It was a Maine lobster town—
each morning boatloads of hands
pushed off for granite
quarries on the islands,
and left dozens of bleak
white frame houses stuck
like oyster shells
on a hill of rock,
and below us, the sea lapped
the raw little match-stick
mazes of a weir,
where the fish for bait were trapped.
Remember? We sat on a slab of rock.
From this distance in time
it seems the color
of iris, rotting and turning purpler,
but it was only
the usual gray rock
turning the usual green
when drenched by the sea.
The sea drenched the rock
at our feet all day,
and kept tearing away
flake after flake.
One night you dreamed
you were a mermaid clinging to a wharf-pile,
and trying to pull
off the barnacles with your hands.
We wished our two souls
might return like gulls
to the rock. In the end,
the water was too cold for us.
✦
Analysis
Water: analysis
Introduction
Lowell's poem is addressed to a companion from the speaker's past. It recalls a bleak lobster town in Maine, a rock by the sea, and a wish the two of them once shared. The title names the element that shapes every part of the scene.
The poem sets memory against plain fact. From a distance the rock seems the colour of rotting iris, but it was "the usual gray rock" (line 18). The sea wears it away flake by flake. A dream of clinging to a wharf-pile and a wish to return "like gulls" lead to a flat final line: "the water was too cold for us."
Summary
The first stanza sets the scene. It was a Maine lobster town. Each morning boats carried workers out to granite quarries on the islands.
The boats left behind dozens of bleak white wooden houses. They were stuck on a rocky hill like oyster shells. The stanza is still part of the opening sentence.
Below the speaker and the companion, the sea lapped at a weir. The weir was a little maze of matchstick-thin stakes. Fish for bait were trapped inside it.
The speaker asks the companion to remember. The two of them sat on a slab of rock. Seen from this distance in time, the rock seems the colour of iris, rotting and turning purple.
But the speaker corrects himself. It was only ordinary gray rock. It turned the usual green when the sea drenched it.
All day the sea drenched the rock at their feet. It kept tearing the rock away. It came off flake after flake.
One night the companion had a dream. In the dream the companion was a mermaid clinging to a wharf-pile. The mermaid was trying to pull off the barnacles by hand.
The two of them wished their souls might return to the rock like gulls. The last sentence states the outcome. In the end, the water was too cold for them.
Themes and meaning
Memory and its distortions are at the poem's centre. The one-word question in line 13 turns the poem toward a shared past. The speaker admits that time has coloured the scene, so the rock now seems "of iris, rotting and turning purpler" (line 16). The next stanza corrects this with "the usual gray rock" (line 18). The poem shows memory decorating what was plain.
Erosion runs through the imagery. The sea "kept tearing away" (line 23) at the rock, "flake after flake". The rock that seemed solid is slowly worn down. This can be read as an image for a relationship worn away by time.
The dream of the mermaid suggests effort without result. The companion is "clinging to a wharf-pile" and trying to pull off barnacles by hand. The task is hopeless and the grip precarious. Readers may take it as a picture of trying to hold on, or of cleaning away what has grown over something.
Longing meets failure at the close. The wish that the souls "might return like gulls" (line 30) is hopeful and free. But the final line answers it bluntly. The phrase "the water was too cold for us" can be read literally, as the cold Maine sea, or as a verdict on the two people.
The opening stanzas add a theme of hard, plain lives. The houses are "bleak" and "stuck" on rock. Workers leave each morning for the quarries. The setting is not romantic, which makes the remembered beauty less trustworthy.
Tone
The tone is quiet, reflective and restrained. The opening stanzas describe the town in a neutral, documentary voice. Words like "bleak" and "stuck" hint at drabness without complaint.
The question "Remember?" (line 13) brings intimacy. The speaker is talking to someone who shared the experience. The poem becomes a private conversation that the reader overhears.
In stanzas 4 and 5 the tone becomes self-correcting. The lush image of rotting iris gives way to "only" and "the usual". The speaker distrusts his own nostalgia.
The mermaid stanza has a dreamlike, slightly anxious tone. The last stanza begins wistfully with the gull image. Then "In the end" brings a flat, final sadness. The understatement of the last line makes the loss feel larger.
Form and structure
The poem has eight quatrains of free verse, thirty-two lines in all. Lines are short, mostly four to eight syllables, with a range of four to eleven. There is no regular metre.
Rhyme is occasional rather than patterned. The words lapped and trapped frame the weir stanza. The word "rock" returns at line ends in four stanzas, binding the poem to that image.
Sentences run across line and stanza breaks. The first three stanzas form one long sentence. Short sentences in the later stanzas, such as "Remember?", slow the poem down. The final stanza splits a sentence at "In the end," so the verdict falls on a line of its own.
Poetic devices
Simile line 7
like oyster shells The white houses look like shells clinging to rock. The comparison makes them seem small, fixed and empty.
Metaphor line 10
the raw little match-stick The stakes of the weir are as thin as matches. The image stresses fragility and smallness.
Rhetorical question line 13
Remember? A one-word appeal to the companion. It shifts the poem from description to shared memory.
Imagery line 16
of iris, rotting and turning purpler Rich colour and decay together. The image shows how memory has altered the rock.
Repetition line 19
turning the usual green Echoes "the usual gray" in line 18. The repeated word deflates the memory back to the ordinary.
Personification line 23
and kept tearing away The sea acts with force and persistence. Its steady destruction suggests time wearing things down.
Symbol line 26
you were a mermaid clinging to a wharf-pile, The dream figure clings and struggles. It can stand for trying to hold on in a cold, hard place.
Simile line 30
might return like gulls The souls are imagined as birds that come back to the same rock. The image expresses a wish for return and freedom.
Understatement line 32
the water was too cold for us. A plain statement ends the poem. Its calm makes the failure it describes more striking.
Enjambment line 17
but it was only The line breaks on "only". The pause sets up the correction that follows.
Words worth knowing
hands
Workers, as in farm hands. The boats carry labourers, not literal hands.
frame houses
Houses built on a wooden frame, usually with clapboard siding.
weir
A fence of stakes set in water to trap fish.
wharf-pile
One of the wooden posts driven into the seabed to hold up a wharf.
purpler
More purple. An unusual comparative that stresses the deepening colour.
What readers have said
Molly, who met the poem in a GCSE exam, found it impossible to analyse in the time and too difficult for sixteen-year-olds. Molly, 2011
Jonty, who sat the same exam, disagrees and argues the poem would not have been chosen if it were too hard. Jonty, 2011
Tim reports that his son agrees with Jonty, but adds that the poem is difficult for anyone to analyse. Tim, 2011
This poem is awesome because its about water and I'm sailor water. So maybe now you could write about stars?
KevinBosnia and Herzegovina
Robert Lowell is dead you fool.
MollyUnited Kingdom
GCSE exam paper
This poem is imposible to analyse in a short amount of time, we just had this for our GCSE exam paper and it was FAR too difficult for what 16 year olds are capable of.
EllieUnited Kingdom
tell me about it! I sat my GCSE this afternoon :)
Jonty
it is clearly not too hard for 16 year old, otherwise AQA would never have picked it and yes, i did sit this exam, today, with this poem
TimUnited Kingdom
Water
Jonty , my son agrees. He sat the exam today as well. The poem is difficult for anyone to analyse!
This poem is awesome because its about water and I'm sailor water. So maybe now you could write about stars?
Robert Lowell is dead you fool.
GCSE exam paper
This poem is imposible to analyse in a short amount of time, we just had this for our GCSE exam paper and it was FAR too difficult for what 16 year olds are capable of.
tell me about it! I sat my GCSE this afternoon :)
it is clearly not too hard for 16 year old, otherwise AQA would never have picked it
and yes, i did sit this exam, today, with this poem
Water
Jonty , my son agrees. He sat the exam today as well. The poem is difficult for anyone to analyse!