Comment 17 of 17, added on January 6th, 2012 at 12:16 PM.
its all bullshit
Comment 16 of 17, added on April 3rd, 2011 at 6:06 PM.
she never had a still born baby but did have a miscarriage in 1961. this
poem was written before that, so it is more of a metaphor for the way she
feels about her poetry.
adrienne from United States
Comment 15 of 17, added on April 14th, 2010 at 7:38 PM.
i really appreciated the stillborn of miss Zainab, i am not criticizing but
supporting the novel, my question to our famous writer is that, we didn't
see another novel of her we have being expecting to see, bye
Comment 14 of 17, added on April 17th, 2009 at 3:42 PM.
until your wives give birth to a stillborn, then you can appreciate how
disgusting visitors are to a mother who just gave birth to a stillborn
child. they just cant say "i grieve with you" and just shut up.
father of yssay
Comment 13 of 17, added on January 19th, 2008 at 3:34 AM.
it is easy to perceive the poem to be about a stillborn child, however
plath uses the metaphor of a stillborn child to portray her distress over
her, apparently, lifeless poetry.
the extended metaphor is introduced in beginning of the first stanza "these
poems do not live: it's a sad diagnosis." plath then continues to describe
the intricacies of the poems, and how, technicaly, they were flawless.
"they grew their toes and fingers well enough... and still the lungs won't
fill and the heart won't start"
upon reading the poem, the viewer is somewhat taken aback by the truculence
and rawness of the language However upon another reading, it is the
ambiguity and repugnance that help us to fully comprehend the emotional
distress these defective poems were causing plath. "they are not pigs, they
are not even fish Though they have a piggy and a fishy air."
the change in persona also shows plaths' changing views on her poetry.
the poem commences in the first person " O I cannot understand what
happened to them!" in the third stanza, however, there is a shift to the
third person. "but they are dead, and their mother near dead with
distraction." this shows her extrication from her poetry.
I hope that was helpful in interpreting the poem.
nicolaaaa :) from Australia
Comment 12 of 17, added on June 14th, 2007 at 12:13 AM.
this poem is just amazing.. the way sylvia works with her language.. and
the dead poems and grotesque imagery such as the pickling fluid or the
piggy and fishy air... the title stillborn could be for the stillborn
children of any woman or sylvias poem which is dead from the beginning,
because such a horrible experience, giving birth to a dead child, cannot be
explained with words.
Mell from Germany
Comment 11 of 17, added on April 5th, 2006 at 3:17 PM.
I don't know how you could write something so cold! I recently lost my
daughter who was stillborn. this poem is sad in a disgusting way.
Morgan from United States
Comment 10 of 17, added on February 2nd, 2006 at 11:50 AM.
i think stillborn is an excellent example of the rawness of pure emotion
that is not done better by anyone. Reading plaths poems evokes emotions on
so many levels, i feel it is like reading someones innermost thoughts she
seemed to get personal comfort of some sort by writing her feelings in the
form of a poem. Lady Lazurus and Daddy are excellent examples. This is no
different writing this appears to be Plaths way of dealing with her
dissatisfaction with her full life, her envy of her husbands sucess is
apparent and we can see she is not at all staisfied with her life, poetry,
marriage or anything. This is earlier than most of the poems which are
graphically suicidal but the unhappiness shines through in the same way.
Comment 9 of 17, added on January 27th, 2006 at 11:22 PM.
In any act of creativity, whether it be growing a baby or "birthing" a poem
or painting a picture, there comes a moment of realization that the
"creation" has taken on a separate and distinct life from it's creator,
that it has somehow miraculously come into being in it's own right, and
although it bares traces and roots it's creator, the genetic imprint
perhaps, somehow it has become more than the sum of the literal bones,
words, or artistic medium. That moment, when it occurs, is an epiphany, a
kana moment, when one sighs and says 'Aha'. Once experienced, that point of
recognition when the baby's independent movement is felt for the first
time, or the character in the story comes to life and is not who the author
thought they would be, speaking in a different voice: that feeling is
unmistakable, as is it's lack. Stillborn is a poem of mourning, a lament,
at the missing element in the poems that would turn lifeless words into
'living' creations. Stillbirth is very effective imagery for the process of
a poem not coming 'to life'.
from United States
Comment 8 of 17, added on November 28th, 2005 at 4:58 PM.
Quick clarification on Jessica's comment... Sylvia Plath does not have "a
history of giving birth to stillborn children." She did, however, have one
miscarriage in 1961, after the birth of her daughter and before the birth
of her son. This poem expresses her anxieties about childbirth and her
feelings of inadequacy. But it also extends that metaphor to the creation
of poetry. Her experience is not actually giving birth to stillborn
children, but stillborn poems. The poems "do not live" as she desires them
to. She admits the effort she has put into them, but mourns her inability
to create lively poems.
Emily from United States
This poem has been commented on more than 10 times. Click below to see the other comments.