“It was wrong to do this,” said the angel.
“You should live like a flower,
Holding malice like a puppy,
Waging war like a lambkin.”
“Not so,” quoth the man
Who had no fear of spirits;
“It is only wrong for angels
Who can live like the flowers,
Holding malice like the puppies,
Waging war like the lambkins.”
Do you have any comments, criticism, paraphrasis or analysis of this poem that you feel would assist other visitors in understanding the meaning or the theme of this poem by Stephen Crane better? If accepted, your analysis will be added to this page of American Poems. Together we can build a wealth of information, but it will take some discipline and determination.
Men see no wrong in committing sins
They see no evil in violence unlike the angels who live their lives perfectly.
The angel tries to convince man not to engage in any kind of sins.. But isn’t it obvious that a man is born to sins. So according to me man see normalism in what the angels see it as evil.
Angels do what they do because they are angels; humans do what they do because they are human. If a creator made man and angels, why did he limit man’s capacity to be peaceful? Do angels have free will? Satan supposedly is an angel who broke from God. But i digress. Perhaps Crane points out the hypocrisy of war in God’s name.
I love all that Crane writes about the relativity of truth and morality– not that there is no such thing, but that what is good for one man may be wicked for another… The angel can live a perfect life, in a place where there is no violence or need for it, and for an angel to commit violence is wicked, but it may not be wicked for a man, in his world, to do the same.
Actually I don’t beleive this poem is about sin, exactly.
The Angel is showing sorrow, remorse, maybe disdain at the wrechedness of mankind, but when he tells the man the man disagrees:
“It is only wrong for angels
Who can live like the flowers,
Holding malice like the puppies,
Waging war like the lambkins.”
I think what he is saying here is that it’s not wrong that I’m so low, but that your so high up judging me.
i think it shows that we can sin, and it is kinda expected and saying that it isnt totally wrong, eventhough it is. i donno what to say about it, i think i said what i thought wrong, sorry…