She had thought the studio would keep itself;
no dust upon the furniture of love.
Half heresy, to wish the taps less vocal,
the panes relieved of grime. A plate of pears,
a piano with a Persian shawl, a cat
stalking the picturesque amusing mouse
had risen at his urging.
Not that at five each separate stair would writhe
under the milkman's tramp; that morning light
so coldly would delineate the scraps
of last night's cheese and three sepulchral bottles;
that on the kitchen shelf among the saucers
a pair of beetle-eyes would fix her own--
envoy from some village in the moldings...
Meanwhile, he, with a yawn,
sounded a dozen notes upon the keyboard,
declared it out of tune, shrugged at the mirror,
rubbed at his beard, went out for cigarettes;
while she, jeered by the minor demons,
pulled back the sheets and made the bed and found
a towel to dust the table-top,
and let the coffee-pot boil over on the stove.
By evening she was back in love again,
though not so wholly but throughout the night
she woke sometimes to feel the daylight coming
like a relentless milkman up the stairs.
✦
Analysis
Living In Sin: analysis
Introduction
This poem follows one day in a studio apartment shared by a woman and her lover. She had imagined the place as a picture of romance. The morning shows her dust, grime, leftover food and a beetle among the saucers.
He plays a few notes, shrugs and goes out for cigarettes. She cleans. By evening she is in love again, but not wholly. At night she wakes to feel the daylight coming up the stairs. The poem sets the ideal of love against the daily work and dirt of living together.
Summary
The poem is a single stanza, summarised here in five parts. The woman "had thought the studio would keep itself." She imagined "no dust upon the furniture of love." It felt like "Half heresy" to want quieter taps or cleaner windows. At his urging, she had pictured a still life of pears, a piano with a shawl and a cat stalking a mouse.
She had not expected what the morning shows her. At five, the stairs writhe "under the milkman's tramp." Morning light reveals scraps of cheese and "three sepulchral bottles." Among the saucers "a pair of beetle-eyes" stares back at her.
Meanwhile, the man yawns and plays "a dozen notes upon the keyboard." He declares the piano "out of tune" and shrugs at the mirror. He rubs his beard and goes "out for cigarettes."
The woman, "jeered by the minor demons," pulls back the sheets and makes the bed. She finds a towel to dust the table-top. She lets "the coffee-pot boil over on the stove."
By evening she is "back in love again." The love is "not so wholly" as before. Through the night she wakes at times. She feels the daylight coming "like a relentless milkman up the stairs."
Themes and meaning
The poem sets romantic expectation against daily reality. The woman thought the studio "would keep itself." She pictured pears, a Persian shawl and a playful cat, a scene like a painting. Morning replaces this with grime, scraps and bottles. The gap between the two pictures drives the poem.
The work of the household falls on her. He plays a few notes, admires himself in the mirror and leaves. She makes the bed and dusts. The poem lists his actions and hers side by side without comment. The imbalance speaks for itself.
The title is ironic and open. The phrase in the title names a couple living together unmarried. Yet the poem's sins are small ones. It is "Half heresy" even to wish the taps were quieter. One reading is that the true sin, in her own eyes, is noticing that love has dust on it.
Love survives, but diminished. By evening she is "back in love again," which suggests it had lapsed during the day. The next line adds "though not so wholly." The pattern seems set to repeat. The final image of daylight on the stairs promises another morning like this one.
Time works as a pressure in the poem. The milkman arrives "at five," and the light is cold. The last simile makes daylight itself "relentless." Each day brings the same exposure of the ideal to the real.
Tone
The tone is ironic and observant. The speaker tells the woman's story in the third person, with sympathy and a little wit. Phrases like "the picturesque amusing mouse" mock her earlier fantasy.
The middle of the poem turns sharper. The bottles are "sepulchral," and the beetle's eyes "fix her own." His careless actions are listed flatly, which makes them look worse. Her irritation shows when she lets the coffee-pot boil over.
The ending is quiet and uneasy. Her return to love sounds relieved, but "not so wholly" limits it. The closing simile of the "relentless milkman" ends on dread rather than rest.
Form and structure
The poem has 26 lines in 1 stanza. It is written in blank verse, unrhymed and close to iambic pentameter. Most lines have 10 or 11 syllables, within a range of 6 to 12. The rhythm is regular enough to feel measured but loosened by conversational phrasing.
There is no rhyme scheme. A few distant echoes occur, such as pears and stairs, and light and night. Long sentences run across many lines with frequent enjambment. The shortest lines, such as "had risen at his urging," mark turns in the story.
Poetic devices
metaphor line 2
no dust upon the furniture of love Love is imagined as a furnished room that never gathers dust. The poem then shows the dust.
personification line 3
to wish the taps less vocal The dripping taps seem to talk. Wishing them quiet feels to her like a small betrayal of love.
imagery line 5
a piano with a Persian shawl, a cat The objects form a picturesque still life. They show the romantic scene she had imagined.
personification line 8
each separate stair would writhe The stairs seem to twist in pain under the milkman. Everyday noise becomes an assault.
diction line 11
three sepulchral bottles Sepulchral makes empty bottles look like tombs. The word turns last night's pleasure into something deathly.
personification line 14
envoy from some village in the moldings The beetle becomes a diplomat from a hidden town. The mock-grand image is funny and unsettling at once.
asyndeton line 18
rubbed at his beard, went out for cigarettes His actions are listed without conjunctions. The quick run shows how casually he moves through the morning.
metaphor line 19
jeered by the minor demons Her small irritations become mocking spirits. The phrase keeps the religious language of the title.
polysyndeton line 20
pulled back the sheets and made the bed and found The repeated and strings her chores together. The rhythm contrasts with his idle list.
simile line 26
like a relentless milkman up the stairs Daylight arrives like the noisy milkman. It brings back the morning and all it reveals.
Words worth knowing
heresy
A belief against accepted doctrine. Here, a thought that betrays her faith in romance.
taps
Faucets. Vocal taps are ones that drip or make noise.
delineate
To outline or show clearly. The cold light picks out every scrap.
sepulchral
Like a tomb, gloomy and deathly.
envoy
A messenger or representative sent on a mission.
moldings
Decorative strips along walls or ceilings, where insects may hide.
Context
The archive's records date this poem's book publication to 1955. It has been on americanpoems.com since 2003. It was the site's Poem of the Day on September 3, 2009. Readers left 22 comments on it between 2004 and 2020.
What readers have said
Melissa reads the title as living together without marriage and sees the milkman as bringing the couple back to reality. Melissa, 2004
Cormac Parle takes the poem to show that no love, however consuming, changes the everyday reality of chores. Cormac Parle, 2004
Erin calls it a poem about the morning after the dream of happily ever after, with the studio standing for the lovers' hearts. erin, 2004
An anonymous reader sees broken pictures and suggests the sin is the couple's futile forward momentum. Anonymous, 2006
Jeff reads it as anti-feminist, arguing that the woman causes her own pain because she does nothing to change her life. Jeff, 2010
Eren answers that it is a feminist poem about women trapped in traditional roles. eren, 2020
Beautifully depicted is this womans anguish with her lover and what he i unable to give. In my opinion the title is referring to the lie she is living by keeping him as her lover, as she makes it known to the reader he cannot give her what she wants.
Anne RiceUnited States
Obviously, the relationship goes nowhere because he is a homosexual. It is almost akin to the life of Cole Porter and his lovely (or delovely) wife. The poem makes the same transition as she does in her own life. At first, she is reminiscent about the furniture of love; however, she becomes agitated when making the bed because of an unconsummated love, yet at the end of the day, she realizes this is still her life partner. It is a tragic tale at best of unrequited love (perhaps, one should address the author's own life as a comparison) -Anne
I would have thought this poem was about how life is an everyday thing, with everyday chores and ups and downs, and no love, no matter how all-consuming, is going to change that reality
Sam
It's about economic instability in the African national of Zimbabwe cleverly metaphorated in a prose unsurpassed by only Marcel Prouse's rhetorical concerning the Chinese Pig Racing scandal of 1923.
erinUnited States
"Living in Sin" is a poem about the morning that comes after the dream of 'happily ever after'. The couple Rich introduces is characterized by the objects in the apartment. The studio apartment symbolizes the hearts of the lovers. It has become the taunting reminder of what happens to the fairy tale when confronted with dirty dishes and grocery lists. The female speaker rfers to the act of noticing the disarray of…
Read the whole comment
"Living in Sin" is a poem about the morning that comes after the dream of 'happily ever after'. The couple Rich introduces is characterized by the objects in the apartment. The studio apartment symbolizes the hearts of the lovers. It has become the taunting reminder of what happens to the fairy tale when confronted with dirty dishes and grocery lists. The female speaker rfers to the act of noticing the disarray of the place as, "Half heresy". This is the feeling that to notice any flaw in the love is to discredit it entirely. He, on the other hand seems much less consciously aware of the predicament. Yet, certain actions of his tell his faded affection for the idea of the love affair. The piano reference is particularly poignant. "declared it out of tune, shrugged at teh mirror". The piano's dischord is the song of the studio and their love. It is there to be touched and known, but has none of the melody that love once promised. The mirror symbolizes the self examination he wishes not to attempt. He frowns because it is clear that things are not as they were. But he walks off because it is easier. The poem ends with the woman acknowledgeing that every night she is revived enough to keep on going as they are. But, the beauty of this conclusion is that she is never brought back to that love they had planned. The dream once faded cannot be revisited. One is only able to just barely recall the shapes and colors and something of the way it felt, but the daytime is so much at hand that it smears and rubbs away the night's memory. She wakes up every morning able to move through teh motions of their life but never able to catch sight of what was supposed to have been. This poem is a sharp and visual portrait of the realities of everyday as they replace the imagined romantics of fantasy and youth.
The poem is about a woman sruggling to maintain contentedness living the life of a homemaker. We are given all the tedious details of her day, so slow it goes that she can having a staring war with a beetle hiding among the saucers. During the day she wonders why it is she is living this life for a man that is not there. Instead of the beauty she thought her home would have because of love, dirt still builds up and…
Read the whole comment
The poem is about a woman sruggling to maintain contentedness living the life of a homemaker. We are given all the tedious details of her day, so slow it goes that she can having a staring war with a beetle hiding among the saucers. During the day she wonders why it is she is living this life for a man that is not there. Instead of the beauty she thought her home would have because of love, dirt still builds up and she finds herself wondering what motivation she has to clean it. At night when he returns her work is justified suddenly, and there is the love and beauty of life, but it seems to be fading and beginning to fall into doubt. At night she feels the daylight coming in, a representation of the true daytime when her doubt is strongest and love does not seem to exist in her home.
These two people are "Living in sin" because they are living together without marriage. I believe that when they are in their apartment they are out of the real world. She doesn't think about what needs to be done around the house because she is caught up in their love. When the milk man comes up the stairs it is bringing them back to reality!!
The poem address the discrepancies in the "ideal" of love and the reality in which Rich's characters are living. It is obvious that the woman longs for the picture which was "risen at his urging" but instead is disappointed by the their actual situation. At night the couple can indulge in romantic endeavors but the rising of the day always sheds light on reality. The characters are "living in sin" among false and fallen hopes.
MarkUnited States
This poem represents a woman who has to live with the consequences of bad choices made soley on desire over logic. She sees the real and does nothing about it. The title of the poem relates to the time this poem was written. IN the 1950's, to live with someone of the opposite sex and not be married was looked down on.She was so excited to move in with this slob of a man that she was willing to settle for less.For her, a new day is one of emotional pain.She moved in only at his "urging" but he never made any promises so in a way she deserves what she gets.
StanselmonUnited States
This poem is a shear masterpiece in its own time, depicting early 1960 life in Shippawee, Illinois, where it was considered illegal to be living together without a marriage license. The boldness of the poem, the actions of the characters, the cheese and empty bottles, paints the clearest picture of the hardships of this troubling time period.
haoraniscoolUnited States
With anxiety and some precaution, Adrienne Rich presents an image with multiple meanings. Her ability to present thoughts in such a precise manner allows the reader to envision possible interpretations and, yet, to focus, finally, on the main point she makes: A woman bound to her husband feels, by forces beyond her control, the need of a frequent visitor. Rich, with delicate hints, enters the evil which encompasses…
Read the whole comment
With anxiety and some precaution, Adrienne Rich presents an image with multiple meanings. Her ability to present thoughts in such a precise manner allows the reader to envision possible interpretations and, yet, to focus, finally, on the main point she makes: A woman bound to her husband feels, by forces beyond her control, the need of a frequent visitor.
Rich, with delicate hints, enters the evil which encompasses the sin insinuated throughout the poem. The reader stands aside with the “approacher” and peeks in through grimey panes. He does his bidding and departs, leaving the woman but a memory to recognize him when he comes again. Meanwhile the husband’s unaware figure is present and then is not. The woman must make haste of what she has formed--an evil dust on “the furniture of love.”
A boiling pot of coffee on the stove signifies normalcy, but the woman is caught in a twister of emotions. Mate or milkman? Two different loves overwhelm her. Only one steals her from her slumber. She is controlled by lustful demons she does not wish to rebuke. In a battle of soul and flesh, Rich emphasizes the dominance of the flesh in a story, unfortunately, too commonly known.
I am looking for information on a poet from early 1900's. May have done some work for or with Victor C. Anderson artist and Alfred S. Campbell Art Co. I am also looking for more information on Alfred S. Campbell Art Co. Possibly all come out of New Jersey area. Elizabeth NJ perhaps? In particular, I am looking for the date of poem called "Losted" by Burges Johnson. Thank you.
KennyUnited States
This poem isn't just about "foregoing the chores." This poem is a reality check. First, there's no mention of the two being a married couple, and I don't believe they are. However, they are living together--a woman with an artist--and how the realty of living with an artist is completely the opposite of the woman's romantic fantasy. The house is filthy. The windows are grimy. There's old food on the countertops. The…
Read the whole comment
This poem isn't just about "foregoing the chores." This poem is a reality check. First, there's no mention of the two being a married couple, and I don't believe they are. However, they are living together--a woman with an artist--and how the realty of living with an artist is completely the opposite of the woman's romantic fantasy. The house is filthy. The windows are grimy. There's old food on the countertops. The taps leak. There are bugs everywhere. The outside stairs are creaky. The artist himself, an unshaven slob, wakes up, taps a few keys on the piano and goes to buy cigarettes while the woman realizes her ideal (the "artist cliches" like a bowl of pears, a Persian rug and the house somehow keeping itself) is just a lie. The end of the poem--"..throughout the night she woke sometimes to feel the daylight coming like a relentless milkman up the stairs"--is her gradual realization that these romantic dreams of living with an artist are absolutely wrong.
The poem is a collection of broken pictures--broken syntactically or psychologically. Putting them together is to find out the nature of this relationship. The "sin" is this sort of futile forward momentum they both are caught up in. The milkman is the coming day or just anothera lover who might bring the same to the relationship with her as the present one does. A very depressing piece of aart this!
~lovely~United States
Every critical reader may see the imagery and diction in the words of Rich that enables the reader to see the woman as the wretch in a life of irresistible passion but the surface of the poem, including its symbols, says more to the reader than over analyzing the space between the lines. The women is the milk, the guy is the milkman. The milk always comes when expected. The milk is always available. The milkman…
Read the whole comment
Every critical reader may see the imagery and diction in the words of Rich that enables the reader to see the woman as the wretch in a life of irresistible passion but the surface of the poem, including its symbols, says more to the reader than over analyzing the space between the lines. The women is the milk, the guy is the milkman. The milk always comes when expected. The milk is always available. The milkman doesn't have to do anything exciting to get the milk. The milkman doesn't have to buy to the cow to get the milk. This milkman gets his milk from a source that works like a machine that gives him milk when he says "come." The girl is the "amusing mouse"; the guy is the cat. The mouse is amused by the chase; the guy chases the mouse by "his urging." This poem is about woman with a possible Christian background that enjoys her routine life of sinful passion rather than a routine life of pure loneliness.
JeffUnited States
This poem is an anti feminist piece that discusses the seven deadly sins from the bible. The anti feministness comes from the fact that this girl knowing that her life could be better, but she does nothing to change it.
Most feminist papers portray a woman as helpless and oppressed by men. While it would appear that she is being oppressed my the "artist", in reality she causes all of her own pain and trauma.
Three of the seven deadly sins can easily be found here; including gluttony (the empty bottles), lust (this one is obvious), and sloth (the lack of effort to keep her apartment or lifestyle clean)
Dude it is a feminist poem about how woman are trapped by traditional female roles. That this relationship, her life, isnt what she thought it would be.
Eren: THANK YOU. Such an "off" perspective from Jeff. It is clearly a feminist poem. We read and dissected this in my Women's Poetry class in college. You nailed it.
David
I just stumbled on this poem last week when looking for something to supplement my teaching of Chopin's "Story of an Hour" and The Awakening. Having taught Rich's "Storm Warnings" for several years, I am familiar with her biography. I think that it may be interpreted that the "sin" in which the woman is living is that of half heartedly fulfilling the obligations associated with the traditional female role in a heterosexual relationship while being aware, privately, that she is a lesbian.
Beautifully depicted is this womans anguish with her lover and what he i unable to give. In my opinion the title is referring to the lie she is living by keeping him as her lover, as she makes it known to the reader he cannot give her what she wants.
Obviously, the relationship goes nowhere because he is a homosexual. It is almost akin to the life of Cole Porter and his lovely (or delovely) wife. The poem makes the same transition as she does in her own life. At first, she is reminiscent about the furniture of love; however, she becomes agitated when making the bed because of an unconsummated love, yet at the end of the day, she realizes this is still her life partner. It is a tragic tale at best of unrequited love (perhaps, one should address the author's own life as a comparison) -Anne
I would have thought this poem was about how life is an everyday thing, with everyday chores and ups and downs, and no love, no matter how all-consuming, is going to change that reality
It's about economic instability in the African national of Zimbabwe cleverly metaphorated in a prose unsurpassed by only Marcel Prouse's rhetorical concerning the Chinese Pig Racing scandal of 1923.
"Living in Sin" is a poem about the morning that comes after the dream of 'happily ever after'. The couple Rich introduces is characterized by the objects in the apartment. The studio apartment symbolizes the hearts of the lovers. It has become the taunting reminder of what happens to the fairy tale when confronted with dirty dishes and grocery lists. The female speaker rfers to the act of noticing the disarray of…
Read the whole comment"Living in Sin" is a poem about the morning that comes after the dream of 'happily ever after'. The couple Rich introduces is characterized by the objects in the apartment. The studio apartment symbolizes the hearts of the lovers. It has become the taunting reminder of what happens to the fairy tale when confronted with dirty dishes and grocery lists. The female speaker rfers to the act of noticing the disarray of the place as, "Half heresy". This is the feeling that to notice any flaw in the love is to discredit it entirely. He, on the other hand seems much less consciously aware of the predicament. Yet, certain actions of his tell his faded affection for the idea of the love affair. The piano reference is particularly poignant. "declared it out of tune, shrugged at teh mirror". The piano's dischord is the song of the studio and their love. It is there to be touched and known, but has none of the melody that love once promised. The mirror symbolizes the self examination he wishes not to attempt. He frowns because it is clear that things are not as they were. But he walks off because it is easier. The poem ends with the woman acknowledgeing that every night she is revived enough to keep on going as they are. But, the beauty of this conclusion is that she is never brought back to that love they had planned. The dream once faded cannot be revisited. One is only able to just barely recall the shapes and colors and something of the way it felt, but the daytime is so much at hand that it smears and rubbs away the night's memory. She wakes up every morning able to move through teh motions of their life but never able to catch sight of what was supposed to have been. This poem is a sharp and visual portrait of the realities of everyday as they replace the imagined romantics of fantasy and youth.
The poem is about a woman sruggling to maintain contentedness living the life of a homemaker. We are given all the tedious details of her day, so slow it goes that she can having a staring war with a beetle hiding among the saucers. During the day she wonders why it is she is living this life for a man that is not there. Instead of the beauty she thought her home would have because of love, dirt still builds up and…
Read the whole commentThe poem is about a woman sruggling to maintain contentedness living the life of a homemaker. We are given all the tedious details of her day, so slow it goes that she can having a staring war with a beetle hiding among the saucers. During the day she wonders why it is she is living this life for a man that is not there. Instead of the beauty she thought her home would have because of love, dirt still builds up and she finds herself wondering what motivation she has to clean it. At night when he returns her work is justified suddenly, and there is the love and beauty of life, but it seems to be fading and beginning to fall into doubt. At night she feels the daylight coming in, a representation of the true daytime when her doubt is strongest and love does not seem to exist in her home.
These two people are "Living in sin" because they are living together without marriage. I believe that when they are in their apartment they are out of the real world. She doesn't think about what needs to be done around the house because she is caught up in their love. When the milk man comes up the stairs it is bringing them back to reality!!
The poem address the discrepancies in the "ideal" of love and the reality in which Rich's characters are living. It is obvious that the woman longs for the picture which was "risen at his urging" but instead is disappointed by the their actual situation. At night the couple can indulge in romantic endeavors but the rising of the day always sheds light on reality. The characters are "living in sin" among false and fallen hopes.
This poem represents a woman who has to live with the consequences of bad choices made soley on desire over logic. She sees the real and does nothing about it. The title of the poem relates to the time this poem was written. IN the 1950's, to live with someone of the opposite sex and not be married was looked down on.She was so excited to move in with this slob of a man that she was willing to settle for less.For her, a new day is one of emotional pain.She moved in only at his "urging" but he never made any promises so in a way she deserves what she gets.
This poem is a shear masterpiece in its own time, depicting early 1960 life in Shippawee, Illinois, where it was considered illegal to be living together without a marriage license. The boldness of the poem, the actions of the characters, the cheese and empty bottles, paints the clearest picture of the hardships of this troubling time period.
With anxiety and some precaution, Adrienne Rich presents an image with multiple meanings. Her ability to present thoughts in such a precise manner allows the reader to envision possible interpretations and, yet, to focus, finally, on the main point she makes: A woman bound to her husband feels, by forces beyond her control, the need of a frequent visitor. Rich, with delicate hints, enters the evil which encompasses…
Read the whole commentWith anxiety and some precaution, Adrienne Rich presents an image with multiple meanings. Her ability to present thoughts in such a precise manner allows the reader to envision possible interpretations and, yet, to focus, finally, on the main point she makes: A woman bound to her husband feels, by forces beyond her control, the need of a frequent visitor.
Rich, with delicate hints, enters the evil which encompasses the sin insinuated throughout the poem. The reader stands aside with the “approacher” and peeks in through grimey panes. He does his bidding and departs, leaving the woman but a memory to recognize him when he comes again. Meanwhile the husband’s unaware figure is present and then is not. The woman must make haste of what she has formed--an evil dust on “the furniture of love.”
A boiling pot of coffee on the stove signifies normalcy, but the woman is caught in a twister of emotions. Mate or milkman? Two different loves overwhelm her. Only one steals her from her slumber. She is controlled by lustful demons she does not wish to rebuke. In a battle of soul and flesh, Rich emphasizes the dominance of the flesh in a story, unfortunately, too commonly known.
I am looking for information on a poet from early 1900's. May have done some work for or with Victor C. Anderson artist and Alfred S. Campbell Art Co. I am also looking for more information on Alfred S. Campbell Art Co. Possibly all come out of New Jersey area. Elizabeth NJ perhaps? In particular, I am looking for the date of poem called "Losted" by Burges Johnson. Thank you.
This poem isn't just about "foregoing the chores." This poem is a reality check. First, there's no mention of the two being a married couple, and I don't believe they are. However, they are living together--a woman with an artist--and how the realty of living with an artist is completely the opposite of the woman's romantic fantasy. The house is filthy. The windows are grimy. There's old food on the countertops. The…
Read the whole commentThis poem isn't just about "foregoing the chores." This poem is a reality check. First, there's no mention of the two being a married couple, and I don't believe they are. However, they are living together--a woman with an artist--and how the realty of living with an artist is completely the opposite of the woman's romantic fantasy. The house is filthy. The windows are grimy. There's old food on the countertops. The taps leak. There are bugs everywhere. The outside stairs are creaky. The artist himself, an unshaven slob, wakes up, taps a few keys on the piano and goes to buy cigarettes while the woman realizes her ideal (the "artist cliches" like a bowl of pears, a Persian rug and the house somehow keeping itself) is just a lie. The end of the poem--"..throughout the night she woke sometimes to feel the daylight coming like a relentless milkman up the stairs"--is her gradual realization that these romantic dreams of living with an artist are absolutely wrong.
This poem was great. I loved the topic.
The poem is a collection of broken pictures--broken syntactically or psychologically. Putting them together is to find out the nature of this relationship. The "sin" is this sort of futile forward momentum they both are caught up in. The milkman is the coming day or just anothera lover who might bring the same to the relationship with her as the present one does. A very depressing piece of aart this!
Every critical reader may see the imagery and diction in the words of Rich that enables the reader to see the woman as the wretch in a life of irresistible passion but the surface of the poem, including its symbols, says more to the reader than over analyzing the space between the lines. The women is the milk, the guy is the milkman. The milk always comes when expected. The milk is always available. The milkman…
Read the whole commentEvery critical reader may see the imagery and diction in the words of Rich that enables the reader to see the woman as the wretch in a life of irresistible passion but the surface of the poem, including its symbols, says more to the reader than over analyzing the space between the lines. The women is the milk, the guy is the milkman. The milk always comes when expected. The milk is always available. The milkman doesn't have to do anything exciting to get the milk. The milkman doesn't have to buy to the cow to get the milk. This milkman gets his milk from a source that works like a machine that gives him milk when he says "come." The girl is the "amusing mouse"; the guy is the cat. The mouse is amused by the chase; the guy chases the mouse by "his urging." This poem is about woman with a possible Christian background that enjoys her routine life of sinful passion rather than a routine life of pure loneliness.
This poem is an anti feminist piece that discusses the seven deadly sins from the bible. The anti feministness comes from the fact that this girl knowing that her life could be better, but she does nothing to change it.
Most feminist papers portray a woman as helpless and oppressed by men. While it would appear that she is being oppressed my the "artist", in reality she causes all of her own pain and trauma.
Three of the seven deadly sins can easily be found here; including gluttony (the empty bottles), lust (this one is obvious), and sloth (the lack of effort to keep her apartment or lifestyle clean)
amazing
I agree. This is so deep.
Dude it is a feminist poem about how woman are trapped by traditional female roles. That this relationship, her life, isnt what she thought it would be.
Eren: THANK YOU. Such an "off" perspective from Jeff. It is clearly a feminist poem. We read and dissected this in my Women's Poetry class in college. You nailed it.
I just stumbled on this poem last week when looking for something to supplement my teaching of Chopin's "Story of an Hour" and The Awakening. Having taught Rich's "Storm Warnings" for several years, I am familiar with her biography. I think that it may be interpreted that the "sin" in which the woman is living is that of half heartedly fulfilling the obligations associated with the traditional female role in a heterosexual relationship while being aware, privately, that she is a lesbian.