"You speak to me of narcissism but I reply that it is
a matter of my life" - Artaud
"At this time let me somehow bequeath all the leftovers
to my daughters and their daughters" - Anonymous
Better,
despite the worms talking to
the mare's hoof in the field;
better,
despite the season of young girls
dropping their blood;
better somehow
to drop myself quickly
into an old room.
Better (someone said)
not to be born
and far better
not to be born twice
at thirteen
where the boardinghouse,
each year a bedroom,
caught fire.
Dear friend,
I will have to sink with hundreds of others
on a dumbwaiter into hell.
I will be a light thing.
I will enter death
like someone's lost optical lens.
Life is half enlarged.
The fish and owls are fierce today.
Life tilts backward and forward.
Even the wasps cannot find my eyes.
Yes,
eyes that were immediate once.
Eyes that have been truly awake,
eyes that told the whole story-
poor dumb animals.
Eyes that were pierced,
little nail heads,
light blue gunshots.
And once with
a mouth like a cup,
clay colored or blood colored,
open like the breakwater
for the lost ocean
and open like the noose
for the first head.
Once upon a time
my hunger was for Jesus.
O my hunger! My hunger!
Before he grew old
he rode calmly into Jerusalem
in search of death.
This time
I certainly
do not ask for understanding
and yet I hope everyone else
will turn their heads when an unrehearsed fish jumps
on the surface of Echo Lake;
when moonlight,
its bass note turned up loud,
hurts some building in Boston,
when the truly beautiful lie together.
I think of this, surely,
and would think of it far longer
if I were not... if I were not
at that old fire.
I could admit
that I am only a coward
crying me me me
and not mention the little gnats, the moths,
forced by circumstance
to suck on the electric bulb.
But surely you know that everyone has a death,
his own death,
waiting for him.
So I will go now
without old age or disease,
wildly but accurately,
knowing my best route,
carried by that toy donkey I rode all these years,
never asking, "Where are we going?"
We were riding (if I'd only known)
to this.
Dear friend,
please do not think
that I visualize guitars playing
or my father arching his bone.
I do not even expect my mother's mouth.
I know that I have died before-
once in November, once in June.
How strange to choose June again,
so concrete with its green breasts and bellies.
Of course guitars will not play!
The snakes will certainly not notice.
New York City will not mind.
At night the bats will beat on the trees,
knowing it all,
seeing what they sensed all day.
✦
Analysis
Suicide Note: analysis
Introduction
"Suicide Note" is a long free-verse poem written as a letter before a planned suicide. It is addressed twice to a "Dear friend". The speaker explains, argues and remembers, but says plainly "I certainly / do not ask for understanding".
The poem moves through images of eyes, a mouth, Jesus riding toward death, and moths drawn to a bulb. It returns again and again to "that old fire" and to earlier deaths: "I know that I have died before". It ends by insisting that the world will not notice. Guitars will not play, and "New York City will not mind."
Summary
The poem opens with a quotation credited to Artaud. It answers a charge of narcissism by calling the matter "a matter of my life". The speaker offers it as a defence in advance.
A second quotation is signed "Anonymous". Its writer wants to "bequeath all the leftovers" to daughters and their daughters. It reads like a line from a will.
The speaker says it is "better" to drop quickly "into an old room". This holds despite the worms, the mare's hoof and girls "dropping their blood". Someone said it is better "not to be born". Worse is being born twice "at thirteen", in a boardinghouse where a bedroom "caught fire" each year.
To a "Dear friend", the speaker says the descent will be "on a dumbwaiter into hell". The speaker will enter death "like someone's lost optical lens". Life is "half enlarged" and tilts back and forth. "Even the wasps cannot find my eyes."
Those eyes were once "truly awake" and "told the whole story". They were also pierced, like "little nail heads" and "light blue gunshots". The speaker calls them "poor dumb animals".
The speaker once had "a mouth like a cup", clay or blood coloured. It was open like a breakwater "for the lost ocean". It was also open "like the noose / for the first head."
"Once upon a time" the speaker hungered for Jesus. The hunger is cried out twice. Jesus, before he grew old, "rode calmly into Jerusalem / in search of death."
This time the speaker asks for no understanding. Yet the speaker hopes others will notice a fish on Echo Lake, moonlight in Boston, and "the truly beautiful" lying together. The speaker would think of these longer if not "at that old fire."
The speaker could admit to being "only a coward" and leave out the moths drawn to the bulb. But "everyone has a death". So the speaker will go now, "wildly but accurately", on the "toy donkey" ridden all these years. They were riding "to this."
The speaker tells the friend not to imagine guitars, a father or "my mother's mouth". The speaker has died before, "once in November, once in June." The snakes will not notice, and New York will not mind. At night the bats will beat on the trees, "knowing it all".
Themes and meaning
Death as a return. The poem presents this death as a repeat. The speaker has "died before", has been "born twice", and keeps going back to "that old fire" and "an old room". Choosing June "again" makes it a pattern. The final death is framed as the end of a journey already long under way: "We were riding (if I'd only known) / to this."
Self-judgement and compulsion. The Artaud epigraph answers a charge of "narcissism". The speaker half accepts it, offering to admit being "only a coward / crying me me me". Yet the gnats and moths are "forced by circumstance / to suck on the electric bulb". This image suggests a pull that is not freely chosen. The poem holds both views and settles neither.
Jesus and a chosen death. The speaker once hungered for Jesus. The poem remembers him riding "calmly into Jerusalem / in search of death", a model of going toward death on purpose. The "toy donkey" of line 80 echoes that ride, and makes the speaker's own route a smaller copy of it. There is no heaven in view, only "a dumbwaiter into hell".
The world's indifference. The speaker expects no ceremony. "Of course guitars will not play!" The snakes "will certainly not notice" and "New York City will not mind." Yet the speaker hopes others will notice beauty, like the fish and the moonlight. Only the bats, "knowing it all", seem to understand.
The wounded body. The poem pictures the self through body parts. The eyes are "pierced", like "nail heads" and "gunshots". The mouth is open "like the noose". Female fertility runs alongside death, in girls "dropping their blood" and June's "green breasts and bellies". Life and bodily growth press on while the speaker turns away.
Tone
The tone is calm, deliberate and often ironic. The speaker speaks to a friend in an even voice. The phrase "wildly but accurately" sums up the mix of passion and control.
The poem refuses to plead. "I certainly / do not ask for understanding" sets the stance. Self-mockery enters with "crying me me me". Bitter humour follows in "Of course guitars will not play!"
There are moments of longing, as in "O my hunger! My hunger!" The hope that others will notice the fish and the moonlight is almost tender. Pain breaks through in the stammer "if I were not... if I were not". The close is quiet and cold, with bats beating on trees in the dark.
Form and structure
"Suicide Note" has 98 lines in 10 stanzas. The first 2 stanzas, of 2 lines each, are epigraphs. The poem's own stanzas run 17, 10, 8, 7, 6, 14, 17 and 15 lines. Lines range from 1 to 17 syllables. The longest lines are the epigraphs, and the poem's own lines are mostly short.
It is free verse, with no regular metre and no rhyme scheme. The poem takes the form of a letter, with "Dear friend" opening the fourth stanza and the last one. Its sentences range from single words to long, winding periods.
Anaphora shapes several stanzas. "Better" opens line 5, line 8, line 11 and line 14. "Eyes" and "I will" repeat in the same way. Very short lines, such as "Yes," at 1 syllable, give single words weight.
Poetic devices
Anaphora line 8
better, "Better" opens line after line in the third stanza. The repetition builds a case, like a person arguing with themselves.
Metaphor line 24
on a dumbwaiter into hell A kitchen lift for food becomes the way down to hell. The homely machine makes damnation mechanical and crowded.
Simile line 27
like someone's lost optical lens The speaker will slip into death like a small lost object. The image stresses lightness and being overlooked.
Metaphor line 39
light blue gunshots Blue eyes become gunshot wounds. The eyes that saw too much are pictured as wounded or as weapons.
Simile line 45
and open like the noose The open mouth is likened to a noose. Speech or hunger is tied directly to death.
Allusion line 51
he rode calmly into Jerusalem The Gospels tell of Jesus riding into Jerusalem before his death. The poem reads that ride as a calm choice of death.
Synaesthesia line 60
its bass note turned up loud Moonlight is given a sound, like music played too loud. Beauty becomes intense enough to hurt.
Repetition line 69
crying me me me The repeated "me" imitates a selfish cry. The speaker voices the charge of self-absorption in order to answer it.
Symbol line 72
to suck on the electric bulb Moths drawn to a bulb stand for a fatal pull that feels compelled. It counters the charge of cowardice.
Oxymoron line 78
wildly but accurately Wildness and precision are joined. The phrase shows a decision that is both frenzied and calculated.
Metaphor line 80
carried by that toy donkey I rode all these years The speaker's life becomes a child's toy ride. It also echoes Jesus riding into Jerusalem toward death.
Irony line 95
New York City will not mind. The flat statement shows the world's indifference. Its calm makes the loss sharper.
Words worth knowing
narcissism
Excessive love of or absorption in oneself. The epigraph answers this charge.
bequeath
To leave something to someone in a will.
dumbwaiter
A small lift that carries food or dishes between floors. Here it carries souls down to hell.
breakwater
A wall built out into the sea to shelter a harbour from waves.
Artaud
Antonin Artaud, a French writer and theatre theorist, quoted in the first epigraph.
Context
Anne Sexton lived from 1928 to 1974. The poem has been on americanpoems.com since February 2003. It was Poem of the Day on November 6, 2007. Readers left 29 comments on it between 2004 and 2020.
What readers have said
Matt reads the last stanza as the speaker refusing to picture the afterlife as a beautiful escape. For this reader the poem lists the reasons the speaker is not doing it, rather than stating why. Matt, 2005
Jonny Doe asks why the boardinghouse caught fire each year, and thinks the guitars are half a joke, the laughter that comes in the middle of crying, aimed at clichés of heaven. Jonny Doe, 2008
Serzi suggests the boardinghouse at thirteen may hint at sexual encounters. Serzi also hears sarcasm toward religion in "born twice". Serzi, 2012
Robert asks how the poem would read without knowing anything of the poet's life, hears no excuses in it, and links the Artaud epigraph to writing out of necessity. Robert, 2005
Violet reads the poem as a speaker questioning the freedom to die once again, having tried before, and finds the tone indifferent to whether readers take it seriously. Violet, 2005
molly answers line 95 directly: New York City may not mind, but molly does, and notices. molly, 2004
That was a really deep poem and really sad. I posted a comment because I want people to acknowledge and recognize this chicks existance in our world. New York City may not mind, but I do and I notice and its not cool. Suicide sucks, for you and the people around you.
I think it is a really good poem, it shows how she really felt and the kind of person she was.She needed somenone by her side to keep going and that is what we all should do, have someone to talk to and never let depression come into our lives.
AmandaUnited States
if you're not going to say something nice about this poem, then don't even bother leaving anything. Stop being immature. thank you, have a nice day :)
LeilaniMexico
I think suicide is commited by persons who see beyond. Anne Sexton obviously did and if her suicide was the only way to make her rest, I guess it makes it kind of ok for her. Not that suicide is ok in every single case, but just in this one, I guess it was the only way out.
this poem is soul-baring.it really speaks 2 me.i understand how 1 can b driven 2 suicide.i understand molly's point,but it is possiblt 2 have a break down + it's very possible 4 1 2 snap + take their life.suicide's avery taboo + foreighn subject 2 the optimistic who just cannot understand it.
I disagree with Leilani, there are so many other ways out of situations then suicide. Anne Sexton took the suckers way out, and insteed of trying to solve her problems or talk to ppl about them she killed herslf. As far as the poem goes i wouldnt say it was one of her best but it was one that expressed her deepest secret.
steph is completley inaccurate----not just bout suicide but about sexton as well.obviousley,steph u have never felt that type od paralyzing despair.+ have'nt u read anne's bio's,steph?she did reach 4 help----especially many times repeatedley at mental institutions.sexton was a very ill person beyond yours or molly's comprhension.
VioletRussia
I got that Anne was questioning her freedom to die once again. By once again, she meant she had attempted before. Thus, do I believe, did she have an entirely apathetic tone as to whether or not those reading took her seriously. She was trying to let us in on the secret of death and what beauty the decision held for her. Why let some omniscient hand guide your fate, when you, who know yourself more than gods can…
Read the whole comment
I got that Anne was questioning her freedom to die once again. By once again, she meant she had attempted before. Thus, do I believe, did she have an entirely apathetic tone as to whether or not those reading took her seriously. She was trying to let us in on the secret of death and what beauty the decision held for her. Why let some omniscient hand guide your fate, when you, who know yourself more than gods can allow, can decide when is right and in what manner is most pleasing for you? For me, Anne is jealous of those who have found death in the medium of violence that suits them. She wishes she could just lay down and have her spirit leave her as it might have occurred in an ancient Hindu Tale. It's not for any of us to judge; her or the others herein. There's a deeper meaning we've all missed, and only Anne can tell.
I disagree with Leilani, How can you think suicide is ok in this case? Suicide is such a selfish way out. It's selfish because your thinking just about yourself and not the people who have to deal with the pain when your gone. I myself was suicidal, I had A void in my heart that I could not feel. It was untill I asked Jesus Christ into my heart that he is the one who filled that void in my heart and restored my…
Read the whole comment
I disagree with Leilani, How can you think suicide is ok in this case? Suicide is such a selfish way out. It's selfish because your thinking just about yourself and not the people who have to deal with the pain when your gone. I myself was suicidal, I had A void in my heart that I could not feel. It was untill I asked Jesus Christ into my heart that he is the one who filled that void in my heart and restored my life. And no, I'm not talking about dead religion I'm talking about having a relationship with the living God. And If that made some of you mad, Well good, because suicide is murder! Yes, murder against your ownself. And the Bible says no murder will inherit the Kingdom of God. IF you murderd someone else yes their is forgiveness as long as your alive. But if you commit suicide, you kill yourself and theirs no time for repenting. So think TWICE befor you think the unthinkable. Theirs Hope in JESUS CHRIST!!!!!1
natalieUnited States
OMG! ann shenae,this is not the room for religious discussion....perhaps you feel you must judge the mentally ill with religious bias because you are questioning your own faith....i think you're looking for a more conservative,organized,intellectual-lacking place of a flock of sheep like you...THIS SITE'S GETTIN NUTS ON HERE AND'LL GO THE DOGS LESS YOU GUYS STOP ACTING AS IF YOU ARE ILLITERATE AND LACKING CULTURE!
Ernest PenaUnited States
this beautiful poetry is written inside of a mind of a great writter that did commit suicide. This shows an inside look of an actual suicide victim, maybe this might show an understanding to people who do it than a just anoter statistic, and maybe this might help people not commit suicide who are on the verge too. Maybe Anne's purpose for writting this poem was to help others or maybe she had no comprehension of helping others
AnnaUnited States
(In regards to earlier comments) I think that the poems we read will be interpreted through our own brain filters and so we will never really know what Anne means or is trying to convey through her works. However, this forum is about sharing our input and our philosophies on what's going on in the poem. Since it is also trying to give different perspectives so that we might be able to see other sides of situation,…
Read the whole comment
(In regards to earlier comments) I think that the poems we read will be interpreted through our own brain filters and so we will never really know what Anne means or is trying to convey through her works. However, this forum is about sharing our input and our philosophies on what's going on in the poem. Since it is also trying to give different perspectives so that we might be able to see other sides of situation, we are all entitled to our own opinions and thoughts. Just because someone makes a comment that doesn't suit your personal beleifs, doesn't give you the right to yell and curse and ridicule and judge them. Please keep this in mind while posting. THANK YOU!
Anyways, I felt as if Anne was trying to convey that she has tried to supress her sucidal thoughts but that she feels she cant hold on anymore and all she wants is that beautiful escape from life.
LauraIreland
wow she seems pretty trobled like she had a deep deep secret i think her poems are beautiful i write poems to but never as good as hers
I've just read all your comments, and I've been thinking this entire time...who are we to judge another person over their oppinion of a poem no one can ever be RIGHT on? hmm... well, personally, I think suicide is not the best choice, and may seem completely irrationalto some while seeming the only way out for others. I have come close to hurting myself, but thoughts of others have always held me back. I think it…
Read the whole comment
I've just read all your comments, and I've been thinking this entire time...who are we to judge another person over their oppinion of a poem no one can ever be RIGHT on? hmm... well, personally, I think suicide is not the best choice, and may seem completely irrationalto some while seeming the only way out for others. I have come close to hurting myself, but thoughts of others have always held me back. I think it depends the person and how they are feeling at the moment. The problem with suicide is it's a mistake one cannot regret later. Well, I'm using mistake in replacement for a better word that i cannot think of. But most things in this world one can regret after they have done them. Suicide is one of the few, or possibly the only, that leaves no room for remorse or second chances.
I think Anne Sexton in this poem is accepting the consequences of suicide, or maybe she is trying to put them in words. The phrase "Of course guitars will not play!" caught my attention because she seems almost exasperated with the reader, almost as if it is the READER that just simply cannot understand how she feels and what she means. It is a poem that can be interpretted many ways, and though there may be some religious allusions, Sexton simply does not seem to care she about religion or that she would go to hell. These are just my thoughts--everyone else is open to their own interpretations, of suicide AND of the poem. I hope my thoughts maybe gave deeper meaning to the poem, and gave all other readers some more food for thought.
WOW I wrote an epic....awesome! sorry....I didn't mean to write an english paper.... haha! Well... I hope everyone else enjoys this and all the other poems as much as I do!
well, she did commit suicide...she actually sipped vodka in her red convertible with the garage closed until it filled up with carbon monoxide and she died of asphixiation...im doing a research paper on her for my LA class and although she was very privaleged, her father and mother sexually abused her...her closest familial relationship was to her aunt who was also chronically depressed and died of suicide as well.…
Read the whole comment
well, she did commit suicide...she actually sipped vodka in her red convertible with the garage closed until it filled up with carbon monoxide and she died of asphixiation...im doing a research paper on her for my LA class and although she was very privaleged, her father and mother sexually abused her...her closest familial relationship was to her aunt who was also chronically depressed and died of suicide as well. she had a terrible life...she also was chronically depressed, and suffered from anxiety disorder. She actually ONLY began writing because her therapist told her to...she was also a model...she is now known as one of the greatest confessional poets of her time...but those of you who believe that suicide is NOT the answer...i totally agree. There are support groups for that. =]
MattUnited States
I think that in the last stanza, Anne is trying to make the reader understand that she does not picture the afterlife to be a beautiful place that she can escape to, she does not expect people to feel remorse for her when she is gone. That's not the point of her "suicide". I don't think she really states a point to her suicide, rather she states all the reasons that she ISN'T doing it.
ToddUnited States
So do we have the Poet because of the illness, or the illness because of the Poet. You can't show me a Poet that is not troubled or tormented or demonized. Even the Poets that write of trees, bees and dandelions must face the everyday hell we call society. Tortured from the inside, tortured from the outside- take your pick.
todd is stupid. you don't know what you're talking about. you just like to put things into neat little packages with broad labels. say something original or don't say anything at all.
Actually Todd said something very important in my opinion. I don't know a single poet who is not tortured. I think the illness creates the Poet.
RobertUnited States
One measure is the number of comments garnered. Is it really her "suicide note" -- what if we didn't know anything about her life. Perhaps she couldn't help but write it. It is eloquent, and darkly beautiful. Languid. Even sensual. Profound. Very sad. She could not live. She is not giving excuses. She bravely and dangerously wrests her inner turmoil and illness out into the open -- not to impress or for praise or…
Read the whole comment
One measure is the number of comments garnered. Is it really her "suicide note" -- what if we didn't know anything about her life. Perhaps she couldn't help but write it. It is eloquent, and darkly beautiful. Languid. Even sensual. Profound. Very sad. She could not live. She is not giving excuses. She bravely and dangerously wrests her inner turmoil and illness out into the open -- not to impress or for praise or any of that (-- thus the epigram by Artaud -- she did it because she had to -- ) such private intimate visceral things so personal she couldn't know them herself until she put them out for the public to ooo, ahh, gawk and spit upon. Yes, what a sad life. What a loss. What if she had kept it all inside? Even a greater loss.
HelenAustralia
"you don't have to be ill to be a poet."
No, you surely don't. You just have to be human. Pain, happiness, depression - all human things that we experience. Some, worse than others. What makes a poet is life, langauge, and being human. Not illnesses. It's the god-given ability to convey thoughts and ideas through metaphores and similies etc. Anne Sexton was truly great. She wasn't psychologically ill. I think we're all psyhcologically ill in the eyes of a psychiatrist. Anne Sexton was just painfully human.
AnaUnited States
Like what was said previously not all poets must be ill to write the way they do. Ok its true that many of them do have expiences that have been hard and depressing that most likely influence their work. But whose to say that a person that is mostly happy can't write a depressing poem. People don't just have one emotion, everyone goes through different phases.
i am ill from pain ill die from shame deppresion is lame and it carnt be named for who i am and what i will be suicidle is becoming of me help is needed help is wanted no one can here my crys of help living on a edge thats about to fall no ones hereing my crys i call no one for me thats the way it will be
~Barb~United States
I love all her poetry, it's honest and deep filled with a distinct understanding of her own pain and suffering. I suggest those that read and judge without knowledge read more of her work and read her Biography. Suicide is not always the answer, but sometimes the only way for a truly tortured soul to finally rest and ease the life-long never ending pain. A great poem, a great writer, and a sister of tortured souls...
Jonny DoeUnited States
Does anyone understand why the boarding house caught fire each year?
It seems like so few of the comments here are about the poem. Someone mentioned the guitars. I think she was sort of joking. Have you ever been in that place where you are crying, but then you start laughing because of how ridiculous it is? I think that's what the "of course" was about, followed by traditional ridiculous images of heaven. Floating up and having guitars play, or seeing her father and he's young enough to have good posture. She thinks the sonar of the bats understand it best: she went from moving to inanimate, and that's all. But I don't get the boardinghouse line and I wish I did.
EtainUnited States
For those who have the nerve to say that suicidal people think of no one but themselves (I'm talking to you here, Ann Shenae), you obviously have never dealt with suicide or even depression in general.
The suicidal, the one's who truly mean to die, go through months and even years of agonizing thought and planning to find a way out that will hurt those around them in the least way possible.
No, suicide is NOT the best option. For some people however, it is the only option that makes sense. And please, don't bring God into this. That never helped anyone.
SerziUnited States
Jonny Doe "Boarding House" comment
"And far better not to be born twice at thirteen where the boarding house, each year a bed caught fire." may be insinuating some sexual encounters at the age of thirteen in a boarding house. Perhaps it is somewhat spitting some sarcastic venom in the direction of religion ("born twice").Whoever posted this poem, THANK YOU. I won a state medal for dramatic interpretation of this back in 2001.
Hello, does anyone know what year, preferably month as well, that this poem was written? I am struggling to find dates for a lot of Sexton's work... Thank you
That was a really deep poem and really sad. I posted a comment because I want people to acknowledge and recognize this chicks existance in our world. New York City may not mind, but I do and I notice and its not cool. Suicide sucks, for you and the people around you.
I think it is a really good poem, it shows how she really felt and the kind of person she was.She needed somenone by her side to keep going and that is what we all should do, have someone to talk to and never let depression come into our lives.
if you're not going to say something nice about this poem, then don't even bother leaving anything. Stop being immature. thank you, have a nice day :)
I think suicide is commited by persons who see beyond. Anne Sexton obviously did and if her suicide was the only way to make her rest, I guess it makes it kind of ok for her. Not that suicide is ok in every single case, but just in this one, I guess it was the only way out.
this poem is soul-baring.it really speaks 2 me.i understand how 1 can b driven 2 suicide.i understand molly's point,but it is possiblt 2 have a break down + it's very possible 4 1 2 snap + take their life.suicide's avery taboo + foreighn subject 2 the optimistic who just cannot understand it.
I disagree with Leilani, there are so many other ways out of situations then suicide. Anne Sexton took the suckers way out, and insteed of trying to solve her problems or talk to ppl about them she killed herslf. As far as the poem goes i wouldnt say it was one of her best but it was one that expressed her deepest secret.
steph is completley inaccurate----not just bout suicide but about sexton as well.obviousley,steph u have never felt that type od paralyzing despair.+ have'nt u read anne's bio's,steph?she did reach 4 help----especially many times repeatedley at mental institutions.sexton was a very ill person beyond yours or molly's comprhension.
I got that Anne was questioning her freedom to die once again. By once again, she meant she had attempted before. Thus, do I believe, did she have an entirely apathetic tone as to whether or not those reading took her seriously. She was trying to let us in on the secret of death and what beauty the decision held for her. Why let some omniscient hand guide your fate, when you, who know yourself more than gods can…
Read the whole commentI got that Anne was questioning her freedom to die once again. By once again, she meant she had attempted before. Thus, do I believe, did she have an entirely apathetic tone as to whether or not those reading took her seriously. She was trying to let us in on the secret of death and what beauty the decision held for her. Why let some omniscient hand guide your fate, when you, who know yourself more than gods can allow, can decide when is right and in what manner is most pleasing for you? For me, Anne is jealous of those who have found death in the medium of violence that suits them. She wishes she could just lay down and have her spirit leave her as it might have occurred in an ancient Hindu Tale. It's not for any of us to judge; her or the others herein. There's a deeper meaning we've all missed, and only Anne can tell.
I disagree with Leilani, How can you think suicide is ok in this case? Suicide is such a selfish way out. It's selfish because your thinking just about yourself and not the people who have to deal with the pain when your gone. I myself was suicidal, I had A void in my heart that I could not feel. It was untill I asked Jesus Christ into my heart that he is the one who filled that void in my heart and restored my…
Read the whole commentI disagree with Leilani, How can you think suicide is ok in this case? Suicide is such a selfish way out. It's selfish because your thinking just about yourself and not the people who have to deal with the pain when your gone. I myself was suicidal, I had A void in my heart that I could not feel. It was untill I asked Jesus Christ into my heart that he is the one who filled that void in my heart and restored my life. And no, I'm not talking about dead religion I'm talking about having a relationship with the living God. And If that made some of you mad, Well good, because suicide is murder! Yes, murder against your ownself. And the Bible says no murder will inherit the Kingdom of God. IF you murderd someone else yes their is forgiveness as long as your alive. But if you commit suicide, you kill yourself and theirs no time for repenting. So think TWICE befor you think the unthinkable. Theirs Hope in JESUS CHRIST!!!!!1
OMG! ann shenae,this is not the room for religious discussion....perhaps you feel you must judge the mentally ill with religious bias because you are questioning your own faith....i think you're looking for a more conservative,organized,intellectual-lacking place of a flock of sheep like you...THIS SITE'S GETTIN NUTS ON HERE AND'LL GO THE DOGS LESS YOU GUYS STOP ACTING AS IF YOU ARE ILLITERATE AND LACKING CULTURE!
this beautiful poetry is written inside of a mind of a great writter that did commit suicide. This shows an inside look of an actual suicide victim, maybe this might show an understanding to people who do it than a just anoter statistic, and maybe this might help people not commit suicide who are on the verge too. Maybe Anne's purpose for writting this poem was to help others or maybe she had no comprehension of helping others
(In regards to earlier comments) I think that the poems we read will be interpreted through our own brain filters and so we will never really know what Anne means or is trying to convey through her works. However, this forum is about sharing our input and our philosophies on what's going on in the poem. Since it is also trying to give different perspectives so that we might be able to see other sides of situation,…
Read the whole comment(In regards to earlier comments) I think that the poems we read will be interpreted through our own brain filters and so we will never really know what Anne means or is trying to convey through her works. However, this forum is about sharing our input and our philosophies on what's going on in the poem. Since it is also trying to give different perspectives so that we might be able to see other sides of situation, we are all entitled to our own opinions and thoughts. Just because someone makes a comment that doesn't suit your personal beleifs, doesn't give you the right to yell and curse and ridicule and judge them. Please keep this in mind while posting. THANK YOU!
Anyways, I felt as if Anne was trying to convey that she has tried to supress her sucidal thoughts but that she feels she cant hold on anymore and all she wants is that beautiful escape from life.
wow she seems pretty trobled like she had a deep deep secret i think her poems are beautiful i write poems to but never as good as hers
Amanda, you are stupid...you poopy head.
I've just read all your comments, and I've been thinking this entire time...who are we to judge another person over their oppinion of a poem no one can ever be RIGHT on? hmm... well, personally, I think suicide is not the best choice, and may seem completely irrationalto some while seeming the only way out for others. I have come close to hurting myself, but thoughts of others have always held me back. I think it…
Read the whole commentI've just read all your comments, and I've been thinking this entire time...who are we to judge another person over their oppinion of a poem no one can ever be RIGHT on? hmm... well, personally, I think suicide is not the best choice, and may seem completely irrationalto some while seeming the only way out for others. I have come close to hurting myself, but thoughts of others have always held me back. I think it depends the person and how they are feeling at the moment. The problem with suicide is it's a mistake one cannot regret later. Well, I'm using mistake in replacement for a better word that i cannot think of. But most things in this world one can regret after they have done them. Suicide is one of the few, or possibly the only, that leaves no room for remorse or second chances.
I think Anne Sexton in this poem is accepting the consequences of suicide, or maybe she is trying to put them in words. The phrase "Of course guitars will not play!" caught my attention because she seems almost exasperated with the reader, almost as if it is the READER that just simply cannot understand how she feels and what she means. It is a poem that can be interpretted many ways, and though there may be some religious allusions, Sexton simply does not seem to care she about religion or that she would go to hell. These are just my thoughts--everyone else is open to their own interpretations, of suicide AND of the poem. I hope my thoughts maybe gave deeper meaning to the poem, and gave all other readers some more food for thought.
WOW I wrote an epic....awesome! sorry....I didn't mean to write an english paper.... haha! Well... I hope everyone else enjoys this and all the other poems as much as I do!
well, she did commit suicide...she actually sipped vodka in her red convertible with the garage closed until it filled up with carbon monoxide and she died of asphixiation...im doing a research paper on her for my LA class and although she was very privaleged, her father and mother sexually abused her...her closest familial relationship was to her aunt who was also chronically depressed and died of suicide as well.…
Read the whole commentwell, she did commit suicide...she actually sipped vodka in her red convertible with the garage closed until it filled up with carbon monoxide and she died of asphixiation...im doing a research paper on her for my LA class and although she was very privaleged, her father and mother sexually abused her...her closest familial relationship was to her aunt who was also chronically depressed and died of suicide as well. she had a terrible life...she also was chronically depressed, and suffered from anxiety disorder. She actually ONLY began writing because her therapist told her to...she was also a model...she is now known as one of the greatest confessional poets of her time...but those of you who believe that suicide is NOT the answer...i totally agree. There are support groups for that. =]
I think that in the last stanza, Anne is trying to make the reader understand that she does not picture the afterlife to be a beautiful place that she can escape to, she does not expect people to feel remorse for her when she is gone. That's not the point of her "suicide". I don't think she really states a point to her suicide, rather she states all the reasons that she ISN'T doing it.
So do we have the Poet because of the illness, or the illness because of the Poet. You can't show me a Poet that is not troubled or tormented or demonized. Even the Poets that write of trees, bees and dandelions must face the everyday hell we call society. Tortured from the inside, tortured from the outside- take your pick.
todd is stupid. you don't know what you're talking about. you just like to put things into neat little packages with broad labels. say something original or don't say anything at all.
Actually Todd said something very important in my opinion. I don't know a single poet who is not tortured. I think the illness creates the Poet.
One measure is the number of comments garnered. Is it really her "suicide note" -- what if we didn't know anything about her life. Perhaps she couldn't help but write it. It is eloquent, and darkly beautiful. Languid. Even sensual. Profound. Very sad. She could not live. She is not giving excuses. She bravely and dangerously wrests her inner turmoil and illness out into the open -- not to impress or for praise or…
Read the whole commentOne measure is the number of comments garnered. Is it really her "suicide note" -- what if we didn't know anything about her life. Perhaps she couldn't help but write it. It is eloquent, and darkly beautiful. Languid. Even sensual. Profound. Very sad. She could not live. She is not giving excuses. She bravely and dangerously wrests her inner turmoil and illness out into the open -- not to impress or for praise or any of that (-- thus the epigram by Artaud -- she did it because she had to -- ) such private intimate visceral things so personal she couldn't know them herself until she put them out for the public to ooo, ahh, gawk and spit upon. Yes, what a sad life. What a loss. What if she had kept it all inside? Even a greater loss.
"you don't have to be ill to be a poet."
No, you surely don't. You just have to be human. Pain, happiness, depression - all human things that we experience. Some, worse than others. What makes a poet is life, langauge, and being human. Not illnesses. It's the god-given ability to convey thoughts and ideas through metaphores and similies etc. Anne Sexton was truly great. She wasn't psychologically ill. I think we're all psyhcologically ill in the eyes of a psychiatrist. Anne Sexton was just painfully human.
Like what was said previously not all poets must be ill to write the way they do. Ok its true that many of them do have expiences that have been hard and depressing that most likely influence their work. But whose to say that a person that is mostly happy can't write a depressing poem. People don't just have one emotion, everyone goes through different phases.
i am ill from pain
ill die from shame
deppresion is lame and it carnt be named
for who i am and what i will be suicidle is becoming of me
help is needed help is wanted no one can here my crys of help
living on a edge thats about to fall
no ones hereing my crys i call
no one for me
thats the way it will be
I love all her poetry, it's honest and deep filled with a distinct understanding of her own pain and suffering. I suggest those that read and judge without knowledge read more of her work and read her Biography. Suicide is not always the answer, but sometimes the only way for a truly tortured soul to finally rest and ease the life-long never ending pain. A great poem, a great writer, and a sister of tortured souls...
Does anyone understand why the boarding house caught fire each year?
It seems like so few of the comments here are about the poem. Someone mentioned the guitars. I think she was sort of joking. Have you ever been in that place where you are crying, but then you start laughing because of how ridiculous it is? I think that's what the "of course" was about, followed by traditional ridiculous images of heaven. Floating up and having guitars play, or seeing her father and he's young enough to have good posture. She thinks the sonar of the bats understand it best: she went from moving to inanimate, and that's all. But I don't get the boardinghouse line and I wish I did.
For those who have the nerve to say that suicidal people think of no one but themselves (I'm talking to you here, Ann Shenae), you obviously have never dealt with suicide or even depression in general.
The suicidal, the one's who truly mean to die, go through months and even years of agonizing thought and planning to find a way out that will hurt those around them in the least way possible.
No, suicide is NOT the best option. For some people however, it is the only option that makes sense.
And please, don't bring God into this. That never helped anyone.
Jonny Doe "Boarding House" comment
"And far better not to be born twice at thirteen where the boarding house, each year a bed caught fire." may be insinuating some sexual encounters at the age of thirteen in a boarding house. Perhaps it is somewhat spitting some sarcastic venom in the direction of religion ("born twice").Whoever posted this poem, THANK YOU. I won a state medal for dramatic interpretation of this back in 2001.
Hello, does anyone know what year, preferably month as well, that this poem was written? I am struggling to find dates for a lot of Sexton's work...
Thank you