humanity.
The first stanza really does it for me. The town does not exist, she says. And in the painting that is so true as well. Except, she continues, where the lone tree projects upward. That image of this immense faceless town that in truth has no existence outside of that one lone tree. And the isolation which that implies. The bitter loneliness that to some extent is the lot of any true artist is so beautifully expressed in this absolutely wonderful poem.
i think this poem is absolutely brilliant. i love anne sexton's writing. i admire how she wrote about a work of art, and it was all about her observations and opinions about the poem. brilliant.
I think Sexton produces incredible imagery in this poem. If one had never seen Van Gogh's painting, it would still be as captivating. Having seen the painting however, I understand the "this is how I want to die" comment. It is not a depressing thought, or even that dark of a comment. It is purely the statement of the brilliance of the stars in the painting, and how if she could choose how to die, it would be to be sucked up into these fantastic stars. Incredible and wonderful.
When I read that a person has allowed themselves to die I think (shall I say? as Anne questioned in her poem) ...I think of Xt. He too allowed others to murder Him, and for no reason. Or was there a reason? We observers from the outside are once again led by (shall I say it...religion)?? yes led into Mystery again and again. Shall I say it Divine Mystery. Can the cause of death be birth? ..for Nicole presently, for Magdeline distantly, for Anne 40+ years past. The sorrowing mother Maria's mother was Anne, over 2000 years past. Now I read the deep and beautiful insights of another Anne whom I find most profound. gratias agamus Domino Deo nostro...
I have to agree with Shawn. The first time I ever read this poem (in tenth grade), I was struck with the sense that the speaker herself wanted to die. I immediately got the feeling that Anne Sexton was suicidal. And then my teacher confirmed it. About her battle with depression, her suicide attempts, her hospitalization, and eventual death. It really is quite amazing how much this poem and Anne Sexton's life go hand-in-hand. It's as if she was speaking in code about her own life, daring someone to figure out the riddle and know the dreadful fate she wished for herself.
I am currenly annalysing this poem for English class and it's so sad for some reason to see comments a few months older than me. I wonder how these people are doing now after 15 years lol. Anyways take care everybody, you got this :)