Poet: Carl Sandburg
Manitoba Childe Roland
Year: Published/Written in 1918
Comment 7 of 7, added on April 14th, 2014 at 1:54 AM.
In â€śChilde Roland to
In â€śChilde Roland to the Dark Tower Cameâ€ť by Robert Browning, it is difficult to say wethehr Childe Roland is a representation of a failure or not because his journey seemed doomed to fail from the very beginning of the poem. The title of the poem informs the reader that the hero is a man yet to be knighted. Browning does not present him in an ideal manner or describe him as a superior being of any kind. Our first impression of Childe Roland is one of paranoia as he expects the old man giving direction to be a fraud and take pleasure in his lies. We immediately doubt that he will fulfill his quest when he takes direction from the man who he previously deemed a liar. He continued on in the direction the old man pointed while doubting his honesty, â€śYet acquiescingly I did turn as he pointed, neither pride Now hope rekindling at the end descriedâ€ť (lines 15-17).Childe Rolandâ€™s quest involves traveling through a wasteland, a setting Browning fills with images of death and desolation, â€śSuch starved ignoble nature; nothing throve: For flowers as well expect a cedar grove!â€ť (Lines 56-57). Browningâ€™s graveyard setting doesnâ€™t allow for hope that Childe Roland will succeed in his journey. We donâ€™t fully believe that the obstacles which he encounters are real. Other dramatic monologues such as â€śPorphyriaâ€™s Loverâ€ť and â€śMy Last Duchessâ€ť Browning ask his audience to question the psyche of the protagonist. In â€śPorphyriaâ€™s Loverâ€ť our hero murders Porphyria for reasons that are not apparent, but likely because of her female sexual desires. In â€śMy Last Duchessâ€ť we learn the duke murdered his late wife because of her flirtatious nature. Having knowledge of Browningâ€™s attempts to explore the sadistic minds of murderers in other dramatic monologues, it makes us suspicious of Childe Rolandâ€™s mental state. Although Childe Roland does not explicitly murder a woman in his dialogue, we still wonder wethehr he is fully sane or not. Many hardships that he faces could be figments of our heroâ€™s imagination as he wanders through a wasteland looking for the Dark Tower which the reader knows nothing about. Although the ending of the poem is rather ambiguous, it is unlikely that Childe Roland is successful.
from Georgia, Republic of
Comment 6 of 7, added on May 25th, 2013 at 2:15 PM.
gAhu7N I really like and appreciate your article.Much thanks again. Keep writing.
Comment 5 of 7, added on May 14th, 2013 at 3:39 PM.
BUhWfy I really liked your article.Much thanks again.
Are you looking for more information on this poem? Perhaps you are trying to analyze it? The poem, Manitoba Childe Roland, has received 7 comments. Click here to read them, and perhaps post a comment of your own.